What do you think?
Rate this book
Hearts of Glass #1
The Artist's Apprentice
10 hours, 56 minutes
In this heart-wrenching and utterly spellbinding story of love and artistic ambition, a young woman fights to be true to herself in a world where duty, money and class jeopardise her dreams.
England, 1908: Alice Dalton never intended to rebel against her aristocratic parents. But after her father’s failed attempt to arrange a marriage for her with Edmund Cutler, son of a wealthy stockbroker, she flees the family home humiliated – and determined to make a life for herself as an independent woman, however hard that might be.
When a chance opportunity leads to her taking a position as a stained-glass artist’s apprentice, Alice is stunned when she meets the man she’ll be working for; the hateful Edmund Cutler. It seems he too has turned his back on his family and has followed his passion for art, and at terrible cost.
But as they work together, mixing paints and composing their stained-glass window commissions side by side, she finds herself softening towards him, and can’t ignore the sparks that fly between them. With family conflict brewing and war on the horizon, soon Alice finds that loving Edmund proves the hardest fight, and greatest adventure, of her life.
A gripping historical novel for fans of Fiona Valpy, Rhys Bowen and Lucinda Riley.
The Artist’s Apprentice was previously published as The Colour of Glass.
In this heart-wrenching and utterly spellbinding story of love and artistic ambition, a young woman fights to be true to herself in a world where duty, money and class jeopardise her dreams.
England, 1908: Alice Dalton never intended to rebel against her aristocratic parents. But after her father’s failed attempt to arrange a marriage for her with Edmund Cutler, son of a wealthy stockbroker, she flees the family home humiliated – and determined to make a life for herself as an independent woman, however hard that might be.
When a chance opportunity leads to her taking a position as a stained-glass artist’s apprentice, Alice is stunned when she meets the man she’ll be working for; the hateful Edmund Cutler. It seems he too has turned his back on his family and has followed his passion for art, and at terrible cost.
But as they work together, mixing paints and composing their stained-glass window commissions side by side, she finds herself softening towards him, and can’t ignore the sparks that fly between them. With family conflict brewing and war on the horizon, soon Alice finds that loving Edmund proves the hardest fight, and greatest adventure, of her life.
A gripping historical novel for fans of Fiona Valpy, Rhys Bowen and Lucinda Riley.
The Artist’s Apprentice was previously published as The Colour of Glass.
Audiobook
Published February 13, 2024
About the author
Clare Flynn
46 books233 followersClare Flynn is the author of twety historical novels and a collection of short stories. She is the 2020 winner of the UK Selfies Adult Fiction prize for her best-selling novel The Pearl of Penang, was shortlisted for the RNA Industry Awards Indie Champion of the Year for 2021 and won the award in 2022.
Clare lives in Eastbourne. on the south coast of the UK. She is a fluent Italian speaker and loves spending time in Italy. In her spare time she likes to quilt, paint and travel often and widely as possible.
Clare Flynn is a Fellow of the Royal Society of Arts, an active member of The Romantic Novelists Association, The Historical Writers Association, The Alliance of Independent Authors and The Society of Authors. More information about her books can be found at www.clareflynn.co.uk
Clare lives in Eastbourne. on the south coast of the UK. She is a fluent Italian speaker and loves spending time in Italy. In her spare time she likes to quilt, paint and travel often and widely as possible.
Clare Flynn is a Fellow of the Royal Society of Arts, an active member of The Romantic Novelists Association, The Historical Writers Association, The Alliance of Independent Authors and The Society of Authors. More information about her books can be found at www.clareflynn.co.uk
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 61 reviews
February 22, 2024
The Artist’s Apprentice (Hearts of Glass #1) was the first book that I have read by author, Clare Flynn. I was quite impressed by her writing and her research into this time period. Clare Flynn excellently portrayed the early 1900’s as not a very opportune time for women. Families placed expectations on their daughters from a very young age. Living during those times put many restrictions on women. Most women that lived during the early 1900’s readily accepted the role that was dictated to them by society. A woman’s role in the early 1900’s was to get married, have children and keep her husband happy by making his home his palace and playing host to his guests. The Suffragette Movement was just catching on but there were enough women who were not interested in the goals the women who supported the movement had set for themselves. Those women were complacent with allowing men to continue to make decisions for them and not involve themselves in politics and voting. There were also defined class distinctions and crossing those lines was frowned upon. The characters in The Artist’s Apprentice were well developed, believable and likable for the most part. It was a compelling work of historical fiction.
Alice Dalton grew up in Dalton Hall and lived a life of privilege that she had always taken for granted. Her parents, Neville and Lavinia Dalton were from old English money. Alice had always been very close to her older brother, Victor, growing up. Recently, Alice’s father had made some poor business investments which had put the family’s financial situation in danger. Neville Dalton had invested in a bank in America that had collapsed. As a result, Neville Dalton came to an arrangement with Mr. Cutler who headed a large stock brokerage firm both in London and in America. Mr. Cutler had begun to oversee all of the Dalton’s investments and finances. Alice learned at a family breakfast that Mr. Cutler had offered her brother Victor a position in his stock brokerage firm in America. Victor had already agreed to accept the position. Both Alice and her mother were shocked by this news. Victor had always shared things with Alice. Why hadn’t he even mentioned this decision to her? The plan that had been set in motion was for Victor to learn all he could about the American stock exchange before he was brought back to London and eventually awarded a senior position in Mr. Cutler’s company. That was not the worst thing, though, that Alice was about to discover that day. Alice’s father and Mr. Cutler had been arranging a marriage for Alice to one of Mr. Cutler’s two sons.
Mr. Cutler’s oldest son, Gilbert, seemed the logical choice. Alice decided to go along with the arrangement and even began to think that it wouldn’t be so bad. She could have done much worse than she had done in deciding to marry Gilbert. After all, Victor and Gilbert had become good friends since they had met. Unfortunately, Alice discovered a deep dark secret that Gilbert had hidden from her. Alice was distraught when she learned the secret Gilbert had hidden from her. She refused to go forward with the engagement that had been planned. Alice’s parents and the Cutler’s were not ready to abandon their plan. They switched gears and insisted that Alice and the younger Cutler son, Edmund, get married instead. This union would guarantee financial stability and a respected place in society for both families. Edmund and Alice had not gotten off on a good foot. Signs of resentment and anger were evident from Edmund when he discovered the plot that was being considered. Edmund devised a plan of his own. When Alice discovered what Edmund had done she was completely humiliated. Alice made up her mind as soon as she learned what Edmund had done and came up with a plan of her own. She was going to leave her childhood home and escape the grim future she would have if she remained at Dalton Hall. Alice realized that her parents saw Alice as a “saleable commodity more than as their daughter “. Alice left Dalton Hall before the sun had risen and never looked back.
Alice had recently met her aunt, her father’s sister, Eleanor, an aunt who she had never seen or heard about while growing up. The two women met at a suffrage movement demonstration. Alice knew that she would be safe living with her aunt and her viscar husband in the village of Little Badgerton. After Alice had been in Litlle Badgerton for a while an opportunity was presented to Alice. An artist had been commissioned by a widow in the town to make two stained glass windows. The artist required an assistant and Alice’s aunt Eleanor thought that it might be a good opportunity for Alice. Art was always something that Alice dabbled in for her pleasure. Alice was quite talented but failed to recognize her own artistic skill. When Eleanor presented the idea of working as the artist’s assistant, Alice thought it was an excellent opportunity to learn a new form of artistic expression. Alice was ready to accept the challenge until she came to realize who the artist was. Edmund Cutler was the commissioned artist, the man who hated her and had humiliated her all those years ago. Despite all that, Alice accepted the position of Edmund’s assistant. Alice and Edmund were given an opportunity to work together, learn from one another and make the most beautiful pieces of stained glass art possible. What transpired between Alice and Edmund was slow to come but beautiful in every way.
I really enjoyed The Artist’s Apprentice by Clare Flynn and am so glad that there will be more books in this series. Alice’s character was so well portrayed. She was compliant when she thought she had no other choice but grew to become an independent and resilient woman. I enjoyed her part and leadership in the suffrage movement and admired her for refusing to give in to the norms society placed on women during the period of time she lived in. The romance that developed between Alice and Edmund was everything I hoped it would be. Edmund’s father, Mr. Cutler, was despicable. I hated how he treated Edmund’s mother and bullied everyone in his family. He was a selfish, self centered and greedy man. Edmund’s wife was also a very shallow woman with no ambition other than to gain material wealth that she felt she was entitled to. I enjoyed the fact that Clare Flynn included the arts and crafts movement in the form of stained glass art in her book. Both Alice and Edmund had been trapped in a life that they were forced to endure when they had lived under their parent’s control. I was so glad that both were able to learn to live their best lives together without the pressure their parents tried to impose and later by the norms society dictated. I can’t wait for the next book in this series to be written and published so I can read it. I highly recommend this book.
Thank you to Storm Publishing for allowing me to read The Artist’s Apprentice (Hearts of Glass #1) by Clare Flynn through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
Alice Dalton grew up in Dalton Hall and lived a life of privilege that she had always taken for granted. Her parents, Neville and Lavinia Dalton were from old English money. Alice had always been very close to her older brother, Victor, growing up. Recently, Alice’s father had made some poor business investments which had put the family’s financial situation in danger. Neville Dalton had invested in a bank in America that had collapsed. As a result, Neville Dalton came to an arrangement with Mr. Cutler who headed a large stock brokerage firm both in London and in America. Mr. Cutler had begun to oversee all of the Dalton’s investments and finances. Alice learned at a family breakfast that Mr. Cutler had offered her brother Victor a position in his stock brokerage firm in America. Victor had already agreed to accept the position. Both Alice and her mother were shocked by this news. Victor had always shared things with Alice. Why hadn’t he even mentioned this decision to her? The plan that had been set in motion was for Victor to learn all he could about the American stock exchange before he was brought back to London and eventually awarded a senior position in Mr. Cutler’s company. That was not the worst thing, though, that Alice was about to discover that day. Alice’s father and Mr. Cutler had been arranging a marriage for Alice to one of Mr. Cutler’s two sons.
Mr. Cutler’s oldest son, Gilbert, seemed the logical choice. Alice decided to go along with the arrangement and even began to think that it wouldn’t be so bad. She could have done much worse than she had done in deciding to marry Gilbert. After all, Victor and Gilbert had become good friends since they had met. Unfortunately, Alice discovered a deep dark secret that Gilbert had hidden from her. Alice was distraught when she learned the secret Gilbert had hidden from her. She refused to go forward with the engagement that had been planned. Alice’s parents and the Cutler’s were not ready to abandon their plan. They switched gears and insisted that Alice and the younger Cutler son, Edmund, get married instead. This union would guarantee financial stability and a respected place in society for both families. Edmund and Alice had not gotten off on a good foot. Signs of resentment and anger were evident from Edmund when he discovered the plot that was being considered. Edmund devised a plan of his own. When Alice discovered what Edmund had done she was completely humiliated. Alice made up her mind as soon as she learned what Edmund had done and came up with a plan of her own. She was going to leave her childhood home and escape the grim future she would have if she remained at Dalton Hall. Alice realized that her parents saw Alice as a “saleable commodity more than as their daughter “. Alice left Dalton Hall before the sun had risen and never looked back.
Alice had recently met her aunt, her father’s sister, Eleanor, an aunt who she had never seen or heard about while growing up. The two women met at a suffrage movement demonstration. Alice knew that she would be safe living with her aunt and her viscar husband in the village of Little Badgerton. After Alice had been in Litlle Badgerton for a while an opportunity was presented to Alice. An artist had been commissioned by a widow in the town to make two stained glass windows. The artist required an assistant and Alice’s aunt Eleanor thought that it might be a good opportunity for Alice. Art was always something that Alice dabbled in for her pleasure. Alice was quite talented but failed to recognize her own artistic skill. When Eleanor presented the idea of working as the artist’s assistant, Alice thought it was an excellent opportunity to learn a new form of artistic expression. Alice was ready to accept the challenge until she came to realize who the artist was. Edmund Cutler was the commissioned artist, the man who hated her and had humiliated her all those years ago. Despite all that, Alice accepted the position of Edmund’s assistant. Alice and Edmund were given an opportunity to work together, learn from one another and make the most beautiful pieces of stained glass art possible. What transpired between Alice and Edmund was slow to come but beautiful in every way.
I really enjoyed The Artist’s Apprentice by Clare Flynn and am so glad that there will be more books in this series. Alice’s character was so well portrayed. She was compliant when she thought she had no other choice but grew to become an independent and resilient woman. I enjoyed her part and leadership in the suffrage movement and admired her for refusing to give in to the norms society placed on women during the period of time she lived in. The romance that developed between Alice and Edmund was everything I hoped it would be. Edmund’s father, Mr. Cutler, was despicable. I hated how he treated Edmund’s mother and bullied everyone in his family. He was a selfish, self centered and greedy man. Edmund’s wife was also a very shallow woman with no ambition other than to gain material wealth that she felt she was entitled to. I enjoyed the fact that Clare Flynn included the arts and crafts movement in the form of stained glass art in her book. Both Alice and Edmund had been trapped in a life that they were forced to endure when they had lived under their parent’s control. I was so glad that both were able to learn to live their best lives together without the pressure their parents tried to impose and later by the norms society dictated. I can’t wait for the next book in this series to be written and published so I can read it. I highly recommend this book.
Thank you to Storm Publishing for allowing me to read The Artist’s Apprentice (Hearts of Glass #1) by Clare Flynn through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
February 13, 2024
This was a good book for its time period. It’s a nice romantic story. I did think it started a little slow but it eventually picked up. I really enjoyed it and am looking forward to the next one.
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the early copy
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the early copy
January 11, 2024
Reviewed in 1st edition.
Clare Flynn excels as always in creating people I care about, trapped in horrible situations and bravely struggling to live their best lives. Badly mistaken about their romantic partners, Alice and Edmund cannot shrug off young mistakes as we are able to nowadays. The mores of pre-WW1 society have shaped their lives but the author shows the courage of two ordinary people as they fight for a different future.
The suffragette movement is not just a historical backdrop but also represents the passion for change and a better world which sweeps up Edmund and Alice in their politics and their personal lives.
The author brings history to life, and particularly the expression of a period through its artwork, in this case the arts and crafts movement, and glassmaking. These fascinating details never detract from a story that keeps you turning those pages, willing Alice in particular to achieve personal freedom against all odds.
Dora is truly hate-worthy and reminded me of the doctor’s wife in ‘Middlemarch’. Clare Flynn has George Eliot’s knack of portraying miserable mis-matches and of teasing the reader with the knowledge that something better does exist. There are elements of romance but with no guarantee of a romantic outcome. The threat of WW1 is in the air.
Clare Flynn excels as always in creating people I care about, trapped in horrible situations and bravely struggling to live their best lives. Badly mistaken about their romantic partners, Alice and Edmund cannot shrug off young mistakes as we are able to nowadays. The mores of pre-WW1 society have shaped their lives but the author shows the courage of two ordinary people as they fight for a different future.
The suffragette movement is not just a historical backdrop but also represents the passion for change and a better world which sweeps up Edmund and Alice in their politics and their personal lives.
The author brings history to life, and particularly the expression of a period through its artwork, in this case the arts and crafts movement, and glassmaking. These fascinating details never detract from a story that keeps you turning those pages, willing Alice in particular to achieve personal freedom against all odds.
Dora is truly hate-worthy and reminded me of the doctor’s wife in ‘Middlemarch’. Clare Flynn has George Eliot’s knack of portraying miserable mis-matches and of teasing the reader with the knowledge that something better does exist. There are elements of romance but with no guarantee of a romantic outcome. The threat of WW1 is in the air.
February 14, 2024
I absolutely adore historical fiction, especially regarding women who were defying convention of their timeand striving for more.
Alice Dalton is a daughter of the gentry and as was commmon in the time, was set up to marry Edmund Cutler, the son of her fathers stockbroker(In order to alleviate the pressure on her father due to his disastrous financial decisions)
However, the trothe is a failure and Alice is devastated, fleeing her home, running away to start over as her own person, independant of the family ties and dramas. However, this is not an era that takes a kind view to a womans independance and Alice is horrified to discover, that when taking a position in an art studio, she discovers she wil be working for Edmund Cutler, the very man that rejected her (who, following a blazing row with his vile father, also cut ties with family money to pursue his passion of stained glass) There is a slow burn between the two as they work but family interference has the potential to drive them apart and Alice must fight for her love, and her independance.
The character development is incredibly strong and the era well researched and described. Clare Flynn is certainly an author I will follow as her writing style is at once illustrative and immersive. There is a deep empathy for the experiences of women in the era of suffrage and this is portrayed beautifully from both sides. Edmund and Alice are desperately trying to defy the conventions forced upon them by the era and their families, which woudl have ben incredibly brave and almost impossible at the time. It was a time for many people to fight for a change in soceital rules so they could live as they chose
Gilbert Cutler, the other brother, is bullied and downtrodden by his father, offered to marry Alice instead, and is a wonderful character, who adores his brother, but also likes to keep his father sweet and thus does as he is told.
Dora Fisher is utterly vile, a true villain. Horrible, horrible girl
Annette Chown is a phenomenal narrator, with fantastic diversity of vocals and wonderful continuity of characters, Her accents are varied and each character is easily identified. A fantastic listen
Thank you to Netgalley, Dreamscape Select, Storm Publishing, the author Clare Flynn and narrator Annette Chown for this stunning historical ALC. My review is left voluntarily and all opinions are my own
Alice Dalton is a daughter of the gentry and as was commmon in the time, was set up to marry Edmund Cutler, the son of her fathers stockbroker(In order to alleviate the pressure on her father due to his disastrous financial decisions)
However, the trothe is a failure and Alice is devastated, fleeing her home, running away to start over as her own person, independant of the family ties and dramas. However, this is not an era that takes a kind view to a womans independance and Alice is horrified to discover, that when taking a position in an art studio, she discovers she wil be working for Edmund Cutler, the very man that rejected her (who, following a blazing row with his vile father, also cut ties with family money to pursue his passion of stained glass) There is a slow burn between the two as they work but family interference has the potential to drive them apart and Alice must fight for her love, and her independance.
The character development is incredibly strong and the era well researched and described. Clare Flynn is certainly an author I will follow as her writing style is at once illustrative and immersive. There is a deep empathy for the experiences of women in the era of suffrage and this is portrayed beautifully from both sides. Edmund and Alice are desperately trying to defy the conventions forced upon them by the era and their families, which woudl have ben incredibly brave and almost impossible at the time. It was a time for many people to fight for a change in soceital rules so they could live as they chose
Gilbert Cutler, the other brother, is bullied and downtrodden by his father, offered to marry Alice instead, and is a wonderful character, who adores his brother, but also likes to keep his father sweet and thus does as he is told.
Dora Fisher is utterly vile, a true villain. Horrible, horrible girl
Annette Chown is a phenomenal narrator, with fantastic diversity of vocals and wonderful continuity of characters, Her accents are varied and each character is easily identified. A fantastic listen
Thank you to Netgalley, Dreamscape Select, Storm Publishing, the author Clare Flynn and narrator Annette Chown for this stunning historical ALC. My review is left voluntarily and all opinions are my own
February 4, 2024
What a lovely storyline and so well written, the story of Alice Dalton and her scheming, thoughtless family. It took a tragedy to drive her away from her family home to an aunt she didn’t know existed and into the arms of a man she never thought to ever see again. So enjoyed this book and looking forward to reading the next book in the series The Artists Wife. My thanks as always to NetGalley and to Storm Publishing for the early read
February 6, 2024
I am not sure how i feel abot this book. Was the locestory good, yes. Where the characters likeable, some choices they made rubbed me the wrong way. But I am still glad i read this book
Thank you to netgalley for letting me read this e arc in exchange for an honest opinion
Thank you to netgalley for letting me read this e arc in exchange for an honest opinion
February 18, 2024
I really loved this book. It's not a typical simple romance. It's complicated. It's messy. It's human. Mistakes are made. Choices very untraditional to the day are made. It's beautiful in its realness.
The book ending definitely leaves you hanging, so have that second book ready to jump to!
I'm off to start it now...
Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC.
The book ending definitely leaves you hanging, so have that second book ready to jump to!
I'm off to start it now...
Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC.
Read
February 17, 20244.25⭐️
Historical fiction a story looking at artistic ambition and love which starts in England 1908
I had the audiobook read by Annette Chown. I didn’t feel that she had the correct accent for the aristocrats, but that wasn’t the biggest section of the book. She had a good range of distinctive voices and accents for the other characters. I enjoyed her narration, which added to the storytelling for me.
This has previous been published as the Colour of glass.
Alice is the daughter of an aristocrat who has fallen into financial hardship her father is looking to marry her off to American new money, as her coming out season failed to find a suitable husband. After being humiliated Alice fleas from her home. Alice desperately wants to be true to herself and independent, finding a job as a stain glass artists apprentice. It’s good to see women striking out against societal expectations, the reader sees Edmund also bucking family pressure.
It covers some real events of the time which adds authenticity.
The characters are interesting with good depth. The plot is layered giving a good level of interest. It’s an easy listening entertaining book which I enjoyed. I really liked the strong women characters, of whom Alice is my favourite.
One I’d recommend if you fancy an easy entertaining listen.
Historical fiction a story looking at artistic ambition and love which starts in England 1908
I had the audiobook read by Annette Chown. I didn’t feel that she had the correct accent for the aristocrats, but that wasn’t the biggest section of the book. She had a good range of distinctive voices and accents for the other characters. I enjoyed her narration, which added to the storytelling for me.
This has previous been published as the Colour of glass.
Alice is the daughter of an aristocrat who has fallen into financial hardship her father is looking to marry her off to American new money, as her coming out season failed to find a suitable husband. After being humiliated Alice fleas from her home. Alice desperately wants to be true to herself and independent, finding a job as a stain glass artists apprentice. It’s good to see women striking out against societal expectations, the reader sees Edmund also bucking family pressure.
It covers some real events of the time which adds authenticity.
The characters are interesting with good depth. The plot is layered giving a good level of interest. It’s an easy listening entertaining book which I enjoyed. I really liked the strong women characters, of whom Alice is my favourite.
One I’d recommend if you fancy an easy entertaining listen.
February 16, 2024
Alice Dalton was a proper lady, considers herself artistic and musical. She was the daughter of aristocratic parents, which gave her privilege; however, she was held to a higher standard. Alice was matched to marry Edmund Cutler, which would elevate bad financial choices made by her father. This was a time when women did not have a choice with their lives. The relationship did not evolve and Alice decided living on her own would be her best choice.
Alice took a job working in an art study, shs was surprised that she was working for Edmund, the man Alice had been matched to.
I admired Alice’s independence by becoming the initial member of the Little Badgerton Women Suffrage Society, which speaks volumes considering that she was raised in privilege.
The novel deserves a 4 out of 5 stars, my issues for me was I had difficulty engaging with the novel. The story was well written and it was clear the author did her research.I would read more women’s literature, especially by this author.
Thank you Clare Flynn, Storm publishing, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read the uncorrected arc.
Alice took a job working in an art study, shs was surprised that she was working for Edmund, the man Alice had been matched to.
I admired Alice’s independence by becoming the initial member of the Little Badgerton Women Suffrage Society, which speaks volumes considering that she was raised in privilege.
The novel deserves a 4 out of 5 stars, my issues for me was I had difficulty engaging with the novel. The story was well written and it was clear the author did her research.I would read more women’s literature, especially by this author.
Thank you Clare Flynn, Storm publishing, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read the uncorrected arc.
January 17, 2024
Clare Flynn, The Artist’s Apprentice, Storm Publishing, February 2024.
Thank you, NetGalley, for this uncorrected proof for review.
This is the first of Clare Flynn’s novels that I have read. There is a lot to admire, for example the range of political and feminist issues that are covered in this essentially romantic novel. However, although I found the novel a good read, engaging, with interesting characters, I cannot give the writing an entirely positive response. Despite that, I am pleased to have had the opportunity to read this example of this popular author’s work and would like to know what happens to the main protagonists in the follow up, The Artist’s Wife.
The novel begins in January 1908 at Alice’s home, Dalton Hall, in Surrey. Alice is sketching in the frost on her window and must take diversionary action so that her lateness to breakfast goes unnoticed. Taking in the mail to effect this, Alice is confronted with an envelope addressed in writing with that makes her uneasy. It is an invitation from the American born wife of a newly rich neighbour, Cutler, inviting them to tea. Lord Dalton is pleased; his wife, unaware of the financial reason for her husband’s enthusiasm, is not. Alice is wary. Her brother, Victor, supports his father – he has prospects of joining the profitable Cutler firm of stockbrokers.
From this beginning, that deftly sketches the outward reasons for the proposed relationship, gradually a more ominous story begins to emerge. Alice and the proposed marriage between her and the older Cutler son appear to be the crucial protagonists in the debates that arise over women’s position, their role in preserving family fortunes through marriage, and their lack of independence in choosing a partner. Behind this story is another that will become pivotal in deciding Alice’s future.
This future brings her into contact with her estranged aunt, and eventually Edmund Cutler, the younger brother whose rebellion has led him into becoming a stained-glass artist. The development of this story includes a wealth of information about the world of art, and impressive detail about the particular art of stained glass. The information here is so engaging that it is difficult to imagine readers not wanting to see for themselves the windows so well described. In the acknowledgements Flynn provides the locations that helped inspire the novel. Christopher Whall, to whom Edmund becomes apprenticed is a real person and his book also provided a source. Others, named in the acknowledgements, are Mrs Bradley, wife of the headmaster of Bedales where Emmeline Pankhurst spoke at a meeting; Karl Parsons, a teacher who worked for Whall; and Mary Lowdnes, a female stained-glass artist and supporter of the women’s movement.
Women’s suffrage and the relative merits of the more radical movement the WSPU under Emmeline Pankhurst in contrast with the National Union of Women’s Suffrage are discussed through the characters and events. Flynn’s attention to both the public and private manifestations of discrimination against women and need for political activism as well as personal resistance are argued in an engaging manner, making this novel a worthy social commentary on the time leading up to World War 1.
The Artist’s Apprentice combines public and personal stories well. Alice and Edmund’s complicated past and defiance of society and the themes of women’s equality and recognition of the need for acceptance of new social mores makes a strong novel and good forerunner to The Artist’s Wife which follows.
Thank you, NetGalley, for this uncorrected proof for review.
This is the first of Clare Flynn’s novels that I have read. There is a lot to admire, for example the range of political and feminist issues that are covered in this essentially romantic novel. However, although I found the novel a good read, engaging, with interesting characters, I cannot give the writing an entirely positive response. Despite that, I am pleased to have had the opportunity to read this example of this popular author’s work and would like to know what happens to the main protagonists in the follow up, The Artist’s Wife.
The novel begins in January 1908 at Alice’s home, Dalton Hall, in Surrey. Alice is sketching in the frost on her window and must take diversionary action so that her lateness to breakfast goes unnoticed. Taking in the mail to effect this, Alice is confronted with an envelope addressed in writing with that makes her uneasy. It is an invitation from the American born wife of a newly rich neighbour, Cutler, inviting them to tea. Lord Dalton is pleased; his wife, unaware of the financial reason for her husband’s enthusiasm, is not. Alice is wary. Her brother, Victor, supports his father – he has prospects of joining the profitable Cutler firm of stockbrokers.
From this beginning, that deftly sketches the outward reasons for the proposed relationship, gradually a more ominous story begins to emerge. Alice and the proposed marriage between her and the older Cutler son appear to be the crucial protagonists in the debates that arise over women’s position, their role in preserving family fortunes through marriage, and their lack of independence in choosing a partner. Behind this story is another that will become pivotal in deciding Alice’s future.
This future brings her into contact with her estranged aunt, and eventually Edmund Cutler, the younger brother whose rebellion has led him into becoming a stained-glass artist. The development of this story includes a wealth of information about the world of art, and impressive detail about the particular art of stained glass. The information here is so engaging that it is difficult to imagine readers not wanting to see for themselves the windows so well described. In the acknowledgements Flynn provides the locations that helped inspire the novel. Christopher Whall, to whom Edmund becomes apprenticed is a real person and his book also provided a source. Others, named in the acknowledgements, are Mrs Bradley, wife of the headmaster of Bedales where Emmeline Pankhurst spoke at a meeting; Karl Parsons, a teacher who worked for Whall; and Mary Lowdnes, a female stained-glass artist and supporter of the women’s movement.
Women’s suffrage and the relative merits of the more radical movement the WSPU under Emmeline Pankhurst in contrast with the National Union of Women’s Suffrage are discussed through the characters and events. Flynn’s attention to both the public and private manifestations of discrimination against women and need for political activism as well as personal resistance are argued in an engaging manner, making this novel a worthy social commentary on the time leading up to World War 1.
The Artist’s Apprentice combines public and personal stories well. Alice and Edmund’s complicated past and defiance of society and the themes of women’s equality and recognition of the need for acceptance of new social mores makes a strong novel and good forerunner to The Artist’s Wife which follows.
January 27, 2024
Oh yes, yes, yes!!! How I love amazingly written books. This is the first book I have read by Clare Flynn, but I will definitely dive into the other ones and I can not wait till the 2nd book in this Series.
The characters were so well-formed and layered that you are instantly drawn into the story. The build-up to the love story between Alice and Edmund was great. I liked the ‘surprise’ meeting between them and their shared passion for craft. I loved how their complicated past let them grow into strong-formed characters. I felt deeply for them as they try to get out of some horrible situations. That said, although I felt sorry for Edmund…I don’t like cheaters and I guess that was the only downside of the story. Alice her aunt will be one of my favourite characters, you can't not love aunt Eleanor. Clare also did an amazing job with creating characters that you would like to smack in the face of worse. The setting of pre-WWI was truly captivating. I enjoyed the subplot of The suffragette movement. I normally don't like books where the author overly throws in politics or annoys the reader with their own personal beliefs and agendas (even if I agree). Clare, however, weaved the discrimination against women and the discussion of it perfectly in. She brought history alive and because of the dialogue and personal growth of both characters you just keep on flicking those pages. What I loved most about it is that women can find the strength within and stand up for their beliefs. Which made me think about this Era and about young women that are still in situations where other people dictate what they have to do. So Clare made me think without throwing it in my face and I genuinely love it when an author is capable of doing so. The pace was very good and the storyline was engaging.
A definitely recommended book if you love historical fiction, romance and the fight for women to have equal rights.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Thank you, NetGalley, and Storm Publishing for this ARC.
The characters were so well-formed and layered that you are instantly drawn into the story. The build-up to the love story between Alice and Edmund was great. I liked the ‘surprise’ meeting between them and their shared passion for craft. I loved how their complicated past let them grow into strong-formed characters. I felt deeply for them as they try to get out of some horrible situations. That said, although I felt sorry for Edmund…I don’t like cheaters and I guess that was the only downside of the story. Alice her aunt will be one of my favourite characters, you can't not love aunt Eleanor. Clare also did an amazing job with creating characters that you would like to smack in the face of worse. The setting of pre-WWI was truly captivating. I enjoyed the subplot of The suffragette movement. I normally don't like books where the author overly throws in politics or annoys the reader with their own personal beliefs and agendas (even if I agree). Clare, however, weaved the discrimination against women and the discussion of it perfectly in. She brought history alive and because of the dialogue and personal growth of both characters you just keep on flicking those pages. What I loved most about it is that women can find the strength within and stand up for their beliefs. Which made me think about this Era and about young women that are still in situations where other people dictate what they have to do. So Clare made me think without throwing it in my face and I genuinely love it when an author is capable of doing so. The pace was very good and the storyline was engaging.
A definitely recommended book if you love historical fiction, romance and the fight for women to have equal rights.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Thank you, NetGalley, and Storm Publishing for this ARC.
February 22, 2024
Thank you to Clare Flynn, Dreamscape Select, and NetGalley for allowing me to listen to a free eaudio ARC in exchange for an honest review.
The summary for the book is misleading. Alice doesn't leave her parents' house until 45%. She doesn't become Edmund's assistant until 73%. Four or five YEARS pass between the broken engagement and their working together. Surprised? I was, too.
I thought they'd defy being matched by their parents then very quickly stumble into working with each other. It'd be an enemies to lovers deal where he'd grump at her and she'd put up with it because she could see the vulnerability underneath. Witty banter would morph into genuine affection and they'd end up doing what their parents wanted them to do to begin with. Hilarity ensues.
No no no. That is not this book.
This book is about a man making a hasty, selfish decision in his youth and spending his life paying for it. It's about a woman sick of being a pawn, a possession, a bargaining chip, and taking control of her own life. And for shits and ironic giggles, they end up together. It's not a romance like the clever summary would have you believe; it's more like two women's fiction storylines running parallel before intertwining in the end.
Alice was an okay character. Sympathetic and relatable in her limited choices, in her being subject to the patriarchy. She wasn't particularly endearing, nor did she have much personality, but she wasn't a bad character.
I didn't like Edmund much but I also don't have much against him. He's not the first man to rush into marriage with the object of his lust. He's also not the first artsy-fartsy kid who doesn't want to go corporate like his parents want. I did respect his efforts to make his marriage better, despite a complete lack of encouragement from his wife.
Omg his wife....I know she's a product of her time and class, but I despised her. So much. I wanted Edmund's father to kill her and free Edmund, I sincerely thought that would happen, but apparently the ol' guy drew a line at murder. I'm not sure how Dora came to be such an entitled brat, but she acted like she deserved a rich lady simply because she paid her dues growing up lower class, taking care of her dad and marrying some schmuck like women were supposed to. Entirely self-centered.
Overall, others make like this novel, but it was not for me. The romance isn't there, the characters are only meh, the story meanders---takes forever to accomplish anything, and I'm seldom a fan of alternating POVs.
The summary for the book is misleading. Alice doesn't leave her parents' house until 45%. She doesn't become Edmund's assistant until 73%. Four or five YEARS pass between the broken engagement and their working together. Surprised? I was, too.
I thought they'd defy being matched by their parents then very quickly stumble into working with each other. It'd be an enemies to lovers deal where he'd grump at her and she'd put up with it because she could see the vulnerability underneath. Witty banter would morph into genuine affection and they'd end up doing what their parents wanted them to do to begin with. Hilarity ensues.
No no no. That is not this book.
This book is about a man making a hasty, selfish decision in his youth and spending his life paying for it. It's about a woman sick of being a pawn, a possession, a bargaining chip, and taking control of her own life. And for shits and ironic giggles, they end up together. It's not a romance like the clever summary would have you believe; it's more like two women's fiction storylines running parallel before intertwining in the end.
Alice was an okay character. Sympathetic and relatable in her limited choices, in her being subject to the patriarchy. She wasn't particularly endearing, nor did she have much personality, but she wasn't a bad character.
I didn't like Edmund much but I also don't have much against him. He's not the first man to rush into marriage with the object of his lust. He's also not the first artsy-fartsy kid who doesn't want to go corporate like his parents want. I did respect his efforts to make his marriage better, despite a complete lack of encouragement from his wife.
Omg his wife....I know she's a product of her time and class, but I despised her. So much. I wanted Edmund's father to kill her and free Edmund, I sincerely thought that would happen, but apparently the ol' guy drew a line at murder. I'm not sure how Dora came to be such an entitled brat, but she acted like she deserved a rich lady simply because she paid her dues growing up lower class, taking care of her dad and marrying some schmuck like women were supposed to. Entirely self-centered.
Overall, others make like this novel, but it was not for me. The romance isn't there, the characters are only meh, the story meanders---takes forever to accomplish anything, and I'm seldom a fan of alternating POVs.
January 10, 2024
A captivating story of aristocracy, romance, and determination.
Alice Dalton lives with her wealthy parents in England in 1908. Her family needs her to marry the son, Gideon, from a wealthy family in order to maintain their status. What ensues for Alice is heartbreak and deception. The arranged marriage with Gideon does not work out. Yet, the two families attempt to continue the arrangement with Edmund, an artist and the younger son. Alice and Edmund flee their families. Fast forward years later, Alice is living with her aunt and gets a job working for Edmund as an apprentice. Their relationship blossoms, and they fall in love.
There was a build-up to the romance. The author did an amazing job of laying out the characters before they came together and fell in love. Alice grew from a duty bound daughter to an independent, strong woman. I wasn’t really a fan of Edmund, who was a little bit of a doormat, until he fell in love with Alice. He found his strength in the love of Alice.
I recommend this book for those who like historical fiction and romance. Pre-order today! This book will be published on February 13th. Thank you to NetGalley, Storm Publishing, and the author for the e-ARC.
Alice Dalton lives with her wealthy parents in England in 1908. Her family needs her to marry the son, Gideon, from a wealthy family in order to maintain their status. What ensues for Alice is heartbreak and deception. The arranged marriage with Gideon does not work out. Yet, the two families attempt to continue the arrangement with Edmund, an artist and the younger son. Alice and Edmund flee their families. Fast forward years later, Alice is living with her aunt and gets a job working for Edmund as an apprentice. Their relationship blossoms, and they fall in love.
There was a build-up to the romance. The author did an amazing job of laying out the characters before they came together and fell in love. Alice grew from a duty bound daughter to an independent, strong woman. I wasn’t really a fan of Edmund, who was a little bit of a doormat, until he fell in love with Alice. He found his strength in the love of Alice.
I recommend this book for those who like historical fiction and romance. Pre-order today! This book will be published on February 13th. Thank you to NetGalley, Storm Publishing, and the author for the e-ARC.
May 1, 2024
A Historical Fiction Book Which Is Magically Narrated.
The Artists apprentice by Clare Flyne, is a professional and beautifully written book which is set before WW1. You have a real feeling of being right in there in the time. This is a historical fiction book which the author has captured beautifully with the beautiful historic background of a young women who works as an artist apprentice which was a very unusual position in the era.
Alice Dalton is being married of two Gilbert Cutler to help both family's fortunes but When Alice is humiliated by Gilbert Alice flees home for London to start a new life and moves in with her aunt who she met at a suffragette meeting. Alice loves the small rural village and the beautiful countryside, and she settles into her new life and gets a job cataloging books.
Edmund Cutler who is Gilberts brother has moved into the village as he has been commissioned to produce two stain glassed windows for Mrs. Bowyer, but Edmund will need an apprentice. Alice takes on the job even though she thinks Edmund is a constant irritant, but Alice quickly finds the work rewarding and loves working with both glass and paint. Surprisingly, Edmund finds she is a fast learner and a very willing pupil. They work well together, and they both soften to each other as they start to open up to each other.
The book works well as the two siblings from each family have their own issues to resolve. Alice is of a strong character and the book is fast paced with a moving story about survival and kinship. the description of the fauna, paintings and the stain glass windows are magically narrated leaving you pulled back in time with a fascinating storyline which is brought to life. I highly recommend this book if you love historical fiction Thanks to NetGalley and to the publishers of this book for giving me a free advance copy of the book to preview and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The Artists apprentice by Clare Flyne, is a professional and beautifully written book which is set before WW1. You have a real feeling of being right in there in the time. This is a historical fiction book which the author has captured beautifully with the beautiful historic background of a young women who works as an artist apprentice which was a very unusual position in the era.
Alice Dalton is being married of two Gilbert Cutler to help both family's fortunes but When Alice is humiliated by Gilbert Alice flees home for London to start a new life and moves in with her aunt who she met at a suffragette meeting. Alice loves the small rural village and the beautiful countryside, and she settles into her new life and gets a job cataloging books.
Edmund Cutler who is Gilberts brother has moved into the village as he has been commissioned to produce two stain glassed windows for Mrs. Bowyer, but Edmund will need an apprentice. Alice takes on the job even though she thinks Edmund is a constant irritant, but Alice quickly finds the work rewarding and loves working with both glass and paint. Surprisingly, Edmund finds she is a fast learner and a very willing pupil. They work well together, and they both soften to each other as they start to open up to each other.
The book works well as the two siblings from each family have their own issues to resolve. Alice is of a strong character and the book is fast paced with a moving story about survival and kinship. the description of the fauna, paintings and the stain glass windows are magically narrated leaving you pulled back in time with a fascinating storyline which is brought to life. I highly recommend this book if you love historical fiction Thanks to NetGalley and to the publishers of this book for giving me a free advance copy of the book to preview and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
February 23, 2024
Be wary of the description, as this book is not as advertised.
It takes place in London, shortly before WW1, but spends minimal time establishing the world in which the characters live, beyond a few mentions of social norms. We are led to feel like so many social standards are unjust, and archaic, but with the scope of what feels like a naive, American, POV. The nuances of English society around this time are really pushed out of the way to accommodate the storyline. And, to be fair, since it’s fiction, why should it matter? It simply happens so often that it made me eye roll, rather than enjoy.
The book also spans years, which gave me the impression that the author was trying to create an epic, grand sweeping love story but fell very very short. I kept thinking, “ugh it’s trying to be Atonement”. In reality, it’s just plain boring. Our characters make knee-jerk reactions and have to live in their own mistakes for 70% of the book with little to no plot advancement. Honestly no one is so like-able that I even cared. And the romance? What romance?! The MCs finally circle back to each other and instantly love each other. What. *bangs head into wall*
The book wasn’t written poorly, and there are worse things out there, but it really could have been so much better. 2 ⭐️
Audiobook note- the narrator, while not awful, struggled with distinct differences in class tone, which at times confused me. I would recommend not listening above 2x speed.
Lastly, trigger warnings were not listed on the audiobook. Be aware of suicide.
Thank you NetGalley for this audiobook, in exchange for my unbiased opinion.
It takes place in London, shortly before WW1, but spends minimal time establishing the world in which the characters live, beyond a few mentions of social norms. We are led to feel like so many social standards are unjust, and archaic, but with the scope of what feels like a naive, American, POV. The nuances of English society around this time are really pushed out of the way to accommodate the storyline. And, to be fair, since it’s fiction, why should it matter? It simply happens so often that it made me eye roll, rather than enjoy.
The book also spans years, which gave me the impression that the author was trying to create an epic, grand sweeping love story but fell very very short. I kept thinking, “ugh it’s trying to be Atonement”. In reality, it’s just plain boring. Our characters make knee-jerk reactions and have to live in their own mistakes for 70% of the book with little to no plot advancement. Honestly no one is so like-able that I even cared. And the romance? What romance?! The MCs finally circle back to each other and instantly love each other. What. *bangs head into wall*
The book wasn’t written poorly, and there are worse things out there, but it really could have been so much better. 2 ⭐️
Audiobook note- the narrator, while not awful, struggled with distinct differences in class tone, which at times confused me. I would recommend not listening above 2x speed.
Lastly, trigger warnings were not listed on the audiobook. Be aware of suicide.
Thank you NetGalley for this audiobook, in exchange for my unbiased opinion.
November 2, 2024
This is the first book in a series featuring Alice in The Hearts of Glass Series.
It's January 1908 in Dalton Hall in Richmond Hall, Surrey, and Alice is horrified at a social gathering that she has been chosen as a suitable wife, something that she had no say in. Her best friend Harriet also has a mismatched marriage. Her husband is much older than her. But when she finds her brother in a compromising position with her boyfriend, she is adamant that they will not marry, although her parents are still happy for the marriage to go ahead.
Things then go very wrong and Alice leaves home secretly to stay with her aunt Eleanor, who is the wife of a vicar but things are certainly not a bed of roses for Edmund and his new wife Dora, and Edmund is mortified when she tells him that she sold her wedding ring, which was a family heirloom and then bought a cheaper ring and some clothes with the money and then he realises that he is tied to Dora for the rest of his life, not only that but also he doesn't love her and they have only been married for two months! Dora then expects Edmund to ask his father for money and when baby Charlotte arrives Edmund knows he would do anything for his daughter, but not his wife and his father definitely wants nothing to do with Dora, or does he?
But then, in a short time Alice and Edmund meet up again, is it going to prove difficult?
I really enjoyed reading this book, I liked that Alice is such a strong woman and that showed in her work with the Women's Suffrage Movement, and her determination to do what she wanted in her life.
A five-star read from me.
It's January 1908 in Dalton Hall in Richmond Hall, Surrey, and Alice is horrified at a social gathering that she has been chosen as a suitable wife, something that she had no say in. Her best friend Harriet also has a mismatched marriage. Her husband is much older than her. But when she finds her brother in a compromising position with her boyfriend, she is adamant that they will not marry, although her parents are still happy for the marriage to go ahead.
Things then go very wrong and Alice leaves home secretly to stay with her aunt Eleanor, who is the wife of a vicar but things are certainly not a bed of roses for Edmund and his new wife Dora, and Edmund is mortified when she tells him that she sold her wedding ring, which was a family heirloom and then bought a cheaper ring and some clothes with the money and then he realises that he is tied to Dora for the rest of his life, not only that but also he doesn't love her and they have only been married for two months! Dora then expects Edmund to ask his father for money and when baby Charlotte arrives Edmund knows he would do anything for his daughter, but not his wife and his father definitely wants nothing to do with Dora, or does he?
But then, in a short time Alice and Edmund meet up again, is it going to prove difficult?
I really enjoyed reading this book, I liked that Alice is such a strong woman and that showed in her work with the Women's Suffrage Movement, and her determination to do what she wanted in her life.
A five-star read from me.
February 23, 2024
Book Title: The Artist’s Apprentice
Author: Clare Flynn
Series: Hearts of Glass #1
Narrator: Annette Chown
Genre: Historical Fiction, Women’s Fiction
Publisher: Dreamscape Select, Storm Publishing
Pub Date was: February 13, 2024
My Rating: 3.6 rounded up
Pages: 334
Story takes place in England, 1908:
Alice Dalton has been slated for an arranged marriage to Edmund Cutter. Edmund however wants no part of an arranged marriage. Alice is so humiliated she leaves home and decides to become an independent woman.
Five years later, Edmund is getting established as a designer of stained glass windows and needs an assistant and our now independent woman Alice who is an artist applies for the job.
Story turned out more complicated than this.
As they work together, mixing paints and composing the design for their stained-glass window designs, Edmund and Alice’s toxic relationship does smooth as they recognize the talents of the other.
This is Book #1 and it ends in 1914. We know WWII starts July 29. 1941 so feel it will play a role in, The Artist’s Wife Book #2 in the ‘Hearts of Glass’ series,
Narrator Annette Chown does a great job performing the characters.
The Artist’s Apprentice was previously published as The Colour of Glass.
Want to thank NetGalley and Dreamscape Select, Storm Publishing for this early Audiobook.
Publishing Release Date was February 13, 2024.
Author: Clare Flynn
Series: Hearts of Glass #1
Narrator: Annette Chown
Genre: Historical Fiction, Women’s Fiction
Publisher: Dreamscape Select, Storm Publishing
Pub Date was: February 13, 2024
My Rating: 3.6 rounded up
Pages: 334
Story takes place in England, 1908:
Alice Dalton has been slated for an arranged marriage to Edmund Cutter. Edmund however wants no part of an arranged marriage. Alice is so humiliated she leaves home and decides to become an independent woman.
Five years later, Edmund is getting established as a designer of stained glass windows and needs an assistant and our now independent woman Alice who is an artist applies for the job.
Story turned out more complicated than this.
As they work together, mixing paints and composing the design for their stained-glass window designs, Edmund and Alice’s toxic relationship does smooth as they recognize the talents of the other.
This is Book #1 and it ends in 1914. We know WWII starts July 29. 1941 so feel it will play a role in, The Artist’s Wife Book #2 in the ‘Hearts of Glass’ series,
Narrator Annette Chown does a great job performing the characters.
The Artist’s Apprentice was previously published as The Colour of Glass.
Want to thank NetGalley and Dreamscape Select, Storm Publishing for this early Audiobook.
Publishing Release Date was February 13, 2024.
February 25, 2024
I have a grouch to make and not at all in the writing of the book, but of the blurb. The way that the blurb is written got me interested in the story and I was eager to request and read the title. The blurb suggests that the pair will end up working together quite soon after their upset and sparks will fly. It isn't until 56% of the book has gone by that the idea is mentioned and at 64% they start working together as the blurb promised. I felt like the beginning was long winded, purely because I was looking forward to seeing the blurb action occur. This is a disservice to the book, as, if it were written differently and the focus was on the lives they lead after the upset occurs, we wouldn't be put off by how long it took to get to the action.
The book itself was delightful! Well paced and beautifully written. The cast of characters is very full of the goodies and the baddies and I feel like I know some of them as the author has really brought them to life. I was upset at the circumstances the characters found themselves in and delighted in their joys too. I guessed the circumstances between both their brothers before it happened although what happened after was a shock! I have suspicions about Lotties origins too although due to the ending, I will have to wait for book 2 to find out more.
Thanks to Netgalley and the author and publisher for a temporary copy in exchange for an honest review.
The book itself was delightful! Well paced and beautifully written. The cast of characters is very full of the goodies and the baddies and I feel like I know some of them as the author has really brought them to life. I was upset at the circumstances the characters found themselves in and delighted in their joys too. I guessed the circumstances between both their brothers before it happened although what happened after was a shock! I have suspicions about Lotties origins too although due to the ending, I will have to wait for book 2 to find out more.
Thanks to Netgalley and the author and publisher for a temporary copy in exchange for an honest review.
April 7, 2024
An arranged marriage, a brother with a secret, and personal tragedy kick things off. Both Alice and Edmund are caught up in their own affairs, which take them far from each other. Both separate from their families - one seeking distance from a cruel, overbearing father, the other wanting to direct their own life and opinions for once.
I tried to stay open to the characters, and I did gravitate more toward Alice, though it took some time to warm up to both of them. Dora was nearly unbearable, creating misery and dripping selfishness in her wake.
When Alice and Edmund meet again years later, I was more than ready for it. Boy did it pay off though, and I was pleased on how it was dealt with by both parties. I found the ending a bit abrupt - I wanted more and wasn't ready for it. I wanted everything to work out in their lives, for all the broken pieces to be mended, and we weren't quite given that. (I just noticed that this is in fact a duology, and I'm very excited to see how things turn out in the second book!)
While it was a bit slow in parts, I found myself caring for both Alice and Edmund in the end. And more than a little drawn to the art of stained glass, something I'd paid little attention to in the past.
The audiobook was well read, and kept my interest. It was also easy to discern between the Alice and Edmund chapters with a slight change in tone, which is always appreciated.
I tried to stay open to the characters, and I did gravitate more toward Alice, though it took some time to warm up to both of them. Dora was nearly unbearable, creating misery and dripping selfishness in her wake.
When Alice and Edmund meet again years later, I was more than ready for it. Boy did it pay off though, and I was pleased on how it was dealt with by both parties. I found the ending a bit abrupt - I wanted more and wasn't ready for it. I wanted everything to work out in their lives, for all the broken pieces to be mended, and we weren't quite given that. (I just noticed that this is in fact a duology, and I'm very excited to see how things turn out in the second book!)
While it was a bit slow in parts, I found myself caring for both Alice and Edmund in the end. And more than a little drawn to the art of stained glass, something I'd paid little attention to in the past.
The audiobook was well read, and kept my interest. It was also easy to discern between the Alice and Edmund chapters with a slight change in tone, which is always appreciated.
February 26, 2024
The Artist's Apprentice by Clare Flynn
Narrated by Annette Chown
England, 1908 - Alice Dalton's only purpose in life has been to make a good marriage. But, with her father's fortunes failing, her parents' pressure to do so grows by the day. When a potential engagement to a handsome young man of a wealthy stockbroker family falls through in the most tragic way, another engagement is planned for her. That one goes awry, too, and Alice flees her home in shame, vowing to never marry.
Edmund Cutler is one of the men that Alice was slated to marry. But his stockbroker father had no care for Edmund's wishes so he thwarted his father's plans and set his own fate. Part of the plan was a sad failure but he did further his hopes of a career as a stained glass artist. Miserable on the home front, his work is his passion and that can keep him going.
Five years later, Edmund and Alice's lives collide. Edmund needs an assistant and willful and independent Alice, now involved in the suffrage movement, wants the job, is more than up to doing the menial chores, and also has the artistic talent to make a real, productive artist's assistant. She's a fast learner and loves the work she learns to do with Edmund. Neither wants to face up to their feelings for each other, one having gone from indifference and other from hate, to both feeling something more. Edmund has obligations elsewhere, their friendship and love for their art must be enough.
When we first meet Alice and Edmund they are young, both naive and immature in a variety of ways. Both of them are caught in the expectations of their families and their Victorian times. They make several hasty and some unwise decisions that lead them to the place they are five years later. Both are forced to grow up, find their ways, and live with knowing their choices got them to where they are in life, for better or worse. They do mature, they do admit mistakes they made. They have moved on as best as possible. This story leaves us in a good place for the most part, except that there is another book after this one. We know there is a war looming and the foreboding is strong that a dark cloud is descending on everyone. Annette Chown does a fine job with the narration of the story, which is not finished yet.
Published February 13, 2024
Thank you to Dreamscape Select, Storm Publishing, and NetGalley for this ARC.
Narrated by Annette Chown
England, 1908 - Alice Dalton's only purpose in life has been to make a good marriage. But, with her father's fortunes failing, her parents' pressure to do so grows by the day. When a potential engagement to a handsome young man of a wealthy stockbroker family falls through in the most tragic way, another engagement is planned for her. That one goes awry, too, and Alice flees her home in shame, vowing to never marry.
Edmund Cutler is one of the men that Alice was slated to marry. But his stockbroker father had no care for Edmund's wishes so he thwarted his father's plans and set his own fate. Part of the plan was a sad failure but he did further his hopes of a career as a stained glass artist. Miserable on the home front, his work is his passion and that can keep him going.
Five years later, Edmund and Alice's lives collide. Edmund needs an assistant and willful and independent Alice, now involved in the suffrage movement, wants the job, is more than up to doing the menial chores, and also has the artistic talent to make a real, productive artist's assistant. She's a fast learner and loves the work she learns to do with Edmund. Neither wants to face up to their feelings for each other, one having gone from indifference and other from hate, to both feeling something more. Edmund has obligations elsewhere, their friendship and love for their art must be enough.
When we first meet Alice and Edmund they are young, both naive and immature in a variety of ways. Both of them are caught in the expectations of their families and their Victorian times. They make several hasty and some unwise decisions that lead them to the place they are five years later. Both are forced to grow up, find their ways, and live with knowing their choices got them to where they are in life, for better or worse. They do mature, they do admit mistakes they made. They have moved on as best as possible. This story leaves us in a good place for the most part, except that there is another book after this one. We know there is a war looming and the foreboding is strong that a dark cloud is descending on everyone. Annette Chown does a fine job with the narration of the story, which is not finished yet.
Published February 13, 2024
Thank you to Dreamscape Select, Storm Publishing, and NetGalley for this ARC.
February 18, 2024
This is a historical fiction that follows Alice in 1908 as she tries and fails to meet her families expectations and then finally decides to set off on her own after a traumatic event happens that leaves her with no other options. We also follow Edmund, who equally struggles with family expectations, as he wants to be an artist but his demanding father wants him to join his finance business. The two characters’ stories intersect closely, but their actual interactions don’t begin until about 70% of the way into the story. Although realistic as far as feelings and circumstances can go, the overall happy acceptance of the situation seemed a bit too unbelievable for me, and not very historically accurate. However, the ending seemed very much to set up the story for the continuation, so I’m assuming that part of the hardship comes later if you continue reading. I’m invested enough to want to do that, so hopefully that audio is available soon! And hopefully it’s the same narrator, as she did a great job, and ups the rating from 3.5 to 4. Thank you to NetGalley and Dreamscape Select for the audio ARC in exchange for my honest review.
February 25, 2024
First, I would like to thank the publisher, author, and NetGalley for allowing me access to this wonderful novel.
I thoroughly enjoyed listening to this book. It was a great story with many believable, lively characters. I was excited how Alice and Edmund found each other once again but what I truly appreciated about was how both characters went out on their own, experienced their own trials and tribulations, lived life. My heart does go out to poor Lottie and I am curious to see what becomes of the father/daughter relationship has the series progresses.
The way this was written was well done. It didn’t focus primarily on love and was certainly not a romance novel. It incorporated history and it gave the reader a real feel on daily life during that time period.
I also appreciated the way the author wrote. She had clever quips and displayed throughout the book that she is a master dialogue writer. It can be difficult for authors to incorporate believable and interesting dialogue, but Flynn did a great job of it.
I definitely recommend this story and would love to hear more. I am excited to discover what the next book in the series has to offer.
I thoroughly enjoyed listening to this book. It was a great story with many believable, lively characters. I was excited how Alice and Edmund found each other once again but what I truly appreciated about was how both characters went out on their own, experienced their own trials and tribulations, lived life. My heart does go out to poor Lottie and I am curious to see what becomes of the father/daughter relationship has the series progresses.
The way this was written was well done. It didn’t focus primarily on love and was certainly not a romance novel. It incorporated history and it gave the reader a real feel on daily life during that time period.
I also appreciated the way the author wrote. She had clever quips and displayed throughout the book that she is a master dialogue writer. It can be difficult for authors to incorporate believable and interesting dialogue, but Flynn did a great job of it.
I definitely recommend this story and would love to hear more. I am excited to discover what the next book in the series has to offer.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 25, 2024
This is the first book in the ‘Hearts of Glass’ series and it is a captivating story of art and love before WW1. Set in England, 1908, Alice Dalton is a young woman with an ambition and the talent to become an artist. However, in her world duty, money and class come first meaning she must fight to be her true self. When her father’s attempt to arrange a ‘suitable’ marriage for her with the son of a wealthy stockbroker named Edmund Cutler fails, Alice fleas. Having been humiliated she is determined to be an independent woman and takes a position as a stained-glass artist’s apprentice. She is shocked to find that the man she will be working for is Edmund Cutler. Alice learns that like her he has turned his back on his family and is following his passion for art. Alice enjoys working alongside Edmund mixing paints and even composing commissions together. However, war is on the horizon and family conflicts are brewing. This captivating story kept me happily turning the pages. The characters and the settings came vividly to life through the descriptive narrative. I’m now impatiently waiting for book two!
January 9, 2024
England 1908; Alice Dalton lives under the expectations of her aristocratic father and when her planned marriage to the son of a wealth stockbroker ends in tragedy, her father plans that instead she will marry his younger brother Edmund Cutler. When this ends in her humiliation, Alice leaves the home of her mother and father determined to make a life for herself.
Though raised as a lady with no opportunity to pursue and education or training in anything, Alice is stunned to meet again the man who rejected her and married someone else, Edmund Cutler.
However, this meeting eventually allows her to pursue a similiar to his: art. Working together and composing stained-glass window commissions for a prominent widow, Alice cannot ignore her growing attraction for Edmund.
I very much enjoyed this story and I look forward to reading more by this author particularly the second book in the series, The Artist's Wife.
Thank you NetGalley for my copy of this story.
Though raised as a lady with no opportunity to pursue and education or training in anything, Alice is stunned to meet again the man who rejected her and married someone else, Edmund Cutler.
However, this meeting eventually allows her to pursue a similiar to his: art. Working together and composing stained-glass window commissions for a prominent widow, Alice cannot ignore her growing attraction for Edmund.
I very much enjoyed this story and I look forward to reading more by this author particularly the second book in the series, The Artist's Wife.
Thank you NetGalley for my copy of this story.
February 8, 2024
The Artist's Apprentice
By: Clare Flynn
4 Stars
This is a new author for me, but I was very impressed. This book had an awesome storyline along with an amazing set of characters.
Alice's parents have her set to be married off, not once, but 3 separate times before she takes off on her own to control her own future. She gets a job, and what she never thought she wanted becomes the one thing she thrives for. Love.
I really enjoyed this story. The history and drama. The scandal and the forbidding romance. It was a very written story. The only complaint is that it ended too quickly. It almost felt like it just ended mid page. I hope and think this just is a smooth transition for the next book.
Overall, this is a great story, and I can't wait to read the next book.
*I want to thank Netgalley and the author for this book in return for my honest review*
Stormi Ellis
Boundless Book Reviews
By: Clare Flynn
4 Stars
This is a new author for me, but I was very impressed. This book had an awesome storyline along with an amazing set of characters.
Alice's parents have her set to be married off, not once, but 3 separate times before she takes off on her own to control her own future. She gets a job, and what she never thought she wanted becomes the one thing she thrives for. Love.
I really enjoyed this story. The history and drama. The scandal and the forbidding romance. It was a very written story. The only complaint is that it ended too quickly. It almost felt like it just ended mid page. I hope and think this just is a smooth transition for the next book.
Overall, this is a great story, and I can't wait to read the next book.
*I want to thank Netgalley and the author for this book in return for my honest review*
Stormi Ellis
Boundless Book Reviews
February 22, 2024
I read the two books almost one after the other because they were good.
1908 and rich English-girls are still expected to do the right thing. Follow their parents instructions, I wouldn’t call it guidance here, and marry into the correct family. Alice seems pliant but she rebelled. The story continues with Edmund the spurred suitor marrying someone else, Edmund’s father taking on a protege, and cutting Edmund off. At the same time Alice finds employment in. Stained glass business with the spurned Edmund of all people.
Working and living with a married man is beyond the understanding or acceptance of most people at the time, and Alice seems to be isolated not just from her family but also from friends. Alice and Edmund have also got to face the prospect of a looming war.
History especially the social mores of the time, along with a typical rich family saga where what everyone thinks and says is very important, this was indeed a good illustration of the times.
1908 and rich English-girls are still expected to do the right thing. Follow their parents instructions, I wouldn’t call it guidance here, and marry into the correct family. Alice seems pliant but she rebelled. The story continues with Edmund the spurred suitor marrying someone else, Edmund’s father taking on a protege, and cutting Edmund off. At the same time Alice finds employment in. Stained glass business with the spurned Edmund of all people.
Working and living with a married man is beyond the understanding or acceptance of most people at the time, and Alice seems to be isolated not just from her family but also from friends. Alice and Edmund have also got to face the prospect of a looming war.
History especially the social mores of the time, along with a typical rich family saga where what everyone thinks and says is very important, this was indeed a good illustration of the times.
January 10, 2024
I enjoyed this book far more than I expected from reading the description. Alice was being married off to someone who was useful to her father’s life. When things intervene, and the marriage plans are in tatters, Alice leaves her family home. Set amidst the time of the Suffragette movement, this book explores women’s and men’s roles and expectations. Alice ends up being quite unconventional. Edmund's story is just as sad, as his sad home life and subsequent impetuous marriage leave him in an ordinary situation. I genuinely liked the main characters and the subtle humour that ran under this especially when Alice lives with her aunt. I hope the sequel comes out soon, as I am invested in these characters and especially want to see what Victor has planned and what the war brings to these characters. Many thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for a copy to freely review.
January 17, 2024
Alice Dalton's life is changed utterly by a series of events, none of which she has caused. Turning her back on her parents and their plans for her, she leaves her home and finds sanctuary with her recently discovered aunt and uncle in the Hampshire countryside. After a few peaceful years in which she becomes a part of her adopted village, her life is once again turned upside down. Her past comes back to meet her and decisions made by others threaten to cause more upheaval.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book set in the early years of the twentieth century. The characters were strong and developed well and the plot cracked along at a good pace. Some of the twists and turns were predictable but others took me by surprise (which, I suppose is akin to real life). Before I got to the end, I was looking forward to the sequel.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book set in the early years of the twentieth century. The characters were strong and developed well and the plot cracked along at a good pace. Some of the twists and turns were predictable but others took me by surprise (which, I suppose is akin to real life). Before I got to the end, I was looking forward to the sequel.
January 31, 2024
Don’t start The Artist’s Apprentice late at night. You’ll find it hard to stop reading because, as usual, Clare Flynn’s fast-paced narrative and much-loved mix of drama and romance keep the reader turning the pages. There is a cinematic quality to her writing that brings to life the settings, action scenes and the painstaking creation of the stained-glass windows.
This book is the first in a series. While the story is sufficiently resolved to make for a satisfying read and a moving conclusion, it’s clear there’s all kinds of trouble ahead (WWI in particular) for the likeable main characters.
If you’re a fan of the high drama of Downton Abbey, or the dysfunctional family conflicts of The Forsyte Saga, you’ll find much to enjoy in The Artist’s Apprentice. An absorbing read.
This book is the first in a series. While the story is sufficiently resolved to make for a satisfying read and a moving conclusion, it’s clear there’s all kinds of trouble ahead (WWI in particular) for the likeable main characters.
If you’re a fan of the high drama of Downton Abbey, or the dysfunctional family conflicts of The Forsyte Saga, you’ll find much to enjoy in The Artist’s Apprentice. An absorbing read.
February 13, 2024
Thank you NetGalley and Storm Publishing for this eCopy to review
A sweeping love story following Alice Dalton and Edmond Cutler, will they ever find true happiness and a meeting of artistic minds or will they be doomed to heartbreak.
Alice and Edmond both leave their families after being forced to marry each other. Edmond marries Dora who he is infatuated with but their marriage is far from happy. Fed up of being used as a bartering chip Alice runs away to live with her Aunt after the proposed marriage to Edmond falls through.
Alice finds fulfilment in village life, when Edmond is commissioned to produce 2 stained glass windows she becomes his apprentice. Unexpectedly, she loves the work and becomes friends with Edmond. Can they follow their hearts and love each other?
A moving story full of beautiful characters and settings
A sweeping love story following Alice Dalton and Edmond Cutler, will they ever find true happiness and a meeting of artistic minds or will they be doomed to heartbreak.
Alice and Edmond both leave their families after being forced to marry each other. Edmond marries Dora who he is infatuated with but their marriage is far from happy. Fed up of being used as a bartering chip Alice runs away to live with her Aunt after the proposed marriage to Edmond falls through.
Alice finds fulfilment in village life, when Edmond is commissioned to produce 2 stained glass windows she becomes his apprentice. Unexpectedly, she loves the work and becomes friends with Edmond. Can they follow their hearts and love each other?
A moving story full of beautiful characters and settings
Displaying 1 - 30 of 61 reviews