Reviewed for Netgalley.
First, I thoroughly enjoyed the mystery of Murder at Raven's Edge, for we had a mystery within a mystery and it was very cleverly done. The ongoing theme: is Milla Graham really Milla Graham or not? Several years ago there was a fire with the death of an adult and some children - only the adult was murdered before the fire started. Someone has been convicted for the foul deed but did he do it or not? The repercussions are still reeling in and around the picture-perfect village of Raven's Edge. But then a young woman turns up claiming to be one of the dead children.
From here, the plot gets complicated with many tangled twists and turns, complicated by our hero detective, Ben Taylor, realising that he's falling in love with Milla (who might or might not be the assumed dead Camilla.)
The red herrings were well done, the plot moved at a good pace - I changed my mind several times about what the truth was or wasn't. (I ended up wrong.) So for that part I thoroughly enjoyed the read.
But (you knew there was going to be a but...) Even though I enjoyed the read, I'm still confused. (And reading some of the other reviews on Goodreads etc., I'm relieved that I'm not the only confused reader.) My main confusion, though, is because this is a series and I'm well and truly muddled about which plot belongs to which book. I think the descriptive blurbs for each could be clearer - this one for instance would be clearer as: 'When the woman claiming to be Milla Graham turns up..."
Book Two, Murder at Ravenswood House the blurb states: "Still reeling from her recent breakup with local police officer Ben Taylor..." Yet the book starts with their relationship intact. (So my first thought: 'Oops, have I missed an episode somewhere?') Confusing? So maybe something like: "when the discovery of a murder causes the breakup..." would be clearer and less confusing.
But my main confusion came because of a completely different book connected to the series, which I read first: Something Wicked: A romantic mystery with a supernatural twist, this one I also thoroughly enjoyed, but is the cause of my confusion because it's set in the same village, with similar characters and a very similar opening. (Woman in road nearly gets killed, meets the detective by chance...) I went back and forth with Murder at Raven's Edge a couple of times thinking 'Hang on, have I already read this one or not?' Then I started wondering, is this the same village/place/author?
These books are all standalone, but there are some loose ends in Murder at Raven's Edge: why didn't the police know that one of their officers used to babysit the children - surely a huge conflict of interest during a new investigation? And why was the murdered woman in this story murdered? (Nor did I consider her 'local' as in the blurb.) How did the murderer get hold of the dress? In such a small village the apparently unlived in cottage would have been well known about - so who did live there, or at least keep the cobwebs at bay? Who was the policeman outside who let Milla sneak off? Loose ends or did I miss something? And Ben's background? This is another puzzle not yet revealed? I guess we'll find out in the next book Murder at Ravenswood House?
But, (yes, another but! :-) despite my comments and continuing confusion I did enjoy these mysteries, and look forward to the series continuing.