Rough Justice: The Rise and Fall of Eliot Spitzer by Peter Elkind
"Rough Justice" is the interesting story of the political career of the very complex and unique Eliot Spitzer. Award-winning investigative reporter and coauthor of the national best seller "The Smartest Guys in the Room", Peter Elkind, provides a comprehensive account of the rise and fall of one of the most promising political careers in America. This is a very solid and even-handed book that takes the reader inside the houses of government, the workings of Wall Street and the political dynamics of our leaders. This 323-page book is composed of the following fifteen chapters: Ironbutt, 2. Becoming a Pol, 3. Eliot Time, 4. Wild Kingdom, 5. Irwin, 6. "Daddy, Please Don't Hit Me Anymore", 7. The Big Ugly, 8. The Haunted House, 9. Sharks vs. Octopus, 10. "Bangbang", 11. "Animals", 12. Crossing the Rubicon, 14. Client 9, and 15. "Who Killed Eliot Spitzer?.
Positives:
1. Well-researched, engaging prose that makes for an enjoyable read.
2. An even-handed account and respectful treatment of the subject.
3. The fascinating rise and fall of a complex man, Eliot Spitzer.
4. The author does a wonderful job of providing keen insights into the life of Eliot Spitzer. From his upbringing to now.
5. An interesting look at Spitzer's family life, his interactions with his wife Silda.
6. No doubt in my mind that Spitzer was born to be an AG (Attorney General). This is one of the most fascinating aspects of this book. His exploits as an AG is remarkable and admirable. Very few people have the guts and intellect to go after Wall Street with the conviction of Eliot Spitzer. He became the most feared regulator. Kudos!
7. Great quotes. One of my favorite Spitzer gems, "The worst thing about political jokes is that some of them get elected."
8. An inside look at the dynamics within the Spitzer team.
9. The inner workings of Wall Street. Regulations and the AG. Spitzer's overall strategy. Great stuff!
10. Spitzer's targets...the war between titans. Spitzer a bully?? "Bullies pick on little people" Spitzer scoffed.
11. Spitzer's rise to becoming governor of New York. Once again, the dynamics of his team.
12. The growing pains of being a governor and the differences between being a governor and an AG.
13. A clash between titans, Spitzer versus Bruno.
14. The scandals, the details of "Troopergate".
15. The scandal that brought Spitzer to his knees. The details.
16. The inner workings of a an escort service.
17. A good summary of prominent politicians who also had their sex scandal.
18. A look at Patterson, the replacement governor.
19. Links worked great.
Negatives:
1. The biggest problem that any book of this ilk faces is that a lot of the most interesting/controversial details are made public before the book is even available for the public.
2. The author failed to give a more detailed account of what drove Spitzer to risk it all. Of course, we all suspect the obvious but with a man of Spitzer's intellect and straight-arrowed facade I was hoping for a bit more.
3. No notes.
4. In spite of my personal interest for this story, the book may have a limited audience outside of New York.
In summary, I enjoyed reading this book. Eliot Spitzer is a fascinating man who I hope will one day return as a politician. It's not every day you encounter a Democrat with the guts of a pitbull. Peter Elkind does a wonderful job of capturing the essence of Eliot Spitzer. My only minor gripe is the lack of detail or even an educated theory of why Spitzer faltered. The other shortfall of course is that the book offers very few new details of the most controversial aspects of the fall. The media and the public devoured the most seedy details of the story so by the book came out well it was like old news. Be that as it may, the political dynamics at the center of Eliot Spitzer is what makes this book compelling. Every reader will be able to speculate what could have been based on the thorough details provided. Personally, I thought Spitzer was working his way through the growing pains of being a governor and was ultimately going to get "it". It's too bad that he allowed a personal shortcoming become his downfall, hopefully, he can bounce back, he is too valuable a leader to be sidelined for too long. Shortcomings aside this is a fascinating political account of an interesting and important political leader, a leader once dubbed, "America's Best Public Servant."
Further suggestions: "Decision Points" by former President George W. Bush, "The Politician: An Insider's Account of John Edwards's Pursuit of the Presidency and the Scandal That Brought Him Down" by Andrew Young, "The Wizard of Lies: Bernie Madoff and the Death of Trust" by Diana B. Henriques, "King of Capital: The Remarkable Rise, Fall, and Rise Again of Steve Schwarzman and Blackstone" by David Carey, "The Post-American World: Release 2.0" by Fareed Zakaria, "That Used to Be Us: How America Fell Behind in the World It Invented and How We Can Come Back" by Thomas L. Friedman and Michael Mandelbaum, "The Monster: How a Gang of Predatory Lenders and Wall Street Bankers Fleeced America--and Spawned a Global Crisis" by Michael W. Hudson, and "Winner-Take-All Politics: How Washington Made the Rich Richer--and Turned Its Back on the Middle Class" by Jacob S. Hacker & Paul Pierson.