You know, most books I rank five stars because I think they're really good, because they bring some special to the table, or because I can enjoy them immensely, no matter what their flaws might be. The Lois Lane Archives falls into this latter category. I am far from a comic book historian, but I am a big fan of comics from the golden, silver and modern ages. While my general tastes tend to lean toward the modern age as it tends to have deeper (albeit much more confusing) storylines and characterizations, I can't help but love classic silver age comics, mostly because they are completely insane and unintentionally hilarious. If you are looking for great unintentional hilarity, look no further than the Lois Lane archives.
All the great characters are there, though maybe not as recognizable as you might remember them. Lois Lane is manipulative and prone to delusions of grandeur (or just flat out delusions, as a knock to the head will make her think she's anything from a witch to Annie Oakley). Superman has problem-solving skills that only a crazy person would view as logical ("I must get out of my apartment without being seen as Superman; I know, let me light this carpet on fire and jump out the window behind it!"). More often than not he's out there looking to teach Lois a lesson instead of saving the world, and all too often the rest of the people in this strange, skewed version of the DC universe play along with whatever craziness is going on in their Super-courtship because, well, why not?
And the plots, oh the glorious plots. Lois quits her job and becomes a chef at a diner so she can win Superman over with her cooking. Superman blasts Lois with an experimental ray that makes her incredibly fat so she won't be killed by a mob hitman. Lois takes a job at a pretzel factory so she can win a job in a Broadway play. Logic and sanity take a vacation in these silver-age adventures of Lois and Superman (never Clark, since Clark is a wimp, and besides, who'd want to be Mrs. Kent when they can be Mrs. Superman?)
And yet, despite the insanity, despite the insulting nature of their gender politics and the bizarre, outlandish way they play with these classic characters, there is an odd charm to these old stories I just can't get around. They're laughably bad, yet strangely endearing all at once.
This is, without a doubt, the most I've ever laughed while reading a book, and some of the most fun I have had reading period. I just hope they continue to release more of these archives in the near future!