Moving into its third decade, Peanuts could have easily been in steep decline; instead, it's not terribly far from peak value in this collection. 1969 launches with a strip on January 1 featuring Lucy vowing that this will be her year to shine. She resents Charlie Brown's overture to claim part of the year for himself, as we all sometimes unreasonably do when others encroach on our grand plans. February 13 (page twenty) is a familiar gag from the 1975 Be My Valentine, Charlie Brown animated special, though here it's Charlie Brown and not Linus pounding the chalkboard erasers. February 16 (page twenty-one) is also in the animated special: Charlie Brown desperately wants to check his mailbox for a valentine from the Little Red-Haired Girl, but what if the box is empty? His indecision is something we've all endured. February 21 (page twenty-three), Sally confides in Charlie Brown that each year she worries Christmas might come and go without her noticing. That seems impossible, but all of us fret about our big moment passing us by without our realizing what we missed.
We see a humorous moment between Lucy and Schroeder on March 20 (page thirty-five). Lucy wants to know the meaning of life, and Schroeder insists it is Beethoven's music. When you're passionate, it's easy to become a hammer in search of a nail. Sunday, April 13 (page forty-five), Snoopy lazes around waiting for supper. He gobbles it with gusto, but feels disappointed in himself that a meal is the highlight of his day. How often is the same true of us? A funny exchange between Linus and Charlie Brown on April 21 (page forty-nine) has Linus over-explaining what pencils are made of; Charlie Brown's muted retort is perfect. July 21 (page eighty-eight), Charlie Brown stands alone at night regretting missed chances now that the Little Red-Haired Girl has moved away. His anger at his own demure nature resonates deeply.
"Unfortunately, in the game of life, I'm always hitting from the back tees!"
—Charlie Brown, P. 91
July 30 (page ninety-one) is a terrific quip bemoaning life's unfairness. Charlie Brown is the crown prince of wry one-liners. Fast-forward to February 13, 1970 (page one hundred seventy-six) for the next great strip, in which Charlie Brown wonders what it's like to receive a valentine from someone you love. Will his day ever arrive? May 4 (page two hundred eleven), Charlie Brown asks Snoopy to stand guard outside the house because of a recent spike in home invasions. Snoopy's interpretation of looking "real mean" is worth a laugh. An important moment in Peanuts history comes June 22 (page two hundred thirty-two). After four years, Snoopy reveals the name of his bird companion: Woodstock, who would remain a staple of the comic strip to its end.
"No matter what anyone says, it's much worse to be unloved than it is to be lost in the woods."
—Charlie Brown, P. 237
I love the July 5 Sunday strip (page two hundred thirty-seven), Lucy trying to convince Charlie Brown there are worse things than feeling unloved. His line in the penultimate panel carries more than just comedic weight. July 21 (page two hundred forty-four), Snoopy makes a simple, relevant observation: time of day and our own emotions dramatically shape our thoughts at any given moment. During a baseball game (August 2, page two hundred forty-nine), Charlie Brown is still torturing himself over the Little Red-Haired Girl's moving away. It pulls him out of the game experience as he suffers wave upon wave of regret. I've certainly been there. Linus returns from vacation August 11 (page two hundred fifty-three). Charlie Brown asks how it went, and Linus observes that all towns are essentially the same. Do we ever truly vacation, or just change location?
Lucy and Schroeder were a superstar duo by this juncture in Peanuts, and August 29 (page two hundred sixty) is a hilarious Lucy comeback to a typical sardonic Schroeder statement. October 12 (page two hundred eighty), Sally comes through with a sparkling moment of humor as she writes her "Columbus Day" report. No one is funnier than Sally Brown! December 6 (page three hundred three) is a revealing commentary as Peppermint Patty laments her lack of academic success. What she blames it on is obviously untrue, but it's always easier to externalize one's own failures. The last great strip in this book is December 28 (page three hundred thirteen), Charlie Brown at Lucy's Psychiatric Help booth confessing he fears life will only get harder as he grows up. Charlie Brown never ducked unsettling truths; perhaps it's easier for us to explore them via his fictional life.
Charles Schulz was unique as a children's author, and I like the two years of strips in this book, but The Complete Peanuts, 1969–1970 is among the weaker collections so far in the series. There are fewer laugh-out-loud moments, not as much insightful or emotional commentary, and at times the characters feel contrived. I still rate the book two and a half stars though, and look forward to 1971-72. Charlie Brown and company serve a vital function in my life and always will.