What do you think?
Rate this book
The [Fake] Dating Game
Ready. Set. Faux .
Holden James picked the worst time to have a meltdown. His chance to audition for his favorite game show, Madcap Market , should have been a moment of triumph—a glorious, loving homage to his adored mom, who died six years ago. Instead, he’s destroying the minibar in a grim Los Angeles hotel room…recently dumped, partnerless and sliding into a crushing black hole of anguish.
But the hotel service in abject misery is sublime. It even comes with an unfairly fit and sexy (smart-ass) concierge who arrives at the door with pizza, Monopoly and deliciously distracting forearms.
All Holden knows about Leo Min is that he’s beautiful and unexpectedly sympathetic, and the chemistry between them is beyond . Maybe it’s even enough to convince everyone, including the show’s casting directors, that they’re a real couple. All they’d have to do is crush the competition, win the huge cash prize and all of Holden’s problems—his broken heart, his buried grief, his complete lack of money and direction—will be fixed.
Of course, reality doesn’t quite work out that way. But love is an entirely different game…
Holden James picked the worst time to have a meltdown. His chance to audition for his favorite game show, Madcap Market , should have been a moment of triumph—a glorious, loving homage to his adored mom, who died six years ago. Instead, he’s destroying the minibar in a grim Los Angeles hotel room…recently dumped, partnerless and sliding into a crushing black hole of anguish.
But the hotel service in abject misery is sublime. It even comes with an unfairly fit and sexy (smart-ass) concierge who arrives at the door with pizza, Monopoly and deliciously distracting forearms.
All Holden knows about Leo Min is that he’s beautiful and unexpectedly sympathetic, and the chemistry between them is beyond . Maybe it’s even enough to convince everyone, including the show’s casting directors, that they’re a real couple. All they’d have to do is crush the competition, win the huge cash prize and all of Holden’s problems—his broken heart, his buried grief, his complete lack of money and direction—will be fixed.
Of course, reality doesn’t quite work out that way. But love is an entirely different game…
Audible Audio
First published January 23, 2024
130 people are currently reading
13996 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 607 reviews
October 6, 2023
I'm going to just straight up admit that it was hard for me to finish this book. The (Fake) Dating Game was my first read from Timothy Janovsky, and it really didn't inspire me to raid his backlist. I struggled the whole way through.
I thought the set up to this book was very cute, but right off the bat, the clunky, awkward language got to me. It just didn't feel natural, and it took me out of every scene. I think it's just the author's style, but it didn't flow for me.
I also didn't like how the MCs just jumped right into sex scene after sex scene (cucumbers??) with very like build-up or chemistry. I like more of a connection before the action begins, and I don't think you get that here.
I was really looking forward to the actual game show stuff, but that came surprisingly late in the story. I was disappointed in that as well.
While this book wasn't terrible, it just felt like it tried too hard and kept missing the mark.
*Copy provided in exchange for an honest review*
goodreads|instagram
I thought the set up to this book was very cute, but right off the bat, the clunky, awkward language got to me. It just didn't feel natural, and it took me out of every scene. I think it's just the author's style, but it didn't flow for me.
I also didn't like how the MCs just jumped right into sex scene after sex scene (cucumbers??) with very like build-up or chemistry. I like more of a connection before the action begins, and I don't think you get that here.
I was really looking forward to the actual game show stuff, but that came surprisingly late in the story. I was disappointed in that as well.
While this book wasn't terrible, it just felt like it tried too hard and kept missing the mark.
*Copy provided in exchange for an honest review*
goodreads|instagram
May 26, 2024
Hello everyone, I'm Mr. C Reviewer, and tonight we're discussing (He/Him) Timothy Janovsky's book. The [Fake] Dating Game. This was my first time reading one of his work's and after reading this one I do think that I would like to give his other book's a go.
I'd like to extend a huge thank you to Netgalley for providing a copy of 'The [Fake] Dating Game' as an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This book is set to be Published January 23rd, 2024. The narrative, told using first person perspective following Holden's point of view and spans 29 chapters and an epilogue which in total has 288 pages.
Summary: Holden James finds himself in a downward spiral as he grapples with the challenges life has thrown his way. His opportunity to audition for the beloved game show, Madcap Market, which should have been a shining moment honouring his late Mum, instead plunges him into a state of despair. Alone in a dreary hotel room, nursing a broken heart and drowning in sorrow after a recent breakup, Holden seeks solace in the confines of his room. However, an unexpected encounter with Leo Min, the charming and enigmatic concierge, brings a glimmer of hope into his bleak existence.
Review: -I appreciated that there was a trigger warning at the beginning of the book. The descriptions of the characters and places were well-done. It was easy to follow along, and there were some humorous moments that helped balance out the seriousness of the plot. I never found myself getting bored while reading. The pacing was mostly good, although I was surprised that the game show portion only lasted for a short time towards the end of the book. I had expected it to be a longer and more prominent part of the story.
I typically don't enjoy books with time jumps, especially after the main character's breakup. However, in this particular book, the timing of the jump felt appropriate and it only occurred once in the main storyline. Plus, We had already gotten to know the main character well by that point. What I enjoyed about the book was the use of a different font for most of the text messages, setting them apart from the rest of the book. However, there was one instance where this was not done - a written note from one of the characters in the story.
My favourite aspect of this book was Holden's journey of healing. I felt it was portrayed with sensitivity, and I appreciated that it took time for him to get there. It wasn't a cliché where love magically solves everything, which was refreshing. Additionally, the scavenger hunt scene was a standout moment for me. The main premise - pretending to date in order to be on a reality show - doesn't quite add up since they are actually seeing each other and wanting to know where it could lead to. However, this minor detail did not detract from my enjoyment of the overall story.
-I thoroughly enjoyed getting to know the characters in the book, especially Holden. His genuine passion and excitement for Madcap Market was contagious and I found myself connecting with him on a personal level at times. It was evident that he carried emotional weight from events in his past, and I could feel his emotions as he spoke about them. This added depth to his character and made me even more invested in his story.
Holden's mother sounded like a remarkable person, always there to support him. I wished there were flashbacks in the book that allowed us to get to know her better. However, I was glad we eventually got to meet Holden's Dad. In the beginning, I wasn't sure if we would since he was only mentioned in phone calls and not seen in person. He turned out to be a kind and caring person.
I couldn't help but think Leo and Holden made the cutest pair. As their journey together progressed, I found myself enjoying their growing bond more and more. They just fit together so naturally that I immediately found myself rooting for them. I loved how open they were with each other, always supporting and understanding each other. Their playful banter was a delight to read, especially when it turned flirtatious. It was heart-warming to see Leo give Holden the space he needed to heal, without pushing him too hard. While I did feel like their relationship timeline was rushed, it was balanced out by seeing how Holden and Leo helped each other in different ways throughout the story. Leo's mother was a great addition to the story, showing love and acceptance towards her son and Holden. I would definitely be interested in tasting some of her dishes after reading about them in the book.
-The book's ending with the epilogue was satisfying and left me feeling fulfilled. While the story didn't completely blow me away, I appreciate the increase in queer sweet, feel-good, rom-coms being released. It left me craving pizza in a hotel room and someone to embrace. I believe this book would make for a great movie on the big screen.
-I was ecstatic when I discovered that this book was also available as an audiobook, and even more so when I found out it was narrated by the talented Mark Sanderlin. Listening to the audio while reading greatly enhanced my experience with the book. Mark's clear and easy-to-understand voice made it even more enjoyable. Each character had their own unique voice in the audiobook, bringing them to life and adding an extra layer of richness to the story. I feel that Holden's character, in particular, was well-suited to Mark's voice.
I rate each story I read out of 10 and for this one, I give it an 7. Remember this was what I thought about the book personally and I suggest that you give it a go for yourself.
I'd like to extend a huge thank you to Netgalley for providing a copy of 'The [Fake] Dating Game' as an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This book is set to be Published January 23rd, 2024. The narrative, told using first person perspective following Holden's point of view and spans 29 chapters and an epilogue which in total has 288 pages.
Summary: Holden James finds himself in a downward spiral as he grapples with the challenges life has thrown his way. His opportunity to audition for the beloved game show, Madcap Market, which should have been a shining moment honouring his late Mum, instead plunges him into a state of despair. Alone in a dreary hotel room, nursing a broken heart and drowning in sorrow after a recent breakup, Holden seeks solace in the confines of his room. However, an unexpected encounter with Leo Min, the charming and enigmatic concierge, brings a glimmer of hope into his bleak existence.
Review: -I appreciated that there was a trigger warning at the beginning of the book. The descriptions of the characters and places were well-done. It was easy to follow along, and there were some humorous moments that helped balance out the seriousness of the plot. I never found myself getting bored while reading. The pacing was mostly good, although I was surprised that the game show portion only lasted for a short time towards the end of the book. I had expected it to be a longer and more prominent part of the story.
I typically don't enjoy books with time jumps, especially after the main character's breakup. However, in this particular book, the timing of the jump felt appropriate and it only occurred once in the main storyline. Plus, We had already gotten to know the main character well by that point. What I enjoyed about the book was the use of a different font for most of the text messages, setting them apart from the rest of the book. However, there was one instance where this was not done - a written note from one of the characters in the story.
My favourite aspect of this book was Holden's journey of healing. I felt it was portrayed with sensitivity, and I appreciated that it took time for him to get there. It wasn't a cliché where love magically solves everything, which was refreshing. Additionally, the scavenger hunt scene was a standout moment for me. The main premise - pretending to date in order to be on a reality show - doesn't quite add up since they are actually seeing each other and wanting to know where it could lead to. However, this minor detail did not detract from my enjoyment of the overall story.
-I thoroughly enjoyed getting to know the characters in the book, especially Holden. His genuine passion and excitement for Madcap Market was contagious and I found myself connecting with him on a personal level at times. It was evident that he carried emotional weight from events in his past, and I could feel his emotions as he spoke about them. This added depth to his character and made me even more invested in his story.
Holden's mother sounded like a remarkable person, always there to support him. I wished there were flashbacks in the book that allowed us to get to know her better. However, I was glad we eventually got to meet Holden's Dad. In the beginning, I wasn't sure if we would since he was only mentioned in phone calls and not seen in person. He turned out to be a kind and caring person.
I couldn't help but think Leo and Holden made the cutest pair. As their journey together progressed, I found myself enjoying their growing bond more and more. They just fit together so naturally that I immediately found myself rooting for them. I loved how open they were with each other, always supporting and understanding each other. Their playful banter was a delight to read, especially when it turned flirtatious. It was heart-warming to see Leo give Holden the space he needed to heal, without pushing him too hard. While I did feel like their relationship timeline was rushed, it was balanced out by seeing how Holden and Leo helped each other in different ways throughout the story. Leo's mother was a great addition to the story, showing love and acceptance towards her son and Holden. I would definitely be interested in tasting some of her dishes after reading about them in the book.
-The book's ending with the epilogue was satisfying and left me feeling fulfilled. While the story didn't completely blow me away, I appreciate the increase in queer sweet, feel-good, rom-coms being released. It left me craving pizza in a hotel room and someone to embrace. I believe this book would make for a great movie on the big screen.
-I was ecstatic when I discovered that this book was also available as an audiobook, and even more so when I found out it was narrated by the talented Mark Sanderlin. Listening to the audio while reading greatly enhanced my experience with the book. Mark's clear and easy-to-understand voice made it even more enjoyable. Each character had their own unique voice in the audiobook, bringing them to life and adding an extra layer of richness to the story. I feel that Holden's character, in particular, was well-suited to Mark's voice.
I rate each story I read out of 10 and for this one, I give it an 7. Remember this was what I thought about the book personally and I suggest that you give it a go for yourself.
April 12, 2024
Timothy Janovsky is one of my favourite authors. I adored Never Been Kissed when I read an ARC copy, and also ended up loving Matthew Prince, which became one of my favourite books of all time! I recently read New Adult, and enjoyed that one too, so needless to say, I had really high expectations for this book.
The (Fake) Dating Game marks a new venture for Timothy Janovsky. This was his most adult book so far, and I enjoyed Janovsky entering his spice era. The representation in this book was wonderful and I loved how the relationship progressed. Holden was a little bit of a disaster main character, but Leo definitely complimented him in the right ways. Holden’s ex was horrendous and I cannot believe he spent so much time with that moron. We are thankful for the healing powers of reality television.
I loved learning about Leo's relationship with his mother, and how much they cared about each other. Their relationship was my favourite thing about the book. I wish we got more of that. I also wanted the reality aspect of the show to be a longer segment of the book. I had a specific idea of what I thought this book was going to be before going in, but it was very different. Unfortunately the fake dating aspect didn’t end up being that significant. Despite those drawbacks, I did really enjoy this lighthearted and fun contemporary romance. It was a very quick and easy read. I don’t think it ranks higher than any of his other books I’ve read, but I'm looking forward to reading more of Janovsky's work soon!
I post about queer books on: Instagram Twitter TikTok
The (Fake) Dating Game marks a new venture for Timothy Janovsky. This was his most adult book so far, and I enjoyed Janovsky entering his spice era. The representation in this book was wonderful and I loved how the relationship progressed. Holden was a little bit of a disaster main character, but Leo definitely complimented him in the right ways. Holden’s ex was horrendous and I cannot believe he spent so much time with that moron. We are thankful for the healing powers of reality television.
I loved learning about Leo's relationship with his mother, and how much they cared about each other. Their relationship was my favourite thing about the book. I wish we got more of that. I also wanted the reality aspect of the show to be a longer segment of the book. I had a specific idea of what I thought this book was going to be before going in, but it was very different. Unfortunately the fake dating aspect didn’t end up being that significant. Despite those drawbacks, I did really enjoy this lighthearted and fun contemporary romance. It was a very quick and easy read. I don’t think it ranks higher than any of his other books I’ve read, but I'm looking forward to reading more of Janovsky's work soon!
I post about queer books on: Instagram Twitter TikTok
January 16, 2026
Oh, this author is really getting to me -- in a super good way. Romance. Steamy scenes. Fun quips. Family dynamics. Makes me wish I were young and single again... if this is all the options that could happen! Books really imitate life, and here's the case why. So much of what happens here is only realistic because of the progress made for LGBTQ in the last decade, and it makes me sentimental, proud, and grateful. Janovsky knows how to build beautiful characters with wonderful backstories. He notches up the sexual tension in all the right places. And he brings the tearful life moments we sometimes brush too quickly beyond. I'm finished with all his stand-alone books. Deciding if I read his 3-book series next or wait until the late 2026 release. Thoughts?
October 30, 2023
Timothy Janovsky has been such a huge presence in the MM romance world and his latest novel, THE (FAKE) DATING GAME has further cemented himself as an auto read for MM romance fans. This novel will be released in January 2024 and it should be at the top of your TBR.
When Holden James gets the opportunity to join reality television competition, Madcap Market, he faces a breakup and painful demise of his long-term boyfriend. Without a partner for the show, Holden is possibly disqualified for the new season. That is, until he meets Leo Min, the concierge at the hotel he is residing at while filming. Leo is the perfect candidate for the show and the chemistry between the two is undeniable. Leo can be the replacement partner for Holden's chance at winning this competition, but when emotions run high, things may not be as easily forged as you may think.
THE (FAKE) DATING GAME is steamy AF (seriously, it might be the steamiest book I've read this year) and unequivocally gay—GAYME ON (ok, I'm corny). If you like steamy gay romance, reality competition shows, or just fun escapist reads, this is your book! This book is the perfect combination of Alexis Hall meets C. Travis Rice (Christopher Rice)'s Sapphire Cove series. I cannot wait to see what Timothy Janovsky has for readers next.
When Holden James gets the opportunity to join reality television competition, Madcap Market, he faces a breakup and painful demise of his long-term boyfriend. Without a partner for the show, Holden is possibly disqualified for the new season. That is, until he meets Leo Min, the concierge at the hotel he is residing at while filming. Leo is the perfect candidate for the show and the chemistry between the two is undeniable. Leo can be the replacement partner for Holden's chance at winning this competition, but when emotions run high, things may not be as easily forged as you may think.
THE (FAKE) DATING GAME is steamy AF (seriously, it might be the steamiest book I've read this year) and unequivocally gay—GAYME ON (ok, I'm corny). If you like steamy gay romance, reality competition shows, or just fun escapist reads, this is your book! This book is the perfect combination of Alexis Hall meets C. Travis Rice (Christopher Rice)'s Sapphire Cove series. I cannot wait to see what Timothy Janovsky has for readers next.
June 5, 2024
4.5 stars rounded up. Containing some of the best steam I've seen in a MLM romance and Timothy Janovsky's signature charm and rom-com goodness, The [Fake] Dating Game reminded me exactly of why I love gay romance written by queer men so much.
Read
August 16, 2023DNF at 32%.
I’m sorry. I can’t even pinpoint why I don’t like this story while I loved Timothy Janovski’s other books.
It could be the setting. I’m not a lover of game shows on television.
It could be the sex in this story. Timothy’s previous books were more or less faded to black and in this one Holden and Leo were already having sex at about 15% of the book. It irritated me that they, after knowing each other for less than 24 hours, talked about STI’s and being tested, and immediately believed each other? So no condoms?????
It could be because I received an ARC of one of my most anticipated 2024 reads and want to start reading that one so badly.
It’s probably a me thing and not the story. But I’m looking forward to Timothy’s next book. After all, I liked all his previous books.
I received an ARC from Harlequin Romance and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Follow me on Instagram
I’m sorry. I can’t even pinpoint why I don’t like this story while I loved Timothy Janovski’s other books.
It could be the setting. I’m not a lover of game shows on television.
It could be the sex in this story. Timothy’s previous books were more or less faded to black and in this one Holden and Leo were already having sex at about 15% of the book. It irritated me that they, after knowing each other for less than 24 hours, talked about STI’s and being tested, and immediately believed each other? So no condoms?????
It could be because I received an ARC of one of my most anticipated 2024 reads and want to start reading that one so badly.
It’s probably a me thing and not the story. But I’m looking forward to Timothy’s next book. After all, I liked all his previous books.
I received an ARC from Harlequin Romance and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Follow me on Instagram
September 22, 2023
✰3.5 stars✰ rounded up
This was a fun and light read. There was some clunky language at times, but not enough to take you out of the story.
It’s a single POV and our narrator/main character Holden James is hilarious. He’s witty and clever and truly a lot of fun.
Holden gets the chance to audition for his favorite game show and when he proposes the idea to his boyfriend he gets dumped and rejected. First off, I feel for Holden because he lost his mom and it was their thing together to watch the show and his ex basically says it’s silly and he needs to stop grieving. yikes. I would have been mad too!
But Holden persists. Determined to still audition, he travels to Los Angeles—heartbroken but with a dream. His initial backup plan for a game show partner fall through and that’s where the incredibly attractive hotel concierge comes in. *enter Leo Min.*
Leo needs the money that could be won by winning the show and he agrees to fake date Holden to audition for the show.
This book gives you the fake dating trope with the bonus addition of a clear connection from the beginning. The characters never deny that they are attracted to each other and it’s a wildly fun ride from start to finish.
There are some plot points that seemed unnecessary and the pacing is a little off at times. My biggest qualm was that this was marketed and focused around the game show but that actual part of the story happens really late in the book and actually comes and goes really quickly. The angst in the story feels a little unnatural and some characters within the book act slightly out-of-character from what you’d expect at times. I think it could have just used some fine tuning. That’s where the demotion of stars comes from for me, but aside from that I truly did enjoy it throughout.
It’s a ridiculous and fun story, and I recommend for a funny, light, and enjoyable read.
I received an eARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This was a fun and light read. There was some clunky language at times, but not enough to take you out of the story.
It’s a single POV and our narrator/main character Holden James is hilarious. He’s witty and clever and truly a lot of fun.
Holden gets the chance to audition for his favorite game show and when he proposes the idea to his boyfriend he gets dumped and rejected. First off, I feel for Holden because he lost his mom and it was their thing together to watch the show and his ex basically says it’s silly and he needs to stop grieving. yikes. I would have been mad too!
But Holden persists. Determined to still audition, he travels to Los Angeles—heartbroken but with a dream. His initial backup plan for a game show partner fall through and that’s where the incredibly attractive hotel concierge comes in. *enter Leo Min.*
Leo needs the money that could be won by winning the show and he agrees to fake date Holden to audition for the show.
This book gives you the fake dating trope with the bonus addition of a clear connection from the beginning. The characters never deny that they are attracted to each other and it’s a wildly fun ride from start to finish.
There are some plot points that seemed unnecessary and the pacing is a little off at times. My biggest qualm was that this was marketed and focused around the game show but that actual part of the story happens really late in the book and actually comes and goes really quickly. The angst in the story feels a little unnatural and some characters within the book act slightly out-of-character from what you’d expect at times. I think it could have just used some fine tuning. That’s where the demotion of stars comes from for me, but aside from that I truly did enjoy it throughout.
It’s a ridiculous and fun story, and I recommend for a funny, light, and enjoyable read.
I received an eARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Read
January 30, 2024DNF @40%
I already didn’t love this, but it was definitely over for me when he shoved a cucumber up his ass. (Yes, you read that right!)
I already didn’t love this, but it was definitely over for me when he shoved a cucumber up his ass. (Yes, you read that right!)
February 8, 2024
Ok but this was sooo good!! Read this in one sitting
I was kindly gifted this by harpercollins/millsandboon/afterglow at their date with a book event at London. After watching a video by the author I knew I would love this book.
The spice in this had me gasping and giggling like a child. Both Holden and Leo were hilarious which is exactly what you want from a easy read like this.
Everyone needs to give this a go. Perfect to read for a guaranteed satisfaction!
I was kindly gifted this by harpercollins/millsandboon/afterglow at their date with a book event at London. After watching a video by the author I knew I would love this book.
The spice in this had me gasping and giggling like a child. Both Holden and Leo were hilarious which is exactly what you want from a easy read like this.
Everyone needs to give this a go. Perfect to read for a guaranteed satisfaction!
January 12, 2024
I'll read anything Timothy Janovsky writes. The fact the plot was born from reality television was the cherry on top!
First off, can we just talk about how steamy this book is!? Oh my! It gets ALL the eggplants!
Secondly, I completely adore Holden and Leo. I loved their relationship from start to finish. The chemistry was top shelf!
I also appreciate the fact the author added trigger warnings to the beginning pages of the book.
I highly recommend The (Fake) Dating Game to those who enjoy romcoms, spicy scenes & reality tv.
My thanks to Harlequin Books and Harlequin Publicity Team for this gifted copy!
First off, can we just talk about how steamy this book is!? Oh my! It gets ALL the eggplants!
Secondly, I completely adore Holden and Leo. I loved their relationship from start to finish. The chemistry was top shelf!
I also appreciate the fact the author added trigger warnings to the beginning pages of the book.
I highly recommend The (Fake) Dating Game to those who enjoy romcoms, spicy scenes & reality tv.
My thanks to Harlequin Books and Harlequin Publicity Team for this gifted copy!
February 24, 2024
[2.9] gah it pains me, but a generous 3 stars. after adoring this author’s debut Never Been Kissed (acespec rep yay!) to pieces, i’ve found his subsequent releases to read increasingly stilted and superficial. with this book in particular, it almost felt like the author had too much fun diving into the more explicit side of writing that the relationship development took a backseat. i can get past the scene for the most part (with a heavy sigh and quick shake of the head), but delaying the all-important game show so it doesn’t really feature until the last portion of the book? at least i tried!
April 9, 2025
Thanks to the author, their publisher, and NetGalley for providing me with an ALC of this novel.
3/5 ⭐️
3/5 🌶️
This was my first Timothy Janovsky book and it won’t be my last. While I didn’t love the story necessarily, I loved the characters and the spice that was thrown in. Give me a good MM romance any day. This def was spice with a side of heart and emotion.
3/5 ⭐️
3/5 🌶️
This was my first Timothy Janovsky book and it won’t be my last. While I didn’t love the story necessarily, I loved the characters and the spice that was thrown in. Give me a good MM romance any day. This def was spice with a side of heart and emotion.
January 2, 2024
I love Timothy Janovsky's books so much. His m/m romances have such heart and humor and are always at the top of my lists. The one thing I had always wished for more of, though, was spice. AND HOLY SMOKES DOES HE BRING IT HERE. I felt my face combusting (in a very good way!) in more than one scene.
Oh wait, should we discuss the story? Sorry, yes. Holden James' bf just dumped him but he was banking on him being his partner when he tries out for this book's version of Supermarket Sweep. Enter the hot concierge from the hotel to pretend to be his boyfriend and try out for the show, and also make creative use of produce. FAKE DATING AND SUPERMARKET SWEEP? Yes, thank you, I will. This book also surprised me with being about grief, as Holden processes his grief over his mom passing. It was very touching and well done. I also loved how Leo’s being Korean felt, to me, authentic and I loved his mom for being loving and accepting and also needing to feed them. Like Janovsky's other works, there was humor and heart, and this time a whole lot of spice. A delight.
The Fake Dating Game is out January 23, 2024.
Thank you NetGalley and Harlequin for the advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
Oh wait, should we discuss the story? Sorry, yes. Holden James' bf just dumped him but he was banking on him being his partner when he tries out for this book's version of Supermarket Sweep. Enter the hot concierge from the hotel to pretend to be his boyfriend and try out for the show, and also make creative use of produce. FAKE DATING AND SUPERMARKET SWEEP? Yes, thank you, I will. This book also surprised me with being about grief, as Holden processes his grief over his mom passing. It was very touching and well done. I also loved how Leo’s being Korean felt, to me, authentic and I loved his mom for being loving and accepting and also needing to feed them. Like Janovsky's other works, there was humor and heart, and this time a whole lot of spice. A delight.
The Fake Dating Game is out January 23, 2024.
Thank you NetGalley and Harlequin for the advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
June 3, 2025
RTC
Second book I’m reading from this author. Sounds very exciting!
Second book I’m reading from this author. Sounds very exciting!
April 8, 2024
I've given this a B for both narration and content at AudioGals.
The trend for reality-TV themed romances continues in Timothy Janovsky’s latest standalone novel, The (Fake) Dating Game, in which the PoV character, Holden James, is hoping to compete in a Supermarket Sweep-style gameshow as a kind of homage to his late mother. I enjoyed the story – the love interest is a good guy, and I liked the unlikely meet-cute, but the gameshow element is fairly minimal, so if that’s the main reason for your interest in this title, you might want to alter your expectations a little.
Holden James’ mother died just before he finished high school, around six years before this story begins. They were very close, and one of their favourite things to do together was watch Madcap Market ; they had even planned to apply to go on the show, but then she got sick, and it never happened. But Holden promised her that one day, he’d go on and win it for both of them, and when the story opens, he’s excitedly asking Buckley, his boyfriend of four years, to fly to California with him to attend the auditions (the competitors are always couples – romantic partners or familial) – he’s already bought the plane tickets. But Buckley immediately throws cold water over the idea, disdainfully dismissing Holden’s enthusiasm as an obsession and telling him he really needs to get over his mother’s death. The evening just goes downill from there and ends with them breaking up.
Four weeks later, Holden lands at LAX, even though he hasn’t been able to find someone to audition with. His last bet is an old school friend who lives there – but when she turns him down, Holden heads back to his cheap hotel room to drown his sorrows in the contents of the mini-bar and break-up songs at maximum volume. His wallowing is interrupted around midnight by a phone call from the concierge to ask him to “stop blasting sad bops on a loop” because it’s disturbing the other guests. Holden recognises the voice on the other end – it’s Leo, the cute guy he’d chatted with and who’d helped get him a restaurant reservation earlier in the day. Tipsy and feeling sorry for himself, Holden rambles about everyone else needing to be as miserable as he is and complains about having run out of booze and snacks, and Leo offers him a deal. If he helps him out with the snacks, Holden will turn the music down. He turns it off, and twenty minutes later, Leo is at his door offering pizza and company.
Over the next hour or so – and the game of Monopoly Leo brought with him (he remembered Holden saying he liked games) – Holden and Leo start getting to know each other a little. There’s real chemistry and connection between them; Leo is kind and sympathetic and easy to talk to (plus he’s really hot), and Holden invites him to stay the night. Leo does – although sleeping is all that happens – but they arrange to meet up the next day for some definitely not sleeping ;). Those plans are derailed somewhat when Leo is fired from his job (due to a scheduling mix-up), but on hearing about the prize money Madcap Market offers, he suggests to Holden that they should pretend to be a couple and audition for the show – his half of the prize money will tide him over while he looks for another job.
Holden tells Leo he’s getting ahead of himself; they have to get through several rounds of auditions before getting onto the show, and then they have to actually compete against two other teams in order to win. Leo is confident they’ll make it, but Holden – who knows the show format inside out – isn’t so sure. Still, he has zero chance of getting on the show on his own, so he decides to take Leo up on his offer. They have a lot of work to do – the contestants need a really good knowledge of grocery brands to win the trivia round, for example, and Leo is pretty clueless, so Holden is going to have to coach him – but he’s determined to give it his best shot.
The romance in this story worked really well for me. It’s sweet and sexy (this is the author’s steamiest book yet) and funny and charming, and the two leads are likeable and thoroughly engaging. They start hooking up pretty early on, but because the author has already established a strong connection between them, the sex never feels casual – it’s more that these two have been in a relationship almost from the start and they just need to realise it. I really liked the way Leo slowly helps Holden start to regain his self confidence, and how he knows to give him the space he needs to heal.
A large part of the story is centered around Holden’s struggles to come to terms with his grief and find a way to move on. His relationship with his mother is genuinely touching; it’s easy to understand exactly why he’s finding it so hard to let go, and the author handles it in a sensitive and relatable manner.
There are a couple of big-ish downsides to the story that caused me to bring my overall grade down a bit, though. First of all, Buckley flip-flops between being an arsehole ex and a partner who deserved better, which makes him seem like two different characters; and secondly, the timeline is really, REALLY off. Quite a few of the reviews I’ve read have complained that the gameshow aspect of the story is too little, too late, although honestly, I didn’t have a problem with that because it wasn’t the main selling point for me. My issue is with the fact that the auditions, call-backs and filming all happen within less than a week, which is highly implausible.
This is the first time I’ve listened to Mark Sanderlin and I confess my reaction is mixed. He’s very good, no question – his performance is well-paced and both the leads and secondary characters are clearly differentiated – it’s just that I didn’t particularly care for his voice-type, which is higher-pitched than pretty much all the other male narrators I listen to regularly. (And honestly, I did occasionally have to remind myself I wasn’t listening to a female narrator with a low-pitched voice!) YMMV on that of course. Mr. Sanderlin hits all the emotional beats of the story and portrays both leads very well, injecting real warmth and humour into their dialogue and bringing out Leo’s confidence and open, friendly personality as well as conveying Holden’s quiet reticence and the deep sorrow lurking just below the surface. The connection between them is nicely conveyed and the sex scenes are well done.
The (Fake) Dating Game a funny, tender and poignant tale about a young man struggling to come to terms with grief and find his way, wrapped up in a sexy/sweet love story, and I enjoyed listening to it despite my reservations.
This review originally appeared at AudioGals .
The trend for reality-TV themed romances continues in Timothy Janovsky’s latest standalone novel, The (Fake) Dating Game, in which the PoV character, Holden James, is hoping to compete in a Supermarket Sweep-style gameshow as a kind of homage to his late mother. I enjoyed the story – the love interest is a good guy, and I liked the unlikely meet-cute, but the gameshow element is fairly minimal, so if that’s the main reason for your interest in this title, you might want to alter your expectations a little.
Holden James’ mother died just before he finished high school, around six years before this story begins. They were very close, and one of their favourite things to do together was watch Madcap Market ; they had even planned to apply to go on the show, but then she got sick, and it never happened. But Holden promised her that one day, he’d go on and win it for both of them, and when the story opens, he’s excitedly asking Buckley, his boyfriend of four years, to fly to California with him to attend the auditions (the competitors are always couples – romantic partners or familial) – he’s already bought the plane tickets. But Buckley immediately throws cold water over the idea, disdainfully dismissing Holden’s enthusiasm as an obsession and telling him he really needs to get over his mother’s death. The evening just goes downill from there and ends with them breaking up.
Four weeks later, Holden lands at LAX, even though he hasn’t been able to find someone to audition with. His last bet is an old school friend who lives there – but when she turns him down, Holden heads back to his cheap hotel room to drown his sorrows in the contents of the mini-bar and break-up songs at maximum volume. His wallowing is interrupted around midnight by a phone call from the concierge to ask him to “stop blasting sad bops on a loop” because it’s disturbing the other guests. Holden recognises the voice on the other end – it’s Leo, the cute guy he’d chatted with and who’d helped get him a restaurant reservation earlier in the day. Tipsy and feeling sorry for himself, Holden rambles about everyone else needing to be as miserable as he is and complains about having run out of booze and snacks, and Leo offers him a deal. If he helps him out with the snacks, Holden will turn the music down. He turns it off, and twenty minutes later, Leo is at his door offering pizza and company.
Over the next hour or so – and the game of Monopoly Leo brought with him (he remembered Holden saying he liked games) – Holden and Leo start getting to know each other a little. There’s real chemistry and connection between them; Leo is kind and sympathetic and easy to talk to (plus he’s really hot), and Holden invites him to stay the night. Leo does – although sleeping is all that happens – but they arrange to meet up the next day for some definitely not sleeping ;). Those plans are derailed somewhat when Leo is fired from his job (due to a scheduling mix-up), but on hearing about the prize money Madcap Market offers, he suggests to Holden that they should pretend to be a couple and audition for the show – his half of the prize money will tide him over while he looks for another job.
Holden tells Leo he’s getting ahead of himself; they have to get through several rounds of auditions before getting onto the show, and then they have to actually compete against two other teams in order to win. Leo is confident they’ll make it, but Holden – who knows the show format inside out – isn’t so sure. Still, he has zero chance of getting on the show on his own, so he decides to take Leo up on his offer. They have a lot of work to do – the contestants need a really good knowledge of grocery brands to win the trivia round, for example, and Leo is pretty clueless, so Holden is going to have to coach him – but he’s determined to give it his best shot.
The romance in this story worked really well for me. It’s sweet and sexy (this is the author’s steamiest book yet) and funny and charming, and the two leads are likeable and thoroughly engaging. They start hooking up pretty early on, but because the author has already established a strong connection between them, the sex never feels casual – it’s more that these two have been in a relationship almost from the start and they just need to realise it. I really liked the way Leo slowly helps Holden start to regain his self confidence, and how he knows to give him the space he needs to heal.
A large part of the story is centered around Holden’s struggles to come to terms with his grief and find a way to move on. His relationship with his mother is genuinely touching; it’s easy to understand exactly why he’s finding it so hard to let go, and the author handles it in a sensitive and relatable manner.
There are a couple of big-ish downsides to the story that caused me to bring my overall grade down a bit, though. First of all, Buckley flip-flops between being an arsehole ex and a partner who deserved better, which makes him seem like two different characters; and secondly, the timeline is really, REALLY off. Quite a few of the reviews I’ve read have complained that the gameshow aspect of the story is too little, too late, although honestly, I didn’t have a problem with that because it wasn’t the main selling point for me. My issue is with the fact that the auditions, call-backs and filming all happen within less than a week, which is highly implausible.
This is the first time I’ve listened to Mark Sanderlin and I confess my reaction is mixed. He’s very good, no question – his performance is well-paced and both the leads and secondary characters are clearly differentiated – it’s just that I didn’t particularly care for his voice-type, which is higher-pitched than pretty much all the other male narrators I listen to regularly. (And honestly, I did occasionally have to remind myself I wasn’t listening to a female narrator with a low-pitched voice!) YMMV on that of course. Mr. Sanderlin hits all the emotional beats of the story and portrays both leads very well, injecting real warmth and humour into their dialogue and bringing out Leo’s confidence and open, friendly personality as well as conveying Holden’s quiet reticence and the deep sorrow lurking just below the surface. The connection between them is nicely conveyed and the sex scenes are well done.
The (Fake) Dating Game a funny, tender and poignant tale about a young man struggling to come to terms with grief and find his way, wrapped up in a sexy/sweet love story, and I enjoyed listening to it despite my reservations.
This review originally appeared at AudioGals .
September 4, 2023
Holden James loves the game show Madcap Market. He and his late mother watched it religiously while he was growing up and he promised her he would someday win the show himself. So when he excitedly asks his live-in boyfriend of 4 years, Buckley, to come on the show with him, he’s shocked when Buckley says no, and then promptly breaks up with him.
Now stuck crashing at his dad’s house in the burbs, Holden decides to fly to LA on a dream and a prayer that he can convince one of Buckley’s friends to go on the show with him. Of course she says no, and Holden ends up drowning his sorrows in his hotel room mini bar. When the cute guy at concierge, Leo, comes to his room to tell him guests are complaining about his wallowing, they end up forming a connection over pizza and monopoly. A plan is hatched for the two to pretend to be a couple and go on Madcap Market together. Because fake dating always works exactly as it should, right?
I loved this book. I read it in one sitting, which is rare for me. I’ve read all of Timothy Janovsky’s books and this one definitely tops the list. And he’s showing us a new side to his writing as he has the spice factor turned all way up with this one 🔥 Although Holden and Leo’s connection could be described as somewhat of an insta-love, don’t be deterred; it felt so organic. This is a sweet and fun romance, but please note that our boy Holden is definitely going through it. I empathized with Holden’s grief and some of the rash decisions he made were so relatable and real. Grief is a central theme throughout this book and my heart broke, but the author did a beautiful job putting it back together.
I found myself smiling constantly throughout this book. I loved watching Leo help Holden reclaim his self-confidence in all facets of life. I loved when Leo didn’t push Holden and gave him the space he needed to heal. I loved learning about Leo’s Korean culture and meeting Ms. Min. And I loveddd Holden’s character growth and the perfect little epilogue to tie up their story. This is the author’s first book with Harlequin and it hit the ball out of the park for me. I can’t wait to see what’s next!
‼️ Just adding a CW: Leo is written as a light dom in the bedroom, but each sexual encounter takes place between two very eager and consenting adult characters. They constantly check-in with one another and have a safe word, if needed.
Thank you to the author and NetGalley for this ARC. Look for The (Fake) Dating Game on 1/23/24 💕
Now stuck crashing at his dad’s house in the burbs, Holden decides to fly to LA on a dream and a prayer that he can convince one of Buckley’s friends to go on the show with him. Of course she says no, and Holden ends up drowning his sorrows in his hotel room mini bar. When the cute guy at concierge, Leo, comes to his room to tell him guests are complaining about his wallowing, they end up forming a connection over pizza and monopoly. A plan is hatched for the two to pretend to be a couple and go on Madcap Market together. Because fake dating always works exactly as it should, right?
I loved this book. I read it in one sitting, which is rare for me. I’ve read all of Timothy Janovsky’s books and this one definitely tops the list. And he’s showing us a new side to his writing as he has the spice factor turned all way up with this one 🔥 Although Holden and Leo’s connection could be described as somewhat of an insta-love, don’t be deterred; it felt so organic. This is a sweet and fun romance, but please note that our boy Holden is definitely going through it. I empathized with Holden’s grief and some of the rash decisions he made were so relatable and real. Grief is a central theme throughout this book and my heart broke, but the author did a beautiful job putting it back together.
I found myself smiling constantly throughout this book. I loved watching Leo help Holden reclaim his self-confidence in all facets of life. I loved when Leo didn’t push Holden and gave him the space he needed to heal. I loved learning about Leo’s Korean culture and meeting Ms. Min. And I loveddd Holden’s character growth and the perfect little epilogue to tie up their story. This is the author’s first book with Harlequin and it hit the ball out of the park for me. I can’t wait to see what’s next!
‼️ Just adding a CW: Leo is written as a light dom in the bedroom, but each sexual encounter takes place between two very eager and consenting adult characters. They constantly check-in with one another and have a safe word, if needed.
Thank you to the author and NetGalley for this ARC. Look for The (Fake) Dating Game on 1/23/24 💕
January 25, 2024
This is such fun and charming romance novel that will interest most millennials because its plot revolves around a Supermarket Sweep-type game show (do I need to say more?). The story is told from Holden's POV, a character who is finding himself a bit lost as he's grieving the passing of his mother, and the sudden dissolution of his long-term relationship leaves him without a partner to audition for said supermarket game show with. Enter Leo, a hotel concierge Holden bonds with over pizza and break-up songs, and a fake dating plot is born. I loved the time that they spent getting to know each other as they prepared for their audition and how they found commonality in feeling a bit unmotivated in their professional lives (a reassuringly realistic experience for twenty-year-olds).
I've really enjoyed Janovsky's previous books and this was another great romance that is definitely much spicier than the rest. I have a few quibbles with the role his ex plays later in the book and the dreaded 3rd act inevitability, but honestly, these are small complaints.
Highly recommend this to all romance readers! Many thanks to Harlequin and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
I've really enjoyed Janovsky's previous books and this was another great romance that is definitely much spicier than the rest. I have a few quibbles with the role his ex plays later in the book and the dreaded 3rd act inevitability, but honestly, these are small complaints.
Highly recommend this to all romance readers! Many thanks to Harlequin and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
July 1, 2025
This was a short, simple read. It was a nice break between some of the darker books I’ve read this year. Holden and Leo were an incredible pair. I loved how mutual the pining was between the two of them. While the development of their relationship was admittedly very fast, the book was well paced for its length.
I do have an issue with stories that punish the main character for being justifiably “rude” to characters who have used them, abused them, or otherwise wronged them. The scene in which Holden apologized to Buckley was so frustrating. Especially when Buckley never actually said the words “I’m sorry” in return. Maybe I would have bought the “we were bad for each other” arc if Buckley hadn’t actively tried to sabotage Holden’s time on Madcap Market when he knew how special it was to Holden. Alsooooo I fear Leo forgiving Holden happened way too fast. Irl the way Holden dipped would have been a major red flag 🚩 like yikes
Overall, it’s a cute book. Not perfect by any means but I enjoyed it nonetheless.
I do have an issue with stories that punish the main character for being justifiably “rude” to characters who have used them, abused them, or otherwise wronged them. The scene in which Holden apologized to Buckley was so frustrating. Especially when Buckley never actually said the words “I’m sorry” in return. Maybe I would have bought the “we were bad for each other” arc if Buckley hadn’t actively tried to sabotage Holden’s time on Madcap Market when he knew how special it was to Holden. Alsooooo I fear Leo forgiving Holden happened way too fast. Irl the way Holden dipped would have been a major red flag 🚩 like yikes
Overall, it’s a cute book. Not perfect by any means but I enjoyed it nonetheless.
March 8, 2024
2.5 - I'm feeling generous. This book is a hot mess, especially the pacing. Also it's really kinky, which I did not expect after reading this author's previous books. It is a Harlequin Romance though, so I should have been less surprised. That's on me.
TW: past death of a parent (blood clot), discussions of cancer, cheating ex, grief
I picked this up specifically because I wanted something short and smutty, and that is what this delivered. The plot has about as much substance as a g-string.
Things To Know:
-The fake dating is really not fake dating. They pretend to be a couple for the show, but before they have to put on the ruse they start having a physical and emotional relationship and hang out for like three days straight, so they're already halfway to love by then.
-There is a scene with a cucumber that will leave you a changed person, but not in a good way. Unless you read erotica. Then it probably won't make you even blink.
-Grief is major theme of the book, but it doesn't really show up in full force for 2/3 or so. Then it hits you like a TRAIN and I was crying. I picked this up for a smutty 230 pages and WAS CRYING. What the hell Timothy Janovsky.
I loved the grief rep, I loved both of their parents and their relationships with each other, I loved the scavenger hunt bit. I liked the meet cute a whole lot. So I would definitely not say I disliked this book, it's just objectively not very good and not worth your time—unless you like your smut with a side of kink.
Rep: gay main character, gay Korean-American love interest
TW: past death of a parent (blood clot), discussions of cancer, cheating ex, grief
I picked this up specifically because I wanted something short and smutty, and that is what this delivered. The plot has about as much substance as a g-string.
Things To Know:
-The fake dating is really not fake dating. They pretend to be a couple for the show, but before they have to put on the ruse they start having a physical and emotional relationship and hang out for like three days straight, so they're already halfway to love by then.
-There is a scene with a cucumber that will leave you a changed person, but not in a good way. Unless you read erotica. Then it probably won't make you even blink.
-Grief is major theme of the book, but it doesn't really show up in full force for 2/3 or so. Then it hits you like a TRAIN and I was crying. I picked this up for a smutty 230 pages and WAS CRYING. What the hell Timothy Janovsky.
I loved the grief rep, I loved both of their parents and their relationships with each other, I loved the scavenger hunt bit. I liked the meet cute a whole lot. So I would definitely not say I disliked this book, it's just objectively not very good and not worth your time—unless you like your smut with a side of kink.
Rep: gay main character, gay Korean-American love interest
April 12, 2024
It's a bit of an up and down with the books of Timothy Janovsky. The first one was good, the second one was okay and the third one was awesome. When I picked up this book, I expected it to be at least okay. Well, this book is kind of a mixed bag of things that don't go together well.
The marketing for this book has set an emphasis on “steam” and “spice”, which is just an euphemism for sex scenes. The ones you get in every romance novel. But here, they don't work. This isn't a romance novel. And, despite the funny title, this also isn't a rom-com. This is drama. A drama with comedic elements, but still drama. You don't expect explicit sex scenes in a drama novel. Most of all, not that many.
Holden, the main character, has been dumped by his long time boyfriend in an unpleasant way. He also lost his mother a few years prior. Two months later he's still dealing with the trauma of both events. Same goes for Leo, the love interest. He's also dealing with the trauma of a previous relationship along with a bunch of other problems. The game show thing is just a plot device to keep things going.
So, we have a story that would have made for a good romantic drama. But it's bloated with unnecessary sex scenes. Throw in a half-baked game show plot and fake dating. I wouldn't mind any of these if it was well written. But it's all just telling instead of showing. So I found myself not only skimming the “spicy” scenes, but also the rest of the book.
In conclusion, this book is boring. Fell asleep after two-thirds and DNF.
The marketing for this book has set an emphasis on “steam” and “spice”, which is just an euphemism for sex scenes. The ones you get in every romance novel. But here, they don't work. This isn't a romance novel. And, despite the funny title, this also isn't a rom-com. This is drama. A drama with comedic elements, but still drama. You don't expect explicit sex scenes in a drama novel. Most of all, not that many.
Holden, the main character, has been dumped by his long time boyfriend in an unpleasant way. He also lost his mother a few years prior. Two months later he's still dealing with the trauma of both events. Same goes for Leo, the love interest. He's also dealing with the trauma of a previous relationship along with a bunch of other problems. The game show thing is just a plot device to keep things going.
So, we have a story that would have made for a good romantic drama. But it's bloated with unnecessary sex scenes. Throw in a half-baked game show plot and fake dating. I wouldn't mind any of these if it was well written. But it's all just telling instead of showing. So I found myself not only skimming the “spicy” scenes, but also the rest of the book.
In conclusion, this book is boring. Fell asleep after two-thirds and DNF.
August 16, 2023
This started off so much fun, and felt like it could be a new favourite. Timothy Janovsky is really great at writing romcoms, and while my enjoyment of this fizzled out a little, I definitely did enjoy it. Alison Cochrun described this as "idiots in love" in the blurb, which is a very apt description and was so fun to read about. My main issue was just with the pacing. We're told in the synopsis that this is a fake dating plot to compete in a game show, but the game show aspect starts so late in the story, and I would have liked to see a lot more of it. And then the resolution after that just feels so short as well, which made everything feel really rushed after the story had been set up so thoroughly. This is especially a shame to me because I loved the first half of the book, which felt refreshing and funny.
April 10, 2024
I liked the two leads but this is an absolute mess. The premise could have been fun but was so poorly executed I was legitimately angry. There is a twist near the end that almost had me DNF and I’m pumping the breaks on reading this author again for quite some time.
July 9, 2024
So freaking cute! This book was really fun and had me laughing at all the adorable moments. it deals with relationships and grief while also having game show TV and all the spice. I was here for it and definitely want to read more by this author now.
February 28, 2024
This was my favorite Timothy Janovsky book to date! Could it be the fake dating? Possibly! Could it be the Supermarket Sweep type game show? Absolutely! Could it be that this is the SMUTTIEST book he’s written? YESSSSSSS!!
The Fake Dating Game starts with Holden getting dumped by his long time boyfriend, Buckley, right as he’s about to ask him to audition for his favorite show, Madcap Market. This is the same boyfriend that in his speech about why they shouldn’t be together, tells him to get over the death of his mother, because it had been years. That definitely shows you what kind of person he is.
Holden decides to fly to LA to audition for the show in the off chance that he can find someone to go on it with him. When he’s turned down by a “friend”, who ends up never having been a friend to him at all, it looks as if all of his money has gone to waste, so he gets drunk to pass the time. Of course, that’s when the cute hotel concierge comes into the picture.
Leo Min is sexy and snarky and more than a little bit kinky (which we find out later)… and all in to fake a relationship for the chance at half of 100k. But like all good fake dating stories, at some point, the fake becomes real and the feelings get involved. Unlike most fake dating, the sex came right from the beginning of their relationship… after everyone was sober, of course.
This was incredibly cute and full of emotions that I wasn’t expecting in a RomCom. I love that the MC falls in love fast… you could say it was one step from insta-love, but not quite. I think anyone that knows queer people (who aren’t on the ace spectrum)… we fall in love quite quickly. We shine bright like a diamond and our love burns like a shooting star. Was that cheesy and cringy enough for you? I got more, if need be!
4.5⭐️
The Fake Dating Game starts with Holden getting dumped by his long time boyfriend, Buckley, right as he’s about to ask him to audition for his favorite show, Madcap Market. This is the same boyfriend that in his speech about why they shouldn’t be together, tells him to get over the death of his mother, because it had been years. That definitely shows you what kind of person he is.
Holden decides to fly to LA to audition for the show in the off chance that he can find someone to go on it with him. When he’s turned down by a “friend”, who ends up never having been a friend to him at all, it looks as if all of his money has gone to waste, so he gets drunk to pass the time. Of course, that’s when the cute hotel concierge comes into the picture.
Leo Min is sexy and snarky and more than a little bit kinky (which we find out later)… and all in to fake a relationship for the chance at half of 100k. But like all good fake dating stories, at some point, the fake becomes real and the feelings get involved. Unlike most fake dating, the sex came right from the beginning of their relationship… after everyone was sober, of course.
This was incredibly cute and full of emotions that I wasn’t expecting in a RomCom. I love that the MC falls in love fast… you could say it was one step from insta-love, but not quite. I think anyone that knows queer people (who aren’t on the ace spectrum)… we fall in love quite quickly. We shine bright like a diamond and our love burns like a shooting star. Was that cheesy and cringy enough for you? I got more, if need be!
4.5⭐️
February 1, 2024
A Joyfully Jay review.
4 stars
This is a fun story with a nice meet-cute for two guys who are not quite sure where they are going with their lives, but unexpectedly find a connection together. Both Holden and Leo are in their mid-20s, doing jobs they don’t really like, and living with their parents. Both are broke and neither quite knows what they want to do with their life. It gives them an immediate connection, even as these guys are also very different. Holden is very clearly still grieving the loss of his mother and he feels her absence keenly. She died right before college and Holden has sort of just powered through without ever really emotionally dealing with his loss. Going on Madcap Market is in part an homage to her, as the show was special to them both and gives him a way to feel a connection to his mother.
There is humor and lightness here, but also some deeper moments, particularly with regard to both of their relationships with their mothers. I found this entertaining overall and a worthwhile read.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
4 stars
This is a fun story with a nice meet-cute for two guys who are not quite sure where they are going with their lives, but unexpectedly find a connection together. Both Holden and Leo are in their mid-20s, doing jobs they don’t really like, and living with their parents. Both are broke and neither quite knows what they want to do with their life. It gives them an immediate connection, even as these guys are also very different. Holden is very clearly still grieving the loss of his mother and he feels her absence keenly. She died right before college and Holden has sort of just powered through without ever really emotionally dealing with his loss. Going on Madcap Market is in part an homage to her, as the show was special to them both and gives him a way to feel a connection to his mother.
There is humor and lightness here, but also some deeper moments, particularly with regard to both of their relationships with their mothers. I found this entertaining overall and a worthwhile read.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
August 12, 2025
I finally really enjoyed a Timothy Janovsky book! The premise of this was really fun, there was great chemistry between the characters, and interesting personal journeys that they both have to go on. There are plenty of silly, fun, and steamy situations throughout the book. But also plenty of heart and emotions dealing with families. Definitely check this one out if you’re a fan of queer romcoms!
July 2, 2025
This was a fast paced faking dating story that had some great spice and some good laughs also. I liked the setting of the story too with the game show and the little bit of opposites attack with a great hea.
April 14, 2024
Dang I adore Timothy Janovsky's writing! His characters are so uniqe and interesting, and the situations Janovsky comes up with are always so clever. The [Fake] Dating Game is funny and sweet and totally adorable.
The audio version is beautifully performed by Mark Sanderlin.
The audio version is beautifully performed by Mark Sanderlin.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 607 reviews