The Velvet Hammer: Judge Belvin Perry, Jr.'s Capital Murder Cases and Memoir

by Judge Belvin Perry Jr., Amy Mitchell

After retiring from twenty-five years on the bench, former chief judge Belvin Perry Jr. reveals a rare and disturbingly vivid firsthand perspective of the most gruesome death penalty cases in which he played a key role, including the infamous Casey Marie Anthony, who was dubbed “America’s Most Hated Mom” after her shocking acquittal.

The Velvet Hammer is the gripping, true-crime memoir of former Chief Judge Belvin Perry Jr., who sentenced some of Florida’s most evil and notorious murderers to death, fulfilling his oath to uphold justice. Perry provides a clear, accurate description of America’s criminal justice system and explains why the death penalty can, and should, work and how it was applied to certain capital murder cases he either prosecuted or presided over.

Perry discusses his journey as an African American growing up in the segregated South, his life as a prosecutor and chief judge, and how he ended up presiding over one of the world’s most intriguing capital murder trials of the State of Florida v. Casey Marie Anthony.

From the widow who slowly poisoned her lovers; to the lust murderer who mutilated his victim while she was still alive; to the serial killer who slayed a family of four, including his own child; as well as several other violent and frightening murders, Perry spares none of the gory details when bringing each case back to life in his debut, true crime memoir.

Genres: True Crime, Nonfiction, Memoir, Biography

336 pages, Paperback

Published September 10, 2024

Reviews

[The Bookish Elf · Rating 5 out of 5]

A Gripping Journey Through Florida's Most Notorious Capital Murder Cases

In the sweltering heat of a Florida courtroom, where the air hangs heavy with tension and the weight of life-or-death decisions, sits a man who has seen it all. Chief Judge Belvin Perry, Jr. has presided over some of the Sunshine State's most gruesome and headline-grabbing murder trials. Now, in his gripping memoir co-authored with Amy Mitchell, Perry pulls back the curtain on his quarter-century career on the bench, offering readers a rare and unflinching look at the American justice system in action.

From Segregation to the Judge's Chamber

Perry's journey from a young African American boy growing up in the segregated South to becoming one of Florida's most respected jurists is nothing short of remarkable. The son of one of Orlando's first black police officers, Perry witnessed firsthand the slow, painful progress of civil rights in America. His accounts of childhood experiences - like tasting his first hot dog at a newly desegregated Woolworth's lunch counter - are both poignant and illuminating.

But it's Perry's legal career that forms the meat of this engrossing true crime memoir. As a prosecutor, he tackled some of Florida's most heinous criminals, including the notorious "Black Widow" Judy Buenoano, who poisoned her husband and drowned her disabled son for insurance money. Perry's recollections of exhuming bodies and the nauseating stench of decomposition are not for the faint of heart, but they lend an undeniable authenticity to his narratives.

The Gavel Falls: Perry's Most Infamous Cases

Perry doesn't shy away from the controversial aspects of capital punishment. He candidly discusses the weight of sentencing eight people to death during his tenure, describing the sleepless nights and moral wrestling that accompanied each decision. His detailed accounts of these cases - from the savage quadruple murder committed by Jerry Correll to the disturbing crimes of Scott Mansfield, dubbed the "lust murderer" - are both horrifying and captivating.

But it's Perry's insider perspective on the infamous Casey Anthony trial that will likely draw many readers to this book. As the presiding judge in what he calls the "trial of the century," Perry offers unique insights into the case that captivated the nation. His frustrations with the antics of both the prosecution and defense teams are palpable, and his assessment of the controversial verdict is both measured and thought-provoking.

More Than Just True Crime

While "The Velvet Hammer" certainly delivers on its promise of gritty true crime content, it's Perry's reflections on the broader issues of justice, race, and morality that elevate this memoir above the typical genre fare. His discussions on the evolution of Florida's domestic violence laws in the wake of tragic cases like that of Karen Spencer are particularly enlightening.

Perry's writing style, likely shaped by his years of crafting legal opinions, is clear and direct. There's a no-nonsense quality to his prose that befits his reputation as a tough but fair judge. That said, moments of unexpected humor and vulnerability shine through, humanizing the man behind the robe.

A Southern Perspective on Justice

Throughout the book, Perry's Southern roots are evident. His colloquialisms lend an authentic flavor to the narrative. When describing particularly gruesome crime scenes or difficult decisions, you can almost hear the slow, deliberate drawl of a man carefully weighing his words.

One particularly affecting passage comes when Perry recalls sitting in the electric chair during a visit to death row with his law clerks:

"During one visit to the prison, I sat in the electric chair. That wooden chair with electrodes reinforced the seriousness of a death sentence, the sacred obligation of being a judge and the oath I took. As a capital murder judge, I was given the power to start the mechanism of death….

…I needed to dot all the i’s and cross all the t’s to ensure my sentences were proper for the crimes committed and the defendants I sentenced to death were fairly judged. When I stood up and walked away from that electric chair, I realized being a judge was a lonely walk. "

The Scales of Justice: Weighing the Book's Merits

Perry and Mitchell have crafted a compelling narrative that manages to be both informative and emotionally resonant. True crime aficionados will appreciate the behind-the-scenes details of high-profile cases, while those interested in the broader workings of the American justice system will find much to ponder.

Verdict: A Must-Read for True Crime Enthusiasts

In the crowded field of true crime literature, "The Velvet Hammer" stands out as a uniquely authoritative and multifaceted work. It's not just a recitation of gruesome crimes, but a thoughtful examination of justice, morality, and the human experience from a man who has seen the best and worst of humanity.

Perry's journey from a segregated childhood to the pinnacle of the Florida judicial system is inspiring, and his candid reflections on the weighty responsibilities of his position are deeply moving. Whether you're a longtime follower of high-profile criminal cases or simply curious about the inner workings of the American legal system, "The Velvet Hammer" offers a compelling and enlightening read.

Highlights:

- Insider perspective on infamous cases like Casey Anthony and Judy Buenoano
- Thoughtful examination of capital punishment and its moral implications
- Unique blend of true crime, memoir, and legal analysis
- Authentic Southern voice brings the Florida courtroom to life

Who Should Read This Book:

- True crime enthusiasts
- Legal professionals and law students
- Those interested in social justice and race relations in America
- Anyone fascinated by high-profile criminal cases

Similar Books:

While "The Velvet Hammer" is Perry's debut memoir, readers interested in similar perspectives from the bench might enjoy:

- "Scalia Speaks: Reflections on Law, Faith, and Life Well Lived" by Antonin Scalia
- "My Grandfather's Son: A Memoir" by Clarence Thomas
- "Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption" by Bryan Stevenson

Final Thoughts

"The Velvet Hammer" is more than just another true crime book. It's a deeply personal account of one man's quest for justice in a complex and often brutal world. Perry's unique perspective as both a trailblazing African American jurist and a key player in some of Florida's most notorious criminal cases makes for a fascinating read.

As Perry himself might say, "Y'all, this ain't just about the gory details of murder cases. It's about the hard work of justice, the weight of making life-or-death decisions, and the never-ending struggle to do what's right in a world that ain't always black and white."

In the end, "The Velvet Hammer" serves as both a gripping true crime narrative and a thought-provoking meditation on justice, race, and morality in America. It's a book that will stay with you long after you've turned the final page, leaving you with a deeper appreciation for the complexities of our legal system and the dedicated individuals who strive to make it work.

So go on, pick up a copy of "The Velvet Hammer." Just don't be surprised if you find yourself staying up way past your bedtime, turning pages faster than a Florida gator can snap its jaws. This is one legal thriller that's all too real, and all the more fascinating for it.

[Khushbu Patel · Rating 5 out of 5]

"I never expected, as a prosecutor or otherwise, to see a case in which I thought a woman deserved to die."

This chilling line from "The Velvet Hammer" sets the tone for Chief Judge Belvin Perry Jr.'s gripping memoir, co-authored with Amy Mitchell. It's a stark reminder that behind the courtroom drama lies the weighty responsibility of deciding between life and death.

Perry's book is a potent blend of true crime, legal thriller, and personal journey. From the segregated streets of Orlando to the judge's bench in some of Florida's most notorious murder trials, Perry's story is as much about the evolution of justice in America as it is about the cases he presided over.

The narrative alternates between Perry's personal history and detailed accounts of the capital murder cases that defined his career. This structure can sometimes feel disjointed, but it effectively illustrates how Perry's experiences as a Black man in a predominantly white legal system shaped his approach to justice.

Perry's writing style, likely honed through years of crafting legal opinions, is direct and unsparing. He doesn't shy away from the gruesome details of the crimes he encountered, from the methodical poisonings of "Black Widow" Judy Buenoano to the savage family slaughter perpetrated by Jerry William Correll. These accounts are not for the faint of heart, but they serve to underscore the gravity of the decisions Perry was called upon to make.

What sets "The Velvet Hammer" apart from typical true crime fare is Perry's willingness to grapple with the moral complexities of his role. His evolution on the death penalty, from skeptic to reluctant proponent, is particularly compelling. Perry doesn't present himself as an infallible arbiter of justice, but rather as a man doing his best to navigate an imperfect system.

The book's treatment of the infamous Casey Anthony trial is especially noteworthy. Perry's behind-the-scenes account of the media circus and courtroom drama offers new insights into a case that captivated the nation. His measured critique of both the prosecution and defense strategies adds nuance to a story often painted in black and white by the media.

While Perry's legal expertise is evident throughout, there are times when the technical details might overwhelm lay readers. A glossary of legal terms could have been a helpful addition. Despite this, the book remains largely accessible, thanks to Perry's clear writing style and Mitchell's skillful co-authorship.

One of the book's strengths is its unflinching examination of race in the Florida legal system. Perry's recollections of facing prejudice, even after ascending to the bench, are both infuriating and illuminating. His pride in being one of the first Black judges elected to the bench in Orange County is palpable, as is his determination to change the system from within.

"The Velvet Hammer" is more than just a collection of sensational crime stories or a judge's memoir. It's a deeply human exploration of justice, morality, and the heavy burden carried by those tasked with making life-or-death decisions. Perry's journey from the segregated streets of Orlando to the pinnacle of Florida's judicial system is a uniquely American story – one of perseverance, integrity, and the enduring belief in the power of the law to create a more just society.

For true crime enthusiasts, aspiring lawyers, or anyone interested in the inner workings of the American justice system, "The Velvet Hammer" is a must-read. Perry and Mitchell have crafted a narrative that balances shocking true crime details with thoughtful analysis of complex legal and social issues. It's a book that will leave readers pondering difficult questions long after they've turned the final page.

In the end, "The Velvet Hammer" stands as a powerful testament to one man's pursuit of justice in an imperfect system. It's a reminder that behind every courtroom drama, every sensational headline, there are real people grappling with impossible decisions. As Perry writes, "There is no such thing as closure when a friend or family member is murdered." But perhaps, through books like this, we can come closer to understanding the complex machinery of justice that grinds on in the face of humanity's darkest impulses.

[Aparna Thaker · Rating 5 out of 5]

Picture a dimly lit chamber, where the air hangs heavy with the weight of countless lives. A solitary figure sits, draped in black, his weathered hands resting on a well-worn gavel. This is the domain of Chief Judge Belvin Perry Jr., where the line between justice and vengeance blurs, and where the echoes of Florida's most heinous crimes still resonate. In "The Velvet Hammer," Perry and co-author Amy Mitchell invite readers into this sanctum, offering a rare glimpse into the mind of a man tasked with meting out justice in a world often devoid of mercy.

"The Velvet Hammer," co-authored with Amy Mitchell, isn't your typical true crime page-turner. It's a deeply personal account from a man who spent over two decades deciding the fates of Florida's most vicious killers. And let me tell you, it's not for the faint of heart.

From Jim Crow to Chief Judge

Perry kicks things off with a look back at his childhood in segregated Orlando. Picture this: a young Black kid, son of one of the city's first Black cops, watching his dad navigate a world that didn't exactly roll out the welcome mat. It's clear these early experiences shaped Perry's view of justice and fairness in a big way.

As he recounts his journey from wide-eyed law student to hard-nosed prosecutor and eventually to chief judge, you get a real sense of the man behind the robe. Perry's writing style is straightforward, almost like he's talking to you over coffee. But every now and then, he'll drop a zinger that'll make you chuckle - or wince, depending on the subject matter.

Florida's Hall of Infamy

Now, let's get to the meat of the book - the cases. Holy smokes, people. If you thought Florida was all Mickey Mouse and beach parties, think again. Perry dives deep into some of the most horrific crimes you've probably never heard of (unless you're a true crime junkie like me).

There's Judy Buenoano, aka "The Black Widow," who poisoned her husband, son, and fiancé with arsenic. Perry's description of watching her execution is... um, let's just say I had to take a breather after that chapter.

Then you've got Jerry William Correll, who went on a stabbing spree that left four family members dead, including his own kid. Perry doesn't pull any punches describing the crime scene. Fair warning: you might want to skip that part if you've just eaten.

And don't even get me started on Scott Mansfield, the "lust murderer." Actually, you know what? I'm not even going to go there. You'll have to read it for yourself.

The Trial of the Century (No, Not O.J.)

Of course, Perry dedicates a big chunk of the book to the case that made him a household name: Casey Anthony. Remember that circus? Perry gives us a front-row seat to all the craziness, from the media frenzy to the shenanigans in the courtroom.

He's pretty even-handed when talking about the key players, like prosecutor Jeff Ashton and defense attorney Jose Baez. But you can tell he's still frustrated with how it all went down. Reading between the lines, it's pretty clear what Perry thinks about the verdict, even if he doesn't come right out and say it.

The Big Questions

Now, this isn't just a bunch of gory stories strung together. Perry wrestles with some heavy stuff throughout the book. The death penalty is a big one. He admits he wasn't always for it, but seeing the impact of these crimes up close changed his mind. It's fascinating to see how his thinking evolved over time.

And then there's the whole issue of race in the courtroom. As one of the first Black judges elected in Orange County, Perry's got some stories that'll make your blood boil. But he's not just complaining - he's showing how he worked to change things from the inside.

The Verdict

Look, "The Velvet Hammer" isn't a perfect book. Sometimes it jumps around a bit, and Perry occasionally gets a little too into the legal weeds for us regular folks. But hot damn, is it a compelling read.

If you're into true crime, legal dramas, or just want to understand how our justice system really works (warts and all), you need to pick this up. Perry's unique perspective as a Black judge in the South, combined with his front-row seat to some of Florida's most infamous trials, makes for one hell of a story.

Just maybe don't read it right before bed. Unless you enjoy nightmares about Florida Man coming to get you. In which case, hey, no judgment here. We've all got our quirks.

In the end, "The Velvet Hammer" is more than just another true crime book. It's a deeply human look at justice, morality, and the crazy, messed-up, sometimes inspiring world of American law. Perry's journey from segregated Orlando to the top of Florida's legal system is the kind of story that reminds you why they call it the American Dream - even if that dream sometimes looks more like a nightmare in the Sunshine State.

[Megan · Rating 1 out of 5]

I regretted purchasing this book the moment I opened it. I expected a lot of insightful comments from a retired, high-ranking circuit court judge - many lessons learned and growth throughout his career; cases which truly impacted his life or possibly changed his worldview, even. A mix of true crime, legal history, and memoir of his time as an African American youth growing up during segregation.

To be fair, we did get a little bit of that. I actually - for the most part - enjoyed the very brief part of the book dedicated to his earlier career as a prosecutor, and then as the first African American judge of the Ninth Judicial Circuit Court of Orlando.

As for the rest? Instead of getting the type of memoir I mentioned in my opening paragraph, I was subjected to the most biased criticism I’ve ever seen from a judge who has presided over life and death cases (and, as we were repeatedly reminded, has sent eight people to the death chamber!).

Here’s a judge who claims that:
”If I were to write my own obituary, there would be no mention of the Casey Anthony murder trial. That might seem strange given that I was the chief judge who presided over her case, which was compared to the courtroom drama of the infamous OJ Simpson murder trial in 1995. Both cases captivated millions of viewers worldwide”

Really? But you will devote 178 pages of your 328 page memoir (54%) to chronicling every little detail of her life - far before she entered your courtroom - resorting to slut shaming and completely unfounded rumors, which you claim are none of your business. Then why mention them in your memoir?

He’s not wrong about how much of a media circus the trial became. I know it was talked about nationwide, but if you lived in Orlando (like I did at the time), then it was ALL over the news. People who went to high school with Casey were selling their yearbooks with her in it on eBay for thousands of dollars. The blue shirt she was wearing in the pictures of her from the security footage at Target was also sold on there.

Isaac and I had debated going to see the trial as members of the public, but as Perry said - it was just too crazy for us to go stand in line. Fistfights were breaking out over getting in to see this trial and that was definitely something we weren’t interested in. I did, however, watch every single moment of this case - from when Caylee was reported missing, to opening statements, to the verdict, to sentencing, then her release - and I never changed my opinion that the evidence was entirely circumstantial, and to sentence someone to death for lying and “partying” (the only things that could be proven) would have been a horrific precedent.

It’s a damn good thing this guy is no longer a judge. He compares Casey to Judy Goodyear, the “Black Widow” killer, who murdered her first husband with poison, killed her nineteen-year-old son, and attempted to poison her fiancé.

He remarks that Goodyear is ”a heartless, diabolical serial killer who inflicted excruciating pain and agony on her victims by slowly poisoning them with arsenic, then sat back and watched them suffer until death. How sinister can one human being be? Did she enjoy watching other folks suffer?”

I don’t know, Judge Perry. But since you gloated about sentencing her to death and going to view her execution so you could watch her die, I’m thinking you know a little bit more about this than the rest of us.

I feel confused by Perry referring to Judy Goodyear as a “serial killer.” I thought initially she’d had a handful of victims, but two victims - or even three (Perry seems uncertain as to the number) over the course of a decade - doesn’t fit the bill for a serial killer. Serial killers are people who, by definition, murder multiple victims in separate events - three or more - with a “cooling off” period before they resume killing. The murders are ”typically driven by psychological factors like thrill, fantasy, or a desire for control, rather than immediate situational factors.”

Goodyear killed her husband, seemingly for his life insurance policy, by poisoning him. She later killed her own disabled son by pushing him out of a canoe, knowing he was unable to swim. I believe she may have killed a common-law husband for his life insurance policy as well, and the attempt on her fiancé’s life didn’t work.

These are clearly murders for financial gain - which have nothing to do with why serial killers kill. It doesn’t make her crimes any less horrific or excusable, but it does make Perry come off as less reliable when he’s seemingly trying to sensationalize it more by using the alluring “serial killer” label.

Even in this chapter, over twenty years before Casey would enter his courtroom, he couldn’t resist mentioning her (I guess because they’re both women?):

”Like Casey Anthony, Judy was the type of person who loved the limelight. She loved being the center of attention… Much like Judy, Casey was a liar and used her femininity to get what she wanted. Both she and Judy deceived their families, but while Judy was a diabolical, sinister killer, Casey was not. Casey had nothing in her life to indicate that she was a murderer. She was just a spoiled party girl who wanted to live the good life, and like most immature, young women, Casey was horrible at balancing motherhood and living the life she wanted to live, which was consistent with her “Bella Vita” tattoo. Casey also appeared to love her daughter. Judy, on the other hand, did not love anyone but herself.”

It’s interesting he says this, because his perception of Casey as someone who loved her daughter, but was just immature, does a total 180 in the later half of the book he devotes exclusively to her trial.

I also find it humorous that he actually believes we’ll buy the stories of young people approaching him on the street years later to thank him for sentencing them to hard prison time.

”Over the years, I have had people approach me after I sentenced them for their crimes. In 2021, a young lady recognized and approached me at a car wash in Orlando. “Judge,” she said, “You don’t remember me, but you gave me a five-year sentence for selling drugs.”
She told me she did her time and got out of prison.
“I hated it at the time,” she said, “but in retrospect, that was the best thing that ever happened to me, or I would’ve still been playing those games.”

What?! Right, because prison has shown to be SUCH a rehabilitating experience for those with addictions. Maybe if he had sent her to a drug rehabilitation center where she herself decided to get her act together, I’d have believed it. But it’s incredibly rare for people to be charged with drug use or distribution (which is always to support their own habit) - go into a prison with hardened, violent criminals - and come out a better, happier person. Especially after half a decade.

“Gee, thanks, Judge! I’m a convicted felon now and can’t get a single job because of my stupid mistakes when I was young, but I learned my lesson thanks to you!” The rate of recidivism is far too high for this to be believable. People end up trapped in a vicious cycle because after they have a record, they can’t get hired anywhere for a legal job, and eventually they turn to crime again as the only way to obtain the money they need to make ends meet.

Who says, “I would have still been playing those games?” !! Sounds like someone with no experience with drugs or crime would say. Hmm.

It was downright disturbing the way he so cavalierly described watching Judy Goodyear’s execution in the electric chair:

”For the first time, Judy looked scared. The guards had topped her freshly shaved head with a gel that highlighted every bump and vein to better conduct the electricity. Restraints crisscrossed her torso and strapped her legs and arms to the chair. A guard wetted all the contact points and put the sponge on her skullcap before covering her face with a part-metal, part-leather mask.

Once the switch was pulled, Judy jolted. Her body began to steam, and her fingers curled, as if with rigor mortis. Tears slowly trickled down her cheeks. The Black Widow was dead. Justice was finally served.

I heard executions were horrific. Some witnesses claimed they were never the same afterward. It surprised me how smoothly the execution went and how quickly it was over. The entire event was antiseptic and routine.”

That’s a little much, sorry. Am I the only one who feels this way? I just can’t understand all the four and five star reviews.

In chapter six, he apparently speaks for all those still living who have lost a loved one due to murder. He states there is no such thing as closure when a friend or family member is murdered (which is obviously true) but then how can he argue the death penalty will bring a sense of closure, or at the very least, justice? I just don’t feel someone who is so lax about the death penalty should have been entrusted with these decisions.

He then goes on to cite his evidence for supporting the death penalty throughout this chapter. Most of it comes from…God and The Bible! ”God is the one who first instituted the death penalty. In the Bible, Genesis 9:6 states, ‘Whoever sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood shed.’
The Bible also states, ‘He must pay according to judicial assessment’. Scripture makes it clear that the government has the authority to determine when death as a punishment is warranted.
The death penalty has been around since the days of the Book of Exodus in the Old Testament, around 1400 BC.”

He continues on in this vein for some time. I have no problem with religion, but I don’t think punishment during biblical times should be comparable to punishment in the 21st century. I suppose I’d like to think mankind has evolved a bit since those times.

What’s really astounding is his proclamation on the next page: ”Capital punishment is a deterrent. The threat of being executed in a capital punishment case would make me reconsider before I premeditated anything because I know the arduous outcome. It is sufficient to keep a significant number of people from committing a heinous crime they may otherwise plan. However, for some, they cannot see past the moment.”

Okay, if you’re going to state that the death penalty deters crime, then there definitely need to be some scientific studies conducted over time that show this conclusion to be correct. However, no studies are cited. Why? I’m guessing because they all show the opposite: it’s NOT a deterrent. I’m not even anti-death penalty (I do believe it should be reserved for the worst offenders, however).

But Perry’s conclusion that the death penalty is a deterrent rests on the logic that if he were thinking about committing first-degree murder, he’d think twice before doing it, because “it’s such a drawn-out process of appeals and constant stays of execution, and the like.” Well, that’s great that in a hypothetical scenario, you don’t believe you’d murder someone. I don’t believe so, either. However, I fail to see how this supports your argument. In the end, Perry even contradicts his own argument by stating that “some cannot see past the moment.”

You’re literally describing nearly every single person charged with premeditated murder! It’s so ridiculous it’s laughable. He then goes on to state that ”the electric chair was supposedly built by prisoners and made from an old army boot and roofing copper. It also had straps and a detachable leather skull cap with felt, mesh, and wire. A sponge soaked in the conductor was sewn into the mesh. The cap was linked to a power source with a nut in a bolt. Death row inmates were gagged and strapped tightly to the chair before execution. With one flip of a switch, they were only supposed to feel a quick jolt and a slight burning sensation at the point of connection.”

Okay, perform a Google search that will take mere seconds of your time: electric chair. Wikipedia will tell you that Alfred P. Southwick, a New York dentist, conceived of the method in 1881. I believe another electrician working under Thomas Edison designed the first one for use in prisons (Edison was a vocal opponent in public, but was involved in some “electric current race” in private).

If you don’t believe Wikipedia, the Library of Congress will tell you the same thing. All I remember thinking was: what?! No. Definitely not. It’s incredible to me that a judge - no, a pro-death penalty judge - would make the mistake of attributing the creation of the electric chair to prisoners. This, for me, really underscores many of the opinions that I already found to be unnecessarily voiced throughout this book.

As Perry points out on page 71, ”Everyone reacts to fear differently. It is tougher than you think when people are scared. They zone out until something snaps. Some people mentally shut down when they are in fear.”

Yes, everyone has very different reactions to trauma, especially if they’ve been traumatized by an early age, or abused or just taught to lie. So why is it he cannot extend this same courtesy to Casey Anthony? That she really was abused. She was in denial. She knew how to block painful things out. I know I do. That doesn’t make me capable of murder. Yet he doesn’t question all of George and Cindy’s habitual lying or believe George could have hurt Caylee, intentionally or accidentally.

He speaks about “poor George” being on the stand and no one backing him up. Does Perry ever wonder that the reason might be because no one can back him up? Caylee reportedly died in the morning after Cindy last saw her before leaving for work at 8:30 AM. Yet both Casey and George were at the house until the afternoon (George was not reported to be at work until 3:00 that afternoon). So how could anyone vouch for him when they only knew where he was and what he was doing from 3 PM onwards?

Later, after Caylee is reported missing, and all kinds of loons and fame seekers are coming to Florida for their fifteen minutes of fame, Judge Perry reports a completely unsubstantiated rumor about Casey and her lawyer, Jose Baez, that the former family bodyguard and personal investigator claimed to have seen:

”The relationship between investigator Dominic and Casey’s defense was falling apart. Dominic allegedly witnessed unethical behavior between Jose Baez and Casey that made him feel uncomfortable. He claimed Casey and Jose were having sex, potentially as payment for her legal fees.

“I arrived at Baez’s office unexpectedly, one day and, once again, witnessed a naked Casey,“ Dominic stated. “This time, she ran from his private office through the conference room to the hallway. That night, I told her she cannot allow him to continue engaging in this behavior. Casey told me she had to do what Jose said because she had no money for her defense.”

Investigator Dominic quit and began working as an investigator and security guard for George and Cindy. I doubt Dominic’s claims, but whatever transpired is none of my business.”

Wait, what was that? None of your business? Then why are you putting it in a memoir for countless people to read and assume?!

He excuses George’s affair with Krystal Holloway, saying “alleged affair” when he never says “allegedly” for most of the negative comments he makes concerning Casey. I don’t believe George, and the evidence corroborates the fact that he was lying. He claimed to have only gone to Krystal’s condo once, yet security surveillance showed multiple instances, just as she’d stated.

Also, I can’t think of many married men who meet a volunteer for a search for their missing granddaughter just once, then sends the person a text saying “Just thinking about you. I need you in my life.” It seems Judge Perry felt sorry for George because of his domineering wife, and found it perfectly acceptable that a man with needs would seek the solace of a woman willing to provide sweet words and sexual pleasure.

He also refuses to even consider George may have sexually abused Casey, despite pointing out all of his odd behaviors toward her that would indicate abuse of the sort.
”This situation was a tragedy. She systematically destroyed her family and portrayed her father and brother as sexual predators. When a child is molested, he or she will never forget it. In most cases, sexual accusations are hard to prove. However, they are often supported by child therapists and social investigators, which Casey had none of for her claims.”

“The defense wanted to have Casey’s psychiatrist testify to regurgitate what she told him about the sexual abuse, but I denied the request. It was irrelevant to Caylee‘s murder.”

Didn’t he just say that no one could support her claims? Just a couple sentences later, he tells us how he refused to let the psychiatrist she spoke with about the abuse testify. So she did have someone to verify her claims, but as Judge Perry deemed this testimony irrelevant, it also apparently made the testimony false.

For the last time, thank God he wasn’t able to issue any punishment in her case:
”The prosecution made a strong case. I thought they showed enough evidence to sustain a guilty verdict for first-degree murder, but the jury did not believe it. Anything can happen in a trial. There are no slam dunks. While I was shocked at the verdict, I knew an acquittal was possible.
Although Casey appeared eligible for the death penalty on paper, the aggravating and mitigating factors suggested otherwise.
Again, the State could not prove how the child died. The big mistake they made was seeking the death penalty, not because I believe Casey was innocent, but because jurors are more hesitant to send someone to death without absolute proof. Jurors have to be absolutely certain the defendant is guilty before they sentence them to death.

That’s absolutely insane. Perry is saying he believed enough evidence was shown to sustain a guilty verdict for first-degree murder, and that you can’t expect jurors to sentence someone to death unless they’re 100% certain of the defendant’s guilt. Saying he believed they showed enough evidence for a guilty verdict and that she appeared eligible for the death penalty on paper is his literal way of saying it’s not something he’d hesitate on. There’s just so much wrong with that.

I’ll finally conclude with this statement he makes concerning Casey (he’s very repetitive):
”In my opinion, her inaction indicated she was guilty of at least knowing something regarding the disappearance of her daughter. One thing about sociopaths and psychopaths is how manipulative they can be.
Casey showcased herself as a good mother in front of people. Was it all just an act? Casey probably did feel love for Caylee.
Psychopaths convince themselves of their self-made realities. Psychopaths will even weep ten seconds after they kill someone they “love”. They can love and kill in the same breath. Is Casey a psychopath? You be the judge.”

We don’t need to be, thanks to Judge Perry relentlessly driving this point home.

I understand this review is excruciatingly long, but I was repeatedly shocked by how awful this reading was. I had to call out this book for its awful bias, self-aggrandizing, and overall bad writing. It’s shocking to me that this was written by a judge with the help of another lawyer.

No one has to read this entire review, but skimming through it should give you enough information to realize this is not a balanced account. I only recommend this book for people who already have their minds made up about Casey, and did so even before her trial even started. I don’t think it’s healthy to obsessively hate a stranger so much, but I can’t control how others spend their time.

[Dipalee Joshi · Rating 5 out of 5]

The stench of death lingers in the humid Florida air, a grim reminder that beneath the Sunshine State's postcard-perfect facade lurks a darker reality. It's this shadow world that former Chief Judge Belvin Perry Jr. invites us to explore in his gripping memoir, "The Velvet Hammer." With unflinching honesty and a judge's keen eye for detail, Perry peels back the layers of Florida's most notorious murder cases, revealing the raw humanity at the heart of even the most inhuman acts.

Co-authored with Amy Mitchell, "The Velvet Hammer" is far more than just another true crime page-turner. It's a deeply personal journey through the evolution of Florida's criminal justice system, viewed through the lens of a man who rose from the segregated streets of Orlando to become one of the state's most respected jurists.

Perry's narrative style is as direct and no-nonsense as you'd expect from a seasoned judge, yet there are moments of surprising vulnerability that catch you off guard. His recollections of growing up Black in 1950s Orlando are particularly poignant, setting the stage for his later reflections on race and justice in America.

The heart of the book lies in Perry's vivid recounting of the capital murder cases that defined his career. From the cold-blooded calculations of "Black Widow" Judy Buenoano to the savage family annihilation perpetrated by Jerry William Correll, Perry spares no gruesome detail. It's not for the faint of heart, but these unflinching depictions serve a purpose, forcing readers to confront the stark realities of violent crime and the heavy burden of judgment.

Perhaps most compelling is Perry's candid exploration of his own evolving views on capital punishment. His transformation from death penalty skeptic to reluctant executioner adds depth to the narrative, challenging readers to grapple with their own beliefs about justice and retribution.

Inevitably, a significant portion of the book is devoted to the Casey Anthony trial, which thrust Perry into the national spotlight. His behind-the-scenes account of the media circus and legal maneuvering is fascinating, offering new insights into a case that captivated the nation.

While "The Velvet Hammer" is undoubtedly engrossing, it's not without its flaws. The book's structure, which jumps between Perry's personal history and various murder cases, can feel disjointed at times. Additionally, Perry occasionally delves too deep into legal minutiae, potentially losing lay readers in a thicket of jargon.

Despite these minor quibbles, "The Velvet Hammer" stands as a unique and valuable contribution to the true crime genre. Perry's perspective as both an insider and an outsider in Florida's legal establishment offers a nuanced view of the American justice system rarely seen in popular literature.

Ultimately, "The Velvet Hammer" is more than just a collection of sensational crime stories or a judge's memoir. It's a thought-provoking exploration of justice, morality, and the heavy weight of wielding the power of life and death. Perry doesn't pretend to have all the answers, but his reflections on these complex issues, informed by decades on the bench, provide valuable fodder for ongoing debates about criminal justice reform in America.

For true crime enthusiasts, aspiring lawyers, or anyone interested in the inner workings of the American legal system, "The Velvet Hammer" is a must-read. It's a stark reminder that behind every sensational headline and courtroom drama are real human beings - victims, perpetrators, and those tasked with the awesome responsibility of dispensing justice. Perry's journey from the segregated streets of Orlando to the pinnacle of Florida's judicial system is a uniquely American story - one of perseverance, integrity, and the enduring belief in the power of the law to create a more just society.

[Lunatic Reader · Rating 5 out of 5]

"Justice may be blind, but the Velvet Hammer sees all."

In "The Velvet Hammer," former Chief Judge Belvin Perry, Jr. and co-author Amy Mitchell peel back the curtain on some of Florida's most notorious criminal cases, offering a rare glimpse into the mind of a judge tasked with meting out justice in a system fraught with complexities.

Perry's memoir is a gripping account of his journey from a young black man growing up in segregated Orlando to becoming the chief judge presiding over the sensational Casey Anthony murder trial. The book's title is apt - Perry earned the moniker "The Velvet Hammer" for his firm yet compassionate approach on the bench. His writing style mirrors this persona, blending matter-of-fact accounts of gruesome crimes with thoughtful reflections on the nature of justice and the weight of judicial responsibility.

The heart of the book lies in Perry's detailed recounting of several high-profile cases, including the chilling "Black Widow" murders and the controversial Casey Anthony trial. Perry's insider perspective provides fascinating insights into the legal strategies, courtroom dynamics, and behind-the-scenes deliberations that shaped these cases' outcomes. His frank assessment of the Anthony verdict - expressing shock while respecting the jury's decision - is particularly compelling.

However, "The Velvet Hammer" is more than just a true crime page-turner. Perry weaves in poignant personal anecdotes about growing up black in the Jim Crow South and the mentors who shaped his career. These sections humanize the author and provide crucial context for understanding his judicial philosophy.

While Perry's accounts are engrossing, the book occasionally suffers from a somewhat disjointed narrative structure. The chronological jumps between cases and personal history can be jarring at times. Additionally, some readers may find the legal jargon and procedural details overwhelming in places.

Despite these minor flaws, "The Velvet Hammer" is a valuable addition to the true crime genre and legal memoir canon. Perry's unique perspective as a trailblazing African American judge adds depth to his analysis of the criminal justice system. His unflinching examination of both its strengths and shortcomings is refreshingly honest.

Ultimately, "The Velvet Hammer" serves as both a captivating read for true crime enthusiasts and a thought-provoking exploration of justice in America. Perry's voice rings clear throughout - measured yet passionate, analytical yet deeply human. Like the judge himself, this book strikes a delicate balance between the cold letter of the law and the complex realities of human nature.

[Reader Views · Rating 5 out of 5]

Not everyone is cut out to be a judge, and it takes a special kind of person to be a Chief Judge. In “The Velvet Hammer: Judge Belvin Perry, Jr.’s Capital Murder Cases and Memoir,” Belvin Perry, Jr. tells us of his classic success story. Raised by a single father, Perry and his two siblings didn’t have things handed to them. His father, a police officer, exposed him to the legal system at a young age, and over the years his early fascination with the law became his passion.

Despite having to deal with institutional racism, Perry was able to get a job in the State Attorney’s office, then later ran successfully for Chief Judge. Over the course of his career, he was involved in numerous murder trials – both as a prosecuting attorney and as a judge – and here he explains the crimes, the trials, and the verdicts. Most famously, the Casey Anthony trial where a young mother was charged with murdering her daughter.

Perry and his co-author Amy Mitchell tell an engaging tale of his upbringing and his journey into the legal profession. His memoir, however, is interspersed between retellings of the trials he was involved with. For the casual reader, the details of the crimes – all murders – may be too much. Perry and Mitchell go into almost exquisite detail when describing the actions of the killers. However, for the fans of true crime novels and podcasts, these details may be just what you’re looking for.

The other thing to keep in mind is that Perry also uses these murder trials as a means to justify the death penalty. From his point of view, that’s understandable. As a prosecutor and judge, Perry has had a front-row seat to some of the most heinous murders in Florida. No one can be repeatedly exposed to those situations without being affected by them. But if you are against the death penalty, you’ll find yourself disagreeing with his arguments and justifications.

“The Velvet Hammer” is a well-written and engaging combination of memoir and true-crime collection. The narrative alternates between Perry’s life and the legal system, offering dissections of his cases and the reasoning behind his legal decisions. I found it insightful; a bit morbid, but overall a fascinating read.

[Dana K · Rating 4 out of 5]

{4.5 stars}

Thanks to BooksGoSocial for gifted access via NetGalley. All opinions below are my own.

I was 100% obsessed with the Casey Anthony trial when it happened. I have always been a Court TV junkie and often have cases on in the background while I am working during the day. Casey’s case was horrific and engrossing and at times completely unbelievable. For me, there were two stars of that case, of course, Jose Baez and Judge Perry. They were both phenomenal characters to watch and be immersed in, but for two totally different reasons. Baez was audacious, creative and in my opinion, lacking morals. Perry, however, what’s the complete opposite; steadfast, practical and amazingly authoritative. I still regularly do an impression of his, “Mr Baez,” when I find a statement unbelievable or out of line.

Anyway, as you’d expect a good portion of this book focuses on that case, his most notorious. He gives us his opinions, how he ended up on the case and the nuts and bolts of the day-to-day and what he thinks could have changed the verdict. Much more compellingly, he tells us of his youth, his choice to go into law, how he became a judge and the rest of his notable death penalty cases. I loved the balance of memoir with true crime. Each case gets so much Dateline-like detail, but also Harry’s opinions on the perpetrator, the victim, and how the case was tried.

If you like law and order or true crime, definitely check this one out.

[Beccas Bookclub · Rating 4 out of 5]

Thank you NetGalley for this eARC!

This book touches on early life, career development, and crime cases that Judge Belvin Jr presided over in the State of Florida.

While much of his career is overshadowed by the infamous Casey Anthony Trial, Judge Belvin allows readers into his less talked about lifestyles, including his view on the death penalty, growing up in the South, and his desire for justice.

I don’t often read memoirs, but this one has influenced me to look into more in the future!

Again, thank you NetGalley 🫶🏼

[Vasiliki · Rating 5 out of 5]

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC! This was an interesting read about the cases Belvin Perry was involved as a prosecutor or presided over as a judge. Some were brutal and hard to read. Tidbits of his professional career sometimes randomly found themselves in chapters regarding a case, however, this was still a great read.

[Laura · Rating 2 out of 5]

I’ve read this book for free through Booksirens.

This book is not what I hoped for, unfortunately. The author(s) states that with this book he wants to provide a description of the justice system and explain his pro death penalty stance. The biggest part of this book is about the Casey Anthony case. I found it unsettling that we learn about the judge’s personal believes (including religion) so much and how much those believe influence(d) his rulings. The personal believe of the guilt of a suspect should not be that relevant. Maybe my perspective is too European, since the death penalty is something that we don’t have. I had hoped to see a more detailed reasoning on why the author believes the death penalty is a valid option, including the worldwide perspective instead of mostly the revenge and good riddance aspect. I did enjoy the parts where the law was discussed, such as with the aggrevating and mitigating factors or the responsibility that comes with creating case law. That is the type of information I expected. A former judge probably has interesting insights in how a law like this should work and what parts he found to be problematic during his tenure. At times, the story felt like the author was boosting about how much of a wonderful job he had done. Some parts really surprised me, such as that Casey was not found innocent, but not guilty, meaning the jury just didn’t know. Isn’t innocense always presumed? Why is a former judge taking this stance? I find that surprising. All in all I had hoped for a book that was less focused on a specific case and more on the width of his career.

[Stacey · Rating 3 out of 5]

The Velvet Hammer is partially a memoir and partially a true crime book detailing some of the more heinous cases that Judge Perry presided over.

Learning his life story was interesting and in particular what lead him into law.

I am a lover of true crime so I was interested in learning more about some of these particularly upsetting cases. Some of the cases are quite gruesome and very disturbing. A lot of time is devoted to the Casey Anthony case - which dragged in parts.

What I was very disappointed in is the very biased way that the judge recounts these cases. I was expecting an objective retelling. Instead the judge is very pro the death penalty and uses every opportunity to advocate for it. For ME that detracted from the story of the cases and impacted my reading of the book.

Overall, if you are a lover of true crime there is lots of interesting information in this book. Just be aware that it does come from a prosecutorial, pro death penalty stance. If that is not an issue that is bothersome to you then you will enjoy learning more about these cases.

[Maartje Paauw · Rating 4 out of 5]

A big thanks to Post Hill Press for the ARC!

“The Velvet Hammer" is an engrossing and insightful memoir by former Chief Judge Belvin Perry Jr., who offers readers a rare glimpse into some of the most harrowing death penalty cases of his career. Among these is the infamous Casey Anthony trial. Perry's personal reflections and insights as the presiding judge offer an unparalleled view, going beyond the courtroom proceedings, providing readers with a behind-the-scenes look at his thoughts and deliberations during the trial.

I liked this book a lot and would recommend it to anyone with an interest in true crime, the judicial process, or the intricacies of capital punishment. Perry's firsthand account provides an interesting perspective on why some individuals support the death penalty, presenting arguments grounded in his experiences and the gravity of the crimes he encountered. His explanations are candid and thought-provoking, shedding light on the often-controversial stance.

I am unsure whether it is primarily a recounting of Perry's life and career, or does it aim to provide an in-depth exploration of the Casey Anthony case and others like it? Ultimately, this duality did not detract from the overall experience, as both aspects are equally compelling and well-written.

[Kathleen Riggs · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Velvet Hammer is a true crime book and alternates between the authors life and the legal system dissecting cases and the legal decisions Judge Belvin Perry has had to make especially as most of these are death penalty cases. In this book Judge Perry must justify the death penalty and shares the shocking moments of the victims in their last moments at the hands of their captures.
The velvet hammer is a real page turner as Perry tells the story of the black widow Judy Buenoano who was the infamous Black Widow. Another story was the infamous Casey Anthony trial of a mother who murdered her daughter. The story was fascinating, and Perry takes on what is known as the highest profile case of his career. Perry gives a good argument for the death penalty in certain cases whether you agree or disagree, his arguments are well grounded in some cases where Perry had to grapple with complexities of justice in the face of unspeakable crimes.
This book is a must for true crime enthusiasts and is an excellent account of the complexities of the American justice system. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily

[Sydney Pettitt (Booked Out Loud) · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was my first true crime book and it didn’t disappoint! It read like a documentary at times in my head which kept it a fast paced and interesting read.

The writing style is smooth and easy to follow. I was particularly pleased at how different law involved in the different cases was explained so effortlessly, making it easy to understand and follow along. I already knew a little about the Casey Anthony case going into this, but the amount of added detail and Perry’s perspective made it feel like fresh knowledge to me.

The only reason I’ve given it a 4 star rating instead of 5 is because I would have liked there to be a bit less on the different motions denied to the defence during the Casey Anthony chapters (this made it really drag at one point where I was tempted to skip a couple of chapters).

#NetGalley #TheVelvetHammer

[Shanti · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Velvet Hammer takes the reader on Judge Perry's journey from his formative years of his career as a prosecutor to the pinnacle of his legal profession, becoming a judge. He has passionately shed some light on the legal exercises, the daily dilemmas and considerations faced inside the courtroom.

In his book, Judge Perry reminded us of our luck compared to the victims he has outlined.
This may have helped some of us to avoid similar situations and make us feel empathy for some of our victims.

I was drawn to the sensational story of Casey Anthony and the disappearance of her two year old daughter Caylee and the desire to understand what drove her to say or do the unthinkable.

A revealing story of a young mother who seem to be lacking emotional attachment to her child.

[Ceeceereads · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was a riveting read, written by a Floridian judge looking back at his career and the cases he oversaw, the most prolific being the Casey Anthony case. I found every case to be incredibly interesting, particularly regarding his experience with death penalty cases. There was also an extensive look at the trial of Casey Anthony from his perspective which was very insightful. I thought it was well written, intelligent and balanced. I didn’t feel overloaded with legal jargon. 4 stars. Thanks to Netgalley for the arc.

[Joan Smith · Rating 5 out of 5]

The velvet hammer is a true crime memoir of Chief Judge Belvin Perry of Orange County, FL...

This novel is unlike any other biography I have ever read. It grabbed me on page one. The book tells about Judge Perry's life, especially moments that molded his moral life path. Judge Perry examines some pass cases that came across his desk.

I thought this book was a phenomenal memoir. Thank you, Judge Belvin Perry and BookSirens.

[Ellis · Rating 4 out of 5]

A must-read for true crime aficionados, Judge Perry goes in-depth on his most famous cases, providing sound background information for the basis on decisions and sentences, while also delving into his personal background. The care and kindness shown to victims and their families is to be admired.

[Sonja Charters · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was such a fascinating book and so much more than I'd been expecting.

Ok, I know it's my own fault - I never read blurbs before reading a book and so this was a 'jusge a book by its cover' pick for me.
Such a striking image with the contrast of the gavel and the blood against that white background - it really stood out to me and I couldn't wait to dive in!

So this was a great introduction to what motivated Perry to want to be involved in the judicial system and I think it's often found that parental careers can often influence us as we grow.
Perry's father being a police officer meant that they must have been exposed to all things law from such an early age.
Plus there's just something about well publicised cases that grab everyone's attention.

Working through the system saw Perry become Chief Judge.
I don't profess to know very much about the legal system, especially not in the US - but this definitely took a lot of motivation, determination and total focus which we saw throughout this book.

On top of this, Perry discusses some of the the most prolific cases that he's been part of and as with many books of this nature, this content can be quite graphic and disturbing to some readers.

Anyone who is obsessed with true crime though will be thoroughly satisfied by these inclusions.

I love how the cases are woven into the memoir parts of the book and this makes everything flow nicely and breaks up each section.
I will say though, that Perry advocates the death penalty throughout his discussions and so there is definitely a bias here - this is not so much a bad thing as it is a personal account - but just be aware if this might be a sensitive topic for you while reading!?

I don't know what I'd expected from this book but I was completely hooked and totally in awe from start to finish.

[Mary Angel · Rating 5 out of 5]

In The Velvet Hammer, Judge Belvin Perry, Jr tells the story of his life while weaving the details of his most memorable cases as both an attorney and judge throughout the book. He leads off with the most infamous case over which he presided, that of the trial of Casey Anthony, but there are many, many fascinating cases that he tried as an attorney and presided over as a judge.

He has led a very interesting life, and I would wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone interested in criminal justice and true crime. Thanks to Book Sirens and the publisher for the ARC.

[Kailene · Rating 5 out of 5]

I'm grateful for the chance to have read this book! It was so so good. It was a chance to learn about history of when the judge was growing up and the racism that was occuring at that time. It was also a chance to learn about different murder trials that he was over. This was a great read. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

[Elizabeth O'Keefe · Rating 4 out of 5]

I used to want to be an attorney for a long long time, then somehow I got into a finance class in high school and fell in love with accounting and finance. Why is this relevant? It isn't, but I have always been fascinated with court cases, judges and everything that happens to lead them to where they are today.

Seeing that Judge Belvin Perry Jr wrote a book, I had to grab it because he has seen some brutal, gruesome, and just horrific things in his time as a prosecutor, and now judge. Naturally my curiosity got the best of me, and I am so glad it did.

Did I want to read this to see/read more about the infamous Casey Anthony? Yes.

Did I realize all the other cases he had done previously, and how messed up they were? No.

Would I read more books like this? Absolutely yes.

Incredible read, be ready for some heavy hitting topics, and heavy talks.

Thank you NetGalley and Post Hill Press for my E-ARC.

[J Kromrie · Rating 4 out of 5]

Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this eARC.

In The Velvet Hammer, Judge Belvin Perry Jr., with the assistance of Amy Mitchell, offers readers a gripping and unflinching look into the world of capital murder cases. This memoir is a recounting of high-profile trials and a deep dive into the complexities of the American criminal justice system, seen through the eyes of a man who has spent decades at its helm.

The book is structured around some of the most notorious cases Judge Perry presided over, including the infamous Casey Anthony trial. Each chapter delves into a different case, providing a detailed narrative that is both informative and chilling. The authors do an excellent job of balancing the legal intricacies with the human stories behind each crime, making the book accessible to both legal professionals and general readers.

Judge Perry emerges as a multifaceted character—stern yet compassionate, methodical yet empathetic. His journey from growing up in the segregated South to becoming a prominent figure in the judiciary is inspiring. The memoir also introduces us to a cast of real-life characters, from victims and their families to the accused and their defense teams, each portrayed with depth and sensitivity.

One of the intriguing themes of The Velvet Hammer is the moral and ethical dilemmas surrounding the death penalty. Judge Perry provides a nuanced perspective, arguing for its necessity in certain cases while acknowledging its profound implications. The book sheds light on the systemic issues within the criminal justice system, including racial biases and the challenges of mental health and substance abuse among defendants.

The writing is clear and engaging, with a narrative style that keeps readers hooked. Amy Mitchell’s contribution is evident in the seamless flow of the prose, making complex legal concepts understandable without oversimplifying them. The vivid descriptions of courtroom drama and behind-the-scenes deliberations add a layer of authenticity and tension to the storytelling.

The Velvet Hammer is a compelling memoir that offers a rare glimpse into the life and career of one of America’s most respected judges. It is a must-read for true crime enthusiasts, legal professionals, and anyone interested in the intricacies of the justice system. Judge Perry’s candid reflections and the meticulous recounting of his most challenging cases make this book an educational and an emotional journey.

Whether you are looking for a deep dive into the legal world or a thought-provoking read on the human condition, The Velvet Hammer delivers, highly recommended.

[Maileen Hamto · Rating 4 out of 5]

Living in a country where the law reigns supreme, it is not surprising that infamous criminals become household names. Real-life courtroom drama preoccupies the national psyche, with the accused, judges, and prosecutors in leading roles. Judge Belvin Perry, Jr. presided over one of the most closely watched death penalty cases in recent history, that of the murder of three-year-old Caylee Anthony. Her mother, Casey Anthony, was accused of the crime but was acquitted by a jury. Now retired, Perry tells his story in the memoir 'The Velvet Hammer," which chronicles his upbringing in the segregated American South to his election as a judge. Despite initial opposition, Perry's dedication and community support led to his ascendancy to the bench, where he served for 25 years. He later became chief judge, known for his firm yet fair approach, earning the nickname "The Velvet Hammer." Perry's story reflects his commitment to justice and the impact of his upbringing on his professional life. ​

I was intrigued by the book because of my cursory exposure to the Casey Anthony case. More than a decade ago, one could not escape the scrutiny of decisions made during the deliberations, which were covered extensively by news outlets. Perry's accounts of his experiences as a presiding judge are raw and honest. Perry and co-author Amy Mitchell provide a detailed account of the Casey Anthony trial, focusing on the events leading up to and during the trial, as well as the aftermath. The memoir delves into the courtroom dynamics, including the strategies used by the prosecution and the defense's, key testimonies, and the contentious interactions between attorneys. Perry also candidly shares his perspective as the judge and the challenges involved in maintaining courtroom decorum. ​

While the book focuses on the Casey Anthony trial, it was eye-opening to learn of Perry's experiences and outlook as the first Black judge elected to the Ninth Judicial Court in Orlando, Florida. Readers learn that Perry's experiences taught him resilience and the importance of defining one's purpose in life. He credits the impact of role models and community support in fostering a deep commitment to justice and fairness. Judges are often portrayed and perceived as impartial and unfeeling, yet Perry offers his reflections on interactions with defendants and victims' families. This reinforced his belief in the need to balance firmness with compassion. ​

Note: I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

[Book Nerdection · Rating 5 out of 5]

“The Velvet Hammer” by Chief Judge Belvin Perry Jr. is one of the most interesting true crime memoirs I have ever read. The book is suitable for lovers of true crime stories. It gives a clear account of some murder cases in Florida which the author had first-hand information on.

From the author’s experiences to his life as a prosecutor, and then a Judge, takes on an interesting journey. Reading this book opened my eyes to the justice system in the United States and detailed information on the infamous murder cases in Florida. From the first page to the very last page, I found myself loving this book.

The authors do a notable job in the portrayal of the characters and their dialogues. Perry’s and Amy’s careful descriptions of everything keep readers engrossed and immersed in the story. Aside from the Casey Marie Anthony story, another story that caught my attention was the story of Jerry William Correll, who committed a horrific quadruple murder in Orange County out of jealousy. He was jealous of the fact that he saw his ex-wife with another man. He became enraged and sought revenge. He broke into the house of his ex-wife. He killed his ex-wife, his ex-mother-in-law, his ex-sister-in-law, and did not even spare his own daughter. He was charged with the murders of his ex-wife Susan, their five-year-old daughter Tuesday, his ex-mother-in-law Mary Lou Hines, and his ex-sister-in-law Marybeth Jones. Correll’s crime was marked by extreme cruelty, and Perry served him the death penalty. With this story, I realized the wickedness of humans, and how far people can go to instigate revenge.

Each and every story in this true crime memoir is important and has significant lessons. I found myself immersed in reading every part. I highly recommend every law student and every true crime lover to read it.

Trigger Warning: The Velvet Hammer:
Contains detailed and graphic content related to violent and horrific murders, including accounts of disturbing crimes, death penalty cases, and extreme cruelty. The book also includes depictions of tragic accidents and family challenges. Reader discretion is advised as the content may be distressing or triggering to some individuals.

Reviewed by Andrew

[Beau Wasserman (Depression Arc) · Rating 5 out of 5]

ARC provided by BooksGoSocial in exchange for an honest review.

The Velvet Hammer is a gripping and insightful memoir that offers a rare glimpse into the mind of Judge Belvin Perry Jr., known for presiding over some of Florida’s most high-profile capital murder cases. Co-authored with Amy Mitchell, this book blends personal anecdotes with professional insights, creating a compelling narrative that explores the complexities of justice and the human experience within the legal system.

Judge Perry’s storytelling is both candid and reflective, revealing the emotional weight carried by those in positions of authority. His portrayal of the courtroom is vivid, providing readers with an understanding of the legal intricacies involved in capital cases while also delving into the moral dilemmas faced by judges. The title, The Velvet Hammer, aptly encapsulates his judicial philosophy: firm yet compassionate, emphasizing the importance of fairness in delivering justice.

Throughout the memoir, Perry recounts pivotal cases that shaped his career and his perspective on the law. Each case is not just a story of crime but a narrative woven with the threads of humanity—detailing the lives affected by violence, the struggles of the accused, and the quest for truth. Perry’s reflections on these cases resonate deeply, inviting readers to contemplate the broader implications of justice, punishment, and redemption.

The collaboration with Amy Mitchell enhances the narrative flow, allowing Perry’s voice to shine through while maintaining an engaging structure that draws readers in. The blend of personal reflection and legal analysis creates a rich tapestry that is both informative and emotionally resonant. Readers gain a profound appreciation for the weight of decisions made in the courtroom and the impact they have on individuals and communities.

The Velvet Hammer is more than just a memoir; it is a poignant examination of the justice system through the eyes of a seasoned judge who has faced the harsh realities of capital cases. This book is a must-read for those interested in true crime, legal affairs, or anyone seeking a deeper understanding of the complexities of justice in America. Judge Belvin Perry Jr.’s insights are as powerful as they are thought-provoking, leaving readers with much to ponder long after the final page.

[Book Reviewer · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Velvet Hammer by former Chief Judge Belvin Perry Jr. offers a unique perspective within the true crime genre. It sets itself apart from the usual narratives penned by detectives, third-party authors, or perpetrators. Instead, it is written by the judge who presided over some of the high-profile cases detailed within its pages. The title, a nod to his courtroom nickname, will be familiar to those who recognize Perry as the judge in the infamous Casey Marie Anthony case.

Perry acknowledges that many readers will be drawn to the book because of his role in the Anthony trial, and he does not disappoint. A significant portion of the book delves into this case, revealing behind-the-scenes details that even avid followers may have missed. Perry shares insights from the courtroom, including moments that weren’t captured by cameras or recorded in transcripts, offering a fresh perspective on a case that captivated the nation. Beyond the Anthony case, The Velvet Hammer explores Perry’s personal life and other significant cases he handled, such as the Judy Buenoano case, also known as the Florida Black Widow. These accounts provide valuable context for understanding Perry’s approach to the highly publicized Anthony trial. The book paints a picture of a judge who, while emotionally detached in his professional capacity, also grapples with the isolating nature of his role. Perry presents certain elements of the case in a matter-of-fact manner, avoiding excessive graphic detail. This makes The Velvet Hammer accessible to a broad audience, including those new to the true crime genre.

For seasoned true crime enthusiasts, the book is a must-read, offering a rare viewpoint from the bench—a perspective that is both judicially objective and personally reflective. Perry’s account sheds light on the complexities of the justice system and the inner workings of a judge’s mind. The Velvet Hammer is a compelling read for true crime aficionados and an excellent entry point for newcomers to the genre. Its balanced approach, combining legal insight with personal narrative, makes it a standout work that offers something unique in true crime literature.

[Roz Anne · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.5 stars! This was an interesting look into the home and working life of judge Belvin Perry Jr. He talks about his structured and strict upbringing with his parents and the strong influence they had upon his life. It was easy to see how the values he was brought up with influenced his decision-making as a judge. He was brought up in a time of segregation and unrest in the south of America. His father became one of the first black police officers in Florida at a time when this was not so easily accepted by his father's colleagues. This was an engrossing view of life in the south and how his father's positive and persistent attitude ensured that both his sons succeeded when doors would usually be closed to such opportunities.

Belvin had 20 cases over his career, where he had to decide on the sentence for capital punishment cases. It was really intriguing how he developed his own rationale based upon the remits of the law he was working within. I live in a country that no longer has the death penalty so I found this aspect of the book thought provoking as I would say I was against capital punishment generally, although Belvin explained his own thoughts eloquently and his thoughts on the subject are measured.

The book focuses on a few cases but gives the most focus to the notorious case of Casey Anthony. I found it interesting to see his views on the evidence and how it was presented and his thoughts on why a lot of people thought a great injustice had been done!

The book is well written and flips from his personal life to his working life. It gives a glimpse into who he is and what has been important to him. I got sucked in and couldn't put it down as it gives a view of a world most of us do not see!

I highly recommend if you like true crime, history, and memoirs.

With thanks to the author and Love Book Tours for providing a copy of the book. This is my honest revie, which I'm leaving voluntarily. 

[Dani · Rating 4 out of 5]

Retired Judge Perry Jr. has told a story that has enticed me from the beginning with his professional role as a Judge in Florida as well as a lawyer previously. Additionally, Belvin explains his upbringing by his single father, his mother who abandoned him and his siblings at a young age, and the great impact his father had on Belvin as a child and as an adult from his own personal experiences as one of the first black police officers during that era. This book had me drawn in from chapter to chapter, page to page, and I cannot say enough good things about how Judge Perry's story was expressed in this book. Lastly, it was essential as I was reading to gain the knowledge in the Judicial system for Florida and some of the legal things that I did not know, yet is pertinent in understanding why decisions were made in the legal system when making the final decisions for a case. The Judge has provided the insight to many of the horrific murder cases he either participated in as an attorney or was present as the Judge. He even admits that he wished the outcome for certain cases would have been different especially that of Casey Anthony's, he points out specifically he would have in fact made the opposite decision of the outcome. Although, that is not what he was able to decide, he explains how the judicial system worked in this case and was able to validate why it was essential for it to happen the way it did, lawfully. Overall, I highly recommend the book if you like biographies and true crime cases as it was intriguing and sustained my interest.

Thank you to #BookSirens, #JudgeBelvinPerryJr, #AmyMitchell, and others on this ARC provided to me.