Initial Thoughts:
Karen Tuft takes readers on an enjoyable story through post-war France as our clueless girl is in search of her brother, and falls in love with her guide along the way. Claiming to have plot twists and an “enemy to lovers” romance, I found none of these, as James was clearly taken by Anna from the first look, and Anna was in need of his help every other second so I do not see how she could hate him. I did not really care for the missing brother storyline, nor see it give a sense of urgency with the timeline. After all they spent days complaining about the bumpy ride in a carriage, and kept spending night upon night in different French inns, so I don't really seem Tuft having them in a hurry in this novel. As this is a proper romance the relationship between James and Anna moved painfully slow at times. Despite this, the other romance that Tuft decided not to develop (I think it's because she hates me) was between Spark and Mary, the servants accompanying Anna on her trip. Now those two had chemistry and it will always be a flaw that Tuft did not explore them more. Oh well maybe in the next novel, because despite being a standalone, characters are apparently interconnected as this novel is eight in a series by Tuft. At least it reads like a standalone, and readers can enjoy it as one as well.
Characters
Brave or stupid, these words can both be used to describe our main character Anna Clifton. With her family home about to be given to her disgusting cousin after the death of her father, Anna’s only way to keep her family home is to find her missing brother and prove a male heir still lives. Her brother, who was wounded in a battle in France, after trying to help get rid of Napoleon, Anna makes the dumb decision to go to France and find her brother, dead or alive. Headstrong and stubborn, Anna is not heroic as she started this journey with the intent of getting help from others. No France, and unknown amount of money, Anna really was going to waltz into a battle going “yoo hoo! Does anyone speak English?”. Thankfully the first person she stumbles upon in her idiotic journey is James who falls in love with her and dedicates himself to help her through this mission. IT’s not that I hate Anna, I just find her a bit ditzy and clueless about what is going on around her, and it just made her hard to love. Pity for sure, but not really relatable. In a dual perspective novel we also get James who sees Anna as the clueless diamond that she is, and made it his mission to help her as he was in love at first sight. James was nice enough, a strong male for his era. Honestly he was kind of dull, with his only character development was to help Anna, and do anything Anna needed. He was truly created for her with no backstory on his own. Honestly it was not until the end of the novel when I was reminded why James was even going to France in the first place, as he truly felt written there in order to suit Anna's needs. Side characters in this novel, honestly not much to say besides Sparks and Mary are the best servants ever and their romance is the story this novel needed.
Plot and Writing
Honestly, too much complaining in the novel made the plot very slow to get through. Not the characters complaining, but Tuft themselves. I think they forgot they wrote their novels of the year 1814, and thus when thinking about the epic journey across France to find Avery, they forgot that travel was not the speed at which we see it today. Thus, the majority of this novel had our characters sitting in an uncomfy carriage as they traveled for days at a time from one location to another. Thus, this story became really repetitive of travel day, inn, travel day, inn; with honestly not much character development nor plot creation happening. It just made the book seem to drag on, with very little excitement. Tuft had the opportunity to make this novel into a mystery thriller, with Anna racing against the clock to remote French towns to see if her brother Avery is even alive, to look at his face in every passing soldier, trying to will him into existence. This could have been the novel, if Tuft writing was more adventurous, rather than romantic. Due to the novel's tone, the writing had Anna on a romantic stroll throughout the novel, lollygagging at every flower, instead of the race to find her brother.
Conclusion
Everything about this novel screams fine, I think Tuft could have done a better job, or at least shortened the novel to one miserable carriage ride instead of several. Still, the love was sweet, and I am so happy that Anna and James found each other (and Mary and Spark not that Tuft would give me that satisfaction), and overall this was a cute novel and definitely worth the read if you are in the mood for a proper romance.