Bullet Review:
Damn, this series just astounds me! The teens act their age and yet still get the chance to be heroic, whether it is by resisting evil Brakiss' teaching or attempting an escape - or realizing that they were wrong and the adults were right. Luke Skywalker is brilliantly done here, a beautiful mentor for these kids, and I love that Luke and Tenel Ka had to pair off to find Jacen, Jaina and Lowie.
This is probably a 4-stars, but because of that ending, the amount of fun I had reading this, I am rounding up to 5-stars. I am excited for book 3!
Full Review:
Jaina, Jacen and Lowbacca head to Uncle Lando's Corusca Gem mining station on Yavin, while unbeknownst to them, Tenel Ka is set to meet an emissary of her prestigius grandmother, Ta'a Chume. However, Jaina, Jacen and Lowbacca are taken away to the Shadow Academy, led by Brakiss and Tamith Kai, who want to teach the talented Force-sensitive teens the true way of the Force. Luke Skywalker and Tenel Ka team up to hunt down the teens - before it is too late.
I'm truly astonished here; I started to read these Young Jedi Knight books just as a final goodbye, before passing them along to a child who would read and adore these. I thought these would be incredibly dorky and embarrassing - like Jacen's bad jokes (which oddly enough, while bad, are nearly endearing). However, this is the second book where I am genuinely carried away by the story, captivated by the characters, and curious how everything will turn out in the end. Oh, and also flabbergasted at the deep insights we gain into the Force and general sentient interactions.
This book, we get to see the infamous Brakiss, Luke's other failed apprentice (his first being the notorious genocidal Kyp Durron), and Tamith Kai, a Dathomiri "Nightsister", as well as our usual Jaina, Jacen, Lowbacca, Emteedee, Tenel Ka, Luke Skywalker and Qorl. May I just say all these characters are so fascinating and well done?! The kids get to be kids (like Jacen, itching to start training on the lightsaber), but they also have their moments of heroics, from Jacen's capture of a Corusca gem (aka Chekov's Gun) to Lowbacca's quick thinking on the computers to Jaina's acumen for the mechanical to Tenel Ka's stubborn refusal to use the Force. Luke Skywalker is an absolutely amazing mentor, with great lines about how the Force isn't just for one gender or one species, about being patient and not acting brashly. Brakiss especially comes across as particularly cunning and ruthless, not the mustache twirling nor the murderous villain we find all too common in the Legends timeline. He remains calm and methodical and logical, even while espousing Dark Side logic. Tamith Kai gets to be our hot-head, which honestly, I love. She's deliciously wicked without resorting too far into cartoonish. And then Qorl! I'm SUPER impressed with the complexity there.
I feel really gushy right now, like a squeeing fangirl, but let's face it, I had a great time reading this! Sure, the story has its hiccups - why spend the effort stealing 3 students when you could find 3 willing participants (in this world, unlike in the Disney Star Wars, you don't need to be a Skywalker, a Solo or a Palpatine to use the Force)? Did Luke just sentence a Nightsister to death by ejecting her in an escape pod? How do Jacen and Jaina not know when monsters are real or holograms - can't they sense them in the Force? But overall, I could sequester those niggling questions away and sink myself into the story (just please no twin kidnapping in book 3!).
I suppose I should rein in my optimism as we are only book 2 into the series, and there are 12 more books to go - and we all know that series can go any which way! But this has been a beautiful moment of rediscovery, of nostalgia, reliving those easy days of my youth when I dreamed of being a Jedi Knight, wielding a lightsaber, standing alongside Luke Skywalker, saving the day. I hope the kids I give these books to have those feelings as well.