Hadd / حد

by Nemrah Ahmed

32 pages, Hardcover

About the author

Nimra Ahmed Khan is a writer. Nemrah ahmed (also known as nimra ahmed or nemrah niazi) is a young pakistani novelist۔ She is the CEO of "Zanjabeel". Her first novel was published in Khwateen Digest.

Reviews

[Rabia · Rating 4 out of 5]

It is not a complete novel but a short story which is known as novelt. When i get its e-copy i didn't get what 'Hadd' means here or in which sense this word is using in the writing.
After reading the novelt i get know author is picking this word from 'Quran' and 'sunnah' according to both there are various acts whose punishment described in Quran and Sunnah as well as how to implement on any culprit is also described clearly. Islam has described very clearly what will be the parameters of justice of any sin. Vis-á-vis Pakistan's legislation and the constitution of 1973 also mention this thing in it. This ordinance was clearly introduced by Zia-ul-haq by the name of Hudood Ordinance.
Nimra Ahmed beautifully indulge her reader in her writing by creating twist and suspense. She always tried to share a message. In this writing she clearly wrote a twist story, where i do realize we have forgotten the true sipirit of Islamic justice and we are finding scientific ways to prove anything in our day to day life or in courts, while we can easily judge the matters by using these measures and quickly decide who is right or wrong.
If anyone in today's society talk about these laws, we ignore the laws by calling them fragile and incompetent according to modern notions.
Secondly she tried to explain about loyalties in her writing, no-one will be loyal to you other then your family and disloyal people always find loopholes in your relations to get benefitted as well as to exploit you. It depends on the nature of benefit they are getting the conspiracy will be that much strong. Instead of believing others do believe in yourself and your family. Don't let anyone know your weaknesses because by giving sympathy they will start looting as well.
Well written book and describes the use of Islamic law in very good manners by creating a story.

[Shabana Mukhtar · Rating 3 out of 5]

Hadd by Nemrah Shah
Non-review rant
This is the last book of Nemrah that was still in my TBR shelf. Now I am DONE.
Review
The plot
A girl named Minal, claims to be the daughter of Jehnagir Shah, and his wife Shehla agrees. Jehnagir and Shehla have thee other kids - Mehrmah, Hasnain and Sohni. After the news a big drama unfolds, including DNA test. When she learns that DNA report is positive, Jehangir's mother passes away; leaving his elder grand-daughter Mehr as the head of the village.
The characters

Minal - the accuser
Jehnagir Shah
Shehla Shah - Jehangir's wife
Mehr Maah - Jehangir's elder daughter
Sohni - Jehangir's younger daughter
Hasnain - Jehangir's son
Bi Jaan - Jehangir's mom
Raza - A family friend




The message here is that Islam and Shariat has defined how to do justice and to determine what's right and wrong. We should not forget that.

General observations about story and writer
Right from the word go, it sounded like Umera Ahmed. Let me be specific: It sounded like Rabeel from 'Abhi To Maat Baqi hai'. The dialogue, the situation, EVERYTHING.
Verdict
3/5.

[Hussnain Ali · Rating 1 out of 5]

I am truly shocked that *Hadd* was written by Nimra Ahmed. I have always admired her work, but this book was extremely disappointing. I never imagined that such a weak and poorly structured novel could come from a writer of her calibre. The story was flawed and felt completely disconnected from the modern and scientific era. It lacked logic and realism, making it difficult to take seriously. The biggest flaw of *Hadd* is its unrealistic and illogical storytelling. The characters' actions do not align with real-world decision-making, making it difficult to connect with or believe the story. Minal’s role in preventing a punishment and Mahar’s ability to easily make life-altering decisions were particularly absurd. Instead of providing a thought-provoking and well-researched perspective, the novel felt like a superficial and exaggerated take on a serious issue.
This book does not match the standard of her previous works, and it feels more like a rushed draft than a well-thought-out novel. If you are a fan of her writing, it is better to stick with her other books, as *Hadd* does not live up to expectations.

[Wahhaaj · Rating 4 out of 5]

A story with twists at every page. A nice story

[Farheen Iqbal · Rating 2 out of 5]

2.5 🌟

[Meena]

Khali title pe review likh dalen open to ho book

[Sulman · Rating 4 out of 5]

open hi naiiii ho raha

[Wasiq Akram · Rating 5 out of 5]

Had everything what a short story should have . Was good

[Alif · Rating 4 out of 5]

very unique and intense. the twist was great!

[Maral · Rating 2 out of 5]

Major eye roll.So now we are just saying that science doesn't exist.K then.But didn't see the plot twist coming.

[Sana Chaudhary]

#love