I received a free copy of this novel. I am voluntarily leaving a review.
Actual rating: 3.75 stars
Warning ahead of time: there is a graphic (/graphic,/ and probably not in the way you're expecting) dog death in this novel.
This is a hard one to rate. I'm not really sure if I enjoyed it, per se, but it was definitely captivating. Most of this novel reads like a character study, as our hero is trying to recover from the horrific suicide of his beloved wife. He has an assortment of friends and random townies trying to both help and hinder him, but spends most of his time alone, tending to his farm. Unfortunately, something strange is happening to his farm, and it seems like the new neighbor next door might be to blame....
I think this novel's greatest strength is its characters. Sylvester was a simple hero, but a likable one. He was quite simply a great guy, and you really just wanted him to feel better and make it through the hard times he's found himself in. I was especially fond of his ability to vocalize his feelings to his friends vs always tucking them behind a masculine facade, especially when he expressed how much he appreciated the baseball game they attend. It was just a really sweet, meaningful scene.
The surrounding cast of characters all feel like real people, with their own quirks and flaws. Even the really minor ones were people I could imagine living in a real podunk town (or people I've met myself). The author really gets into Sylvester's head and explores his thoughts and feelings to an incredible degree. If you don't enjoy that sort of slow analysis, you will not enjoy this novel, but if you do, this will definitely deliver.
The weakness of the book, I think, comes from the plot/pacing. Very very (very) little in terms of spookiness happens throughout most of the book. There are little hints and shivers here and there, but the evil doesn't come out into the open for hundreds and hundreds of pages. Once it does, it's sufficiently horrifying/compelling, but I think the book definitely drags trying to get there. There are also these aside bits from Maria's POV that felt entirely unnecessary. I kept waiting for some big reveal that would tie it back into the main plot, but that never happened, it was just an exploration of her character that ultimately didn't matter that much (to us, at least). It felt like the author was just indulging his interest in the character vs serving the story.
I also wasn't fond of the ending. Not only is the ending sequence clumsy in its execution (it's very much a start/stop/start/stop kinda climax, which is weird), but I wasn't happy with the ultimate choice Sylvester makes or how the danger resolves itself. It felt to me like the whole story was about exploring his mindset/grief, and instead of that resolving in a powerful way, the story just took a typical way out. But your mileage may vary.
Overall, this was definitely a haunting story, but maybe not a great horror novel. The characters were deep and likeable. The horror, when it came, was sufficiently scary/WTF. But there's an awful lot of space in between, stretches of the same old feelings/sensations/thoughts over and over, like rolling cornfields....If that's your niche, you'll enjoy this, but if not, you'll be doing a lot of skimming.