Missing Person: Alice is the second book in the Finder Mysteries series by British author, Simon Mason. In mid-July, 2015, twelve-year-old Alice Johnson doesn’t turn up to school: her bag of papers is located part-way through her morning paper round; a motorist sees her some distance from there, apparently heading for the highway; a businesswoman spots her in a town some distance away, chatting to the driver of a black car, then getting in. She isn’t seen again, and no body is found.
Nine years later, Vince Burns is arrested for the murder of fourteen-year-old schoolgirl, Joleen Price, and proximity puts him under suspicion for Alice’s possible abduction: he had the opportunity, and he doesn’t have an alibi. His attitude during questioning about Alice is strangely coy.
Former police detective, Talib, aka The Finder, is called in to review the missing person case. He studies the file, and interviews those associated with the case: the police SIO, the witnesses, and Alice’s mother, her father, the woman Rob Johnson lived with at the time, staff, teachers and classmates at her school, her newsagent employer. The owner of his B&B offers an opinion.
The witness statements seem to contradict one another, while the girl described by those who should have known her well were inconsistent enough that a teacher wondered if she was “a girl deliberately presenting others with different, sometimes contradictory, versions of herself.”
The Finder traces her route from where she was last seen and speculates on possible destinations that might have put her in Burns’s orbit. He interviews Burns, and wonders if the man’s coyness about Alice may point to a desire for notoriety rather than actual guilt.
He keeps in mind all the potential reasons that a pre-teen might go missing: “Because they are forcibly abducted. Because they are persuaded or coerced. Because they are frightened. Because they want to escape. Because they are rescued. Because they have done something terrible. Because they are victims of a crime. And also, sometimes, for no reason they could ever explain, out of an inexplicable but overwhelming need.” What applies to Alice Johnson?
The finder’s own story is only hinted at, but it’s clear he is intelligent and thorough, compassionate and kind. When the B&B owner is curious about his motivation for such a challenging job, he muses “Would I have said that I was driven to find out the truth, to ‘change the picture’, to replace a false story with the true one?”
When he witnesses a heated exchange between Alice’s still grieving, embittered, estranged parents, he wonders if the novel he’s reading in his down time offers a clue to the truth? The plot takes a few turns and, even though the astute reader may have a strong suspicion about Alice’s fate, especially if they have read the other book in this series, the reveal is definitely worth persisting for. More of this series will be most welcome.
This unbiased review is from an uncorrected proof copy provided by NetGalley and Quercus Books/riverrun.