A MOUNTAIN OF DISTORTIONS ENDS IN ZAHI HAWASS'S MOUNTAINS OF THE PHARAOHS
Zahi Hawass has produced another rather sad and sorry book that attempts to transform the ancient African Negro cultures of the Nile Valley into the "Middle Eastern" culture of "Ancient Egypt".
Mr. Zahi Hawass has set for himself an impossible task.
In his mad and frantic flight from the black African realities of his "Ancient Egypt," Mr. Hawass has embraced an extreme form of out of date German Eurocentricism tinged with modern Egyptian nationalism.
Surely, Mr. Hawass knows enough about ancient African Nile valley cultures to realize that his beloved "Ancient Egyptians" would have instantly considered him to be a "sand dweller" (shau), not a man of the Black Land (Kemit)! Mr. Hawass would have been considered a foreigner.
Let's state at the outset that Mr. Hawass gets no points for being born in Egypt. Nor is his attempt at scholarship in anyway enhanced by his place of birth or his nationality.
Modern Egyptians had nothing to do with the ancient African Nilotic and nonNilotic cultures of the Nile.
Modern Egyptians are mainly the descendants of various invaders and many other settler populations, composed of various Arab tribes, Persians, Greeks, Romans, African,Turks and others.
Modern Egypt is not African; nor are we talking about the modern country of Egypt. Our subject is the ancient African Nile valley civilizations(kemet) now referred to as "Ancient Egypt."
We must remember that all we admire about ancient Egyptian Civilization was already in place during the reign of Djoser ( 3rd Dynasty) 5018-4989 BC.
So the later Arab Muslim invaders(639-641AD) and settler populations had nothing to do with the building of Pharaonic civilization along the Nile.
After stripping his mythical "Ancient Egypt" of its black African core, Mr. Hawass is left with gross distortions in the form of an empty shell of disconnected facts and silly speculations.
On page 6 Mr. Hawass writes about the impact of the work of the 150 or so French scientist and scholars who compiled the huge DESCRIPTION de l'EGYPT.
Hawass goes on to mention Jean -Francois Champollion the gifted French linguist"who brought the silent hieroglyphic writing back to life."
The mad flight from Africa emerges almost immediately: in the Description de l'Egypt there is a very interesting bas reliefs of men jumping over a bull while other men appear to be holding the bull.(See A Vol. V. Pyramides de Memphis. PL18 #8 Monuments of Egypt, Napoleonic Edition ,The Complete Archaeological Plates From LA DESCRIPTION DE L'EGYPT, Editors: Charles C. Gillispie and Michel Dewachter 1987 Princeton Architectural Press.
Eurocentric scholars pass over in utter silence the Jumping the bull ceremonies that occurs to this very day in many parts of Africa. In these ceremonies the bulls are jumped over as part of initiation rituals.
The place of cattle in many parts of modern Africa can help shed light on the ancient cultures of the Nile valley.
Yet, Hawass dare not step outside the intellectual paradigm set up by his German masters.
Hawass goes on to mention Champollion. We must remember that after studying the people, language and culture of the ancient Egyptians, Champollion made this unequivocal statement:"Tout en semble, en effet, nous montre dans les Egyptiens un peuple tout-a-fait etranger au continent asiatique." (In fact everything about the Egyptians seem to show that they were a people completely foreign to the Asian continent.) See Precis Du Systeme Hieroglyphique Des anciens Egyptiens Elibron Classics page 456.
Mr. Hawass continues on page 14 with this gross distortion of the African reality that he finds so repulsive. "In ancient Egypt, queens-the king's chief wife, his mother, and sometimes his eldest daughter symbolized the female principle and were essential to rule."
Mr. Zahi Hawass does not want his least informed readers to realize that his "Ancient Egypt" was not patriarchal. The kinship system is completely different from Arab, Hebrew and European kinship patterns. Descent was traced through the mother-not the father. The divine right to be pharaoh came from the Royal Mother.Perhaps this helps explain the many depictions of the Pharaohs seated beside their mothers. There are depictions of Pepi sitting on his mother's lap. We could give many more examples. This is alien to European cultures and perhaps more so to any form of Semitic cultures both Hebrew and Arabic.
There could be no God without a Goddess in ancient African Nile Valley cultures!
Like most other African languages the Egyptians had no word for"cousin".
A cousin would be a "brother or a "sister" since both would have had the same mother(the grandmother).
Hawass ignores these facts and attempts to force his Eurocentric world view on these ancient African peoples we now call "Egyptians".
Later Mr. Hawass admits that the"eldest son" of the king does not "necessarily" inherit the throne. p.135
Mr. Hawass even calls George Reisner "the great American Egyptologist", yet he clearly has ignored George Reisner's conclusions after a lifetime of study: "Egyptian civilization was from the south and from the black tribes of Punt and that Egypt and Lower Nubia were "culturally and racially one land".
See Race and the Writing of History Maghan Keita, 2000 Oxford, page 79.
Mr. Hawass continues to distort the ancient cultures of the Nile when he writes on page 136 that the dwarf performed dances for the "amusement" of the king.
This is a typical euro-centric distortion.
If Mr. Hawass knew anything about African cultures he would know that the Twa peoples(the dwarfs) have always been associated with the mythology and culture of African life. Not only did they perform sacred dances of Gods and Goddesses(in African religions each deity has a special dance and a particular piece of music, this seems to have also been the case in ancient Egypt) the deng(dwarfs) also took part in burial ceremonies of the sacred Apis bull. This indicates a profound cultural , ethnic and racial connection between the Egyptians and other African peoples. Dwarfs have always been considered keepers and guardians of wild and domestic animals. In Peul mythologies of Senegal. dwarfs were said to have been the original shepherd for the sacred cattle of the God Geno. Dwarfs were believed to bring good fortune to others. So we see that dwarfs were an integral part of both ancient Egyptian African cultures and modern African cultures. See De L'Origine Egyptienne Des Peuls ,Aboubacry Moussa Lam Presence Africaine .
Mr. Hawass engages in this kind of distortions time and time again in this book. So much so ,until the book collapses under the heavy weight.
In his effort to strip "Ancient Egypt" of all things African, Mr. Hawass has delivered a mass of distortions and personal opinion based largely on dogma and ideology.
Perhaps Mr. Zahi Hawass should spend less time with his fan club and his line of clothes and hats.
In any case, this is a book that cries out for the oblivion that it so richly deserves.