Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Color Over Occam

Rate this book
Gorman County disappeared decades ago when floodwaters rose to fill a reservoir. So why should the ghosts of drowned villages resurface only now, in a new century? And what does the reservoir have to do with the grisly deaths, disease, and disappearances stalking the benighted little town of Occam?

Amateur paranormal sleuth Jeff Slater poses these innocent questions, only to encounter hostility, intimidation, and violence wherever he turns. In this saga of Lovecraftian horror, noirish detection, and festering corruption, Slater comes to understand how little he ever knew of his hometown’s macabre history and its bizarre present. Meanwhile, those who do know of Occam’s sinister past warn him with one voice: unearthly doom is on its way. Run or die. But Slater can’t abandon his search for the truth so easily. Can he alter the fate of a town facing cosmic annihilation without destroying himself?

311 pages, Hardcover

First published January 1, 2012

62 people want to read

About the author

Jonathan Thomas

77 books16 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
2 (12%)
4 stars
6 (37%)
3 stars
6 (37%)
2 stars
2 (12%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 5 of 5 reviews
Profile Image for mark monday.
1,860 reviews6,263 followers
November 13, 2019
synopsis: there's something's in the water at Arkham Occam, and it's not good for anyone. choose La Croix!

Oh man I wanted this to be so much better than it turned out to be. I really dug Thomas' story "Tempting Providence" in the first volume of Black Wings of Cthulhu, which was a deftly written, melancholy, layered surprise. Color Over Occam shows that Thomas is a talented author, but there is a feeling of spinning wheels and painting by numbers here. Things proceed mildly - so mildly that when Occam finally goes bonkers, it came out of left field. And the version of "bonkers" here was so mildly depicted that it was hard to be surprised or impressed. I should be surprised and impressed at a whole town of people frozen into place as they are slowly being transformed into whatever they are being transformed into! I don't mind a low-key writing style, but this a low-key bridge too far. Thomas' narrator speaks in a clipped, dispatches-from-the-frontlines style of delivery, including frequently dropped articles, and while this prose experiment should have compelled me, it only added to my lack of engagement. Most egregious was the drab characterization. Hard to be scared for people who may lose their lives if they haven't come alive in the first place. Also didn't help that the protagonist is certainly the shittiest friend around - I mean the guy doesn't even check on a baby while babysitting! Or help clean a place up for a friend who is completely traumatized and helpless. Was it an intentional decision to make our hero a mild sort of douchebag who isn't particularly offensive but isn't particularly helpful - or humane? Perhaps it was, but even if that were the case, it only further served to distance me from the entire story.

So that's a lot of complaining. I do want to end on a positive note because the book is not a waste of time - its execution and characterization just needed (a lot) of improvement. Thomas has a bunch of intriguing ideas and they were on display on here, sometimes surprising me, other times disturbing me, and at least one time genuinely scaring me.
Profile Image for Justin Steele.
Author 8 books70 followers
April 19, 2013
Publisher Larry Roberts has been consistently putting out some wonderful work. Arcane Wisdom Press is one of his imprints, and one series under the imprint is the Modern Mythos Library. Lovecraft scholar S.T. Joshi and Larry Roberts have teamed up to print what S.T. Joshi's blog refers to as "vital and significant contemporary works of Cthulhu Mythos fiction by leading authors." As to date the series is two volumes strong; Cthulhu Cult by Rick Dakan, and The Color Over Occam by Jonathan Thomas.


In the introduction S.T. Joshi explains how Thomas approached him and proceeded to woo him with some short fiction. One thing led to another, and as of now Thomas has two short story collections, Midnight Call and Other Stories, and Tempting Providence and Other Stories (both of which are published by Hippocampus Press). The Color Over Occam is Thomas's first published novel, and upon reading it's easy to see why Joshi scooped up on the chance to include it in the Modern Mythos Library.


Any Lovecraft fan should read this title and instantly recognize what this novel is based on: H.P. Lovecraft's 1927 tale The Colour Out of Space. For readers who are not familiar, The Colour Out of Space is one of Lovecraft's more famous stories, and one that is more overtly science fiction than most of his other works. It also bears the distinction among Lovecraft's stories as being the one most adapted to film. The story is about a meteor that crash lands on an Arkham farm in 1882. The "being" that came with it is basically a non corporeal life form that appears as a shimmering color. Weird horror follows.


It is worth noting that it is not necessary to have read The Colour Out of Space before delving into The Color Over Occam, but of course it does enhance the reading experience to be familiar with the tale it's based on.


The novel follows Jeffrey Slater, city clerk by day and amateur paranormal sleuth by evening. Slater and his friend Wil run a public access cable show of the "ghost-hunters" variety. While out one evening investigating "corpse lights" at the local reservoir, they have a strange encounter which prompts further investigation by Jeff, leading him down a proverbial rabbit hole. It is apparent that something buried under the reservoir is finally making it's move, and is beginning to affect the town of Occam (renamed from Arkham) in numerous ways. Jeff begins a one man campaign to investigate this mystery and do what he can to save the town of Occam, although it's apparent from early on that he's fighting an uphill battle.


The entire novel is told in first-person from Jeff's point of view, and has a very noir-ish flavor all throughout. Jeff is an interesting character to follow, and is not without his faults. He is a cynic, he only has one friend, and while Jeff is intelligent he sometimes doesn't do the smartest things, although he is usually quick to catch himself after the fact. His dealings with the matter starts to induce a high level of paranoia, and it's not long before Jeff finds himself totally alone, convinced that everyone is part of a conspiracy and out to get him. As the story progresses Jeff becomes more and more obsessed with the mystery of "The Color", and makes a few desperate, ill-thought out attempts to do something about it.


While the noir style of narration is a huge strength of the novel, it's also the way in which Thomas handles the ideas and concepts from Lovecraft's stories. Thomas effectively and respectively utilizes some of the core ideas and concepts, all while making the story his own. There are some moments of hair-raising horror, and some moments of just plain strangeness. Also Lovecraft fans should pay attention to many of the character's surnames, as there are plenty there to tie many of Lovecraft's stories together in the present day setting.


It's obvious that Thomas put a lot of time and effort into this novel, and as a sequel it works perfectly. The noir-style of narration is spot on, and couldn't be done any better. In the Lovecraftian realm of fiction it is the short story and novella that dominate, and it's not very often a novel-length work comes along. The Color Over Occam is a more than welcome addition, and fans of Lovecraft's classic tale of alien horror will find a lot to enjoyable. Also, fans of supernatural noir or the X-Files wouldn't be remiss to check this one out.

Originally appeared on my blog, The Arkham Digest.
Profile Image for Jonathan.
116 reviews2 followers
November 2, 2017
Set in and around the New England town of Occam, The Color Over Occam is narrated by Occam city clerk Jeffrey Slater. Slater and his friend Wil run a public access cable show involving their investigations of the supernatural. As the novel begins, they're paddling around the city reservoir -- once farmland but flooded since the 1920's -- investigating claims of "ghost lights" on the waters at night. And they find them. But they're not ghosts.

You see, Occam was renamed from its original 'Arkham' a couple of decades back. And readers of H.P. Lovecraft's seminal horror story "The Color Out of Space" will quickly recognize that haunted reservoir...

Thomas' first novel is a witty, cynical, often satiric addition to the Cthulhu Mythos. The problems of civic politics (and politicians covering their own asses) make for a welcome new spin on cosmic horror. There are points at which The Color Over Occam is quite funny, and not always bleakly (though Thomas does bleak too!).

I think one can read The Color Over Occam without having read "The Color Out of Space." Or perhaps preferably, read or re-read Lovecraft's story AFTER reading The Color Over Occam. Thomas deftly weaves the original into his novel without imitating Lovecraft's prose or narrative emphases.

While there's drollery and a bit of comic over-emphasis at points in the narrative, the text maintains a sense of verisimilitude throughout. How would a small-town government deal with cosmic horror building in its town? How would an amateur ghost-finder deal with potentially world-shattering events? How will Slater deal with his low alcohol tolerance? Why does office work suck so much?

The Color Over Occam compares favourably with several novels I can think of. Its occasionally hapless protagonist and the cosmic but town-centric events he's trapped within remind me of Ramsey Campbell's Creatures of the Pool and The Last Revelation of Gla'aki. The office- and civic-based comedy repeatedly reminded me of William Browning Spencer's hilarious Resumé with Monsters.

But this novel is also its own self with an unusual mix of wit, satire, cosmic horror, and body horror that pay suitable homage to Lovecraft's great original without attempting to mimic "The Color Out of Space" in form, style, or mood.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
1,175 reviews4 followers
November 27, 2020
A pretty good retelling of Lovecraft's 'A color out of Space'. The Author keeps the tension building and the story rolling along nicely. The characters are for the most part believable although the story could have done with a epilog of some form
A good novel and makes me want to see what else Jonathan Thomas has written.
Profile Image for Larry.
766 reviews4 followers
March 11, 2022
A decent novel-length sequel to The Color Out of Space, set in modern times.
It's written in a peculiar, sort of breathless style where the author avoids the use of the word "I" by just starting his sentence with the verb ("Went outside and called the dog").
Displaying 1 - 5 of 5 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.