While this is a prequel to the Star Wars: Rebels episode “Breaking Ranks” in the first season, it is completely unnecessary to have seen that episode or any episode, really, of Rebels. That may not fully be the case for the other books in this series but it certainly is for this one.
For a junior novel, I was shocked at how good it was. But again, I feel like this is a testament to the writing. Jason Fry knows Star Wars front to back and recognizes that there is no need to “dumb it down” for children because the films don’t do it so why should he? I can’t stress this enough for authors of middle and lower grade books for kids— writing for kids isn’t an excuse for poor writing. Fry, on the other hand, nails it and writes a story that I can confidently say both kids and adults will enjoy this read.
Personally, one of my favorite things about this book is it acts as a way for kids to fully grasp the negative aspect of the Empire as not just “the bad guys” but as a totalitarian military dictatorship under an absolute monarchy. An easy comparison one can make is a dystopian teen novel in the vain of Divergent, The Giver, Hunger Games, or Maze Runner. Applying that theme to Star Wars is absolutely brilliant because that is essentially what the Empire is, but often that oppression is often glossed over. So seeing that dystopia from the perspective of people inside the imperial military— cadets or soldiers— helps paint a bigger and clearer picture of how the Empire operates.
Another notion strengthened in this novel Fry tackles was the concept of racism (which is brought to the forefront with speciesism towards aliens and non-humans). Combating racism has always been an underlying theme in Star Wars— whether it was intentional or not. From the original film you see aliens on the side of the Rebels but all of the Imperials are human and often speak with a British accent. Of course part of that had to do with filming in Great Britain and not having the budget to make tons and tons of aliens, but it’s something that the community have embraced in both Legends and Canon continuities: Palpatine is overtly speciesist, therefore so is the Empire. It’s a rarity, but Palpatine has been known to place non-humans in power (such as Mas Amedda, The Grand Inquisitor, and of course, Grand Admiral Thrawn) but does not allow them to becomes stormtroopers or even fully diverse with humans. Seeing this reflected in the novel by having alien grav-ball players be pushed out because of their species was absolutely good thing to add from a writing standpoint— not only to appease logical canon junkies such as myself, but so kids can learn how to combat racism when or if it comes their way or to others around them. It’s another way of teaching right and wrong; the way it was written was extremely tasteful and well done.
On a more positive note, the book has tons of diverse concepts that many different kids and teens can gravitate towards: everything from politics, to sports, computer tech, romance, military and even farming. It’s got something for everyone. Additionally, I think it’s a fantastic extension of Rebels. We are introduced to Zare there, but he is completely fleshed out in the novel(s) and it helps add addition context to episodes that feature him and his story.
I think the only things I didn’t like the book were really give-and-take problems. Such as grav-ball. The inclusion of the sport was important for a lot of plot reasons as well as reasons to draw kids in who love sports. So I understand that. But as someone who isn’t big into sports, it was kind of hard to follow what the actual sport was. However, once I just imagined it to be space soccer, it flowed a lot better. So that’s nearly a non issue. The next issue is debatable. The back of the book literally spoils a plot point with Zare’s sister that doesn’t even happen until the end of the book. That’s not right, but I can’t really fault the book itself for it, so it’s alright I guess, but nearly everything else hit the mark to with near perfect precision.