While technically speaking, Sy Montgomery’s 2004 The Tarantula Scientist could of course be considered as a picture book (and yes, I find Nic Bishop’s accompanying photographs a superb visual mirror to and for author Sy Montgomery’s printed words, albeit the pictures of in particular the tarantulas do sometimes aesthetically feel a bit uncomfortably in my face with regard to their intense focus), I would personally and instead rather consider The Tarantula Scientist more as an illustrated science and biology themed textbook, narrationally geared towards children above the age of nine or ten, but certainly also with sufficient presented information and details even for interested adult readers (who might also enjoy and be enlightened by science based texts that are sufficiently detailed and intensive but without too much potentially confusing science jargon).
And yes and in my humble opinion, the author’s, Sy Montgomery’s writing and contents and how they are presented in The Tarantula Scientist do totally, do educationally and wonderfully provide a very much detailed and thorough (yet at the same time also straight forward and never textually overwhelming) introduction to not only tarantulas (in particular) but actually to arachnids, to spiders and their kin in general, including showing that tarantulas are considered to be living fossils (with their lineage dating back more than 150 million years), that there are actually many species of spiders which yet remain undiscovered and that featured tarantula scientist Sam Marshall is in fact one of only a handful of academics, of college/university scientists whose specific area of expertise is tarantulas (and indeed, with the inclusion of a glossary, general spider statistics and a short but sufficient bibliography of both books and relevant websites being not only the icing on an already wonderful cake for me but also moving The Tarantula Scientist far far above compared to similarly interesting science based introductions I have encountered but which annoyingly did not bother to include any bibliographic materials whatsoever).
Finally, considering that in The Tarantula Scientist Sy Montgomery spends much of her presented text depicting and analysing both Sam Marshall’s field work observing the largest tarantula discovered to date (the Goliath Bird Eating Tarantula) in the jungles of Guatemala and how Professor Marshall and his students also and equally study living, captured spiders at university, in Marshall’s laboratory, I do think that teachers, parents etc. should probably be prepared for their students, for their children to ask pointed questions as to why in order to study them, spiders are not just being observed on site (in their natural surroundings) but also in the artificial confines of a college/university lab. And no, I do not think that this is in any way either sufficiently answered or even all that much considered by Sy Montgomery, and well, in my humble opinion, it really should be. For while there are of course many good and scientifically sound, legitimate reasons as to why scientists specialising in spiders (and other invertebrates) must also be studying captured specimens, there are of course questions and considerations regarding the morality of and the justification for this, and indeed, that this is in my opinion all rather being ignored by Sy Montgomery is also the main reason why even though I do find The Tarantula Scientist in many, in most ways spectacular, my star ranking will be four and not yet five stars.