Rogue deals with or at least touches upon: Asperger’s Syndrome, biculturalism, cancer, meth production, BMX and mountain bike culture, alcohol poisoning, child abuse, ADD, the El Salvadorian genocide, the X-Men as metaphor, the death of a parent-figure, and foster care. That’s a lot of stuff for one little book to deal with, but the main theme should come out clear to readers: it is the story of how a lonely, misunderstood outsider finds a way to use her talents to connect with others. Kiara is in 8th grade, or would be, if she wasn’t being homeschooled after losing her temper one time too many at school. Kiara has a hard time controlling her emotions and interacting with other people and her homeschool teacher suspects Kiara might have Asperger’s Syndrome. Even though she is at home and away from all the other kids who taunt her, Kiara still feels isolated: her mother is a small-time musician away on an extended band tour, her two older brothers are off at college, and her father is a bit lost himself without his wife at home. Kiara mostly spends her time obsessively looking up facts on the Internet and fantasizing that she is Rogue from the X-Men series because she relates to the feeling of being a “mutant” who secretly has hidden powers.
So when twelve year old Chad moves into the empty house on her block, Kiara sees a new opportunity to make a friend. Unfortunately, Chad thinks she’s as weird as everyone else does, and only agrees to go on bike rides with her for his own ulterior motives. Kiara knows he’s using her, but agrees to show him the secret spot in the woods where her older brothers used to mountain bike and do BMX tricks, and in doing so slowly starts to feel included by the BMX boys, especially when she starts videoing them and getting them positive attention on YouTube. Soon, however, her involvement with both Chad and the BMX boys leads to unexpected upheavals in Kiara’s life. With her social blindspots and hotheadedness, Kiara makes some pretty bad decisions when dealing with these upheavals, and faces some serious consequences for her actions. Yet, by the end of the book, Kiara feels like she has figured out her Rogue superpower, and figured out a way to be better connected to her family and peers. A good book for both boys and girls about the middle school struggle to find one’s place.
Three stars because of how many ISSUES were packed into the story, which I thought was a little unnecessary and distracting. Also some deductions for: being in the dreaded First Person Present Tense; the kind of heavy-handed X-Men metaphor; the confusing preference of '90s music by teens in 2013; and an ending which forces Kiara's mom to give up her dreams to be more "mom"-like. Bonus points for the author's dedication which is: "To my Secret Gardeners".