The Mill River Redemption” belongs to books that leave me speechless for a long time after reading them. This novel was a perfection in every single detail and I find it really hard to write a review that is going to do this book a justice. Thank you so much Clara for offering me this book to read and review, you really do know my tastes!
I was not aware before I was sent the book that there is a first book in the series, „The Mill River Recluse” and now I desperately want to read it as well! Though you can read „Redemption” easily as a stand – alone novel.
JosieDiSanti has lost her husband and house in the fire and we meet her when she and her two little daughters Rose and Emily are on their escape from New York to Josie`s only living relative, her mother’s sister Ivy, to Mill River. Ivy has her own bookshop and decides to take her niece in although they don’t know each other at all.
Josie and the girls easily settle to their new life in Mill River, and it’s also thanks to an anonymous person, who tends to help people of Mill River in their hour of need. Josie gets a house across the street from Ivy and the life goes on, with Josie starting to train to be a real estate agent after the girls went to school. But when the girls are adults, a tragedy happens, a tragedy that tears the sisters apart for years.
Fast – forward some years on and we meet the sisters and Ivy at Josie’s funeral. Desperate to bring her daughters together even from beyond her grave, Josie writes a will. Rose and Emily will get their inheritance but first they must move to Mill River again and work together for clues that are going to allow them to obtain the inheritance.
Is this possible to bring the girls together at all? Are they able to work on their differences and their grudge? Would it be possible for them to find the hidden key? What else are they going to discover?
Darcie can wonderfully describe the dynamics of the family, the feelings between the family members and she doesn’t left any doubt why the bonds look like this. And she also perfectly writes characters that you love or love to hate, which was a case with me. I had a problem with Rose from the very beginning, she seemed to me to be a very cold, very unhappy, very dissatisfied woman and what I learnt through the book only confirmed me in my belief. In my eyes she and only she was to blame for a life that she had, she wanted to be so independent, she was too proud to ask for help or admit defeat. But on the other hand there was more to Rose than our eyes saw. She carried a great amount of guilt in herself.
I was looking for any flaws in Emily but didn’t find any. She’s down – to – earth, very lovely character and to be honest, I didn’t suppose that she can hold to her traumas so long. She was easy – going and open to the world and I guess you couldn’t not like her.
I admired Josie. We get to know her as a helpless, heartbroken widow and tell our goodbyes later to a strong, successful woman. I adored her determination to make the girls’ life better and at ease and really admired how far ahead she went to show her daughters what is important in life.
There was a bunch of other brilliant characters in the book as well. Ivy was a great aunt and friend, Daisy was so good – natured, Father O’Brien with his hidden secret, they were all written in a fantastic, vivid way and added so much warmth to the whole story. It wouldn’t be the same book without them all. But I still am not sure about the plot with Claudia and the young police officer. Yes, of course, they were a part of some scenes, and while Kyle was in some ways significant to the story, I couldn’t really place Claudia. The way she was described and the way some of the chapters were dedicated to her I was sure she’s going to be an important part of the story, of the plot but in my eyes, she was not. Hers served maybe as a kind of a getaway, a breath of fresh air between the drama developing.
The characters are very mobile, they all grow up and develop in this book, they are complex and they’re just popping out of the pages to embrace you and drag you into their lives.
The things that the sister did to each other as a revenge were ridiculously funny! I guess I would never hit upon such ideas. Of course it hurts to see that, firstly, they did such things, and secondly, that they could only see the way to solve the problems through police.
The setting of the story, Mill River, couldn’t be better. Darcie describes it as a friendly, charming town, full of nice people, people helping each other, town where the biggest misdemeanour was to destroy someone’s lawn or cut the tires in someone’s car . And this all actually after the sisters moved into the town…
I was immediately drawn into the story, into the drama and the mystery puzzle. There was not a single flat moment in this book, the tension was palpable through the whole story. We gradually learn that there happened something very tragic in the past, something that brought the two sisters apart but Darcie keeps us in uncertainty what it was almost till the end, but I must tell that waiting for this secret to be revealed didn’t spoil the reading at all. There are some books when you wait, and wait, and wait for something important to be told and the waiting makes you desperate and bored but it was absolutely not the case here, there was so much happening in this book, drama intertwined with humour and there were many twists and turns to keep your attention the whole time.
The story jumps back and forth in time, and it starts in 1983 with Josie’s arrival, and takes us on a journey to 2013, when she unexpectedly dies. In between we get to know Josie, Ivy and the girls, and learn about how they settled in the town, and how their lives looked life, with the girls going to kindergarten and school, with the girls growing. The sisters couldn’t be more different, they’re like chalk and cheese, and it was visible from the very beginning. Rose, the wilder one, the one so seeking independence, is now a wife with a rich husband and a very intelligent, young son, who in fact helps her to resolve the mystery. But apart of the inheritance Rose has a lot of other problems, starting with her husband, his job and ending with alcohol. Emily, on the other hand, is a carpe diem type of girl, she doesn’t have a firm, solid place, she moves a lot and appearances are not as important for her as they are to Rose. She drives old car (you wouldn’t see Rose in such one), she has a dog (Rose hates dog), she feeds birds (birds are full of bacteria and germs for Rose) and can do things that usually no other girls do: plumbing, repairing cars, changing the tyres… Such things. The day of her mother’s funeral is the first day that she sees her nephew Alex. The time gap let us to catch on all the development the characters undergo, I especially loved how Josie blossomed, from the widow in despair to a very successful businesswoman.
The story is told in third person, from very different point of views, but everything is clear and wonderfully explained and described, no confusions here. Written in a very captivating, elegant and tender way, it has you rooting for the characters and wanting to desperately know what’s going to happen. And it has one of the biggest twists in the books. Period.
This book was perfect in every single detail. The characters, the descriptions, the plot, and that every thread has found its end, and it left me feel so satisfied and content. I have found answers to all my questions. I love when authors don’t choose the easy way to write the book and make it complex and complicated, and they don’t keep out of difficult situations to put the characters through. That was the case here and I have enjoyed the read through and through, I actually couldn’t put it down and some of you know that it’s really hard for me to find time to read as much as I’d like. Well, I finished this book in two days. It was unputdownable, I found myself obsessing about the story and I only wanted to dive into it again. It’s my sure bet, this book, and I would heartily recommend it to you to read it as soon as you can.
Copy received from publisher in exchange for a review.