Several other reviews outline the synopsis for this compelling novel, so I'm not going to set out the plot or summarize the story again. I’m going assume that anyone reading this is already familiar with authors work, and the previous installment ‘A Gathering of Twine’.
Rather, I hope that these words will provide a few extra ponderings to add to the thought provoking points already made.
Let me begin by asserting that, to me, ‘The Beggar of Beliefs’ is a Yin Yang of a book - a book of deep contrasts, of immense dark and light and the interplay between them. Yet it's not dark and light in the usual sense of creating a good/bad division between hero and enemy. In this book the primary focus of the dark and light polarities exist within a family and the various alliances that they create and break. And, more than that, the book in fact encourages the reader to get in touch with the self-same dark and light polarity within themselves.
After all, if you knew that your country was a gonner, would you collaborate with the enemy in return for a better life? What about if it was not your country, but your world?
But more on that in a moment. First let me say this; for me The Beggar of beliefs was a real page turner. Excuse the pun but, from the moment I opened it I was sucked through to a beautifully described alternate reality... and then dragged helplessly into an adventure of darkness, deceit and betrayal that never let me go until the very end. Rarely does a book hold me captive the way this did. It was an utterly compelling read… and mostly because it was not written in the typical horror style. Very little happens at night or in the dark – rather we are exposed to the idea that there is terror in the light, because they light brings shadows, and the shadows see us.
At least in the dark we can all hide. So, let's look at that theme of darkness, light and the human condition.
In a way I saw A Beggar of Beliefs as an up-to-date version of IT (but instead of aliens, it’s vengeful gods). However, where Pennywise determines his own fate by his need to feed, Freeman (our new hero) is what he is because it is what he is born to do. And he’s going to have to venture into some pretty appalling places to do it, simply by accident of birth.
And yet some see his insight into the lie at the heart of the world as a dark blessing, and this understanding is reinforced by the arcane language that litters this sweeping text, like a forgotten prayer.
And here's where we're brought to our own dark and light. The author is a master of merging age old myths into modern history. Yet he always manages to avoid the modern day tendency to clean up, waterdown or make pretty that we often find in other attempts to re-write the gothic horrors. However, the heroes of this book are as flawed as the villains, making bad choices and errors of judgment, just as we all do every day.
Rather than launching into an all out religious war, they become sentinels for humanity – minding the rift between worlds, and trying to put a stop the insidious Raven Men. But often to protect the greater good, they have to discriminate against their own allies, who in turn are forced to betray them as a result. The chain of cause and effect is just fantastic.
The thing is, even the villains have redeeming qualities. If you invert this story, it is one where a people will do anything to help their god win a celestial war… even if that means feeding Her a lesser species (humanity) who they view as cattle. It may be morally questionable, but it makes sense.
And this is what's so disturbing for the reader. This is what drags us down into our own darkness. The Raven Men are as persuasive as they are brutal. And faced with your own certain death, would you swap it for a life of luxury if that meant selling out the rest of your species? You see the point that is being made.
But make no mistake; these monsters are still monsters in the real sense of the word. The only difference is that they are aware of the moral state of their victims and will only kill those they see as a threat. And before you know it you, the reader, begin to sympathize with both factions. And if you're not extremely careful, by the end of the book you find yourself joining the crowds of cheering characters who celebrate the coming apocalypse with an almost religious passion, because The Raven Men offer a world that is intrinsically better than ours… but it one that we can neither enjoy nor inherit.
And who can blame you? The wrongdoers are punished, the innocent remain unaware of their role in a universe spiraling towards apocalypse. By the end of it, even I wanted to be a Raven Man, knowing full well their role and what they do to our kind.
I have to say that this makes the book extremely uncomfortable reading. And so it should.
Humanity has failed on every level in the 20th and early part of the 21st century, and this book details some of the darkest moments as it blends fact and fantasy in a heady mix. I could not help but wonder if the heroes of this story were on the wrong end of history. Maybe humanity is not worth saving.
For those, like me, who like to see ourselves as liberal, compassionate, forgiving, sane, balanced and moral, this The Twine should be our saviors… but whilst they can save us from The Raven Men, they cannot save us from ourselves.
When my own tradition (Christianity) bangs on about `living in the light,' claiming that God cannot look upon darkness, and that we must abstain, deny and (pushed to an extreme) even punish our own flesh, we only create bigger demons. I've learned from my Pagan friends, that a healthy dose of Yin and Yang, of light and dark, makes for a more grounded and far less destructive personality.
So, finally, that's what I feel the monsters from the author gives us. A metaphor for what lies deep down within us all… and on the boundary of our world. He offers no answers, and how can he? The question is for each of us to ask independently and of ourselves; what /who is this shadow within me?
And what would I give up to preserve it?
A stunning book that fans of the genre will love.