4.9/5 STARS
Profanity:4.5/5 (there was one word at the very end of the book B-word)
Plot: 5/5
Sexual content: 5/5 (There were no explicit scenes except when vague memories of real people where she say ‘made love’
Character arc: 5/5 The people who had to go through this were all portrayed in accurate lighting to the real events
Bonus (Faith): 5/5 I wasn’t expecting to see any faith but it was with the PI who has a very strong faith in Christ
STORY PLOT
This is a non-fiction but I think plot is still important because there needs to be a good sense of timeline in order to make a piece like this work. And let me tell you I felt like I was watching a special on Dateline!
The story begins in the hours just before Jayne’s death and then we are thrown into the begining of David Miller’s life and how he got to where he was. It was not only insightful, but I often forgot that I wasn’t reading fiction. We got commentary throughout on David's psyche and the key moment when David’s deceptions began to crumble and he started to panic.
It has been a long time since I have gotten goose bumps when reading a book but the end when we are able to hear the closing statement of the persecutor — WOW! I read it a couple more times and it had the same effect! I was unable to put this book down, I truly do feel sorry for the family of Jane and Dorothy. This was great to see how bad things happen all the time and that not everyone is perfect. This isn't biased, the victims still made mistakes and bad choices which I am very happy Karen Kinsgbury included in her overview of the case.
If you can get your hands on this one, I strongly suggest you do! (I found my copy on an only thriftbook shop)
PROFANITY
I found it a bit shocking since Karen Kingsbury is a Christian author. But she is also writing a nonfiction piece so I understand. She definitely skipped through 99.99999% of the profanity that she probably had to suffer through herself as researching for this book.
There is [One cuss-word] in the whole book on page 366 (If I remember) it is the B-word. And I believe is a copy and past direct statement from the witnesses who viewed the murder of Jayne. I shaved half a point for it simply being there, but honestly, it didn’t bother me too much.
SEXUAL CONTENT
There is no sexual content in this book. There are references to it Example: “When they made love” But it is rarely referenced as it isn’t the point of this piece. In the beginning when David Miller is living a more promiscuous life and it IS the center of his life for the first 60 pages or so, it is referred to as him ‘staying the night’ things like that, but again no detail, just sharing the fact of what he was doing in his life as a general report.
CHARACTER ARC
Some names were changed, but David Miller kept his. I thought everyone who was mentioned in this book was presented with respect and authenticity. The good, the bad and the ugly was all in here for every character, regardless of whether they were the victim or the predator. That was what I liked so much about this book.
Don't confuse me with implying this was filled with every detail of ‘drama and gossip’ that is not what I am implying at all. Rather, there were no missing pieces. Part of Jayne's death I think had to do with her own pride and disparity to not have another marriage fail and she let her anger get the best of her. Obviously not a christian woman but those in the faith know that Revenge is the Lord alone (Romans 12:19). Also she didn’t seem to listen to her family and friends who had never fallen fully under David’s trance. This is an example of what I mean but - good, bad and the ugly.
All the people were written this way so we could understand how someone could be stuck believing a lie or set of lies by one man for so long (in Dorthy’s case over a decade). I was able to really know who these people were or at least a basic view of who these people were and that really helped this true-crime retelling flourish.
(BONUS) FAITH
This isn’t a Christian book so I wasn't expecting to see any faith past the dedication page but I was pleasantly proven wrong. Although it is not a large piece we do get to be introduced to the private investigator who was able to help Jayne learn more about who her husband was and what he’d been up to. I will say that it was satisfying to see David’s tower of lie finally crumble to the ground.
But Kignsbury made sure to represent the private investigator in a light that he would have wanted, which was under the glory of God. It is a small segment (I believe only in one chapter) but during his interviews the Private Investagator proclaims that he was able to solve closed and/or forgotten cases only through prayer and aid of the Lord, and gives all credit to his Faith in Christ. Kingsbury also explains further that it was this ‘edge’ and faith in the Lord that allowed him to shine above the others in his field.
I appreciated it because had this been anyone else writing this piece, the investigator’s faith would have been overlooked or summed up as “the best in his field” to avoid the mentioning fo Christ which would have been unfortunate. I am very thankful that this was not the case though.
WOULD I RECOMMEND
Yes I would recommend this to anyone who enjoys true crime or maybe you enjoy Dateline and x-files and you want to get into reading more btu don’t know where to start and fear disappointment and boredom.
I would suggest this book to you. It may be hard to find but I am sure any older library and or thrift store would be able to find a copy. I am also sure there are kindle versions as well although they are a bit pricey.
Obviously I wouldn't’ recommend to a younger audience just because it is true crime and there is mentioning of promiscuity when necessary, however if there is a mature 13 or 14 year old out there who already knows about that stuff, I think it would be a great book to read with them and talk about the danger of lies and letting vanities dictate your life and how quickly it crumbles.