The Taking of Irene Hart

by Madeleine Reiss

1859. Somerset, England.


When widow Hester Hart decides to sign over all her family’s worldly goods – and their freedom – to a secretive religious community, her daughters, headstrong Ruby and fragile Irene, have little say in the matter.

Led by the charismatic Reverend Peters, the women enter a world with its own set of rules and where Irene, cursed with seizures and ill health, is believed to have second sight. But as Hester and Irene are drawn into the community’s twisted philosophy, Ruby detects a darker truth stalking its shadowy corners.

When a shocking discovery throws the community open to scrutiny, the stakes are raised and Ruby realises that it is not only their souls that must be saved …

Genres: Historical Fiction, Historical, Gothic, Fiction

368 pages, Kindle Edition

Published February 13, 2025

Reviews

[CarolG · Rating 4 out of 5]

In 1859 widow Hester Hart falls under the spell of the charismatic Reverend Peters and signs over all her worldly goods to his secretive religious community and then moves with her two daughters into the "Garden Kingdom". The daughters, Ruby and Irene, are like chalk and cheese (or silk and hemp as their mother says) with Ruby being more pragmatic than Irene. Irene suffers from seizures and experiences visions which some in the Community interpret as meaning she has second sight.

Inspired by a true story, this is a well-written novel of atmospheric suspense with a pervasive feeling of impending doom. The characters are well fleshed out and I especially liked the police officer, Constable Philip Hodge. Obviously this type of cult has been around for a very long time and there will always be followers looking for something to believe in. The ending was exactly what I had hoped for. A solid 4-star read. And what a lovely cover too.

Thank you to HarperCollins UK, One More Chapter, via Netgalley, for approving my request to read an advance copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Publication Date: February 13, 2025.

[Ceecee · Rating 4 out of 5]

Bridgewater, Somerset, 1859.
Ruby and Irene Hart’s mother is in deep mourning for the loss of her husband several months ago. The sisters persuade her to finally leave the house and curiosity about why crowds have gathered leads the women into the orbit of the charismatic Reverend Peters of the Garden Kingdom based at Yaxton. He seems to offer Hester‘s life a meaning, it’s almost like she’s bewitched. When she decides they will all move into the community, she signs over her house and wealth to Reverend Peters. It’s fair to say their lives will never be the same again. Meanwhile, Police Constable Philip Hodge is trying to find the mother of a newborn baby found bundled into a hedge at Yaxton. Is it anything to do with the Garden Kingdom?

I really enjoy this well written engaging tale, which is told at a good pace and keeps my attention throughout. What emerges is a mystery, a puzzle at the centre of which is the enigmatic Peters who clearly I view brimful of 21st century cynicism. There’s a very good Gothic tone which the author strikes and it’s full of tension and atmosphere, albeit an increasingly rotten one. Some of the descriptions are rich and engage all the senses.

The characters are terrific and the standouts are Ruby and Hodge. I love the tenacity of Hodge who despite the best efforts of his lazy lugubrious boss Jowler, he keeps using his instincts and persists in his investigation. He’s a man of great kindness too. As for Ruby, I love her robust spirit and her love, care and tenderness for the delicate flower that is Irene, whose “takings“ are also central to the plot. Ruby knows there is something wrong at the Garden Kingdom and she bravely keeps going despite the dangers. Why doesn’t her mother sense it too?? She’s a self-indulgent woman but her reactions and that of plenty of others to the ethos of Garden Kingdom are both fascinating and thought provoking. How can somebody be so totally convinced by what they are told and blinded to the realities? Some of the things that occur in the Kingdom are no great surprise but that said there are shocks
and much danger in store which brave souls will have to take on in order to survive.

Overall, this is a gripping, dark, well written story and I root throughout for the sisters and for Hodge.

With thanks to NetGalley and especially to HarperCollins, One More Chapter for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review.

[Sheila · Rating 3 out of 5]

I received a free copy of, The Taking of Irene Hart, by Madeleine Reiss, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Its 1800 in England, some religions are like cults, with their own secrets and laws. Hester and her daughters Irene and Ruby are drawn into a cult. A clever read.

[EmG ReadsDaily · Rating 4 out of 5]

A dark historical story, inspired by true events. Set in England in 1859.

🍂 Isolated religious community with cultish vibes
🍂 Gothic setting
🍂 Strict rules
🍂 Psychological tension
🍂 Despicable behaviour
🍂 Shocking discoveries

[Cindy Spear · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is one of the most disturbing and heartbreaking stories I have ever read and to know it is based on a real cult that flourished in Somerset England in the mid 1850’s puts it in an even more distressing light. It is not a novel that made me feel good as the subject matter cuts like a knife through the sane psyche.

Many years ago in Sociology class I studied cults and why some people fall into them and under the spell of their charismatic leaders. Of course, we had to analyse the modern cult of Jonestown and the massacre that followed. It is one of those events in history that always comes to mind, I suppose, as a result of its horrid effects and outcome. Even then, when I learned all about it and had to write an essay, I felt as if I could not breathe after knowing the facts. The bondage and entrapment experienced by the deluded felt horrifying. It is a sad day of revelation for those to discover they have been taken in—that they have trusted someone with their lives who have evil intent. Of course, some never come to this conclusion or get the chance. And one fact that makes me even angrier is that such cults are created in the name of religion. The focus may initially be on ‘God’ as a means to justify their existence but devotion ultimately is transferred to the cult leader. The Taking of Irene Heart is an incredible example of such a perverted system. The ‘community’ as they call it is built on falsehoods. They succeed by taking control and separating its members from the rest of society to brain wash them: make them believe that their ‘salvation, eternal life, and chance to live forever’ is reserved only for those in their ‘community.’ Anything outside their four walls is a distraction, sin and damnation.

After the death of Rubie and Irene’s father, their mother one day decides to give all her belongings, home and money to the one they call “The Beloved’ or ‘Pastor Peters – a man who was once a medical doctor but has set up his Garden Kingdom. The daughters initially are appalled and Rubie does not want to be part of her mother’s plans. But after much struggle within herself, she goes along with it to stay with and care for her sister. Irene has seizures, that, of course, we know today it is a neurological disorder. But her condition is used by the ‘community’ to proclaim she has some prophetic abilities. And the longer they remain in this cult, the more of their true selves are lost. Though Ruby is the only one to fight against it. Her mother in time, becomes like a stranger to her, losing all sensibility, all desire to protect or assert herself. This demeanour is ‘replaced by a kind of indifference and the same unblinking gaze she saw on many of the saints’ faces.’

Suicides with messages attached to the victims and an abandoned baby brings Police Constable Hodge inside the community to question Pastor Peters. His slippery answers show a lot about his character. Also, the fervour of his declaration that he is leading his flock to redemption fills the Constable with dread. This man who has written his own narrative and of those around him, is someone with ‘absolute control over the way the story’ ends. He ‘could justify almost anything and would always be able to shape things to fit his own purposes.’ The Constable is very perceptive and knows this makes Peters a very dangerous man.

So many things that happen in this story have scientific or medical explanations but are interpreted as some handiwork of the Pastor, like the Solar storm seen by many inside the community. And as Ruby discovers, also seen by others across the world. Pastor Peters, like many cult leaders, want their followers to believe they have some supernatural powers as it gives them more control when people have faith in them. So sad, this blind trust.

This novel is about so many things related to cults, spiritual seduction and blindness. It is a real study in human behaviour that includes betrayal and false justification to defend those actions. In an environment such as this, that puts itself outside the law, people begin to lose a sense of right and wrong. And as Ruby confesses to her friend, ‘This place is full of shadows.’ Leading to frightening truths, shocking secrets, mysterious happenings and plenty of on the edge of your seat action in the lead up to the finale.

But…I am glad to report, there is a happy ending and light re-enters the once darkened scene. I will say no more but if you dare to enter this realm, it will pierce your heart and awaken your spirit. The Taking of Irene Hart covers a difficult subject matter but the author handles it well and makes you appreciate your freedom. 4 Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Thanks to One More Chapter and Netgalley for a review copy.

[Carole Tyrrell · Rating 4 out of 5]

It is 1859 and in Bridgwater, Somerset the Hart family; eldest daughter Ruby, her sister Irene and their mother Hester, have been in full mourning for six months. It was Ruby that found the body of her father in his study and time literally seems to have stopped. Hester has withdrawn into herself and
‘hoarded her sorrow, lingering over its heft, counting its facets and piling up its weight, leaving Ruby no way to share the extent of the loss, or even to expend her own.’
But the two girls persuade Hester to accompany them on a shopping expedition and it’s there that their lives take a decisive turn. Ruby remembers it as when their lives changed forever. A man is preaching to a gathering on the street. He is called Rev Peters and he talks about a commune of believers called the Garden Kingdom. Hester is entranced and comes back to life again. She follows him around the country and life for Ruby and Irene improves as they are allowed to see their friends again. Ruby and Cousin Anna are discussing the latter’s forthcoming wedding although for Ruby:
‘it was galling to expend so much energy expressing enthusiasm for table napkins.’
Then Hester announces they are all going to live at the Kingdom and that she has sold all their worldly possessions to gain entry. They will all become as Hester describes it:
‘Brides of Christ’
But Irene has a secret. She suffers from fits or ‘takings’ as she calls them in which she has visions of the future and talks about what she has seen afterwards. It ruined her blossoming romance with a man called William who was shocked by seeing her during one of her ‘takings.’
But in Yaxton where the Kingdom is located, an abandoned baby has been found under a hedge. PC Philip Hodge is investigating and trying to find the mother. He suspects that it might be connected to the Garden community and is reluctantly allowed to interview some of the residents. Several members of the community have their own reasons for being there and regard it as a safe haven. Men and women are separated and there are no children. They are all interested in Irene’s ‘takings’ which begin to increase after she is prescribed a tincture.
A member of the Kingdom, a girl named Hattie, is found in the orchard having committed suicide with a note pinned to her chest. When Philip discovers that there have been other suicides in the same place in successive years he realises that the apparently idyllic community is hiding a dark secret.
Hattie had recently given birth….
As Irene’s visions become darker and Rev Peters resolves to take a Bride Ruby begins to discover the other side of the Kingdom…
The idealistic community with a canker at its heart is one that has appeared in several novels and the fact that it is based on a real life one in Somerset in the 19th century makes it even more convincing. The inspiration for the book was that the residents of the real life community were supposedly not as clean living as they professed to be. But the Kingdom is really a cult with its own rules and punishments.
I liked the way in which the author built up the atmosphere from when the Harts arrive and it all seems very idyllic and welcoming. But Ruby and Philip gradually become privy to what lies beneath the surface. I felt that there were hints of Midsommar in parts of the text. A really dark, Gothic influence pervades the book with a sense of doom. This contrasted with the happy residents who do not see anything even when people seemingly vanish never to be seen again. Hester is totally taken in and happy to be there forever.
There was a subplot with William that didn’t seem to go anywhere but Ruby was an engaging character, forceful and determined, as she sought to care for the increasing frail Irene. She realises that Irene is being cruelly exploited.
Philip was another strong character as he pressed on trying to solve the mystery of the baby while having his own problems at home and facing indifference and hindrance by his superior, Jowler. He recognises that Rev Peters is a man:
‘possessed by his own dogma.’
This is a wonderful piece of historical fiction with some evocative descriptions. However, towards the end the narrative dragged a little as revelations tumbled out but the plotting was immaculate.
My thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for an ARC.

[Jerica Mercado · Rating 4 out of 5]

Set in 1859 Somerset, England, The Taking of Irene Hart is a historical fiction inspired by a real religious community/cult. The story focuses on the Hart sisters, headstrong Ruby and the more delicate Irene, whose mother has fallen under the sway of the community’s charismatic leader, Reverend Peters. While Irene starts to feel acceptance and comfort within the community, Ruby is less sure. As she spends more time within the secluded community, talking to the members and asking questions, she starts to fear that the community is only idyllic on its surface.

I love historical fiction, so I was immediately drawn in to the idea of a Victorian-era cult operating in a sleepy English town. I found the entire premise so fascinating and full of stakes—Irene suffers from seizures, a condition little understood at the time by the wider public, which essentially ostracizes her from much of polite society. Compounding that is the fact that the sisters are women in Victorian England, unable to do much about their own fates. While author Madeleine Reiss doesn’t harp on this, it's evident throughout the novel that fear and a lack of power and self-determination helps effectively trap the Hart sisters within the community just as much as Reverend Peters’ warnings of damnation if they leave.

While the story primarily focuses on Ruby as she tries to navigate her space within the community, we also get chapters from the point of view of Phillip Hodge, a local constable investigating the community for various suspicions. I loved Phillip’s chapters—while he helped further the sense that dark things were happening in the shadows—he also helped to contextualize the setting. Through him we see the poverty and hardship the working class endured, and the hardships the Hart sisters could face without financial protection.

I also feel like this could qualify as a mystery/thriller. Throughout the novel we see hints of darker things happening behind the scenes; Ruby and Phillip are both convinced that something is not right within the community. There’s a definite looming sense of dread that permeates the pages. We have come to care about Ruby and Irene and don’t want to see them remain inside the walls of this sinister place, and we can’t put our finger on exactly what is wrong or who’s behind it. That dread had me flying through the second half of the book, desperate to see the conclusion.

My only quibble was that in the first half of the book we are treated to small bits of insight from other characters, members of the community who also believe in Reverend Peters’ mission. I really liked these moments, so I was a bit disappointed when they trickled off in the latter half of the book. But overall this is a good read for fans of historical fiction who enjoy a mystery on the side.

[Ale · Rating 5 out of 5]

TA
La famiglia Hart, Hester e le figlie Ruby e Irene, è in lutto in quanto il padre è morto da poco in modo inaspettato. Ruby, la figlia maggiore, riesce a convincere la madre ad uscire a fare una passeggiata.
Durante questa passeggiata, incuriosite da un gruppo di persone, incontrano il reverendo Peters. La madre, colpita dalle parole e dai modi del reverendo, inizia a partecipare ai suoi sermoni fino a quando comunica alle figlie che si è spogliata dei suoi averi (ossia ha ceduto casa e patrimonio al reverendo) e loro andranno a vivere nella comunità del reverendo, “Garden Kingdom.”.
L’agente Philip Hodge trova una bambina appena nata abbandonata fuori dalle mura della comunità e cerca di trovare chi l’ha abbandonata e perché.
La storia è liberamente ispirata a una storia vera di una setta religiosa presente nel Somerset nel periodo (1859) in cui avvengono le vicende narrate.
La storia mi è piaciuta molto. L’alternanza delle vicende di Ruby all’interno della comunità e delle indagini di Hodge all’esterno rende la storia più avvincente, con il ritmo giusto di narrazione. La storia principale è quanto succede nella comunità: all'inizio c’è un’atmosfera ovattata quasi paradisiaca, sembra andare tutto bene, fino a quando, combinando le indagini di Hodge e lo scetticismo di Ruby, tutto diventa claustrofobico, ansioso e sopratutto è necessario agire in modo urgente.
Molto consigliato!
Ho ricevuto una copia gratuita. Questa recensione contiene la mia opinione ed è pubblicata liberamente.

ENG
The Hart family, Hester and daughters Ruby and Irene, is grieving as their father recently died unexpectedly. Ruby, the eldest daughter, manages to convince her mother to go out for a walk.
During this walk, intrigued by a group of people, they meet Reverend Peters. The mother, impressed by the reverend's words and manner, begins to attend his sermons until she informs her daughters that she has divested herself of her possessions (i.e., given her house and estate to the reverend) and they are going to live in the reverend's community, “Garden Kingdom.”
Officer Philip Hodge finds a newborn baby girl abandoned outside the community walls and tries to find who abandoned her and why.
The story is loosely based on a true story of a religious sect present in Somerset at the time (1859) when the events narrated take place.
I liked the story very much. The alternation of Ruby's events inside the community and Hodge's investigations outside makes the story more compelling, with the right pace of narration. The main story is what happens in the community: at the beginning there is a muffled, almost heavenly atmosphere; everything seems to be going well, until, combining Hodge's investigations and Ruby's skepticism, everything becomes claustrophobic, anxious, and above all, urgent action is needed.
Highly recommended!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

[Frankie · Rating 3 out of 5]

Well, this is different, it's dark and a little disturbing, especially once you realise that it is loosely based on real events, it's certainly the darkest book I have read in a long, long time, and I am still in two minds over whether I actually liked it or not.

It took a lot out of me to finish it, it felt heavy and at times, I did put it down to read something lighter as I felt it darkened my mood, but I did persevere with it, not sure if it was the best course, but I finished it eventually.

The Taking of Irene Hart tells the story of how after the death of her husband, Hester Hart becomes a a bit of a recluse, her daughters Irene and Ruby eventually get her out of the house but she soon makes the acquaintance of the Reverend Peters who after getting inside her head with his religious cultish nonsense he eventually persuades her to leave behind everything she knows and move her and her daughters to live with him at him commune but to be able to live there she must sign everything she owns over to him.
At this part of the story, I know what was coming, and I wanted to scream at her to, "Run for the hills, Hester, run for the hills!!"

But she does it and this si the start of their new, hugely controlled and very disturbing way of life; Ruby is a great character she is not happy with whats going on and fears there is something not quite right about those place and its members but she stays with her sister and mother, but things takes a turn when Irene who has always suffered with seizures has one in the commune and soon becomes an idol for the commune for they thing she can interpret the future.

Other things happen, abandoned babies, murder, a police investigation, all of which add up to the fact that this place and these people are all bonkers, and there is something very wrong going on.

It isn't the easiest of reads and I did struggle with it, I do love a bit of gothic fiction but this is very disturbing, it's not for the light hearted and it's themes of control and manipulations as well as everything else swiling around the background isn't the easiest thing to digest.

[Milly Reynolds · Rating 4 out of 5]

Set in Somerset in the 1850s, it is not until you read the author’s afterword that this is based upon a real cult that was in Somerset in this period. Therefore, after reading it, this little piece of information makes you look at what you have read with a different eye, if you see what I mean. After the death of their father, Ruby and Irene Hart are taken by their mother, Hester, to live in a community called the Garden Kingdom, having fallen under the spell of The Beloved, or Pastor Peters, and handed over all of her money and property to him. Irene suffers from what are called ‘takings’, seizures, and so Ruby, who is a super, strong character, is protective of her. Their mother has given them no choice in this matter and while Irene feels more accepted within this community, Ruby is appalled that this is to be her life. As the book progresses, we see the manipulation of Pastor Peters and how he separates these women from the rest of the town. He makes them believe that only by living in the Garden Kingdom will they be able to achieve eternal life. But Ruby realises that not is all it seems. And so does Constable Philip Hodge who is determined to find out the truth about a baby that was found abandoned outside the walls of the community. Especially as marriages within the Garden Kingdom and spiritual and not physical. He also wants to find out the truth about the suicide of a young woman from the community who was found hanged outside. He believes something rotten is going on within the walls of the community and that Pastor Peters rather than being a spiritual leader is in fact a dangerous man. This is an excellent read and although it is dark and you do feel the horror that is within the Garden Kingdom, especially as it is based on fact, you are on the side of Ruby as she fights to protect her sister, you cheer on Constable Hodge as he stands firm before Pastor Peter and the dramatic finale will reveal all. A book has everything, history, scary moments, shocking events, secrets, and even romance.

[Baeannereads · Rating 4 out of 5]

A huge thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and Madeleine Reiss for providing me with an ARC of The Taking of Irene Hart in exchange for my honest review.

The Taking of Irene Hart by Madeleine Reiss is a beautifully crafted historical fiction novel set in the atmospheric backdrop of Somerset, England, in 1859. At the heart of the story is Hester Hart, a widow, who is drawn into a mysterious and secretive religious community led by the enigmatic Reverend Peters. Along with her two daughters, Irene and Ruby, Hester becomes enmeshed in a web of fervent beliefs, hidden agendas, and emotional struggles, all of which culminate in a tale as haunting as it is captivating.

One of the novel's most compelling aspects is its basis in true events, which lends an additional layer of intrigue and authenticity to the narrative. Madeleine Reiss's writing is richly descriptive, painting vivid images of the period's setting and the oppressive atmosphere of the community. Her skillful prose immerses readers, making it easy to feel the tension and unease that permeate the story.

The plot is expertly woven with unexpected twists and turns, keeping the reader on edge throughout. Just when you think you understand the characters and their motivations, Reiss surprises you with revelations that deepen the story's complexity. A touch of romance adds warmth to the otherwise dark and gripping tale, balancing the emotional weight of the narrative.

I found The Taking of Irene Hart to be a thoroughly engaging read. It masterfully combines historical detail, suspense, and emotional depth to create a story that lingers in the mind long after the final page. Madeleine Reiss proves herself to be a storyteller of remarkable talent, and I eagerly anticipate exploring more of her works in the future.

If you're a fan of historical fiction with elements of mystery, drama, and romance, this novel is for you.

[Krystal · Rating 4 out of 5]

Based loosely on actual events this is a story about those who yearn for acceptance and direction and the danger of finding either in the wrong place.

Hester is a widowed mother with two young adult daughters Irene and Ruby. After the death of her husband Hester is devastated and not coping. Today there would be medical assistance for her mental state, but in 1859 there is no such help, and her daughters are relieved when she finds the will to live again until they realize what it will mean for their family. One day Hester met a charismatic man who said all the right things to sooth her troubled mind. Not only that, if she signs all her worldly possessions over to him, she and her daughters can come and live among his followers at his compound and study his teachings. That's right.....a cult. As sad as I was for Hester's predicament her character was a constant source of anger for me. I wanted to scream at her every time she opened her mouth.

Irene experiences seizures accompanied by visions of the future. Ruby questions everything around them and holds fast to the dream of getting herself and Irene out of the cult. She looks out for Irene and worries when the leadership takes a special interest in Irene's visions. She feels the sole responsibility of her sister because their mother is thoroughly brainwashed. Ruby has many flaws and although I felt exasperated with some of her choices, I appreciated that she was written with these faults because it made her more realistic. Irene might be the sister with a gift, but Ruby's bravery was quite admirable.

Darker themes are explored, and I experienced a feeling of unease throughout. The pace is a bit slow in the earlier chapters, but towards the end I was turning pages like mad to find how events would unfold.

Thank you to NetGalley and HarperCollins UK for providing an Advanced Readers Copy. These are my unbiased opinions.

[aishareadsnrambles · Rating 4 out of 5]

BOOK: THE TAKING OF IRENE HART
AUTHOR: MADELEINE REISS
PUB DATE: FEBRUARY, 2025
👭🏼👮🏼‍♂️
REVIEWThanks to Netgalley and the Publisher for this ARC. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
👮🏼‍♂️👭🏼
I liked this book because it was different. A religious cult in the late 1800s? Sign me up! Plus, the author said it was based in a real life story. This just shows that we're not really different from those in the past.
👭🏼👮🏼‍♂️
Anyway, the book follows Ruby Hart, who followed her mother, Hester, alongside her epileptic younger sister, Irene, to the Garden Kingdom after her mother lost her senses after her husband and their father's death. Irene also has 'sightings' when she has seizures predicting the future. Hester didn't make any impression on me at all. She was my least favorite character here, even more than the villains, because she was weak and failed to protect her young daughters.
👮🏼‍♂️👭🏼
This book was slow paced, but it will keep you engaged, wanting to know the next thing. The other main character was Inspector Philip Hodge, he was a dedicated police officer and a good person in general. He started investigating the cult when he found a newborn baby abandoned in the compound. I admired his doggedness.
👭🏼👮🏼‍♂️
Now, through Ruby, the female main character, we were able to experience what leaving in the community did. It was just like how cults are described. The gullible followers and the charismatic leader who thinks he's a God wannabe. I liked Ruby's description. It was similar and engaging. I liked it.
👮🏼‍♂️👭🏼
I liked the book, but I wanted more of an epilogue, especially the aftermath and the lives of Ruby and Philip. Regardless, it was good, and I'm glad I read it. I'd definitely recommend it.
👭🏼👮🏼‍♂️

[Annette Jordan · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Taking of Irene Hart by Madeleine Reiss is a slow burn but one where menace oozes off the page. Set in Somerset, England in 1859 and loosely inspired by a real religious group in that area at that time, this book tells the story of two very different sisters who find themselves becoming part of an unusual community led by the charismatic Reverend Peters when their widowed mother is swept away by his teachings. Elder sister Ruby is not keen on the move, fearing it will leave the family isolated and at the whims of a stranger while younger sister Irene is more keen as the Community seems to be a welcoming place for those with shortcomings such as hers, she is prone to seizures and her ill health has already cost her a suitor. Of course the Community is not the paradise it seems and when a determined policeman is determined to investigate its links to an abandoned baby found in the area his scrutiny feeds into Ruby's fears. The only question is if it will be enough to save her little sister.
As I have already said this is a book for those who like a slower paced darker read. If like me you find cults fascinating, this book is a great historical take on the subject and the author does a very good job of showing how easily vulnerable women in particular could find themselves caught up in such an organisation. The cloistered setting of the Community adds a sense of claustrophobia, as a reader I felt almost as trapped as the characters I was reading about, and the feeling of menace that built over the course of the book was more than a little unsettling.
I read an ARC courtesy of NetGalley and the publisher, all opinions are my own.

[Bzz Kolla · Rating 3 out of 5]

Thank you NetGalley and HarperCollins UK for this eCopy to review

'The Taking of Irene Hart' by Madeleine Reiss is a historical gothic thriller, it was a compelling, if somewhat unsettling, read.

The story is set in 1859 Somerset, England, and it centres on widow Hester Hart and her two daughters, Ruby and Irene. Hester, seeking spiritual solace, decides to join a secretive religious community led by the charismatic Reverend Peters. Once inside, the family's lives are drastically altered.

I was immediately drawn into the oppressive atmosphere of the community. Reiss does a fantastic job of creating a sense of unease and dread. The community's strict rules, the reverend's manipulative charisma, and the growing sense of isolation all contributed to a truly gothic feel.

Irene, who suffers from seizures and is believed by the community to have second sight, is a particularly intriguing character. Her vulnerability and the way she's exploited by the community were deeply disturbing. Ruby, the headstrong sister, becomes the voice of reason and resistance. I was rooting for her as she began to suspect that something sinister was happening within the community's walls.

The plot unfolds as Ruby uncovers dark secrets and a twisted philosophy that threatens her family's safety. The suspense builds as she realizes that they're not just fighting for their souls but for their very lives. The shocking discovery that throws the community into scrutiny adds a layer of urgency and danger.

If you enjoy historical gothic thrillers with a touch of mystery and suspense, you'll likely find this book engaging

[Celine loves books · Rating 4 out of 5]

Well to say that this book was different is an understatement this book would not have been my choice as I was unaware of the author if it had not came up as a suggestion.
This book tells the story of the Hart family set in the 1850 I do love a good thriller book but this was a fascinating book based on a true story that told the tell of the Hart women after their father passed and their mother became overwhelmed with her new life and in turns she becomes intrigued with a travelling preacher man reverend Peters who promises them eternal life.. With the interest Reverend Peters has on the family and especially that of the youngest child Irene and her visions will make you feel uneasy and question his motives towards welcoming them into the Garden kingdom walls. This is a gothic history thriller with twists around that of a life within a commune alongside a police officer who unfolds a story of the finding about a baby found in a bush why is it there and what has happened to its mother.
The build up of the characters are very good and the writing reflects this and will have you looking towards the mother and questioning why does she not see what is happening there is very strong characters in this books which will make you feel uneasy though the role of the constable is very well incorporated into the story.
This is a dark, gripping gothic read which will hold you to wanting to find out what happens behind the walls of the garden kingdom and what happens to those who live there.
Thank you NetGalley, One more chapter and HarperCollins uk for the ARC copy of this book for an honest review ..

[Lynda · Rating 4 out of 5]

Loosely based on a true story this is set in Somerset, UK in 1959. Following the death of her husband Hester Hart goes into deep mourning, leaving sisters Ruby and Irene to their own devices. When they do eventually persuade her to leave the house she hears Reverend Peters talk and is entranced. Following him around and listening to more she eventually decides to moves herself and two daughter to a religious community run by Peters, signing over all that she owns to them. This is a slow burn which suits the story as the atmosphere becomes more and more tense.

Briefly, headstrong Ruby is not happy with the turn in their lives but decides to go with her mother and sister to watch out for them. Irene suffers with seizures, which recently caused her fiancé to leave her so when a seizure happens at the commune and she mutters what appears to be a vision of the future she expects horror from the other members. But the opposite happens and she becomes respected and treated with importance. Meanwhile, following the discovery of a newborn baby near the commune and later a hanged woman the local police are investigating and the members are under some suspicion.

The actions within the commune are quite scary. The rules are very strict and the ideology of “The Beloved” as Peters is known are dark and twisted. It’s shocking to see how easily people are taken in by a charismatic character. Ruby is a great, albeit flawed, character who is determined to do right by her family. A dark and disturbing historical fiction novel, very enjoyable.

[Haxxunne · Rating 4 out of 5]

Rollicking historical thriller of cults and women’s lives
—
Don’t let the gorgeous cover fool you: this is a book full of dark and disturbing actions, based on a more benign true story. In 1859, forthright Ruby Hart and her invalid sister Irene are forced into seclusion when their recently widowed mother Hester decides to give up all their worldly goods to the Garden Kingdom, an alternative religious community headed by the charismatic Reverend Peters. As odd and unworldly as the community is, Ruby and her new friend PC Philip Hodge are more concerned by the mysterious disappearances and deaths of other young women from the Garden Kingdom, and the abandonment of a newborn on the neighbouring country road. Could there be a dark secret in Ruby’s supposed new Eden?

The eponymous ‘taking’ is how Irene’s fits are described, and when she recovers, her visions are taken as holy by the community. It’s an interesting interpretation of a woman’s unusual qualities and reads well as part of this well-researched Victorian pastoral Gothic, and the Hart family are all so well drawn that you can’t help feeling for the daughters when their mother steadily falls into the scam of the Garden Kingdom, a cult like any other. It’s only through the incisive detective work of Ruby and her admirer PC Hodge that things end satisfyingly, although with enough gore, sensationalism and death for any crime reader.

A thoroughly enjoyable four stars.

[Amy Dora · Rating 5 out of 5]

As soon as I saw that beautiful cover and the words 1859 Somerset, I knew this was going to be a Dark, rich, gothic historical story and it did not disappoint. I loved the descriptions, it was so atmospheric throughout it had me holding my breath. Ruby and Irene are really put through the mill by their mother, Hester, who decides to sign over their house to the Reverend Peter's, after the death of her husband (their father), and move into the Garden Kingdom, and when consequently it all goes downhill. The historical aspect and the cults that were around in those times are terrifying and I can't imagine what it must have been like to be sucked into that system, and their trust be broken, especially in the religious context where trust shouldn't be questioned and yet it is taken advantage of in the most heinous of ways. On top of that, poor Irene's seizures, which are completely exploited by the community, and further leads to the sisters detachment from their mother. The mysterious 'suicides' in the community attracts the attention of the Police Constable, Hodge, who starts to delve deep into the puzzle and is very suspicious and acutely aware of how dangerous Reverend Peter's is, especially when his position gives him so much influence and power over 'his people'.
An incredibly written masterpiece that was terrifying and enchanting at the same time!

[Lindsey Pope · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5 ⭐️
Set in Somerset, England in 1859 this is a tale loosely based on a real life religious group in that era.
After the death of her husband Hester is in deep mourning and is drawn in by the charismatic Reverend Peters and his teachings of a new way of life. She decides to move herself and her daughters Ruby and Irene to the Garden Kingdom where they will live in the community to gain ever lasting life.
The sisters have little choice to go with their mother and the eldest Ruby is not happy about it. Irene suffers with seizures and while being ostracised by many in their previous life is thought of as a visionary when she sees things during her ‘takings’ that could be seen as visions of the future.
There is a mystery element which I enjoyed in this story. Supposed suicides, stolen pineapples, cult secrets and an abandoned baby are investigated by Constable Phillip Hodges who is the local law enforcement in the area.

Phillip and Ruby were by far the most interesting characters and I found myself rooting for them the most.

I really enjoyed this read although found it slow going in places.

With thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for sending me the arc.

[Holly · Rating 3 out of 5]

The Taking of Irene Hart by Madeleine Reiss is an historical novel that shows how little women were respected in the Victorian age of England. Hester becomes widowed and falls under the spell of a con-man selling religious salvation. Hester's daughter's Ruby and Irene are forced to join their mother in the religious cult, leading to tragedy and trauma.
The story shows the lack of respect and the lack of voice that women in Victorian England had. It shows how women, during this time had no support when left widowed, leaving them to latch on to any chance of salvation whether financially or spiritually despite the consequences. The trauma these women faced in lieu of God's instructions was horrendous.
The story was well written, despite the difficult topic. It was told from multiple viewpoints so it occasionally was difficult to keep track of who was telling the story. It occasionally was so slow paced that you wondered if anything was going to happen. However, if you can look past that and continue with the story, it was an interesting look at a real event that took place in history.
Thank you to NetGalley, HarperCollins UK, and One More Chapter for the advanced copy.

[Jules · Rating 3 out of 5]

This was not something I would have picked up to read in my own. This is a VERY LATE ARC review 😂😭

While I did not entirely enjoy this story, the writing and the pace was chefs kiss. Short chapters. Multi POV. Everything I truly enjoy. The story on the other hand, NOT at all what I expected.

This is set in the late 1800s apparently, though most times it felt very current. I didn’t FEEL dated in any way so I guess that’s a good thing.

Basically the story is about a family of women, whose patriarch does, and then find a new life in a cult/compound. Like you can probably imagine, the cult is not who they say they are; dead women show up. As well as an abandoned, almost dead, baby. Irene, whose name is literally the title, has seizures which are seen as “premonitions” to the future of the cult and she’s eventually also found missing. The police get involved, stir up some stuff, and then the mystery is solved when other cult members decide to do the right thing.

Didn’t hate it. Didn’t love it. It was DARK and unexpected. Historical fiction in a way, but also spooky too.

[KDRBCK · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Taking of Irene Hart by new to me author M. Reiss, published by Harper Collins UK / One More Chapter, is a -n historical fiction novel, that gives all the feels, had me intriguied from start till the last page. Drama laden and action packed, twwitsy till the end.
Blurb: 1859. Somerset, England.
When widow Hester Hart decides to sign over all her family’s worldly goods – and their freedom – to a secretive religious community, her daughters, headstrong Ruby and fragile Irene, have little say in the matter.
Led by the charismatic Reverend Peters, the women enter a world with its own set of rules and where Irene, plagued with seizures and ill health, is believed to have second sight. But as Hester and Irene are drawn into the community’s twisted philosophy, Ruby detects a darker truth stalking its shadowy corners.
When a shocking discovery throws the community open to scrutiny, the stakes are raised and Ruby realises that it is not only their souls that must be saved…

[Zandra · Rating 4 out of 5]

I was offered an arc of this book and I am so glad I was, as I possibly wouldn’t have considered this book, and that would have been a big mistake! I was fascinated by it. It was only when I had finished that I discovered it is historical fiction, based on an actual religious sect in Somerset. The characters however are fictional.
The story is set in the mis 1800s. When Hester Hart’s husband dies, she meets Rev Peters and he persuades her to sign over all her worldly possessions to him. In exchange, Hester and her two daughters, Ruby and Irene, move into the walled community. They are free to leave if they so wish, but nobody ever does. Irene has seizures and Rev Peters, the Beloved, believes she has second sight. The story has a few deaths - are they suicide or are they murder? You will need to read the story to find out!
I would like to thank NetGalley, the publishers Harper Collins and Madeleine Reiss for an arc of this exciting book

[Louise Wilson · Rating 4 out of 5]

Ir's 1859, in England where some religions were like being in a cult. They had their own laws and secrets. Hester Hart is a widow who is drawn into a secretive and mysterious community in Somerset. Hester and her daughters, Irene and Ruby, become entangled in intense beliefs, emotional struggles, and hidden agendas. Irene and Ruby are quite different from each other. The community is led by charismatic Reverend Peters. Irene is prone to seizures, Ruby is a determined young woman, she was not keen to join the cult.

The book is loosely based on a true story. It can be quite a devastating read. This book has a slow pace, and it's also quite dark. Some of the actions in the commune were scary, the rules were strict. Irene was believed to have second sight. This is an intriguing read.

Published 13th February 2025

I would like to thank #NetGalley # HarperCollinsUK #OneMoreChapter and the author #MadeleineResis for my ARC of #TheTakingOfIreneHart in exchange for an honest review.

[Colin Bell · Rating 4 out of 5]

I read this book with a touch of morbid fascination. Based loosely upon a cult in Victorian Somerset it tells the story of a widow, Hester, and her two daughters Irene and Ruby. Hester is swayed by the charismatic Reverend Peters and sells her property and gives all her monies to him so that she and her daughters may join the cult. It is difficult to place yourself in that situation, I certainly hope that I wouldn't be taken in by such a way, however it is clear that even today, when people should be better informed, that such cults still exist. It is interesting to see how the story develops, including an abandoned baby and a police constable who is uneasy with the commune. Not really my cup of tea, but I can see that many people would enjoy it and have scored it accordingly.
I received an advance copy of this book from the publisher through Netgalley, however this did not influence my review of the book.

[Hilary · Rating 4 out of 5]

Thanks to the publishers and NetGalley for an ARC.

An historical novel with a message for today. Inspired by the story of a religious cult in 1850s rural Somerset The Taking of Irene Hart follows three women - Hestor and her two daughters Ruby and Irene. Recently widowed Hestor comes under the influence of Rev Peters and signs over her possessions and joins his community, taking the girls with her. Irene has been prone to seizures and Ruby wants to ensure her sisters safety, but headstrong Ruby isn't as under the influence of Rev Peters as her mother. She starts to question what is happening in the community and dares to ask questions. She is helped in this by local policeman Philip who also has questions to ask about what is happening behind the walls of this closed community.
An interesting and thought-provoking read.

[Peter · Rating 4 out of 5]

A fictional tale set in 1859 rural England. A father’s death leads to Hester and Irene being dragged by their mother into a closed community by their mother’s blind infatuation with a charismatic clergy man. We find these characters subsumed into a cult environment. When does that ever have a happy ending? The community is rife with secrets. Will Hester, Irene and their mother regret their decision, especially as Irene is given a special place in the Master’s plans. Thank you to Harper Collins UK, One More Chapter and NetGalley for the ARC. The views expressed are all mine, freely given.

[Kim · Rating 3 out of 5]

Thank you to NetGalley and Harper Collins UK One More Chapter for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

I’m really not sure how to review this one. The premise was intriguing, a historic fiction set in the throes of a religious cult. Somehow I expected a little more though, and while I enjoyed the book I felt a little unsatisfied at the end. It was enjoyable and the characters were well written and the plot was enjoyable but I guess I just expected a little more from the summary. I’m glad I read it and I enjoyed it but it’s not going to be on my highlights reel.

[Elina · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is a dark and heartbreaking story inspired by true events that took place in England in the mid 1850's. It is about a religious cult that manipulates people in grief by taking advantage their religious beliefs with the ultimate goal of complete submission.This ultimately leads to the estrangement of individuals from their family, to bad behavior and sometimes even to suicide.It describes the religious fanaticism and how it can destroy people and human relationships.
This is not a light story but a strong punch that conveys many messages.