✰ 3 stars ✰
“And that, just like he can never stomp the flowers out fully, I won’t let that spark of goodness in me die completely either.
No matter how many beasts we bury in my heart.”
The winner for the most villainous of father's goes to Mancella's father! 🙅🏻♀️ A man so cruel and pure evil that every time he appeared on page, I was visibly outraged and frustrated on behalf of Mancella's helplessness, because the man had no filter - no qualms - no moral compass whatsoever over his actions! I swear, I despised him on sight and he has no signs of redeeming himself in any way! 🤬
“If you let someone else set the rules for you, then you’ll be stuck in the game they want to play.”
I did like the idea behind The Beasts We Bury is a very interesting one. To imagine a young girl having the ability to harbor the souls of animals into her body, but only after she kills them, by engaging in a battle to the death, in order to strengthen the magic that is needed to strengthen their kingdom is a compelling concept. And for how sixteen-year-old Mancella is the unfortunate destined soul who has been tasked to bear this unfortunate burden does not certainly come without a price.
One that comes with even deeper claws that wish to sink into her soul and spirit in the face of her delusional and power-hungry father, who asks of her to do the one impossible thing that she knows she'll never be able to come back from, if she chooses to go through with it. 😟 But it will take more than a little liquid courage and the help of a young man, Silver, who has his own reasons for seeking out Mancella's help, that will have her face her greatest enemy - that may or may not be a wolf in sheep's clothing.
It was easy to stay connected with the story; at times vicious, at times coming-of-age, at times a sweet romance amidst a fantasy setting of political intrigue, there was a little bit of everything that managed to keep it afloat. Mancella is at a really crucial stage in her life that will not only decide the fate of her family's realm, but her own well-being, as well. The danger of what she is expected to do is a crippling one, and it serves as the root of much of her actions, as well as Silver's involvement with her.
I liked how we felt her rage and her compassion - her survival instincts kicking in, as well as her considerate heart of not wanting to hurt any living creature or a life of violence, but compelled to. Who was a beautiful creature at times, but could be a fast, sharp, savage predator when the time called for it. I still felt, though, at times, that there was something holding it back from being really good; maybe because it is Young Adult and also a debut, there was some hesitancy in either going completely dark or being too graphic, so it made the tone feel rather uneven. But, when you felt the tension and darkness, then it did resonate with me. ✨
“Nothing in your life is going to change unless you change it.”
Silver's story-line could have used a little more
oomph
. I know he is there to be Mancella's love interest and her ally, as also one with his own agenda, but he needed a little more to really engage with him. 😕 And while I did think their romance was a bit too on the nose instant, they did share some sweet scenes together. 😊💓 He had a strong sense of loyalty to Rooftop and Vie, which was nice to see, but also a strong level head and conscience. Granted, the slight outburst of emotion at one moment was a bit unnecessary, but what happened afterwards was a nice segue from what could have been a more annoying contrivance. 🥲
What stood out for me the most was Mancella's resistance and her affiliation with the helpless animals she had been tricked, coerced, or forced to kill in order to satisfy the hunger of an even crueler father. 😢The guilt and pain with every kill was palpable, as well as the lingering memories that now coexist within her of their skills and their pasts. It is a deep rooted connection that continues to lend a helping hand on numerous occasions. She was a capable girl, just unfortunately at her wits ends at perils not in her control.
And the twists! Some were a bit expected, some not so much, but I enjoyed the slight moment of surprise when they happened, even if they hurt. But, definitely the highlight was Mancella's father - he was just the epitome of rotten, such a scoundrel that was hell-bent on destroying his daughter for his own gain that my blood boiled at how hard she was fighting to survive and do the right thing. 'Your dad’s a real scumbag, you know that?' 🙂↕️🙂↕️🙂↕️ Understatement of the century!!!! 😡 So many of her enemies were from within - so much judgment that she had no control over - it's no wonder she felt closest and safest with those she harbored inside of her.
“If you think my animals are my only weapon, then you have vastly underestimated me.”
A few points of improvement that I felt could have made it a more enticing and gripping YA fantasy were a little more details into the world-building. It felt lacking that there was no name to the Coast Realm or Land Realm; I don't know if it was meant to be quirky, but it made it feel rather simple. 🙍🏻♀️ I also wish there could be more substance and development to the supporting cast; it felt like very limited interaction between everyone save Mancella with her sister and father, and Silver, well, with really only Mancella and Guerre. To make it feel like a more dynamic duology, especially with what's to come, I think it could help to have a little more insight into the other key players. 🤷🏻♀️
The extra .25, however, was rightfully earned by its ending; I did not see that coming in the slightest and well done to the author for having it play out in a totally unexpected way. 🤌🏻 🤌🏻 You know how in movies the background music changes when something is about to happen; very rarely have I read books that emit that same feeling. But D.L. Taylor brought that here. I heard the wisp of change and it was enough to convince me that I have to return for the sequel to the duology. I want to see Mancella's strength and resolve shine in her new role, along with certain characters' she's recently acquired to join her collection. 🥺 I want to see how Silver's role will change now that he does not have much to fight for, and haha, okay, actually he might just have the toughest job now, and it's gonna be interesting to see how it will unfold. 🫣
And also kudos for an absolutely smashing of a gorgeous cover! It perfectly captured the essence of the plot - the details of the flower merging with the jaguar - stunning! 🤩🪻
*Thank you to Edelweiss for a DRC in exchange for an honest review