What do you think?
Rate this book
A Heart Bent Out of Shape
From the author of The Book of Summers, picked for Richard & Judy's 2012 summer book club, comes the story of a first love, a terrible tragedy, a snow-filled paradise; a year that will never be forgotten.
For Hadley Dunn, life so far has been uneventful - no great loves, no searing losses. But that's before she decides to spend a year studying in the glittering Swiss city of Lausanne, a place that feels alive with promise. Here Hadley meets Kristina, a beautiful but elusive Danish girl, and the two quickly form the strongest of bonds. Yet one November night, as the first snows of winter arrive, tragedy strikes.
Hadley, left reeling and guilt-stricken, beings to lean on the only other person to whom she feels close, her American Literature professor Joel Wilson. But as the pair try to uncover the truth of what happened that night, their tentative friendship heads into forbidden territory. And before long a line is irrevocably crossed, everything changes, and two already complicated lives take an even more dangerous course...
For Hadley Dunn, life so far has been uneventful - no great loves, no searing losses. But that's before she decides to spend a year studying in the glittering Swiss city of Lausanne, a place that feels alive with promise. Here Hadley meets Kristina, a beautiful but elusive Danish girl, and the two quickly form the strongest of bonds. Yet one November night, as the first snows of winter arrive, tragedy strikes.
Hadley, left reeling and guilt-stricken, beings to lean on the only other person to whom she feels close, her American Literature professor Joel Wilson. But as the pair try to uncover the truth of what happened that night, their tentative friendship heads into forbidden territory. And before long a line is irrevocably crossed, everything changes, and two already complicated lives take an even more dangerous course...
400 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published September 12, 2013
37 people are currently reading
1181 people want to read
About the author
Emylia Hall
22 books250 followersEmylia Hall lives with her husband and son in Bristol, where she writes from a hut in the garden and dreams of the sea. THE SHELL HOUSE DETECTIVES is her first crime novel and is inspired by her love of Cornwall’s wild landscape. Emylia has published four previous novels, including Richard and Judy Book Club pick THE BOOK OF SUMMERS and THE THOUSAND LIGHTS HOTEL. Her work has been translated into ten languages and broadcast on BBC Radio 6 Music. She is the founder of Mothership Writers and is a writing coach at The Novelry.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 108 reviews
September 11, 2013
Okay, so, I didn't really read this properly. I read about half, scanned through most of the rest, and then read the last couple of chapters. The reason I am giving it an I-liked-it rating of three stars anyway is that I don't think I am really the right audience for this book, and I think it would be unfair for me to write a bad review when my problems lie with some of the details of what happens, and not with the author's ability to create atmosphere or tell a story.
The book is set in the French-speaking Swiss city of Lausanne, where English student Hadley Dunn spends a year studying abroad. While content with life, Hadley feels that nothing really remarkable has ever happened to her - she still lives with her parents, studying at a university in the local town - and when an acquaintance suggests that she wouldn't be able to cope with international study, she becomes determined to break away and have an adventure. She immediately develops a passion for Lausanne, which deepens when she forms a close friendship with a fellow international student, Kristina, who lives in the next room at their shared lodgings. The only obstacle to Hadley and Kristina's bond is the latter's mysterious relationship with Jacques, her ever-absent boyfriend, about whom she is extremely secretive. Meanwhile, Hadley is developing a dangerous crush on her American Literature professor, Joel Wilson, and her daydreams about him slowly change to suspicions that he may feel something for her too.
A Heart Bent Out of Shape is, as far as I know, being marketed as adult fiction, but I think it would do better out of being positioned as a young adult novel, or perhaps part of that tenuous new adult genre. Hadley's age (she's 19 and turns 20 during the course of the story) and the themes of the novel (coming of age, first love, finding yourself in a place far away from home) fit perfectly within that category. Personally, I just couldn't get past the thought that it was weird and creepy for Joel to be so interested in Hadley, to the point of roaming Lausanne's streets looking for her on the night of her birthday. I'm sure if I'd been reading the book when I was quite a bit younger, I would have seen all this as romantic, but from an older perspective all I could think was if I knew someone like Joel who was my age (let alone almost forty) and following one of his students around like this, I'd be telling him to pull himself together and get a grip and/or some professional help.
I liked the fact that the twist at the end . I felt Hadley was a little bit blank and could have been a more distinctive character, but I did like her friendships with both Kristina and Hugo. I thought the students at Les Ormes were all really well-written too, especially considering that some of them didn't appear that often. From my point of view, the main strength of the narrative was in the author's portrayal of Lausanne - a romantic portrait which brought the city to life for me and made me want to go there. I could certainly understand why Hadley fell in love with the place, which compensated a little bit for the fact that I couldn't understand her similar feelings about Joel.
For me, this didn't match up to Hall's equally evocative debut, The Book of Summers. I like the author's style and she has a fantastic ability to create a sense of place and completely immerse the reader in whatever the setting happens to be; I just wasn't particularly interested in or engaged by the story told here. I would definitely recommend A Heart Bent Out of Shape to teenage readers, but think it's perhaps best left to them. If you're above 20, I wouldn't bother.
The book is set in the French-speaking Swiss city of Lausanne, where English student Hadley Dunn spends a year studying abroad. While content with life, Hadley feels that nothing really remarkable has ever happened to her - she still lives with her parents, studying at a university in the local town - and when an acquaintance suggests that she wouldn't be able to cope with international study, she becomes determined to break away and have an adventure. She immediately develops a passion for Lausanne, which deepens when she forms a close friendship with a fellow international student, Kristina, who lives in the next room at their shared lodgings. The only obstacle to Hadley and Kristina's bond is the latter's mysterious relationship with Jacques, her ever-absent boyfriend, about whom she is extremely secretive. Meanwhile, Hadley is developing a dangerous crush on her American Literature professor, Joel Wilson, and her daydreams about him slowly change to suspicions that he may feel something for her too.
A Heart Bent Out of Shape is, as far as I know, being marketed as adult fiction, but I think it would do better out of being positioned as a young adult novel, or perhaps part of that tenuous new adult genre. Hadley's age (she's 19 and turns 20 during the course of the story) and the themes of the novel (coming of age, first love, finding yourself in a place far away from home) fit perfectly within that category. Personally, I just couldn't get past the thought that it was weird and creepy for Joel to be so interested in Hadley, to the point of roaming Lausanne's streets looking for her on the night of her birthday. I'm sure if I'd been reading the book when I was quite a bit younger, I would have seen all this as romantic, but from an older perspective all I could think was if I knew someone like Joel who was my age (let alone almost forty) and following one of his students around like this, I'd be telling him to pull himself together and get a grip and/or some professional help.
I liked the fact that the twist at the end . I felt Hadley was a little bit blank and could have been a more distinctive character, but I did like her friendships with both Kristina and Hugo. I thought the students at Les Ormes were all really well-written too, especially considering that some of them didn't appear that often. From my point of view, the main strength of the narrative was in the author's portrayal of Lausanne - a romantic portrait which brought the city to life for me and made me want to go there. I could certainly understand why Hadley fell in love with the place, which compensated a little bit for the fact that I couldn't understand her similar feelings about Joel.
For me, this didn't match up to Hall's equally evocative debut, The Book of Summers. I like the author's style and she has a fantastic ability to create a sense of place and completely immerse the reader in whatever the setting happens to be; I just wasn't particularly interested in or engaged by the story told here. I would definitely recommend A Heart Bent Out of Shape to teenage readers, but think it's perhaps best left to them. If you're above 20, I wouldn't bother.
August 14, 2013
I thought The Book of Summers was a beautifully written debut novel by a gifted new writer, and this captivating second novel by Emylia Hall confirms that talent.
Hadley Dunn is studying English at University, her life quiet and contented, when she discovers there is the opportunity to spend a year abroad in Lausanne, Switzerland. She’s still living happily at home, yet, realising this would be a year of freedom and opportunity for her, she grasps it. There she becomes firm friends with Kristina, an enigmatic Danish student. However, one snowy evening there is tragedy. Hadley turns in her anguish to Joel, her American Literature professor, with whom she feels a connection and a shared passion for Hemingway. As they join forces to unravel the mystery of what happened, their relationship looks set to develop beyond the bounds of friendship.
Emylia Hall writes beautiful prose and through her compelling narrative she captures that sense of curiosity and excitement experienced in spending a year overseas when you are young and eager, and the world feels so ripe for discovery and promises new experiences.
The beautiful, enchanting setting of Lausanne is vividly evoked; the lake, the mountains, the people were all conjured up as I read, and the place holds a charismatic presence over the tale.
I had a year abroad myself and I think the author captures this experience wonderfully. I believed in Hadley’s world utterly and felt her sheer delight and her terrible sadness. I was drawn into the characters’ lives, from handsome, damaged Joel, to wise old Hugo.
This is a poignant coming-of-age story of first love, desire, friendship, tragedy, grief and self-discovery in a stunning location.
Hadley Dunn is studying English at University, her life quiet and contented, when she discovers there is the opportunity to spend a year abroad in Lausanne, Switzerland. She’s still living happily at home, yet, realising this would be a year of freedom and opportunity for her, she grasps it. There she becomes firm friends with Kristina, an enigmatic Danish student. However, one snowy evening there is tragedy. Hadley turns in her anguish to Joel, her American Literature professor, with whom she feels a connection and a shared passion for Hemingway. As they join forces to unravel the mystery of what happened, their relationship looks set to develop beyond the bounds of friendship.
Emylia Hall writes beautiful prose and through her compelling narrative she captures that sense of curiosity and excitement experienced in spending a year overseas when you are young and eager, and the world feels so ripe for discovery and promises new experiences.
The beautiful, enchanting setting of Lausanne is vividly evoked; the lake, the mountains, the people were all conjured up as I read, and the place holds a charismatic presence over the tale.
I had a year abroad myself and I think the author captures this experience wonderfully. I believed in Hadley’s world utterly and felt her sheer delight and her terrible sadness. I was drawn into the characters’ lives, from handsome, damaged Joel, to wise old Hugo.
This is a poignant coming-of-age story of first love, desire, friendship, tragedy, grief and self-discovery in a stunning location.
March 14, 2020
Absolutely gorgeous setting, ideally read in winter to help you appreciate the beauty of a fresh frost and cold, clear air. The first half is a great exploration of the city as a study-abroad student with a new friend, as well as a smattering of scenes from a literature class, and the second grieves the loss of that friend while replacing it with a swoon-worthy student/teacher romance.
There ends up being a physical component to it, but it's a fairly slow burn nevertheless, and I wouldn't say that's the main draw. The only reason they start spending time together outside class is because she wants help trying to find her friend's lover to tell him what happened, and the teacher has endured the same kind of loss/grief that she's going through.
Rounding out the story are Hadley's conversations with Hugo Bezier, a charming retired writer she runs into by chance at a hotel bar and continues to randomly meet for Cognac & conversation, particularly after her friend dies. He's wise counsel, and also a general delight.
There ends up being a physical component to it, but it's a fairly slow burn nevertheless, and I wouldn't say that's the main draw. The only reason they start spending time together outside class is because she wants help trying to find her friend's lover to tell him what happened, and the teacher has endured the same kind of loss/grief that she's going through.
Rounding out the story are Hadley's conversations with Hugo Bezier, a charming retired writer she runs into by chance at a hotel bar and continues to randomly meet for Cognac & conversation, particularly after her friend dies. He's wise counsel, and also a general delight.
March 8, 2014
Paperback Publication Date: March 13th 2014 from Headline.
For Hadley Dunn, life so far has been uneventful – no great loves, no searing losses. But that’s before she decides to spend a year studying in the glittering Swiss city of Lausanne, a place that feels alive with promise. Here Hadley meets Kristina, a beautiful but elusive Danish girl, and the two quickly form the strongest of bonds. Yet one November night, as the first snows of winter arrive, tragedy strikes.
I adored “The Book of Summers” so was eager to read the next novel from Emylia Hall and if anything I probably adored this one even more but in a very different way.
This is a love story, a coming of age tale with a hint of mystery that flows gently off the page, first embedding you into the beauty of Lausanne seen through fresh new eyes, then taking you on a journey. Hadley’s journey, as she forms friendships, falls in love, suffers a tragic loss and comes to terms with it. Beautifully done, utterly captivating and at times a very emotional experience.
I loved the characters – Hadley herself, so determined to make the most of her year, the eclectic group of students she finds herself housed with – Chase I was particularly fond of and would have liked to know more about – some whom I was not so fond of. And of course Kristina, perfectly drawn, slightly bohemian Kristina – Hadley’s constant companion and friend, someone who dazzles her and shows her an unexpected life. As they find Lausanne together their relationship is compelling.
Ms Hall is developing a trademark with her settings – in the evocative “The Book Of Summers” I ended up determined to visit Hungary. Now, I am equally determined to visit Switzerland. Her own experience of the places that provide the backdrop to her stories makes them pop off the page as real, living breathing entities in their own right. I love that I kind of feel I have already visited. I have a half formed plan to await a few more novels from her and then go on a whistlestop actual tour of all the places I’m sure I’m going to be visiting virtually during the next few years. I can’t wait to find out where next…
Overall another wonderful read, another peak into another place and another life – one that will make you ponder life and love, joy and pain, with some realistic and heartfelt characters that will stay with you. I miss Hugo already.
Happy Reading Folks!
For Hadley Dunn, life so far has been uneventful – no great loves, no searing losses. But that’s before she decides to spend a year studying in the glittering Swiss city of Lausanne, a place that feels alive with promise. Here Hadley meets Kristina, a beautiful but elusive Danish girl, and the two quickly form the strongest of bonds. Yet one November night, as the first snows of winter arrive, tragedy strikes.
I adored “The Book of Summers” so was eager to read the next novel from Emylia Hall and if anything I probably adored this one even more but in a very different way.
This is a love story, a coming of age tale with a hint of mystery that flows gently off the page, first embedding you into the beauty of Lausanne seen through fresh new eyes, then taking you on a journey. Hadley’s journey, as she forms friendships, falls in love, suffers a tragic loss and comes to terms with it. Beautifully done, utterly captivating and at times a very emotional experience.
I loved the characters – Hadley herself, so determined to make the most of her year, the eclectic group of students she finds herself housed with – Chase I was particularly fond of and would have liked to know more about – some whom I was not so fond of. And of course Kristina, perfectly drawn, slightly bohemian Kristina – Hadley’s constant companion and friend, someone who dazzles her and shows her an unexpected life. As they find Lausanne together their relationship is compelling.
Ms Hall is developing a trademark with her settings – in the evocative “The Book Of Summers” I ended up determined to visit Hungary. Now, I am equally determined to visit Switzerland. Her own experience of the places that provide the backdrop to her stories makes them pop off the page as real, living breathing entities in their own right. I love that I kind of feel I have already visited. I have a half formed plan to await a few more novels from her and then go on a whistlestop actual tour of all the places I’m sure I’m going to be visiting virtually during the next few years. I can’t wait to find out where next…
Overall another wonderful read, another peak into another place and another life – one that will make you ponder life and love, joy and pain, with some realistic and heartfelt characters that will stay with you. I miss Hugo already.
Happy Reading Folks!
November 17, 2013
A beautiful prologue about Lausanne and its effect. From the very beginning I felt the magic of this place …
Beginning with Hadley observing a fellow student looking through the brochure for L’Institut Vaudois we find out how Hadley has stayed in her home town for Uni and how inexperienced she is with life. Family is the focus and mainstay for her.
She’s ready for change though and on the brink. Her perceptions are changing as she takes a step out of that ordinary life …
Hall captures the excitement of exploring a new place. Lausanne comes alive for the reader and places us right by Hadley’s side. I felt the cadences of emotion, settling into halls, making friends.
On her first night out in Lausanne, Hadley decides to walk home after the pub. With all her emotions and senses heightened, she wants to ‘feel’ where she will be making her home for the next year. A voice out of the dark halts her. A brief exchange and she’s on her way.
And then there’s Kristina.
Their bond is there from the beginning, one seemingly balancing the other. Kristina appearing so sophisticated and worldwise against Hadley’s naiveté. Kristina’s mysterious boyfriend Jacques does change their friendship. I did have my suspicions about who he was, although I was wrong on that count, I was right on another.
I also enjoyed the friendship between Hadley and Hugo Bezier. An aging customer in the hotel who she bumps into time and again and who becomes important to her. Not quite a fatherly figure (he’s mourning the loss of his youth), after the tragedy he makes suggestions that lead Hadley on the wrong path (and the reader :) ). Hadley is a catalyst for him that I hadn’t foreseen. I loved that she enriched his life!
So, we know from the blurb that something tragic is going to happen – the seed is already there. With the build up there is no surprise when it comes. However, we get to see another side to Lausanne. The veneer of magic, like all ‘perfect’ places in the world, has an undertow …
Before the tragedy, Hadley has growing feelings for Joel, her literature professor, and often replays the sentences and looks that pass between them (I remember those days well!) He is her first port of call. There is something dark and menacing underlying their relationship as they investigate and become closer and closer. The love is raw and intense with that feeling of anxiety always below the surface.
A Heart Bent Out Of Shape is so poignant. The story of a girl who hasn’t suffered any grief in her life but who comes alive emotionally and feels the blackness of sorrow and confusion of love. Although Hadley does spend time in halls, establishments in Lausanne and with others, this is primarily a journey in isolation. She is such a fabulous character. I still think about her now!
I loved the pace of the plot unfolding, the characters, the place. From the very beginning I have been totally swept up in Hadley’s world in Lausanne. Hall’s writing paints the scenes in vivid detail. One life ended, another life finding meaning again and a waking of emotions. I highly recommend you add A Heart Bent Out Of Shape to your reading list.
I would like to thank @BenWillisUK for offering a copy in exchange for an honest review.
Beginning with Hadley observing a fellow student looking through the brochure for L’Institut Vaudois we find out how Hadley has stayed in her home town for Uni and how inexperienced she is with life. Family is the focus and mainstay for her.
She’s ready for change though and on the brink. Her perceptions are changing as she takes a step out of that ordinary life …
Hall captures the excitement of exploring a new place. Lausanne comes alive for the reader and places us right by Hadley’s side. I felt the cadences of emotion, settling into halls, making friends.
On her first night out in Lausanne, Hadley decides to walk home after the pub. With all her emotions and senses heightened, she wants to ‘feel’ where she will be making her home for the next year. A voice out of the dark halts her. A brief exchange and she’s on her way.
And then there’s Kristina.
Their bond is there from the beginning, one seemingly balancing the other. Kristina appearing so sophisticated and worldwise against Hadley’s naiveté. Kristina’s mysterious boyfriend Jacques does change their friendship. I did have my suspicions about who he was, although I was wrong on that count, I was right on another.
I also enjoyed the friendship between Hadley and Hugo Bezier. An aging customer in the hotel who she bumps into time and again and who becomes important to her. Not quite a fatherly figure (he’s mourning the loss of his youth), after the tragedy he makes suggestions that lead Hadley on the wrong path (and the reader :) ). Hadley is a catalyst for him that I hadn’t foreseen. I loved that she enriched his life!
So, we know from the blurb that something tragic is going to happen – the seed is already there. With the build up there is no surprise when it comes. However, we get to see another side to Lausanne. The veneer of magic, like all ‘perfect’ places in the world, has an undertow …
Before the tragedy, Hadley has growing feelings for Joel, her literature professor, and often replays the sentences and looks that pass between them (I remember those days well!) He is her first port of call. There is something dark and menacing underlying their relationship as they investigate and become closer and closer. The love is raw and intense with that feeling of anxiety always below the surface.
A Heart Bent Out Of Shape is so poignant. The story of a girl who hasn’t suffered any grief in her life but who comes alive emotionally and feels the blackness of sorrow and confusion of love. Although Hadley does spend time in halls, establishments in Lausanne and with others, this is primarily a journey in isolation. She is such a fabulous character. I still think about her now!
I loved the pace of the plot unfolding, the characters, the place. From the very beginning I have been totally swept up in Hadley’s world in Lausanne. Hall’s writing paints the scenes in vivid detail. One life ended, another life finding meaning again and a waking of emotions. I highly recommend you add A Heart Bent Out Of Shape to your reading list.
I would like to thank @BenWillisUK for offering a copy in exchange for an honest review.
February 15, 2018
A fun and quick read. The author beautifully captured the magic of Lausanne and the glamorous lifestyle of its inhabitants. I didn't quite understand the link between Hadley and Kristina--their friendship did not seem as deep or true as Hadley thought it was, and it didn't make sense that Hadley became so obsessed with finding Jacques after Kristina died. In general, Hadley seemed naive and unable to think for herself, and I found myself increasingly annoyed with her as the book wore on, especially in how she treated Joel. Still, I enjoyed the book overall and would like to read more from this author.
November 8, 2013
I loved Emylia Hall’s first novel, The Book of Summers, so I was always going to be looking out for more of her writing, but I suspect that a lovely title, a beautiful cover, and an intriguing title would have pulled me into this, her second novel, even if I’d had no idea who she was.
This is Hadley’s story. She was in her first year at university, still living at home, and shed had a smooth passage through life. She was bright, she was pretty, she was bookish and she came from a happy family. But she was beginning to realise how much the world had to offer, and she seized the chance of a year studying in the Swiss city of Lausanne.
Hadley was captivated by the city, by the student community, by the books she was studying; and she formed a close friendship with Kristina, a Danish student who was just a little more sophisticated than her.
The early part of the story was quiet and uneventful, but it was lovely. Emylia Hall writes beautifully and she brought the city to life. I saw the people, the places, the lake, the mountains; I saw everything so clearly through Hadley’s eyes. And I felt her curiosity, her excitement, her realisation that life was full of possibilities.
I loved the friendship between Hadley and Kristina; I loved Hadley’s chats with an elderly writer she met on her first night in the city, they were a lovely counterpoint to the main storyline; and I loved the way she fell in love with the books she read as she studied the lost generation.
Hadley was devastated when Kristina was killed, in an accident that seemed quite inexplicable. As she struggles to cope with the first loss of her life she realises just how alone she is, without her family and so far away from home. Looking for support, she leans on her American literature professor. He helps her to uncover the events that led to Kristina’s death, and they become close; maybe too close …
The story was simple, and a little predictable, but that really didn’t matter, because it was emotionally pitch-perfect. Hadley’s complecx emotions; her friends’ reactions; her parents response, when she tells then what happened. They were all caught beautifully, but I was particularly taken with Hadley’s parents, who loved her, who wanted to protect her, but who knew it was time for her to grow up.
That might be because I’m from their generation, and I suspect that this book might speak more profoundly to readers nearer Hadley’s age.
But that’s not to say that I didn’t find many things to love. I loved the way I was transported to a city I’d never visited and that I now feel I know do well. I loved the way I was reminded of what it was like to be part of a group of students, at that wonderful point in life. And I loved watching Hadley learn and grow.
I’m inclined to call ‘A Heart Bent Out of Shape’ a lovely light read, with serious underpinnings …..
This is Hadley’s story. She was in her first year at university, still living at home, and shed had a smooth passage through life. She was bright, she was pretty, she was bookish and she came from a happy family. But she was beginning to realise how much the world had to offer, and she seized the chance of a year studying in the Swiss city of Lausanne.
Hadley was captivated by the city, by the student community, by the books she was studying; and she formed a close friendship with Kristina, a Danish student who was just a little more sophisticated than her.
The early part of the story was quiet and uneventful, but it was lovely. Emylia Hall writes beautifully and she brought the city to life. I saw the people, the places, the lake, the mountains; I saw everything so clearly through Hadley’s eyes. And I felt her curiosity, her excitement, her realisation that life was full of possibilities.
I loved the friendship between Hadley and Kristina; I loved Hadley’s chats with an elderly writer she met on her first night in the city, they were a lovely counterpoint to the main storyline; and I loved the way she fell in love with the books she read as she studied the lost generation.
Hadley was devastated when Kristina was killed, in an accident that seemed quite inexplicable. As she struggles to cope with the first loss of her life she realises just how alone she is, without her family and so far away from home. Looking for support, she leans on her American literature professor. He helps her to uncover the events that led to Kristina’s death, and they become close; maybe too close …
The story was simple, and a little predictable, but that really didn’t matter, because it was emotionally pitch-perfect. Hadley’s complecx emotions; her friends’ reactions; her parents response, when she tells then what happened. They were all caught beautifully, but I was particularly taken with Hadley’s parents, who loved her, who wanted to protect her, but who knew it was time for her to grow up.
That might be because I’m from their generation, and I suspect that this book might speak more profoundly to readers nearer Hadley’s age.
But that’s not to say that I didn’t find many things to love. I loved the way I was transported to a city I’d never visited and that I now feel I know do well. I loved the way I was reminded of what it was like to be part of a group of students, at that wonderful point in life. And I loved watching Hadley learn and grow.
I’m inclined to call ‘A Heart Bent Out of Shape’ a lovely light read, with serious underpinnings …..
January 31, 2014
Original review found at http://kristineandterri.blogspot.ca/2...
* I won a copy of this book in a Goodreads giveaway in exchange for an honest review.*
I had mixed emotions when it came to this book. On one hand, I adored the setting and the description of Lausanne and felt that it was a story in itself. Reading how Hadley viewed the city and landscape was pure pleasure. On the other hand, the story that happens within the beautiful landscape fell a little bit short. I'm not sure if it was meant to be a love story, a mystery or a story of friendship.
The friendship between Hadley and Kristina felt a little one sided in my opinion and Hadley seemed almost creepily obsessed with Kristina even before tragedy struck. Initially I thought that this was going to be the "love" story because of how strange the friendship felt to me. When it became clear that it was not Kristina that Hadley desired but Joel I just couldn't feel the chemistry or emotion. To use a phrase from the book, I was "Switzerland" when it came to their relationship. Mix in a mysterious ex lover, an insightful old man (Hugo) and a hit and run and you have a story that is all over the map.
I didn't dislike the book but I didn't love it either. Hadley was a little annoying and naive and the story was totally predictable. In fact, I had the ending figured out very early on in the book. There are some beautiful moments, mostly in the descriptions of the setting and the interactions between Hadley and Hugo but the rest lacked the emotion that I desired.
* I won a copy of this book in a Goodreads giveaway in exchange for an honest review.*
I had mixed emotions when it came to this book. On one hand, I adored the setting and the description of Lausanne and felt that it was a story in itself. Reading how Hadley viewed the city and landscape was pure pleasure. On the other hand, the story that happens within the beautiful landscape fell a little bit short. I'm not sure if it was meant to be a love story, a mystery or a story of friendship.
The friendship between Hadley and Kristina felt a little one sided in my opinion and Hadley seemed almost creepily obsessed with Kristina even before tragedy struck. Initially I thought that this was going to be the "love" story because of how strange the friendship felt to me. When it became clear that it was not Kristina that Hadley desired but Joel I just couldn't feel the chemistry or emotion. To use a phrase from the book, I was "Switzerland" when it came to their relationship. Mix in a mysterious ex lover, an insightful old man (Hugo) and a hit and run and you have a story that is all over the map.
I didn't dislike the book but I didn't love it either. Hadley was a little annoying and naive and the story was totally predictable. In fact, I had the ending figured out very early on in the book. There are some beautiful moments, mostly in the descriptions of the setting and the interactions between Hadley and Hugo but the rest lacked the emotion that I desired.
March 1, 2015
Hadley leaves her simple English life to travel to Lausanne, Switzerland for a year's study abroad. She immediately befriends the beautiful and mysterious, Kristina, and the two embark on a friendship riddled with secrets. When a tragic accident happens the night of Hadley's birthday, Hadley tries to decipher the secrets and make sense of a senseless accident.
This book, apparently somewhat based on Hall's own experiences studying abroad in Lausanne, puts a stunning city on display (I was especially bewitched by the city in the Christmas scenes). The plot, who at points seemed not too complex, actually quite surprised me. I thought I had uncovered the "secret," but when the actual truth was revealed, I found myself shocked (and a little surprised that I hadn't seen certain realities sooner). I really enjoyed this book. Hadley was a really likable main character, and being a Hemingway / Moveable Feast fan myself, the parallels drawn between Hemingway and Hadley's own experiences captivated me. Excellent winter read.
This book, apparently somewhat based on Hall's own experiences studying abroad in Lausanne, puts a stunning city on display (I was especially bewitched by the city in the Christmas scenes). The plot, who at points seemed not too complex, actually quite surprised me. I thought I had uncovered the "secret," but when the actual truth was revealed, I found myself shocked (and a little surprised that I hadn't seen certain realities sooner). I really enjoyed this book. Hadley was a really likable main character, and being a Hemingway / Moveable Feast fan myself, the parallels drawn between Hemingway and Hadley's own experiences captivated me. Excellent winter read.
December 21, 2015
I took too long reading this; I got a library book with a waiting list while I was part-way through and so had a stop-start reading experience. This book has an absolutely wonderful sense of place, first experiences and the powerful nature of friendships, it seemed to lose momentum a bit in the middle, but that might be due to picking it up again after a break of a few days. Very enjoyable.
July 4, 2017
I did a lot of skimming. I should have taken a hint from the fact that the author loved Hemingway. So, a lot of her book is people talking in bars and cafes. She also does a lot of telling instead of showing. I saw the plot twist coming. meh.
July 20, 2019
Hadley Dunn führt ein Leben, dass eigentlich völlig normal erscheint. Familie, Freunde, Uni. Kein Freund, aber auch keinen großartigen Schmerz, der sie ereilt haben könnte.
Eigentlich erscheint ihr Leben recht eintönig und genau aus diesem grund entschließt sie sich, zu einem Auslandssemster in der Schweiz.
In Lausanne am Genfer See lernt sie Kristina kennen und die beiden liegen sofort auf einer Wellenlänge.
Als ihre beste Freundin teilt sich Hadley mti der jungen Frau nicht nur den Flur, sondern auch ein Teil ihres Lebens.
Bis zu einer verhängnisvollen Nacht, der nicht nur Hadleys Leben ändert, sondern auch das der Menschen in ihrem Umfeld.
Ich muss direkt gestehen, dass ich mit dem Schreibstil große Probleme hatte. Ich habe wirklich schwer in das Buch gefunden und kann nicht mal genau sagen, woran es lag.
Vielleicht ein wenig an der Übersetzung, vielleicht hätte es mir im Original ein wenig besser gefallen?
Wer weiss das schon.
Mit Hadley als Charakterin bin ich allerdings auch nicht richtig warm geworden. Ich meine, sie war eine junge Frau, die bislang noch nicht viel in ihrem Leben erlebt hat. Zumindest empfindet sie das so.
Um diesen Umstand zu ändern,entschließt sie sich, ihr Studium in der Schweiz zu absolvieren. Die Idee dahinter hat mir sehr gefallen, ebenso wie die Landschaftsbeschreibungen der Autorin.
Ich habe mich fast direkt in die Schweiz versetzt gefühlt, an diese Uni am Genfer See.
Die Freundschaft zwischen den beiden Mädchen fand ich wirklich schön. Sie lagen direkt auf einer Wellenlänge und die beiden teilen so manches Geheimnis.
Nur aus ihrem Freund, aus dem macht Kristina ein großes Geheimnis.
Ich persönlich fand die junge Frau mit ihrer lebensfrohen Art und Weise wirklich eine Bereicherung für das Buch.
Als Kristina unerwartet stirbt, gerät Hadlyeys heile Welt erneut aus den Fügen. Dennoch beginnt sie auf eigene Faust zu ermitteln und nähert sich dabei ihrem Dozenten etwas an.
Sußerdem lernt sie Hugo kennen. Einen alten Mann, der in seinem Leben viel erlebt hat und Hadley so den einen oder anderen guten Ratschlag geben kann.
Er war zweifelsohne mein Lieblingscharakter. ♥
An sich fand ich die Storyline recht gut, aber die Umsetzung hat mir nicht so richtig gefallen. Das Ende war zum Teil vorhersehbar und hatte doch eine Überraschung parat, die ich so nicht erwartet hätte.
Alles in allem war es ein Buch, dass mich zwar durch Landschaftsbeschreibungen in die Schweiz versetzen konnte und auch Charaktere hervorgerufen hat, die sich in mein Herz geschlichen haben, aber so richtig überzeugen konnte es mich nicht.
Der schwierige Schreibstil und die Geschichte dahinter konnten mich nicht richtig überzeugen. Ich kann nicht mal genau sagen, woran es lag.
Dennoch wollte ich - allein durch Hugo und seine manchmal wirklich sehr hilfreichen Ratschläge - wissen, wie es weitergeht und ob der Unfall von Kristina wirklich nur ein Unfall war.
Kurz gesagt: Man kann es lesen, aber es ist auch kein Buch das wirklich hängen geblieben ist oder welches ich noch ein zweites Mal lesen wollen würde.
Und wenn dann nur wegen Hugo.
April 15, 2021
This story revolves around the writer’s twin loves: for the city of Lausanne [pronounced “low-zawn”] Switzerland, and for writer Ernest Hemingway, who spent a considerable time in Lausanne and wrote some of his most famous works there. I pulled this book at random off my public library’s bookshelf intrigued with the Lausanne setting because I had spent some time on Lake Geneva in Switzerland, in nearby Milan, and studied French.
I had also given my 15- year- old grandson “A Farewell to Arms” by Hemingway for Christmas, his first “grown up” book.
The flyleaf led me to expect only an easily guessed mystery plot and a breezy romance. I was wrong. There was the story within a story about Hugo the elderly writer using Hadley’s life to create a mystery novel. Also the mystery plot led me to one conclusion early on, then proved me wrong, and finally took another dramatic one eighty before the last pages. Don’t skip to the end! Finally, the story of protagonist Hadley’s (yes, Hadley was also the name of Ernest Hemingway’s first wife, explored in the novel “The Paris Wife” by Paua Mclain) affair with Joel was much deeper and ended more sadly than I could imagine. The difference between earthly reality and Hadley’s [past] blind love for Joel was this:
“Hadley held her breath. She thought of Joel Wilson, spinning on his heel at the front of the class, blasting passion, and how she had felt... as though the top of her head had come clean off, and she’d dissolved, tiny stars fizzing in the ether. He had taken so much away, but he had given that. That feeling that didn’t belong anywhere on earth, where there were fears and blizzards and dark nights and consequences and loathing and shame and pretending that things were all right when they weren’t, not even close.”
An excellent read.
I had also given my 15- year- old grandson “A Farewell to Arms” by Hemingway for Christmas, his first “grown up” book.
The flyleaf led me to expect only an easily guessed mystery plot and a breezy romance. I was wrong. There was the story within a story about Hugo the elderly writer using Hadley’s life to create a mystery novel. Also the mystery plot led me to one conclusion early on, then proved me wrong, and finally took another dramatic one eighty before the last pages. Don’t skip to the end! Finally, the story of protagonist Hadley’s (yes, Hadley was also the name of Ernest Hemingway’s first wife, explored in the novel “The Paris Wife” by Paua Mclain) affair with Joel was much deeper and ended more sadly than I could imagine. The difference between earthly reality and Hadley’s [past] blind love for Joel was this:
“Hadley held her breath. She thought of Joel Wilson, spinning on his heel at the front of the class, blasting passion, and how she had felt... as though the top of her head had come clean off, and she’d dissolved, tiny stars fizzing in the ether. He had taken so much away, but he had given that. That feeling that didn’t belong anywhere on earth, where there were fears and blizzards and dark nights and consequences and loathing and shame and pretending that things were all right when they weren’t, not even close.”
An excellent read.
April 17, 2019
The Swiss Affair, Emylia Hall
I almost stopped reading this book when I noticed that it was published by Harlequin. But, since it isn't one of those trashy romances, I gave them and it the benefit of the doubt. I'm glad I did. The novel is a romance, but one much more about the love of a place then about a love affair. Yes - it's also a love story, but that and the murder mystery that is part of that story is almost secondary to the the beauty of Lausanne, Switzerland. The novel centers around the experience of a second year British student living and studying abroad for a year, and it captures the adventure and her excitement well. The first time novelist also does a good job of making you want to see what happens as several twists and turns make for an exciting read. I guess Harlequin is publishing more high brow work, since this is well beyond a sexy love story. Not intellectual by any means but very entertaining.
I almost stopped reading this book when I noticed that it was published by Harlequin. But, since it isn't one of those trashy romances, I gave them and it the benefit of the doubt. I'm glad I did. The novel is a romance, but one much more about the love of a place then about a love affair. Yes - it's also a love story, but that and the murder mystery that is part of that story is almost secondary to the the beauty of Lausanne, Switzerland. The novel centers around the experience of a second year British student living and studying abroad for a year, and it captures the adventure and her excitement well. The first time novelist also does a good job of making you want to see what happens as several twists and turns make for an exciting read. I guess Harlequin is publishing more high brow work, since this is well beyond a sexy love story. Not intellectual by any means but very entertaining.
January 19, 2019
Der Klappentext passt nicht ganz zum Buch. Ich hatte die Vorstellung, dass Hadley erst eine leidenschaftliche Beziehung beginnt und dann ein Unglück in ihrem Leben passiert. Tatsächlich ist es andersherum. Und von der "leidenschaft" merkt man nicht viel, außer "dass sie zu Boden sinken", der Rest ist der eigenen Phantasie überlassen. Die Beziehung steht nicht im Vordergrund ist aber trotzdem wichtig. Hadleys Versuche das Unglück aufzuklären beschert ihr unerwartet neue Bekannte, die zu Freunden werden und ihr durch diese schwere Zeit helfen.
Besonders die Figur Hugo hat mir besonders gefallen. Ein alter Mann, der schon etwas gebrechlich ist, freundet sich mit Hadley an und ist zeitweise ihre einzige Stütze. Kristina hat mir mit ihrer lebensfrohen Art einige Schmunzler und etwas Kopfschütteln beschert. Lediglich mit Hadley bin ich absolut nicht warmgeworden.
Besonders die Figur Hugo hat mir besonders gefallen. Ein alter Mann, der schon etwas gebrechlich ist, freundet sich mit Hadley an und ist zeitweise ihre einzige Stütze. Kristina hat mir mit ihrer lebensfrohen Art einige Schmunzler und etwas Kopfschütteln beschert. Lediglich mit Hadley bin ich absolut nicht warmgeworden.
March 14, 2025
Wat een geweldig verhaal met een onverwachte plot. Het is heel poëtisch geschreven verhaal over een jonge pientere vrouw die aan het begin van haar volwassen leven iets ongelofelijk prachtig meemaakt geboren uit een vreselijk en ingrijpende gebeurtenis. Hoe de stad en de emoties die deze oproept bij de personages worden beschreven laten je ook op afstand verliefd worden, de schrijver neemt je hier in mee.
February 17, 2018
This never really grabbed me; it felt all a bit cliche and I never really connected to the characters. That said, I was actually surprised by the ending - the first 'twist' was something I'd seen coming for ages, but the second was unexpected. I also loved the descriptions of the town, and the landscape; definitely made me want to visit Switzerland!
July 26, 2018
Based on what I'd enjoyed about Hall's first book, The Book of Summers, I looked forward to some kind of surprise romantic happy ending. As the story got closer and closer to its end, though, that became less and less possible. Affair rightly connotes something temporary and perhaps complicated. So the title was spot on!
January 19, 2020
The beginning of this was so slow that I almost gave up on it a few times. It picks up in the middle and is a bit of a wild ride until the end. I thought I’d figured it out, but was surprised when I hadn’t!
I didn’t like the college setting, the romance, or the poncey literary stuff but I loved the setting of Switzerland!
I didn’t like the college setting, the romance, or the poncey literary stuff but I loved the setting of Switzerland!
April 4, 2024
This was a little disappointing after reading Emylia Hall's more recent books. I was at a loss as to when it was set, even having mobile phones and internet doesn't really date it. Some of the characters seemed to be from 60s in their language and actiions. Good to see she improved as a writer in the decade since!
September 7, 2017
I enjoyed this book, unusual plot, with a fairly sad ending, felt sorry for Joel.
May 12, 2019
Good story.....unexpected happenings !!!
January 19, 2021
Entretenido y muy invernal.
Si bien el final es algo sorprendente, hubiera preferido algo más positivo para la pareja, pero la autora ha optado por la opción más realista.
Si bien el final es algo sorprendente, hubiera preferido algo más positivo para la pareja, pero la autora ha optado por la opción más realista.
Read
May 16, 2022Dnf…
Beautiful cover, but I'm having a hard time getting into the story…
Beautiful cover, but I'm having a hard time getting into the story…
June 30, 2024
I liked the premise but I couldn't buy into the coincidence at the end.
April 7, 2018
The only thing interesting about this book was the location. The author seems to have a near spiritual love for the city of Lausanne, and she does an excellent job of making you feel as if you are experiencing the city in its glory and its darkness. The story itself, though, was boring, and the book was much too long. The characters were not well-developed, and I could not connect to any of them. Their motivations made no sense. I couldn't understand why Joel did what he did, nor why Hadley was so obsessed with Kristina, a person she seemed to know for a couple of weeks. It took me much longer than expected to slog through the tedious dialogue, and the "twists" were entirely too predictable. Honestly if not for the author's careful crafting of the city and her deep love affair with Lausanne, it would be one star for me.
January 14, 2014
LAUSANNE Une Aventure*
Anyone who dreams of a picture book build-up to Christmas should spend December in Switzerland! "In Lausanne's old town, felt-hatted merchants in leather aprons sold brown paper bags of hot chestnuts and cups of spiced wine. Sturdy, apple-cheeked men and women set up their tables in the Place de la Palud, laying out discs of hard cheese, and bouquets of lavender. At nightfall, the frost-licked shopping streets were swept with quiet, perhaps just a blast of music as the door of a cavern bar was pulled open by the wind, or the click of an elderly man's tongue as he politely waited for his dog to do his night-time business. Christmas was approaching, and Lausanne glittered serenely, quietly."
(extract from A Heart Bent out of Shape)
As I read this novel, I truly felt enveloped by the feel of Switzerland, which is why it was a particularly great read in TripFiction terms of 'seeing a location through an author's eyes'. The neatness and propriety of La Suisse has been beautifully captured, the mountains that can overpower the view across Lake Geneva made their stunning presence felt and the swirling snow that whisked its way past old buildings adjacent to newer concrete edifices just transported me there. Over a steaming cup of coffee, a renversé as the Swiss call it, I enjoyed how the storyline, with its fluid twists and turns, was reflected in the lapping waves on Lake Geneva, just by the city of Lausanne.
Hadley has come to Lausanne for her year abroad and finds herself in student accommodation at Les Ormes. Here she meets Kristina who encourages her to come out of herself and blossom as a young woman. Kristina is open and sociable on the one hand, yet very guarded about her private life on the other, and it is the mystery of her love life that threads its way through the book. With elderly writer Hugo, Hadley begins to explore Kristina's life in a more expressive way, and she almost becomes the muse who kickstarts his own neglected writing career - she becomes his new story, and fact and fiction become blurred. But she is a grounded young woman, who deals with what life throws at her in an enthusiastic, yet sensible way.
One might guess from her name that the story isn't complete without mention of Ernest Hemingway who of course spent time travelling around Europe, writing and recording, often in the company of his first wife Hadley. And it was she, of course, who lost his manuscripts on the train as she came to join him in Lausanne. Lausanne is truly the 'city of literary greats' and the author even has her character pondering (as she immerses herself in the torrents of sorrow in Hemingway's A Farewell to Arms) "why more stories weren't set in the shine of Lausanne" with its expansive boulevards and frosted buildings, exotic sprays of palm and silver stretches of water....
This is a particularly great read not only for Swissophiles, but for anyone embarking on their year abroad in order to study; it has a developed storyline, and it also deals with the hardships and joys of being in a new environment, forging new friends and understanding a new culture. And to crown it all, it also takes you on a bit of a skiing adventure. So put your feet up by the fire and enjoy a bit of indulgent reading. This novel ticks all the boxes. And let's hope the Lausanne Tourist Board can be persuaded to stock copies in their shops - reading novels set in location is just a great way to get to know a place and by reading this novel you will certainly get under the skin of this pretty city.
*Une Aventure in French is translated as an 'affair' in English.
Anyone who dreams of a picture book build-up to Christmas should spend December in Switzerland! "In Lausanne's old town, felt-hatted merchants in leather aprons sold brown paper bags of hot chestnuts and cups of spiced wine. Sturdy, apple-cheeked men and women set up their tables in the Place de la Palud, laying out discs of hard cheese, and bouquets of lavender. At nightfall, the frost-licked shopping streets were swept with quiet, perhaps just a blast of music as the door of a cavern bar was pulled open by the wind, or the click of an elderly man's tongue as he politely waited for his dog to do his night-time business. Christmas was approaching, and Lausanne glittered serenely, quietly."
(extract from A Heart Bent out of Shape)
As I read this novel, I truly felt enveloped by the feel of Switzerland, which is why it was a particularly great read in TripFiction terms of 'seeing a location through an author's eyes'. The neatness and propriety of La Suisse has been beautifully captured, the mountains that can overpower the view across Lake Geneva made their stunning presence felt and the swirling snow that whisked its way past old buildings adjacent to newer concrete edifices just transported me there. Over a steaming cup of coffee, a renversé as the Swiss call it, I enjoyed how the storyline, with its fluid twists and turns, was reflected in the lapping waves on Lake Geneva, just by the city of Lausanne.
Hadley has come to Lausanne for her year abroad and finds herself in student accommodation at Les Ormes. Here she meets Kristina who encourages her to come out of herself and blossom as a young woman. Kristina is open and sociable on the one hand, yet very guarded about her private life on the other, and it is the mystery of her love life that threads its way through the book. With elderly writer Hugo, Hadley begins to explore Kristina's life in a more expressive way, and she almost becomes the muse who kickstarts his own neglected writing career - she becomes his new story, and fact and fiction become blurred. But she is a grounded young woman, who deals with what life throws at her in an enthusiastic, yet sensible way.
One might guess from her name that the story isn't complete without mention of Ernest Hemingway who of course spent time travelling around Europe, writing and recording, often in the company of his first wife Hadley. And it was she, of course, who lost his manuscripts on the train as she came to join him in Lausanne. Lausanne is truly the 'city of literary greats' and the author even has her character pondering (as she immerses herself in the torrents of sorrow in Hemingway's A Farewell to Arms) "why more stories weren't set in the shine of Lausanne" with its expansive boulevards and frosted buildings, exotic sprays of palm and silver stretches of water....
This is a particularly great read not only for Swissophiles, but for anyone embarking on their year abroad in order to study; it has a developed storyline, and it also deals with the hardships and joys of being in a new environment, forging new friends and understanding a new culture. And to crown it all, it also takes you on a bit of a skiing adventure. So put your feet up by the fire and enjoy a bit of indulgent reading. This novel ticks all the boxes. And let's hope the Lausanne Tourist Board can be persuaded to stock copies in their shops - reading novels set in location is just a great way to get to know a place and by reading this novel you will certainly get under the skin of this pretty city.
*Une Aventure in French is translated as an 'affair' in English.
March 17, 2014
Review originally posted to my blog:
http://www.pagetostagereviews.com/201...
In 2012 I read Emylia Hall's The Book of Summers, which due to its flowery cover came across as a cute and flirty summer read, but it turned out to have a lot more depth than the chick-lit novel I imagined it to be. Beautifully written and non-stop engaging this was an exceptional debut and one which put the author's name on my radar. So when I read that her second novel would be released this year you can imagine my excitement, and it didn't disappoint.
A Heart Bent Out of Shape tells the story of Hadley Dunn, an American student who has lived a fairly sheltered and unimaginative life until she finds herself in the foreign and beautiful Lausanne in Switzerland. The university there is twinned with hers and while she never really considered studying abroad, she comes across the application by chance and before she knows it she is walking the vertical streets of the Swiss city and breathing the crisp air while taking in the mountains towering in the distance.
What starts of as a gentle coming of age story, mainly involving Hadley discovering new places and meeting interesting people along the way, turns into something much more profound when an terrible accident shatters what up until that point had been a blissful journey. Suddenly the city Hadley so quickly has fallen in love with shows a darker side and what follows is a confusing and emotional period for her, while at the same time the story becomes reminiscent to that of a mystery novel - which sounds like a strange combination, but it works.
Just like with The Book of Summers, the novel is set in a place that to me was foreign at the start of the story, but through the incredibly vivid descriptions - at times the sounds and smells of Lausanne practically leaped of the page while I was reading - I felt I was there with Hadley; experiencing the city through her eyes and wanderings. Not only that, but Hall managed to make it sound very appealing from a visitor's point of view and while the city wasn't on my radar before, it's now been added to my list of "must-see places".
The novel balances a beautiful setting with a poignant story in a very effective way. With lush descriptions of the people, landscape and atmosphere Hall paints a romantic and almost magical picture of Lausanne, though one with a surprisingly dark side too. The only reason A Heart Bent Out of Shape is not a solid five-star novel for me is that along the way it became somewhat predictable - thought the ending managed to take me by surprise. I was still enthralled by the beautiful storytelling, which for me was reason alone to read this novel, but the story almost took a backseat to the prose at times.
Nonetheless, this journey of self-discovery was beautiful, fascinating, heartbreaking, haunting and ultimately very profound. A Heart Bent Out of Shape is one of those rare novels that leaves an impression long after turning the final page and for that reason I've been recommending it extensively since reading it last week. It's a memorable one, this, and I look forward to seeing what enticing foreign location Hall will invite us to next.
4.5 stars
http://www.pagetostagereviews.com/201...
In 2012 I read Emylia Hall's The Book of Summers, which due to its flowery cover came across as a cute and flirty summer read, but it turned out to have a lot more depth than the chick-lit novel I imagined it to be. Beautifully written and non-stop engaging this was an exceptional debut and one which put the author's name on my radar. So when I read that her second novel would be released this year you can imagine my excitement, and it didn't disappoint.
A Heart Bent Out of Shape tells the story of Hadley Dunn, an American student who has lived a fairly sheltered and unimaginative life until she finds herself in the foreign and beautiful Lausanne in Switzerland. The university there is twinned with hers and while she never really considered studying abroad, she comes across the application by chance and before she knows it she is walking the vertical streets of the Swiss city and breathing the crisp air while taking in the mountains towering in the distance.
What starts of as a gentle coming of age story, mainly involving Hadley discovering new places and meeting interesting people along the way, turns into something much more profound when an terrible accident shatters what up until that point had been a blissful journey. Suddenly the city Hadley so quickly has fallen in love with shows a darker side and what follows is a confusing and emotional period for her, while at the same time the story becomes reminiscent to that of a mystery novel - which sounds like a strange combination, but it works.
Just like with The Book of Summers, the novel is set in a place that to me was foreign at the start of the story, but through the incredibly vivid descriptions - at times the sounds and smells of Lausanne practically leaped of the page while I was reading - I felt I was there with Hadley; experiencing the city through her eyes and wanderings. Not only that, but Hall managed to make it sound very appealing from a visitor's point of view and while the city wasn't on my radar before, it's now been added to my list of "must-see places".
The novel balances a beautiful setting with a poignant story in a very effective way. With lush descriptions of the people, landscape and atmosphere Hall paints a romantic and almost magical picture of Lausanne, though one with a surprisingly dark side too. The only reason A Heart Bent Out of Shape is not a solid five-star novel for me is that along the way it became somewhat predictable - thought the ending managed to take me by surprise. I was still enthralled by the beautiful storytelling, which for me was reason alone to read this novel, but the story almost took a backseat to the prose at times.
Nonetheless, this journey of self-discovery was beautiful, fascinating, heartbreaking, haunting and ultimately very profound. A Heart Bent Out of Shape is one of those rare novels that leaves an impression long after turning the final page and for that reason I've been recommending it extensively since reading it last week. It's a memorable one, this, and I look forward to seeing what enticing foreign location Hall will invite us to next.
4.5 stars
September 9, 2013
Hadley Dunn has lived a rather safe life, with nothing out of the ordinary ever happening to her. But when a chance to spend a year in the Swiss city of Lausanne appears, Hadley jumps at the chance to explore somewhere new, somewhere alive and full of hope. Hadley quickly befriends Kristina, a beautiful Danish girl, and they both create a strong friendship in each other. But when tragedy strikes, Hadley turns to the only other person she feels a connection with – her American Literature professor Joel Wilson. As they both try to uncover and make sense of what has happened, they are drawn closer together…
I absolutely LOVED A Heart Bent Out Of Shape! I opened the first page and I was so drawn in by what I was reading that I read the entire book in one sitting….wow.
The characters were perfectly written. I warmed to Hadley straight away, I liked how she was a girl wanting to take a chance in life and try somewhere new, have an adventure and get some excitement out of her life. I particularly loved the friendships and bonds she created. Hadley and Kristina made a lovely friendship and it reminded me of the friendships I had at college, so I could really relate to Hadley’s feelings and closeness for Kristina.
I enjoyed Hadley’s friendship with Hugo the most, it was so heart-warming and special, and it genuinely touched me. Hugo made me smile and I always looked forward to the scenes where he featured. Even after finishing the story, I miss Hugo and I was so thrilled that Emylia wrote a character like him!
I need to talk about Joel – wow. He is handsome! I completely fell in love with him from the beginning and I’m certain that he will have the same effect on many other readers too! He made me want to rush out and buy a plane ticket straight there, to capture and take in the beautiful sights, and fall in love.
The setting was beautiful. I loved the descriptions of Lausanne and whilst I was reading I felt as though I had been transported there and was wandering the streets, gazing at the relaxing lake and looking up at the stunning mountains in front of me. Lausanne had a touch of magic for me, it felt exciting and new and I could sense Hadley’s heart full of hope as she arrived unknown in this beautiful city.
The element of mystery and suspense was fantastic. I became really involved in the plot line, and like Hadley I was desperate to know what had happened, I was even formulating events in my head and I was racing through the pages because I was keen to see what Hadley would discover next. At times my heart raced, my breath caught in my chest, and I was very much rooting for Hadley throughout. It was a very emotional read too, I had a tear in my eye at some points, and I became truly lost in this wonderful story.
I thoroughly enjoyed this, and I’d go as far to say that A Heart Bent Out Of Shape is one of my favourite novels that I have read this year! It is a gripping story full of romance, secrets, loss and hope. I honestly am so excited to have discovered an author like Emylia Hall and I can’t wait to read her future releases! A stunning novel.
I absolutely LOVED A Heart Bent Out Of Shape! I opened the first page and I was so drawn in by what I was reading that I read the entire book in one sitting….wow.
The characters were perfectly written. I warmed to Hadley straight away, I liked how she was a girl wanting to take a chance in life and try somewhere new, have an adventure and get some excitement out of her life. I particularly loved the friendships and bonds she created. Hadley and Kristina made a lovely friendship and it reminded me of the friendships I had at college, so I could really relate to Hadley’s feelings and closeness for Kristina.
I enjoyed Hadley’s friendship with Hugo the most, it was so heart-warming and special, and it genuinely touched me. Hugo made me smile and I always looked forward to the scenes where he featured. Even after finishing the story, I miss Hugo and I was so thrilled that Emylia wrote a character like him!
I need to talk about Joel – wow. He is handsome! I completely fell in love with him from the beginning and I’m certain that he will have the same effect on many other readers too! He made me want to rush out and buy a plane ticket straight there, to capture and take in the beautiful sights, and fall in love.
The setting was beautiful. I loved the descriptions of Lausanne and whilst I was reading I felt as though I had been transported there and was wandering the streets, gazing at the relaxing lake and looking up at the stunning mountains in front of me. Lausanne had a touch of magic for me, it felt exciting and new and I could sense Hadley’s heart full of hope as she arrived unknown in this beautiful city.
The element of mystery and suspense was fantastic. I became really involved in the plot line, and like Hadley I was desperate to know what had happened, I was even formulating events in my head and I was racing through the pages because I was keen to see what Hadley would discover next. At times my heart raced, my breath caught in my chest, and I was very much rooting for Hadley throughout. It was a very emotional read too, I had a tear in my eye at some points, and I became truly lost in this wonderful story.
I thoroughly enjoyed this, and I’d go as far to say that A Heart Bent Out Of Shape is one of my favourite novels that I have read this year! It is a gripping story full of romance, secrets, loss and hope. I honestly am so excited to have discovered an author like Emylia Hall and I can’t wait to read her future releases! A stunning novel.
March 18, 2014
I was intrigued by this book because of the description: "For Hadley Dunn, life has been predictable and uneventful. But that is before she spends her second year of college abroad in Lausanne, a glamorous Swiss city on the shores of Lake Geneva. Lausanne is imbued with the boundless sense of freedom Hadley has been seeking, and it is here she meets Kristina, a beautiful but mysterious Danish girl. The two bond quickly, but as the first snows of winter arrive, tragedy strikes." (from BookReporter.com)
So, Switzerland, new perspective and adventure, friendship, and then a mystery. Sounds great!
And, you know? It was. Hall did a really impressive job of bringing her characters to life - every one of them. From sweet and innocent Hadley to brash and fun Kristina to deep and brooding Joel to all the peripheral characters. SO much brought to life, in fact, that when the tragedy did strike, I was actually affected by it. My husband asked why I was so sad... I had to explain about the book. ;)
Hadley is a simple girl, living with her parents still, in a smallish town in England. She decides to apply for a study abroad program and goes to Lausanne, Switzerland to spend her 2nd year of college (University). There, she meets the exotic and full-of-life Kristina, who quickly becomes Hadley's best friend. She also meets Joel, her American Literature professor, a charismatic and dark personality that she is drawn to. And she meets Hugo, an elderly man who frequents a fancy hotel cafe and who imparts love, hope, and wisdom onto Hadley.
And then, yes, tragedy strikes (and heck no, I won't ruin it by stating what the tragedy is). And Hadley sets out to discover the truth about what happened, how, and about herself. It's a sort of growing-up novel, a sort of love affair novel, and a sort of mystery novel, all neatly wrapped into one.
In my opinion, the biggest downside to the novel (and it's not such a big downside :)) is that the romantic tension and lovey-dovey portion were a little run-of-the-mill in the midst of the rest of the excitement. Hall did such an impressive job bringing Lausanne to live, bringing her characters to life, bringing Hadley's obsession to life... and yet the romance was flat and uninteresting (to me). It served a purpose to moving certain aspects of the plot forward, but mostly I was just eager to get back to the real story. As I said, it's not such a big downside -- I appreciated Hall's tact in her presentation of the love affair (not "affair" in that sense -- I just mean "a happening"), that she didn't resort to cheap tricks in the bedroom, and the scenes were soft and romantic... just wasn't my favorite part of the book.
Overall, I definitely recommend to readers -- those who want to visit Lausanne, if only in their minds, those who have romantic notions about life and love, those who want to venture with Hadley as she discovers "the truth."
So, Switzerland, new perspective and adventure, friendship, and then a mystery. Sounds great!
And, you know? It was. Hall did a really impressive job of bringing her characters to life - every one of them. From sweet and innocent Hadley to brash and fun Kristina to deep and brooding Joel to all the peripheral characters. SO much brought to life, in fact, that when the tragedy did strike, I was actually affected by it. My husband asked why I was so sad... I had to explain about the book. ;)
Hadley is a simple girl, living with her parents still, in a smallish town in England. She decides to apply for a study abroad program and goes to Lausanne, Switzerland to spend her 2nd year of college (University). There, she meets the exotic and full-of-life Kristina, who quickly becomes Hadley's best friend. She also meets Joel, her American Literature professor, a charismatic and dark personality that she is drawn to. And she meets Hugo, an elderly man who frequents a fancy hotel cafe and who imparts love, hope, and wisdom onto Hadley.
And then, yes, tragedy strikes (and heck no, I won't ruin it by stating what the tragedy is). And Hadley sets out to discover the truth about what happened, how, and about herself. It's a sort of growing-up novel, a sort of love affair novel, and a sort of mystery novel, all neatly wrapped into one.
In my opinion, the biggest downside to the novel (and it's not such a big downside :)) is that the romantic tension and lovey-dovey portion were a little run-of-the-mill in the midst of the rest of the excitement. Hall did such an impressive job bringing Lausanne to live, bringing her characters to life, bringing Hadley's obsession to life... and yet the romance was flat and uninteresting (to me). It served a purpose to moving certain aspects of the plot forward, but mostly I was just eager to get back to the real story. As I said, it's not such a big downside -- I appreciated Hall's tact in her presentation of the love affair (not "affair" in that sense -- I just mean "a happening"), that she didn't resort to cheap tricks in the bedroom, and the scenes were soft and romantic... just wasn't my favorite part of the book.
Overall, I definitely recommend to readers -- those who want to visit Lausanne, if only in their minds, those who have romantic notions about life and love, those who want to venture with Hadley as she discovers "the truth."
Displaying 1 - 30 of 108 reviews