So I have FINALLY finished The Penguin Book of Western Fairy Tales, which is almost 800 pages of fairy tale goodness. The selection ranges from Cupid and Psyche (2nd century) to Pichounetta and the Sergeant of Arles (1988). The tales vary greatly in length and tone, with stories from fairy tale heavyweights like Grimm and Andersen. There are also contributions from well-known writers like Goethe, Oscar Wilde, Mark Twain and Tanith Lee.
I have to say, my enjoyment of them also varied greatly. Many did not have quite the alacrity of, say, the tales by the brothers Grimm, with which I’m most familiar with. They were often bogged down with unnecesary details and/or uncertain pacing. The fairy tales also got quite cynical and rather weird when I got to the 20th century. That said, the 20th century also offered a rather lovely of The Princess and the Frog and I really enjoyed Tanith Lee’s retelling of Cinderella (I’ve read some books by her. They’re rather dark in tone, but so so good.)
In conclusion, while I liked some stories more than others, this is still a great anthology for those who are interested in more than just the classic Grimm and Andersen fairy tales. It is very interesting to see how our relationship with fairy tales changes through the years.