I'm counting this one as finished because I managed about half of it before I just couldn't anymore.
Like every book I read lately, it seems, I really wanted and expected to love this book. It came with high praise. I have liked some of Preston's blog entries. But while the book is, fortunately, better than Blue Like Jazz (which it is often compared to), it is full of equally uninteresting college feelings and drama and poetic language. Oddly enough, all things I like in moderation, but there is not really any moderation here.
It is like reading someone's Livejournal from their college years - and I say that from experience because I kept one at that time. All angst and vagueness and no explanatory details. Names of friends and peers thrown around until you can't figure out who they are, or why you should care. Conversations and things that were Very Important to the person experiencing them because College and Life Transitions and because they know the details and the context that we, as the readers, just don't. I almost said can't, but I don't think that's true. We could have, but this book just doesn't get us there.
Maybe I am too old and jaded to be the target market for this book. But college feels were previously my love language, and I just slogged through this one, thinking, dude, you went to college and had feelings? Welcome to ALL OF US. I agree with Madeleine L'Engle that it's not anyone's job to tell it best but to tell it in their own way, but I never connected with Yancey's spiritual journey here in a way that illuminated mine... or, for that matter, his, because it was all pseudofactual details trying to be forced to have Great Meaning. And one sentence paragraphs. AAAAAH.
I felt as if I was reading a monologue of his. Maybe it would have changed had I persevered through the backstory wedged between the initial silence of God and (I assume) the later discussion of the silence of God, but I just couldn't because after trying for a while I realized I didn't care at all. Having gone through my own college silences, and in the middle of one now, I had to finally admit I had negative amounts of interest in it and give up on this book, which I am still counting as finished, because I deserve that and I'm an adult and I do what I want.
Preston makes one comment that stuck with me because I happen to know, or assume, some of the backstory. He wonders about the things he didn't write down. I am the same way. However, he never describes this. Talking about your (I assume) need to write all things down to remember them would be appropriate here.
I think this could have been a very good book, with some ruthless editing. Unfortunately, that didn't happen.