Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Redeem Them All

Rate this book
Romance, survival horror, and the supernatural
After a night out one of the girls goes missing, that leaves Courtney and her friends in a clearing to search for clues. An old wire fence awaits and Courtney's fear chokes her over crossing. She doesn't want to be a coward, something she always hated about herself.
Luka, the cute blonde from last night, blocks her from the fence. Evidently both her fear and him win on this. The other members search. Another girl goes missing, just she isn't missing she's dead. The members in the group start seeing strange beings that demand they redeem someone. These judges have dragged them into a trial.
Now they have to solve the trial before they are all dead. Courtney has to face her fear or listen to it. Either way it could get her killed.

Tropes/
Athletic Runner FMC
Cosmic Horror
Unique Fantasy Beings
Sweet love interest
Struggle for Survival
Angered Ancient Power

268 pages, ebook

Published May 16, 2024

1 person is currently reading
34 people want to read

About the author

Emily Casilli

8 books80 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
10 (18%)
4 stars
22 (40%)
3 stars
11 (20%)
2 stars
6 (11%)
1 star
5 (9%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews
Profile Image for ems_booknook.
445 reviews19 followers
May 11, 2024
I was given an ebook copy of this book in exchange for my honest review by the author.

Unfortunately, I’m not vibing with this one at all. It started off so strong and I was super excited with a few of the creepy scenes that were happening, the plot of a group of friends being hunted down by the Judges. There is SO much potential here!

However I am finding things so confusing. I am getting lost quite frequently with events that are occurring, who is who, where they are and what is happening. I think the plot is moving way too fast and it’s quite jumpy and erratic, to the point where I can’t keep up. There is barely any character development and while people are being brutally slaughtered - I don’t have any connection with them so am totally unbothered. The only character trait I’ve actually managed to glean is that one of the girls is a complete bitch.

I feel like there’s a lot of unnecessary things happening too. There’s been quite a few times with character conversations or romantic aspects that I’ve found myself skipping over because it’s irrelevant and is just filler.

It’s a shame, because the ideas in this one are actually really strong.

Thanks so much to the author for the free copy in exchange for my opinions!
Profile Image for Paige Ray.
1,115 reviews70 followers
May 21, 2024
Redeem Them All is a unique story involving many different elements and genres. I think overall it reads as a YA thriller with horror, romance and fantasy thrown into the mix. It has predominant supernatural elements throughout. There’s honestly a little bit of everything in this story, which made it unique. This was a good debut novel and had me intrigued as to how it would end. There’s plenty of action and romance throughout with some creepy demon-like creatures. Emily is great at descriptive writing, leaving hardly anything to imagination. 👏

Thank you, Emily, for this ARC.
Profile Image for Sarah Froiland.
61 reviews7 followers
May 30, 2024
The overall vibe of this book hooked me from the very beginning. I enjoyed reading this ARC for the author, all views and opinions in this are my own.

The plot of this thriller is all about owning up to the consequences in order to save your friends. Are you willing to do it or will you let them pay the ultimate price? Courtney and her friends are caught in an otherworldly battle with creatures much different than themselves. The twists and turns captivated me and I had a very hard time putting this book down.

I enjoyed the underlying love storying within this novel as it brought just a little something extra to this book. This is my first time reading anything from this author and I look forward to her next work.
Profile Image for Michaella.
141 reviews15 followers
May 26, 2024
I loved this story. This is my first spooky/ horror type of romance. I enjoyed how unique the story went and the way you describe Luka is **chefs kiss***. I enjoy seeing more of your work. If you like fantasy, horror, romance, with some paranormal kinda of vibes all wrapped up in one and placed with a bow then this is definitely a book to read
Profile Image for Danielle Brown.
379 reviews21 followers
June 12, 2024
This had to be the most bizarre story I've ever read and a little hard to follow sometimes but I liked it all the same.. the horror aspects and the gore etc was awesome and the slight twists and turns were something to behold.
Profile Image for chesirern.
869 reviews18 followers
May 19, 2024
Redeem Them All by Emily Casilli is a thriller novel. This novel was a young adult horror novel with a little twist of romance. I enjoyed the premise and planned plot of this novel. I say planned because there was a few times it did go off target and lost me. The author had so many thoughts she wanted to spill on to the page and I think sometimes that got lost in the writing. However, the story is an original concept and I loved trying to figure out what was going on. These are your friends and you do not know who you can trust. Then there are the creepy judges who you just want to hide from.
I enjoyed reading this and finding out the answers. I look forward to watching Emily Casilli grow as an author and to read more from her.
1 review1 follower
August 8, 2024
I was hooked upon reading the first chapter of this book. Every chapter ends on a cliffhanger which ultimately made me curious to read more and find out what happens next. The writing style and how descriptive this book was had my imagination running wild and I was captivated and the characters are all relatable in their own way. This book is as much horror as it is romance while friends search for a way to save themselves from the Judges that torment them.
Profile Image for RaeAnne Palmer.
145 reviews7 followers
May 31, 2024
This story was interesting and caught me from the start. This is like modern time fantasy/paranormal with some thriller and horror thrown in! Now, personally, I would say this is more NA, and the author had clarified it's considered NA also.

In this story, we get really unique creatures called judges. This is dual POV as well. So we follow Courtney, our FMC, who loves running but also has a lot of fears she tries to overcome in this book. She is also very stubborn. Then we have Luka, our MMC, who had met Courtney and her group of friends the day before things started happening. Luka is a pretty mysterious guy, but later, we get more on him.

Courtney and her friends all meet up one night to hang out and have a good time. Come to find out the next day, one of those friends is missing, and their car was found by a wire fence in an area none of them had a reason to be. As the group eventually all moves over the fence, they start to see creepy beings. These beings demand they redeem someone, but no one seems to understand what that means. These beings are our judges, and they have dragged this group into a trial where they have to figure out what to do or die trying.

It is interesting as Courtney had these big fears and wanted to overcome them. As well as essentially the plot being about accepting your consequences from actions you had made to get you there. And trying to save your friends.

The story is so interesting that I could see it almost being a movie or TV series with the concept of it all! Everything is very descriptive, so it gives you a good visual as you read. It all feels pretty original and unique.

There were times I felt lost with what was going on or who was who. I wish things were slowed down a bit as it did feel pretty fast at times so we could also get more character development. It would have been nice to have a bit more descriptive words or variants than we got in the story. The romance hasnt made sense to me, but i have a feeling that will be explained more in the next book. We were left with a cliffhanger, so there totally will be a book 2 to this, so i can't wait to see where it takes us. Overall, though, I did really enjoy the story.

I was given this book for free as an ARC, but all of this is my honest review. Thank you, Emily, for this opportunity!
Profile Image for Vikki.
554 reviews
May 30, 2024
Redeem Them All by Emily Casilli is a gripping blend of romance, survival horror, and the supernatural that will keep readers on the edge of their seats. The story starts with a seemingly ordinary night out that takes a terrifying turn when one of Courtney's friends goes missing. The search for clues leads Courtney and her friends to a clearing, where an old wire fence becomes a symbol of her deepest fears.

Courtney's internal struggle with her fear is palpable, and her character's vulnerability makes her both relatable and compelling. Luka quickly becomes a focal point in her life, complicating her emotions as they navigate this perilous situation.

The plot of Redeem Them All is refreshingly unique, combining elements of survival horror with supernatural themes and romance. The eerie atmosphere is well-crafted, and Casilli's incorporation of deities and paranormal entities adds a rich layer of intrigue to the story. The supernatural elements are seamlessly woven into the narrative, creating a world that is both terrifying and fascinating.

Casilli excels at building suspense, and the sense of impending doom is ever-present. The characters are well-developed, and their interactions are authentic and engaging. Courtney's journey is particularly compelling as she grapples with her fears and tries to find the strength to survive. The dynamic between her and Luka adds a touch of romance that balances the horror and supernatural elements nicely.

The trial that Courtney and her friends face is both a literal and metaphorical journey, forcing them to confront their deepest fears and insecurities. The concept of redemption is central to the plot, and the characters' struggles with this theme add depth to their development.

Overall, Redeem Them All is a thrilling read that offers a fresh take on the survival horror genre. Emily Casilli has created a captivating story that will appeal to fans of supernatural thrillers and romantic suspense. The blend of horror, romance, and the supernatural makes for a unique and engaging read that will keep you turning pages late into the night. If you're looking for a book that is both different and enthralling, Redeem Them All is definitely worth a read.
Profile Image for Rebecca.
Author 2 books7 followers
March 10, 2024
I was provided a copy of Redeem Them All from Emily Casilli for an honest review of her book.

Redeem Them All starts off with a missing friend. From there, it unravels into a story of judges, cults, relationships, and death.

I think with a great amount of editing, there could be a good story here. But it was far too confusing for me to keep up with everything.

There were way too many characters in the book for me to be able to grow attached to any of them or care about what happened to them. They'd be introduced with absolutely no background, just with a mention and the continuation of their story from then on.

It also jumped between present and past, but in a way that was difficult to understand what moment in time I was reading. Sometimes it would mention "Past" or "Present" at the start of a new chapter, other times I don't think it did. I tried to follow along as best I could, but I just couldn't keep it straight.

I don't care for unnecessary romantic elements/spice/etc, and all of the romance in the book confused me. One of my best friends just died? Time to make out. I think I'm about to die? Let's start a romance with the one who I think is going to kill me. And all of the relationships in the book - platonic, familial, or romantic - really confused me. I couldn't keep up with who was who. Some people who apparently just met were now acting like they had been friends since childhood.

The sentence structure was lacking, with rarely any variations between them. It was either sentence fragments or short, barely descriptive sentences.

I'm giving it two stars because I do think it has promise in the plot, it just needs a decent amount of editing in order to form a cohesive story. The idea of the judges and the trial were there, but I want something I can follow, and not something that leaves me with many more questions by the time I finish the book.

Thank you for a copy of the ebook in exchange for my opinion!
Profile Image for Suzi Vee.
349 reviews15 followers
June 2, 2024

3.5 ⭐️
1 🌶️

Redeem Them All was a fun read that combined some of my favorite elements. The story begins innocently enough with a night out, but quickly spirals when one of the girls go missing. Courtney's struggle with her fear is intensely vivid, her hesitation to cross the fence practically leaping off the page.

The suspense ramps up to a fever pitch when another girl turns up d3ad. This gruesome revelation introduces the malevolent judges, supernatural beings who demand redemption and ensnare the group in a deadly trial. These feckers are creepy and i am here for it.

The plot is engaging, but the character development occasionally feels rushed. Despite this l thought that Redeem Them All was a good blend of romance / supernatural, making for a fun read.

What holds Redeem Them All back from a full 4-star rating is the character development and pacing. It felt like there were a loooooot of characters and it was hard to keep up with them. I wanted to love everyone.

Redeem Them All is a captivating experience, packed with suspense and unexpected twists. Though it stumbles in a few areas, fans of supernatural thrillers and romantic suspense will find it a thoroughly engaging experience.

ps. while the characters are youngish, this is not a YA novel.

I received an advanced copy for my honest opinion.
Profile Image for Erin.
72 reviews
May 15, 2024
I was given an ebook copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review.

Unfortunately I couldn't get into this book at all, it started out strong and I was excited with the creepy/suspenseful scenes with a group of friends being hunted by the judges is a great concept and had so much potential but it fell flat.
I found things confusing and getting lost a lot of the time while reading the storyline and events unfolding. The plot is quite jumpy and moves to fast to the point where I can't keep up and have to go back and reread spots to make sure I didn't miss anything. People are being brutally slaughtered left, right and centre with very little character development, there wasn't much connection to them so I wasn't phased when they died... There were alot of unnecessary things happening as well like an awkward romance which I felt was irrelevant as if it was a filler?
It's a shame really you could tell the author was really passionate about the gory scenes but I felt she wasn't quite sure how string them together.
A note to the Author: Great concept, keep up the writing it will get better as you go. Thank you so much for a chance to read a free copy of this book in exchange for my opinion.
14 reviews
April 14, 2025
Thank you for this arc, but honestly I couldn't manage reading after the beginning of the second chapter!
So, in the first chapter the protagonist meets with her friends and more new characters the protagonist meets for the first time. We have a detailed description of the guys, but there isn’t dialogue. We get to know nothing about their personality and yet the protagonist seems to root for a guy named Luka because he’s cute, sweet and has fluffy bangs!? Basically, the entirety of the first chapter is a summary-telling-Info dumping.
The chapter gets too descriptive as the characters go to the arcade and at some point the author decides to sprinkle hope for potential romance in the future chapters.
Then, the characters go on a ‘quest’ to search for a movie to watch. The protagonist, watches a friend of hers having a near panic attack because of a movie she holds, she tells us how much unlike her is such a thing to do and yet she lets it pass, not saying anything because all of a sudden she is hungry! You see where I go with this? These are not realistic characters! Then the second chapter comes, and they are searching for a girl in their group who has gone missing!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for This.
39 reviews3 followers
May 31, 2024
This book was a struggle.

There are WAY to many characters to count, I frequently lost track of who was doing what since many sections were incredibly vague.

This needs some heavy handed editing to trim off all the unnecessary details and add more details to the things that matter. 25 antagonists feels like way to much, and a lot of the side characters were nothing more than cannon fodder to up the body count.

The short version of this is 14+ people die so that a girl they didn't even know save for a few could learn to have empathy. At the end she is forgiven and told to live a better life so their sacrifice wasn't in vain and those who survived are traumatized, Injured and hate this girl forever for needlessly refusing to help them survive.

The"Romance" is incredibly awkward and in my opinion not a romance but what happens when a human is enthralled by a supernatural creature. They often kiss or make out at inappropriate times, even after the death of their friends.

Everyone sobs and hisses in this book WAY to much.
Profile Image for Monica Nichols.
127 reviews4 followers
February 20, 2024
I like how the author started the book from the future then the next chapter started at the beginning. The descriptive words used are unique and very detailed. The details are so real and descriptive- very intense moments at times. I can actually picture the “judge” right in front of me! I really appreciate the going back and forth between the present time and the events that les to what seems to me to be “releasing demons” into the world. That’s the closest thing I can call whatever is happening in this book. Fans of the Halloween franchise will fall in love with this book. The judges appear and disappear just like Michael Myers does. Eerily creepy but at the same time can’t stop reading. The judges- I would have never called them that, I would have called them demons honestly but I also like how the author called them something that most people would never think of referring to a monster as.
Profile Image for Elvira.
66 reviews11 followers
May 27, 2024
***** Arc Read Review *****
3.5 ⭐️ in my opinion

This Story is YA story that incorporates a good amount of different elements and genres to make one unique story. This story was encapsulating from cover to cover for me honestly. Emily is incredibly talented and descriptive and has a really great on her hands. “Redeem Them All” has a little bit of everything, for those that like a good inclusive story line. The way she describes each “Judge” is unique and would honestly love to see some artwork of them.


The only reason I took off one star was because to me the story was predictable. The characters also lacked development and it was hard to keep up at times, which sucked with how much I was enjoying the story. This story has potential to be sooo much better.
Profile Image for Savannah.
Author 4 books41 followers
May 6, 2024
A fun night with friends turns into a nightmare for Courtney when one of the group goes missing. Things quickly get intense as the group stumbles into a horrifying ordeal. Casilli does a fantastic job infusing her story with tension and intensity. The book grabs your attention and doesn't let go. There are elements of cosmic creatures and a sweet romantic subplot. But the real star of the show was the monsters, known as "the judges." I can't say more without spoiling, but this was definitely a quick, fun spooky read!

Thank you to Emily for this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily and all views expressed are my own.
Profile Image for Sami Elaine.
41 reviews9 followers
May 16, 2024
I did not initially vibe well with this read. The first chapter, after the short prologue, I had to read several times to follow the interactions so I had a good base going forward but I am really glad I read through to the end. The story ended up being full of twists and excitement that kept me engaged to the last page.

This is my first time reading a work from Emily and she has a real gift for plot. Her writing style can take a little to settle into but it is descriptive and paints a wonderful picture in your minds eye. I look forward to reading more of her work and seeing her grow as an author.
Profile Image for KELSEY TINKER.
4 reviews1 follower
May 18, 2024
I was given a copy of this book I. Exchange for an honest review! The author is sweet and you can tell they have a lot of passion and care about the project a lot.
Unfortunately, the book has a lot going on and it very confusing to keep up with. I think with some editing and major changes it could be a really great read. I like the plot and the storyline is cool if just is all jumbled up. It wa shard for me to form any sort of emotional attachment to the characters because there were so many. Emily, I think you have a strong idea it just needs some work to get the book to a 5 star read ✨✨
Thank you for allowing me to read! Good luck!
Profile Image for Joan Smith.
813 reviews21 followers
February 19, 2024
Thank you, Emily Casilli

The novel starts as a fun night out with friends until the main character gets notified that her sister is missing. It's like her sister vanished into thin air, leaving her worthly possessions. This is where the book started to grab my attention and hold it. It truly makes you wonder who has your back and how far you will go to prove your loyalty to a friend. The atmosphere is on point. You can almost smell the blood from the trials. I really liked this 4.5 story that is why I rounded up for a 5 star.

Romantic Horror
Cosmic Creatures
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
63 reviews4 followers
May 25, 2024
Okay, are you ready for a ride of your life. Whether or not you make it out alive is up to you. The adventures that start out so innocently end up being so deadly. Especially when you have someone who won't admit to their failings. Even when their friends start dying around them. Courtney sees the fear she has but is willing to help other but then she has to make a decision that is hard for her, to let the consequences happen to the one who will not admit her failing and redeem themselves, even to save her friends. This novel would give Poe a run for his money.
Profile Image for Nikki .
245 reviews22 followers
May 31, 2024
I was very fortunate to be able to read this book!


Emily did such a good job with this book and the characters. I really enjoyed how it was written. It has the genres I really enjoy. I love romance, supernatural and some horror.
Courtney and her friends start out with a normal night out and then all of a sudden one of them goes missing. The way Emily writes the rest of this story is so good. It kept me turning page to page. I could literally picture each event as it was happening. It made me jump at certain spots. I look forward to reading more by this author.
Profile Image for Micki-D.
1,348 reviews37 followers
March 18, 2025
Redeem Them All is a creepy, suspenseful yet romantic supernatural thriller horror novel all blended together making this a unique tale. Emily tells eerie and creepy story

We start off with a starts off with Courtney’s missing friend and the search for clues. As the story unravels with cults and people being brutally slaughtered left right and centre what more can you want from a horror book. Every chapter ends on a cliffhanger only making me curious as to what is coming next and keep me interested to find out what happens next.
17 reviews1 follower
May 18, 2024
The trials have started and the redeemer must redeem.
Courtney and her friends are caught up in something that is killing them one by one. Plus, Courtney has a huge secret that she has to keep hidden.
Can Courtney save her and her friends, and keep her secret before time runs out?
Highly addictive read.
Highly recommended for those who love a supernatural way of justice.
EXTRA: I read the last 200 pages of the ebook in one sitting, and never realized it, until I reached the last page.
Profile Image for Juju.
109 reviews4 followers
May 30, 2024
I loved the creepy scenes in this book so much. I noticed when I was reading at night I had to put the book down because there were some really good creepy scenes and it takes a lot for me to get creeped out. I do think the book was moving at a very fast pace which was good in some aspects but sometimes I was confused on what was going on. But overall I really enjoyed this book. Thank you again Emily for this book for an honest review. Keep doing creepy because you do it so well.
Profile Image for ChanaReadsHorror.
252 reviews17 followers
May 29, 2024
This book is such a thrill ride with just a hint of romance thrown in as well.
We follow a group of teenagers are they are being hunted/chased/stalked by something and it is taking them out one by one. Not only do they need to figure out what is going on and how to stop it, the one friend has to figure out of she can hide her secret in the end.
This one took me a bit to get into, but once I did I was not able to stop turning the pages.
Profile Image for Tonna.
210 reviews5 followers
May 30, 2024
Horror, Fantasy, & Romance? What more could you ask for. This is the 2nd book I've read by Emily and I was yet again blown away. I loved the creepy vibe of the story, the "monsters" were so unique, the FMC was my favorite. She kept the biggest secret from her friends who were dying one by one because one of them would not admit to their faults. I quickly devoured this book and loved every second of it.
Profile Image for j a y • d e p r a v e d - .dammnitjay..
721 reviews29 followers
June 1, 2024
This is definitely a unique story.
It borders lines of spooky, horror and thriller.

I found the hunting down by the Judges to be a great plot point and made your heart do that little speed up with the suspense.
I love the aspect of "owning it" - owning what you say, what you do, how you act.

This was a refreshing read, and as my first read from this author - I am excited to see where she goes and what she puts out next.
Profile Image for Dayton.
492 reviews5 followers
March 18, 2025
3.5 stars

This book was decent. It was a little hard to read given how long the chapters are and each chapter was like a cliffhanger, while it pulled you in and kept your reading, it was a little much. The characters, there were a handful of them, were written nicely, the plot was there, i enjoyed it overall. It could’ve had more here and there and things could’ve been taken out but it was a good read.
Profile Image for Angela L.
219 reviews11 followers
March 19, 2025
This was a unique story that blended a lot of different genres, including romance, horror, triller, and paranormal. The writing was very descriptive, and I could picture the scenes really well in my head. It was fast-paced. It did have a lot of characters, and because of that they wasn't a lot of character development, and it was harder to form attachments. Overall, though, good story that kept me reading more and more so I could find out what happens next.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.