This time the crew has come across a functional alien civilization, or at least the artificial lifeforms created by that civilization which forms its own separate civilization. Humanity has long distrusted artificial intelligence due to their propensity to try to destroy all biological life, but perhaps they were created by humans. AI created by aliens may be entirely different. There's only one way to find out, and they may be the key needed to unlock even greater technological wonders.
The alien AI are suitably alien aren't merely humans described differently. They hate all biological life because it's unclean and causes them shun any member who comes into microbes or anything else biological. For the sake of their advance they're willing and able to overcome their disgust and the existential threat posed by humanity. Biological life has all other sorts of shortcomings, but there's no sense to hold that against them.
The ethics of the characters continue to make me wonder. There's seemingly only two solutions to ethical dilemmas. Either ignore them entirely or destroy their source. There's no working through them, coming to a compromise, or otherwise interacting with them. They're nothing if not ruthlessly decisive regardless of what the matter is. The primary benefit of this is that it doesn't involve many pages of moping, agonizing, or otherwise discussing decisions internally or externally. It does make the character seem rather callous at times though.
The biggest problem I have with this series is that it hypes something up only for it the fizzle out over and over again. It's basically "Here's a really cool thing. Woah, wouldn't it be awesome if we did this? Think of the implications! Did you think of them? Yeah, I think the same way, so it's a good thing we're not going to let the cool thing happen in any meaningful way. Consider all the problems that would cause. Anyway, here's a really cool thing..." Maybe it's intentional and trying to teach a lesson that not everything should be done and that we ought to be glad when our recklessly cool plans are obstructed. Even so, it makes me want to see the teacher after class and give them a failing grade.
Despite that, the promises made for the last book are grand ones indeed. I know that I should doubt them and expect that the same thing will happen yet again, but I want to believe. Surely the promise of cool thing and neat stuff will be fulfilled next time. If they aren't, well, that'd be disappointing but in line with what's come before and I won't judge it harshly for that.
Rating: 3.5/5