What do you think?
Rate this book
Lady Librarian Mystery #2
Once Upon a Murder
Miss Tiffany Woodall must sleuth the slaying of a footman to clear her beloved's name in the second Lady Librarian mystery, in the vein of Deanna Raybourn and perfect for fans of Bridgerton.
1784 England. Officially hired as the librarian for the Duchess of Beaufort, Miss Tiffany Woodall is through with masquerades and murders for good. That is, until she stumbles upon the frozen dead body of former footman Mr. Bernard Coram. The speed with which her peaceful new life is upended is one for the record the justice of the peace immediately declares her the primary suspect in the murder.
As Tiffany hunts for the truth to clear her name, she learns that Bernard got into a fight over a woman at the local pub the night of his death–but he was also overheard blackmailing Samir. The justice of the peace arrests Samir, and Tiffany realizes that her life may have more in common with a tragic play than a light-hearted romance.
With her love locked up in jail and her own reputation on the line, Tiffany must attempt to solve the murder before the book closes on her or Samir’s life.
1784 England. Officially hired as the librarian for the Duchess of Beaufort, Miss Tiffany Woodall is through with masquerades and murders for good. That is, until she stumbles upon the frozen dead body of former footman Mr. Bernard Coram. The speed with which her peaceful new life is upended is one for the record the justice of the peace immediately declares her the primary suspect in the murder.
As Tiffany hunts for the truth to clear her name, she learns that Bernard got into a fight over a woman at the local pub the night of his death–but he was also overheard blackmailing Samir. The justice of the peace arrests Samir, and Tiffany realizes that her life may have more in common with a tragic play than a light-hearted romance.
With her love locked up in jail and her own reputation on the line, Tiffany must attempt to solve the murder before the book closes on her or Samir’s life.
Audiobook
First published February 1, 2024
34 people are currently reading
820 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 216 reviews
February 20, 2024
When the sequel ruins the first book…
I’m going to prefix this by saying I really enjoyed the first book, it was fun and quirky and the heroine was so strong. She took her dire situation into her own hands and triumphed. She found the love of a great man with integrity who supported her throughout. I was extremely excited to read more about these two great characters but alas it was not to be.
In the second book, without revealing spoilers, Tiffany was a meek mouse and Samir was a lying, equally meek, milksop. I envied the dead guy, because I would have loved a knock to the head to forget much of this.
The plot was messy, character details didn’t jive with the first book and the twists and turns were nonsensical much of the time. I ended up disliking both mains at the end and couldn’t care less about their HEA. If ever a second book was not needed it was this book. I am very disappointed.
Thank goodness I had my emotional support buddy reader with me through this traumatic time. ❤️ Dab, we got through this together.
Thanks to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Publishing for providing the copy in exchange for my honest review and sorry for being so very honest.
I’m going to prefix this by saying I really enjoyed the first book, it was fun and quirky and the heroine was so strong. She took her dire situation into her own hands and triumphed. She found the love of a great man with integrity who supported her throughout. I was extremely excited to read more about these two great characters but alas it was not to be.
In the second book, without revealing spoilers, Tiffany was a meek mouse and Samir was a lying, equally meek, milksop. I envied the dead guy, because I would have loved a knock to the head to forget much of this.
The plot was messy, character details didn’t jive with the first book and the twists and turns were nonsensical much of the time. I ended up disliking both mains at the end and couldn’t care less about their HEA. If ever a second book was not needed it was this book. I am very disappointed.
Thank goodness I had my emotional support buddy reader with me through this traumatic time. ❤️ Dab, we got through this together.
Thanks to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Publishing for providing the copy in exchange for my honest review and sorry for being so very honest.
February 11, 2024
Three stars for this one because it did at least try to be a bit different.
Set in 1784 the book has a number of historical references and descriptions of everyday life in a small village. Tiffany Woodall is an interesting character and Samir Lathrop even more so. There is plenty of action, lots of evil characters and some very cute moments with small boys and babies.
I was irritated by Tiffany's weak constitution though. I did a quick check on my Kindle and discovered she mentions cramps 14 times and her stomach 32 times during the book. And it is not a very long book. I doubt if I will look for another in the series.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this book.
Set in 1784 the book has a number of historical references and descriptions of everyday life in a small village. Tiffany Woodall is an interesting character and Samir Lathrop even more so. There is plenty of action, lots of evil characters and some very cute moments with small boys and babies.
I was irritated by Tiffany's weak constitution though. I did a quick check on my Kindle and discovered she mentions cramps 14 times and her stomach 32 times during the book. And it is not a very long book. I doubt if I will look for another in the series.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this book.
August 7, 2023
I wish Tiffany could dress up as her brother and take me back to the first book.
I thought I would love having more time with Tiffany and Samir but this story took all sorts of wrong turns. There are new facts about old characters that make very little sense. Someone sold his wife at a fair, another’s wife left him and went to live with a blacksmith, everyone seems to be everyone’s half-brother, brother-in-law or stepson. Such close connections and scandals would not have been so easily forgotten in a small community.
The worst was ow drama which distracted me so much that I forgot all about the murder mystery. It also confused me because Tiffany and Samir were a delightful couple and deserved a perfect hea. They got it eventually, but I was too tired of this story to fully enjoy it.
I’m giving this book 2,5 stars and rounding it up mostly because of my love for the first one.
Thank you Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley for the chance to read this book in exchange for an honest review.
——
Approved for the arc, buddy reading with Kristina! 🥳🥳🥳
I thought I would love having more time with Tiffany and Samir but this story took all sorts of wrong turns. There are new facts about old characters that make very little sense. Someone sold his wife at a fair, another’s wife left him and went to live with a blacksmith, everyone seems to be everyone’s half-brother, brother-in-law or stepson. Such close connections and scandals would not have been so easily forgotten in a small community.
The worst was ow drama which distracted me so much that I forgot all about the murder mystery. It also confused me because Tiffany and Samir were a delightful couple and deserved a perfect hea. They got it eventually, but I was too tired of this story to fully enjoy it.
I’m giving this book 2,5 stars and rounding it up mostly because of my love for the first one.
Thank you Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley for the chance to read this book in exchange for an honest review.
——
Approved for the arc, buddy reading with Kristina! 🥳🥳🥳
on-hold
February 9, 2024I GOT ANOTHER ARC ????? AND IT IS AN AUDIOBOOK??? ALSO LOOK AT THE COVER :))))
February 26, 2024
3.5 ⭐
I did prefer the first book, but I did enjoy this book a lot! I think its a good sequel, it wraps up nice! A very sweet cozy mystery.
thank you Netgalley for a copy of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review!
I did prefer the first book, but I did enjoy this book a lot! I think its a good sequel, it wraps up nice! A very sweet cozy mystery.
thank you Netgalley for a copy of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review!
February 21, 2024
I absolutely loved Once Upon a Murder! It’s a fabulous historical mystery with such endearing characters. I thoroughly enjoyed A Novel Disguise & this second book in the Lady Librarian Mystery series is even better if possible.
Miss Tiffany Woodall’s a 40 year old spinster who’s also the librarian for the Duchess of Beaufort. She’s intelligent, humorous, and has the brilliant ability to solve mysteries. She fell in love with Mr. Samir Lathrop, a bookseller and local constable when they solved the murder of her brother. When a dead body is found near Tiffany’s cottage, she becomes the prime suspect, but when she’s exonerated Samir is accused. It’s up to Tiffany to solve the mystery & clear Samir’s name.
I loved this Georgian era mystery/romance! Tiffany is such a great character and I loved getting further glimpses into her personality. Though she’s a spinster, she longs for motherhood and a chance at love. I also love Samir and was really thrown for a loop when a secret he’s been hiding is revealed. It threatens his relationship with Tiffany and causes all kinds of chaos. I love the chemistry he has with Tiffany and was hoping there would be a way for them to be together.
The mystery was so good with all kinds of twists and turns. There are a host of suspects and I enjoyed trying to figure out who the murderer was. It’s a race against time and all comes down to a court trial in the last few chapters in the story. While everything was expertly wrapped up with a nice bow, I’m hoping that the series will continue. I thoroughly enjoy these characters and can’t wait to see the next chapter in their lives.
Highly recommend to those who enjoy romantic, closed door, cozy historical mysteries! Though Once Upon a Murder could be read as a standalone, I highly recommend reading A Noble Disguise first. I received an advanced complimentary copy from the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions are my own and voluntarily provided.
Miss Tiffany Woodall’s a 40 year old spinster who’s also the librarian for the Duchess of Beaufort. She’s intelligent, humorous, and has the brilliant ability to solve mysteries. She fell in love with Mr. Samir Lathrop, a bookseller and local constable when they solved the murder of her brother. When a dead body is found near Tiffany’s cottage, she becomes the prime suspect, but when she’s exonerated Samir is accused. It’s up to Tiffany to solve the mystery & clear Samir’s name.
I loved this Georgian era mystery/romance! Tiffany is such a great character and I loved getting further glimpses into her personality. Though she’s a spinster, she longs for motherhood and a chance at love. I also love Samir and was really thrown for a loop when a secret he’s been hiding is revealed. It threatens his relationship with Tiffany and causes all kinds of chaos. I love the chemistry he has with Tiffany and was hoping there would be a way for them to be together.
The mystery was so good with all kinds of twists and turns. There are a host of suspects and I enjoyed trying to figure out who the murderer was. It’s a race against time and all comes down to a court trial in the last few chapters in the story. While everything was expertly wrapped up with a nice bow, I’m hoping that the series will continue. I thoroughly enjoy these characters and can’t wait to see the next chapter in their lives.
Highly recommend to those who enjoy romantic, closed door, cozy historical mysteries! Though Once Upon a Murder could be read as a standalone, I highly recommend reading A Noble Disguise first. I received an advanced complimentary copy from the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions are my own and voluntarily provided.
February 17, 2024
Accused of murder!
Lively, pirate playing governess, forty year old Tiffany Woodall, who’s the librarian for the Duchess of Beaufort is in love with Indian Samir Lathrope. He’s the bookshop owner and constable in the village of Mapledown. Tiffany is also teaching the six year old Duke using unusual and quite joyful methods. I’m in love with her wonderful joie de vivre.
However their relationship is strained when Tiffany becomes the suspect in the murder of ex footman and altogether womaniser Bernard Coram, and Tiffany is arrested.
Not only that Tiffany discovers that Samir has been married for the last ten years. His pregnant wife Evie turns up in the village long enough to have the baby and depart, leaving Tiffany literally holding the baby.
To cap it off, Samir is accused of murdering Bernard. A trial date is set and Tiffany must do all she can to have Samir acquitted.
Interesting fact emerges about how the common folk went about divorcing. The husband would sell his wife at a fair.
A somewhat cozy 1784 Georgian Mystery with heaps of charm and plenty of action.
A Crooked Lane ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
(Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)
Lively, pirate playing governess, forty year old Tiffany Woodall, who’s the librarian for the Duchess of Beaufort is in love with Indian Samir Lathrope. He’s the bookshop owner and constable in the village of Mapledown. Tiffany is also teaching the six year old Duke using unusual and quite joyful methods. I’m in love with her wonderful joie de vivre.
However their relationship is strained when Tiffany becomes the suspect in the murder of ex footman and altogether womaniser Bernard Coram, and Tiffany is arrested.
Not only that Tiffany discovers that Samir has been married for the last ten years. His pregnant wife Evie turns up in the village long enough to have the baby and depart, leaving Tiffany literally holding the baby.
To cap it off, Samir is accused of murdering Bernard. A trial date is set and Tiffany must do all she can to have Samir acquitted.
Interesting fact emerges about how the common folk went about divorcing. The husband would sell his wife at a fair.
A somewhat cozy 1784 Georgian Mystery with heaps of charm and plenty of action.
A Crooked Lane ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
(Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)
August 15, 2023
The second installment of Tiffany's story starts with our main character literally stumbling over a body. That scene is quickly overshadowed by the charming way Tiffany interacts with the child Duke, the son of her employer. I wish those sweet scenes were even more numerous because there are a lot of awkward, abrupt moments in this story.
While it's refreshing to have a historical that isn't set during the 1800s (the Regency and Victorian periods seem almost ubiquitous these days), there are points are incredibly modern that pull you out of the story. Time and again, I kept coming back to "This is 1785?" The author definitely found some historical details they liked and put them in here (shoe pattens, selling your wife at a fair), but there is a lot that feels very modern in this story. As with the first book, there's the insertion of praise for Methodist evangelism that seems shoe-horned in during a wedding.
I wish the author slowed down a bit when it came to character development and writing scenes that should have been emotional. For example, Tiffany professes her love to Samir suddenly, he rejects her just as suddenly, and they continue walking to a destination. She only pauses to react hours later.
While it's refreshing to have a historical that isn't set during the 1800s (the Regency and Victorian periods seem almost ubiquitous these days), there are points are incredibly modern that pull you out of the story. Time and again, I kept coming back to "This is 1785?" The author definitely found some historical details they liked and put them in here (shoe pattens, selling your wife at a fair), but there is a lot that feels very modern in this story. As with the first book, there's the insertion of praise for Methodist evangelism that seems shoe-horned in during a wedding.
I wish the author slowed down a bit when it came to character development and writing scenes that should have been emotional. For example, Tiffany professes her love to Samir suddenly, he rejects her just as suddenly, and they continue walking to a destination. She only pauses to react hours later.
April 21, 2024
*I received an e-arc via Netgalley from the publisher. Thank you for the opportunity to review. All thoughts are my own*
I thoroughly enjoyed this second installment in the Lady Librarian Mystery Series! I liked how Samantha Larsen interwove fairytales, like Little Red Riding Hood, into this Victorian Era story. I recommend reading the first book in the series before diving into this one, as you really get to know the characters and this book jumps into where book one left off.
Tiffany Woodall is such a fun, witty and strong female character! I loved seeing how she, with the help of some friends and allies, attempts to clear her name and that of Samir’s. There were some interesting twists and turns along the way, and I love how everything came together in the end.
Highly recommend!
I thoroughly enjoyed this second installment in the Lady Librarian Mystery Series! I liked how Samantha Larsen interwove fairytales, like Little Red Riding Hood, into this Victorian Era story. I recommend reading the first book in the series before diving into this one, as you really get to know the characters and this book jumps into where book one left off.
Tiffany Woodall is such a fun, witty and strong female character! I loved seeing how she, with the help of some friends and allies, attempts to clear her name and that of Samir’s. There were some interesting twists and turns along the way, and I love how everything came together in the end.
Highly recommend!
September 13, 2023
As much as I liked book 1 in this series, I liked this book 2 even more.
This story is a direct continuation of book 1 and I recommend you read it first. Tiffany is officially the librarian for the duchess and on the way to work stumbles on a dead body laying in front of her cottage. This event precipitates everything going wrong for her and also Samir.
I liked everything about this book: the clever writing; the stable, steady romance between the main characters: the mystery and the way Tiffany solved: the village life and villagers; the Duchess and her household. Excellent series!
I received a copy from the publisher via NetGalley and this is my honest opinion.
This story is a direct continuation of book 1 and I recommend you read it first. Tiffany is officially the librarian for the duchess and on the way to work stumbles on a dead body laying in front of her cottage. This event precipitates everything going wrong for her and also Samir.
I liked everything about this book: the clever writing; the stable, steady romance between the main characters: the mystery and the way Tiffany solved: the village life and villagers; the Duchess and her household. Excellent series!
I received a copy from the publisher via NetGalley and this is my honest opinion.
June 21, 2025
Dollycas’s Thoughts
The Duchess of Beaufort has formally hired Miss Tiffany Woodall as her head librarian, meaning the woman can be herself and leave her disguises behind. Miss Tiffany is also teaching 6-year-old Duke of Beaufort (Beau) until a proper governess can be found.
As she leaves her home, Bristle Cottage, to go to Astwell Palace, she trips over the body of a dead man, half covered in the snow. She recognizes that it’s Mr. Bernard Coram, a former footman at the palace. Found in front of her home, she is named the prime suspect by the justice of the peace. In an effort to clear her name, she learns that on the night of his death, Mr. Coram was involved in a fight at the local pub, but also that he was blackmailing the love of her life, local bookseller and constable, Samir Lathrop. Soon, it is Samir who is arrested. Tiffany is going to need all the help she can get to prove his innocence. A new arrival in town adds to the drama. The Lady Librarian has her hands full. Can she find the real killer? Or will Samir hang for a crime he didn’t commit?
Like in the first book of this series, A Novel Disguise, Ms. Larsen’s characters come alive within these pages. They are diverse, coming from all classes, and Miss Tiffany Woodall interacts with them all. She beams as she teaches her young charge, really making learning fun. She is comfortable in her new position, and a new friendship blooms when she needs a friend most. She thought she knew where her relationship with Samir was going, but new developments, and he being accused of murder, could mean she may never get her happy ever after.
I really enjoyed the author’s descriptive writing style, especially when Tiffany, her friend Thomas, and others traveled around the countryside trying to find the answers they needed. It’s always great to have a friend with power and the right connections to help move investigations along. Through the author’s words, I felt that I was right on the scene, whether it be at the palace, in the kitchen or library, the church, the pub in town, or the blacksmith shop in a town up the road.
I loved the way Tiffany fostered young Beau’s love for books. The palace library was “sadly lacking in children’s literature,” and she was determined to fix that by adding several books, including fairy tales. They were reading Gulliver’s Travels, complete with dressing up as pirates with swords to search for hidden treasure and with mathematical pirates’ problems to solve.
Ms. Larsen packs a lot into this well-plotted and well-written book. It is filled with twists and turns, a very satisfying reckoning, and a delightful final chapter and epilogue.
What we didn’t know when this book was released was if there would be a book 3. I can now report that there is, but the release is unique in that A Poetic Pox is being released first as an audiobook/CD on July 22, 2025, and will be released in other formats a few months later.
Once Upon a Murder is a captivating and entertaining story filled with a smart and loyal protagonist, a motley cast of supporting characters all caught up in an intriguing mystery, that includes the perfect amounts of romance and humor. To enjoy this book to the fullest, I believe you have to read A Novel Disguise first, as Once Upon a Murder picks up right where it leaves off. Then you will be ready when A Poetic Pox hits stores.
I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. Thank you to Crooked Lane Booksand NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
The Duchess of Beaufort has formally hired Miss Tiffany Woodall as her head librarian, meaning the woman can be herself and leave her disguises behind. Miss Tiffany is also teaching 6-year-old Duke of Beaufort (Beau) until a proper governess can be found.
As she leaves her home, Bristle Cottage, to go to Astwell Palace, she trips over the body of a dead man, half covered in the snow. She recognizes that it’s Mr. Bernard Coram, a former footman at the palace. Found in front of her home, she is named the prime suspect by the justice of the peace. In an effort to clear her name, she learns that on the night of his death, Mr. Coram was involved in a fight at the local pub, but also that he was blackmailing the love of her life, local bookseller and constable, Samir Lathrop. Soon, it is Samir who is arrested. Tiffany is going to need all the help she can get to prove his innocence. A new arrival in town adds to the drama. The Lady Librarian has her hands full. Can she find the real killer? Or will Samir hang for a crime he didn’t commit?
Like in the first book of this series, A Novel Disguise, Ms. Larsen’s characters come alive within these pages. They are diverse, coming from all classes, and Miss Tiffany Woodall interacts with them all. She beams as she teaches her young charge, really making learning fun. She is comfortable in her new position, and a new friendship blooms when she needs a friend most. She thought she knew where her relationship with Samir was going, but new developments, and he being accused of murder, could mean she may never get her happy ever after.
I really enjoyed the author’s descriptive writing style, especially when Tiffany, her friend Thomas, and others traveled around the countryside trying to find the answers they needed. It’s always great to have a friend with power and the right connections to help move investigations along. Through the author’s words, I felt that I was right on the scene, whether it be at the palace, in the kitchen or library, the church, the pub in town, or the blacksmith shop in a town up the road.
I loved the way Tiffany fostered young Beau’s love for books. The palace library was “sadly lacking in children’s literature,” and she was determined to fix that by adding several books, including fairy tales. They were reading Gulliver’s Travels, complete with dressing up as pirates with swords to search for hidden treasure and with mathematical pirates’ problems to solve.
Ms. Larsen packs a lot into this well-plotted and well-written book. It is filled with twists and turns, a very satisfying reckoning, and a delightful final chapter and epilogue.
What we didn’t know when this book was released was if there would be a book 3. I can now report that there is, but the release is unique in that A Poetic Pox is being released first as an audiobook/CD on July 22, 2025, and will be released in other formats a few months later.
Once Upon a Murder is a captivating and entertaining story filled with a smart and loyal protagonist, a motley cast of supporting characters all caught up in an intriguing mystery, that includes the perfect amounts of romance and humor. To enjoy this book to the fullest, I believe you have to read A Novel Disguise first, as Once Upon a Murder picks up right where it leaves off. Then you will be ready when A Poetic Pox hits stores.
I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. Thank you to Crooked Lane Booksand NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
February 20, 2024
The second installment in the Lady Librarian Mysteries is divine. I loved the mash-up of so many fairytales in this Victorian setting, but most especially Little Red Riding Hood.
Miss Tiffany Woodall finds a dead body in front of her cottage and takes it upon herself, along with her crew of unlikely friends, to solve this mystery. I feel it’s important to read the first book in the series to get a feel for the relationships, as many revelations come to light throughout these pages. The connections are powerful and what solidified my attention to this book.
It was enjoyable to see this strong female lead cast aside the social norms of this time, while indulging in her deepest desires. The layers of the mystery were peeled off like layers of an onion, giving way to new clues and insights that gave this tale a fresh, crisp, competent feel and was very engaging. I love how everything came together and in such sweet, twisty, and surprising ways.
Content/TW with POSSIBLE SPOILERS:
*I received a complimentary copy through Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own and were voluntarily given.*
Miss Tiffany Woodall finds a dead body in front of her cottage and takes it upon herself, along with her crew of unlikely friends, to solve this mystery. I feel it’s important to read the first book in the series to get a feel for the relationships, as many revelations come to light throughout these pages. The connections are powerful and what solidified my attention to this book.
It was enjoyable to see this strong female lead cast aside the social norms of this time, while indulging in her deepest desires. The layers of the mystery were peeled off like layers of an onion, giving way to new clues and insights that gave this tale a fresh, crisp, competent feel and was very engaging. I love how everything came together and in such sweet, twisty, and surprising ways.
Content/TW with POSSIBLE SPOILERS:
*I received a complimentary copy through Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own and were voluntarily given.*
January 17, 2024
Reasons to read:
- Murder Mystery
- Romance between older characters (FMC is 40/ MC is 35)
- Fun, twisty plot
- Diverse cast of characters
𝐂𝐨𝐧𝐭𝐞𝐧𝐭 :
Romance: Closed-Door
Trigger warning: light violence, murder, past r*pe of a secondary character, graphic childbirth, racism, abuse
𝐌𝐲 𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬:
Once Upon A Murder feels like a new-age, satirical murder mystery film, with a feminist nod. A Whodunit, with a strong cast of characters, with even stronger motives to kill.
Let me begin by saying I loved so many parts of this book! After the previous installment, Tiffany’s life seemed to be coming together, with her ownership of a cottage, new position as a librarian, and budding romance with the town law enforcer/bookseller, Samir. Her life is suddenly thrown for a loop with the murder of a person with many enemies, including herself.
The strength of this book is the characters. It’s so unique, with its diverse cast! I love Tiffany and her intelligent, but innocent nature. This combination made for many funny situations. Her determination to find answers and forge ahead, was to be admired, especially when it came to solving a complex murder and clearing others of suspension. The returning cast added to the plot and development of the case; it was an added plus to see them again.
This story discussed many difficult topics such as racism, abuse, violence, and assault in a respectful way. It added a certain realism to the story that many historical romances do not explore. I enjoyed the historical notes and the flow of the story.
I will say, that I am uncertain how I felt about the author's decision to describe things that happen to the female body in a slightly graphic way. I applaud her for adding in those parts (especially since they also added a level of comedy and helped show/develop Tiffany’s character), but also am not used to reading about them in novels. So if you are squeamish, you may want to skip ahead.
All in all, I would love to read another installment in the Lady Librarian series!
*I received a complimentary copy of this book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
- Murder Mystery
- Romance between older characters (FMC is 40/ MC is 35)
- Fun, twisty plot
- Diverse cast of characters
𝐂𝐨𝐧𝐭𝐞𝐧𝐭 :
Romance: Closed-Door
Trigger warning: light violence, murder, past r*pe of a secondary character, graphic childbirth, racism, abuse
𝐌𝐲 𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬:
Once Upon A Murder feels like a new-age, satirical murder mystery film, with a feminist nod. A Whodunit, with a strong cast of characters, with even stronger motives to kill.
Let me begin by saying I loved so many parts of this book! After the previous installment, Tiffany’s life seemed to be coming together, with her ownership of a cottage, new position as a librarian, and budding romance with the town law enforcer/bookseller, Samir. Her life is suddenly thrown for a loop with the murder of a person with many enemies, including herself.
The strength of this book is the characters. It’s so unique, with its diverse cast! I love Tiffany and her intelligent, but innocent nature. This combination made for many funny situations. Her determination to find answers and forge ahead, was to be admired, especially when it came to solving a complex murder and clearing others of suspension. The returning cast added to the plot and development of the case; it was an added plus to see them again.
This story discussed many difficult topics such as racism, abuse, violence, and assault in a respectful way. It added a certain realism to the story that many historical romances do not explore. I enjoyed the historical notes and the flow of the story.
I will say, that I am uncertain how I felt about the author's decision to describe things that happen to the female body in a slightly graphic way. I applaud her for adding in those parts (especially since they also added a level of comedy and helped show/develop Tiffany’s character), but also am not used to reading about them in novels. So if you are squeamish, you may want to skip ahead.
All in all, I would love to read another installment in the Lady Librarian series!
*I received a complimentary copy of this book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
August 26, 2025
Wonderful series. Highly recommend!
November 25, 2023
I'm loving these Lady Librarian Mysteries! This is book two and I would really suggest reading the first book, A Novel Disguise, before diving into this one.
Tiffany Woodall was such a fun character in the first book. I loved her tenacity and doing what she needed to do to survive. She has a sharp mind and is a person that most everyone around her is able to befriend and relate to.
She's back with a new mystery to solve. Another dead body, this time found outside her small cottage. But when her name and other's names are in the running for the prime murder suspect, she's going to need all of her wits and then some to clear everyone's names.
I loved the twists and turns and the piecing together of all the clues. I love a well written murder mystery, especially if I can't quite figure out it too quickly and this one kept me guessing and guessing again pretty close to the end.
There's a sweet underlying theme of family which really made me smile and melted my heart in some scenes!
Now I'm ready for more, but I'll just have to be patient as this second book doesn't release until February 2024. But you better believe I'll be jumping on the chance to read more of Miss Tiffany Woodall, Lady Librarian, amateur sleuth!
Content: There is a murder and a couple attacks but everything was written in a non graphic way. There is a character who has had a baby with someone other than her spouse (does not go into detail, written in a sensitive manner). There is a love story with nothing more than a couple kisses. I consider this one to be a clean read.
I received a copy from the publisher, Crooked Lane Books, via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions in the review are my own.
Happy Reading!!!
Tiffany Woodall was such a fun character in the first book. I loved her tenacity and doing what she needed to do to survive. She has a sharp mind and is a person that most everyone around her is able to befriend and relate to.
She's back with a new mystery to solve. Another dead body, this time found outside her small cottage. But when her name and other's names are in the running for the prime murder suspect, she's going to need all of her wits and then some to clear everyone's names.
I loved the twists and turns and the piecing together of all the clues. I love a well written murder mystery, especially if I can't quite figure out it too quickly and this one kept me guessing and guessing again pretty close to the end.
There's a sweet underlying theme of family which really made me smile and melted my heart in some scenes!
Now I'm ready for more, but I'll just have to be patient as this second book doesn't release until February 2024. But you better believe I'll be jumping on the chance to read more of Miss Tiffany Woodall, Lady Librarian, amateur sleuth!
Content: There is a murder and a couple attacks but everything was written in a non graphic way. There is a character who has had a baby with someone other than her spouse (does not go into detail, written in a sensitive manner). There is a love story with nothing more than a couple kisses. I consider this one to be a clean read.
I received a copy from the publisher, Crooked Lane Books, via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions in the review are my own.
Happy Reading!!!
February 24, 2024
This is another wonderful book from one of my favorite authors. Larsen sets the perfect tone for this historical cozy mystery. And i am loving this series.
My favorite librarian, Tiffany Woodall, is back, as well as Samir, Thomas, Mary, Catharine and sweet Beau. (The interactions with him and Tiffany were so enjoyable and enduring). Many in the town are harboring secrets and have something to hide regarding the death of Bernard Coram and I loved trying to sort out the whodunit. It’s a race to catch the killer as someone who Tiffany holds dear is wrongly accused.
The mystery had me guessing and there many twists I wasn’t expecting. I am hoping for another book in this enjoyable series.
I received a copy from the author and a Netgalley link. All views and opinions are my own.
My favorite librarian, Tiffany Woodall, is back, as well as Samir, Thomas, Mary, Catharine and sweet Beau. (The interactions with him and Tiffany were so enjoyable and enduring). Many in the town are harboring secrets and have something to hide regarding the death of Bernard Coram and I loved trying to sort out the whodunit. It’s a race to catch the killer as someone who Tiffany holds dear is wrongly accused.
The mystery had me guessing and there many twists I wasn’t expecting. I am hoping for another book in this enjoyable series.
I received a copy from the author and a Netgalley link. All views and opinions are my own.
December 16, 2023
I’m not entirely familiar with what entails a cozy mystery, but if I had to guess, it would be a read like this as that is exactly what it felt like. A historical cozy mystery. Set in the late 1700s, our main FMC Tiffany finds a body outside of her cottage. Someone has been murdered. Thus ensues a lot of finger pointing among the town, resulting in her lover being taken in as the culprit simply because he is of color and foreigner, therefore he must be the murderer right? So Tiffany tries her best to find the real murderer, which in the process uncovers a lot of secrets, and tries to get Samir released from the jail for a crime he very much did not commit. I did appreciate that— especially given the time period— she was like shame on you for being racist to the people who were like yeah Samir should hang for this, even if they knew he wasn’t the one who did it.
From this you’re probably like, what cozy about this? Well it was a nice read to just sit back and relax to and read as Tiffany brambles about town uncovering secrets and figuring out what happened to the dead man. Plus there is a baby, and a happily ever after for our dear spinster.
Thank you NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for the early copy!
From this you’re probably like, what cozy about this? Well it was a nice read to just sit back and relax to and read as Tiffany brambles about town uncovering secrets and figuring out what happened to the dead man. Plus there is a baby, and a happily ever after for our dear spinster.
Thank you NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for the early copy!
April 19, 2024
This book was a disappointment. I really enjoyed the premise of the first book- it was much cleverer. This one had the same beating over the head of the progressive ideology, but without a good plot, so it wasn’t enjoyable. The only good thing about it was that it was really short.
One of my frustrations with much historical fiction written today is that authors make almost zero attempt( or so it seems) to understand the worldview of the common people of the time. Often the themes are superimposed modern worldviews that make no sense for the time period. Why even write a book set in that time period then? It seems like Larson wrote this book to show just how backwards people of the 1700’s were. This kind of huge stroke of certain time periods really bothers me because it fails to consider CONTEXT and the GOOD about the time period. Often authors have either a solely negative or romanticize version of
Historical time periods.
I also found her repetition of certain things really annoying (her cycle, her love for Samir, how badly women are treated, etc). Larson isn’t one for subtlety.
One of my frustrations with much historical fiction written today is that authors make almost zero attempt( or so it seems) to understand the worldview of the common people of the time. Often the themes are superimposed modern worldviews that make no sense for the time period. Why even write a book set in that time period then? It seems like Larson wrote this book to show just how backwards people of the 1700’s were. This kind of huge stroke of certain time periods really bothers me because it fails to consider CONTEXT and the GOOD about the time period. Often authors have either a solely negative or romanticize version of
Historical time periods.
I also found her repetition of certain things really annoying (her cycle, her love for Samir, how badly women are treated, etc). Larson isn’t one for subtlety.
March 1, 2024
I was so excited about the release of Book two in the 'A Lady Librarian Mystery Series'. Librarian Miss Tiffany Woodall returns with her books, inquisitive nature, and affection for bookseller, Samir.
The story opens as Tiffany, who's rushing to work, stumbles over a corpse hidden in the snow. She begins a quest to uncover the murderer and the reason behind the body's appearance at her doorstep. Tiffany finds herself accused of the crime, alongside Samir, and several others in the village. A skilled sleuth, Tiffany meticulously gathers clues around the village, keeping readers thoroughly engaged as they piece clues together along with the Lady Librarian.
A remarkable character I loved is the Duchess of Beaufort, whose strength, wisdom, and kindness deeply impressed Tiffany with the Duchess offering invaluable support and true friendship. Tiffany's own intelligence, resilience, and determination are admirable traits shown throughout the novel. The relationship between Tiffany and Samir is tested by uncertainties, making them question trust and loyalty. The novel has serious themes including murder, abuse, racism, extramarital affairs, and a past sexual assault that is linked to the murder, also there are mildly descriptive scenes of childbirth.
I caution you to read book one in the series first, to fully grasp the characters' motivations in the second book. So readers, brace yourself for unexpected twists, interesting personalities, themes of family bonds, and of course a touch of romance.
The story opens as Tiffany, who's rushing to work, stumbles over a corpse hidden in the snow. She begins a quest to uncover the murderer and the reason behind the body's appearance at her doorstep. Tiffany finds herself accused of the crime, alongside Samir, and several others in the village. A skilled sleuth, Tiffany meticulously gathers clues around the village, keeping readers thoroughly engaged as they piece clues together along with the Lady Librarian.
A remarkable character I loved is the Duchess of Beaufort, whose strength, wisdom, and kindness deeply impressed Tiffany with the Duchess offering invaluable support and true friendship. Tiffany's own intelligence, resilience, and determination are admirable traits shown throughout the novel. The relationship between Tiffany and Samir is tested by uncertainties, making them question trust and loyalty. The novel has serious themes including murder, abuse, racism, extramarital affairs, and a past sexual assault that is linked to the murder, also there are mildly descriptive scenes of childbirth.
I caution you to read book one in the series first, to fully grasp the characters' motivations in the second book. So readers, brace yourself for unexpected twists, interesting personalities, themes of family bonds, and of course a touch of romance.
March 8, 2024
At first I found the voices from the narrator over the top and silly. The Heroine Tiffany seemed immature and like she was feeling sorry for herself because she was a forty year old spinster. Gradually, the story grew on me voices and all.
While Tiffany did annoy me in the beginning I love how big her heart is and how she cares for everyone around her. I enjoyed the romance budding between her and the Constable Samir and how they handles the challenges thrown at them.
This story has a diverse cast of colorful characters set in a small Georgian era town. It was pretty well researched and I enjoyed the historical fiction aspects.
The murder mystery aspect was well thought out and planned This story is worth the read and I enjoyed it.
Thank you to Netgalley and Dreamscape Media for this audiobook. All views are expressed are my own.
While Tiffany did annoy me in the beginning I love how big her heart is and how she cares for everyone around her. I enjoyed the romance budding between her and the Constable Samir and how they handles the challenges thrown at them.
This story has a diverse cast of colorful characters set in a small Georgian era town. It was pretty well researched and I enjoyed the historical fiction aspects.
The murder mystery aspect was well thought out and planned This story is worth the read and I enjoyed it.
Thank you to Netgalley and Dreamscape Media for this audiobook. All views are expressed are my own.
January 14, 2024
Such an emotional Lady Librarian Mystery. And filled with so much love, be it romantic, familial, friendship, or found family. Tiffany literally has a body dropped on her doorstep, which causes a ripple effect of unimaginable proportions. I also found the mystery to be sharp and smart, and it kept me guessing.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
February 19, 2024
A good balance of Regency romance and historical mystery, I enjoyed this solid mystery and rooted for the characters
Recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this ARC, all opinions are mine
Recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this ARC, all opinions are mine
October 25, 2023
This was such a fun and cosy read! I really enjoyed my time reading this.
This book is part two in the A Lady Librarian Mystery series, but it is not you do not have to read the first book in order to be able to understand and enjoy this one! Believe me, all you need to know about the characters is in the book.
Talking about the characters, I thought they were fun and sweet, I loved the diversity of the characters. The relationship between Tiffany and Samir was so sweet and beautiful. It made me not want to put the book down.
The reason why I gave this book 4 stars instead of five has to do with this relationship though in some way, because I feel like the story focuses more on the relationship between these two and the little side stories instead of actually solving the murder. The murder gets solved quite quickly in the end, so it makes me feel like it was not supposed to be the main subject of the book, yet it is marketed that way.
This book is part two in the A Lady Librarian Mystery series, but it is not you do not have to read the first book in order to be able to understand and enjoy this one! Believe me, all you need to know about the characters is in the book.
Talking about the characters, I thought they were fun and sweet, I loved the diversity of the characters. The relationship between Tiffany and Samir was so sweet and beautiful. It made me not want to put the book down.
The reason why I gave this book 4 stars instead of five has to do with this relationship though in some way, because I feel like the story focuses more on the relationship between these two and the little side stories instead of actually solving the murder. The murder gets solved quite quickly in the end, so it makes me feel like it was not supposed to be the main subject of the book, yet it is marketed that way.
September 10, 2023
Tiffany is fully engulfed in a second murder mystery with very personal implications.
This is a fun story despite the subject matter. Tiffany is forced to figure out a second murder, this time to save Samir. She is able to find friends in unexpected places and piece together what is going on in her little part of the world. There are things that she would rather not know and she finds unique ways of finding the truth, especially given the prejudices of the society around her.
This story is well written with a bit of a comedic yet dramatic bent. It feels like a genuine who dunnit while set in a more proper time and place. Tiffany and Samir must work together to figure out the truth, while at the same time facing new information and challenges. I enjoyed the story and found it very satisfying from beginning to end.
I received an early copy through NetGalley and this is my honest review,
This is a fun story despite the subject matter. Tiffany is forced to figure out a second murder, this time to save Samir. She is able to find friends in unexpected places and piece together what is going on in her little part of the world. There are things that she would rather not know and she finds unique ways of finding the truth, especially given the prejudices of the society around her.
This story is well written with a bit of a comedic yet dramatic bent. It feels like a genuine who dunnit while set in a more proper time and place. Tiffany and Samir must work together to figure out the truth, while at the same time facing new information and challenges. I enjoyed the story and found it very satisfying from beginning to end.
I received an early copy through NetGalley and this is my honest review,
November 23, 2023
1785. The body of disliked ex-footman Bernard Coram is discovered by Tiffany Woodall outside her cottage. Eventually the man she loves is arrested for the murder. Can she find the real murderer.
A cozy historical romance and mystery but I did not find the two main characters particularly interesting. Maybe it would have been better to have read the first book in the series.
An ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
A cozy historical romance and mystery but I did not find the two main characters particularly interesting. Maybe it would have been better to have read the first book in the series.
An ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
May 12, 2025
A lot of stars more for the fact that this book made me have feelings than for the actual storyline. I feel you should always give due credit when a book makes you feel things. I was absolutely irate most of the book as I sorted through the injustice of women's rights back long ago and how far we still have to go today. The storyline itself was very "To Kill a Mockingbird" reminiscent but I still really enjoyed it all.
March 14, 2024
The mystery is good, but everything else . . . Not so much. Uneven pacing, poor character development, the dialogue?? Seriously, the dialogue takes you right out of the story. Sometimes, the author attempts dialogue in the manner of the late 18th century, but most of the time, there is no attempt at authenticity. Why bother setting the story in that era then?
February 26, 2024
*I received a copy of this book on NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for this opportunity*
In the second installment of the Lady Librarian Mystery series, our heroine Miss Tiffany Woodall-- no longer forced to dress and act as her older brother-- literally stumbles across a the body of someone familiar dumped right outside her cottage. Forced once again to solve a mystery to clear her own name (and the name of those she's fond of), Tiffany has to balance her growing responsibilities as librarian for the Duchess of Beaufort and her deepening affection for a certain Mr. Samir Lathrop with the mystery at hand.
I loved the first book of this series, and there was so much I loved about its sequel! Set in the 1700s, I particularly appreciated Tiffany's desire to explore more traditional female roles. (Here me out! I promise I'm not anti-feminism!) While I am 250% for female representation in all types of roles and forms of media, it was nice to read about a character that wants to raise a child and (in the vein of Bridergton Season 1) who discovers more about her body throughout the story (albeit in a child-birthing manner rather than sexual) which would have been accurate for the time period. Tiffany is a different sort of female character than most written about today, and I think her desires and goals should be just as celebrated.
However, while the mystery was fun and the characters weirdly interconnected, I feel like some of the main characters strayed a little too far from their characterizations in the first book. I found myself frankly shocked at one character's secret marriage, another's blatant (and out of character) racism, and Tiffany's loss of gumption. It felt as though Larsen had an idea of how she wanted the mystery to end and, rather than working with the lovely characters she had, she twisted them to fit her needs.
While I still enjoyed the story, and the epilogue absolutely stole my heart, I found myself wishing some things had played out a little bit differently.
In the second installment of the Lady Librarian Mystery series, our heroine Miss Tiffany Woodall-- no longer forced to dress and act as her older brother-- literally stumbles across a the body of someone familiar dumped right outside her cottage. Forced once again to solve a mystery to clear her own name (and the name of those she's fond of), Tiffany has to balance her growing responsibilities as librarian for the Duchess of Beaufort and her deepening affection for a certain Mr. Samir Lathrop with the mystery at hand.
I loved the first book of this series, and there was so much I loved about its sequel! Set in the 1700s, I particularly appreciated Tiffany's desire to explore more traditional female roles. (Here me out! I promise I'm not anti-feminism!) While I am 250% for female representation in all types of roles and forms of media, it was nice to read about a character that wants to raise a child and (in the vein of Bridergton Season 1) who discovers more about her body throughout the story (albeit in a child-birthing manner rather than sexual) which would have been accurate for the time period. Tiffany is a different sort of female character than most written about today, and I think her desires and goals should be just as celebrated.
However, while the mystery was fun and the characters weirdly interconnected, I feel like some of the main characters strayed a little too far from their characterizations in the first book. I found myself frankly shocked at one character's secret marriage, another's blatant (and out of character) racism, and Tiffany's loss of gumption. It felt as though Larsen had an idea of how she wanted the mystery to end and, rather than working with the lovely characters she had, she twisted them to fit her needs.
While I still enjoyed the story, and the epilogue absolutely stole my heart, I found myself wishing some things had played out a little bit differently.
March 24, 2024
I read this book in ONE day. 🧩❤️
Rating: 4.5 ⭐
Thank you Samantha Larsen, Crooked Lane, and NetGalley for the gifted e-ARC in exchange for this honest review!
PUB DATE: 20 Feb 2024
Samantha Larsen does it again! This series is 2-for-2 in reads I devour within 24 hours. One of my comfort-premises these days is “Strong, Resourceful Woman Solves Crimes in a Historical Time.” And Larsen takes us to 18th-century England, a time period I don’t often find myself in. Even better, she ensures a level of diversity within her cast that I think historical fiction tends to lack, but Larsen proves WITH RECEIPTS at the end of the book how and why diversity and historical settings are not universally exclusive elements.
I really love how our amateur sleuth, Tiffany, gains confidence in her independence as she finds her place in the community her half-brother’s controlling oppression was withholding from her prior to his death in book 1. She also continues to face challenges to her own morality and sense of justice surrounding serious issues: domestic violence and SA, prejudice and racism, and sexism. I have so much respect for an author who can juggle serious topics in a compelling murder mystery. This is a MUST read for historical mystery lovers!!
- SYNOPSIS -
“Miss Tiffany Woodall must sleuth the slaying of a footman to clear her beloved’s name in the second Lady Librarian mystery, in the vein of Deanna Raybourn and perfect for fans of Bridgerton.
1784 England. Officially hired as the librarian for the Duchess of Beaufort, Miss Tiffany Woodall is through with masquerades and murders for good. That is, until she stumbles upon the frozen dead body of former footman Mr. Bernard Coram. The speed with which her peaceful new life is upended is one for the record; the justice of the peace immediately declares her the primary suspect in the murder...”
Rating: 4.5 ⭐
Thank you Samantha Larsen, Crooked Lane, and NetGalley for the gifted e-ARC in exchange for this honest review!
PUB DATE: 20 Feb 2024
Samantha Larsen does it again! This series is 2-for-2 in reads I devour within 24 hours. One of my comfort-premises these days is “Strong, Resourceful Woman Solves Crimes in a Historical Time.” And Larsen takes us to 18th-century England, a time period I don’t often find myself in. Even better, she ensures a level of diversity within her cast that I think historical fiction tends to lack, but Larsen proves WITH RECEIPTS at the end of the book how and why diversity and historical settings are not universally exclusive elements.
I really love how our amateur sleuth, Tiffany, gains confidence in her independence as she finds her place in the community her half-brother’s controlling oppression was withholding from her prior to his death in book 1. She also continues to face challenges to her own morality and sense of justice surrounding serious issues: domestic violence and SA, prejudice and racism, and sexism. I have so much respect for an author who can juggle serious topics in a compelling murder mystery. This is a MUST read for historical mystery lovers!!
- SYNOPSIS -
“Miss Tiffany Woodall must sleuth the slaying of a footman to clear her beloved’s name in the second Lady Librarian mystery, in the vein of Deanna Raybourn and perfect for fans of Bridgerton.
1784 England. Officially hired as the librarian for the Duchess of Beaufort, Miss Tiffany Woodall is through with masquerades and murders for good. That is, until she stumbles upon the frozen dead body of former footman Mr. Bernard Coram. The speed with which her peaceful new life is upended is one for the record; the justice of the peace immediately declares her the primary suspect in the murder...”
November 3, 2025
I'm afraid this was quite bad in more ways than one. The biggest one for me being the author's afterschool special approach to writing a male lead of color in a historical fiction novel. I'm morbidly curious exactly how many mentions of "color of his skin," "skin color," "brown skin," "dark skin," and other variations there are in the book and am absolutely persuaded that if one were to drink at each mention one would not make it through the end of the book alive. The constant references to Samir's skin color are both grating and jarringly ahistorical: At one point the main character wishes that Samir would be judged by the "content of his character" instead of the color of his skin—ma'am, why do you have a white lady in 1784 paraphrasing MLK Jr, and misappropriating his words to boot?
I want to appreciate the author's effort to introduce more diversity into the genre and educate readers that brown and Black people did exist and even thrive in Georgian England, but...wow, this really doesn't seem like how to do it. Things are not helped by the equally frequent signposting from the female characters about how hard it is for them to be a woman in their time and place.
The mystery was unsatisfying, the male and female leads went from feisty and smoldering in book one to simpering and sadly uncompelling in the sequel, and the story was both unbelievable and uninteresting. The first book was flawed but entertaining; this installment needed both much more time in the incubator and a firmer editorial hand.
I want to appreciate the author's effort to introduce more diversity into the genre and educate readers that brown and Black people did exist and even thrive in Georgian England, but...wow, this really doesn't seem like how to do it. Things are not helped by the equally frequent signposting from the female characters about how hard it is for them to be a woman in their time and place.
The mystery was unsatisfying, the male and female leads went from feisty and smoldering in book one to simpering and sadly uncompelling in the sequel, and the story was both unbelievable and uninteresting. The first book was flawed but entertaining; this installment needed both much more time in the incubator and a firmer editorial hand.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 216 reviews