I'm just speaking from experience / Nothing can compare to your first true love / So I hope this will remind you / When it's for real, it's forever (Don’t Forget About Us – Mariah Carey).
Whenever I start a manga, nowadays I'm only ever really looking for these few things: is it gay, lovely, and… oh yeah, is it so cute that it rips my heart out in the process. That’s not too much to ask for, is it? Yeah, I think I've gotten a little spoiled whenever it comes to queer stories recently because back in the days of yore, I was just happy when a manga didn't include a harmful gay stereotype! I love Dragon Ball, I really do, but there's some awful imagery in there, I can't lie. I'm mostly kidding, I'm well aware that my checklist is not an easy hurdle to clear, and yet here we are with another awesome manga that clears it. Cool! In fact, I’m starting to think that this incredible run of manga that I’ve had for the last couple of months is the result of some kind of blessing, like a spirit of gayness cast “Abracadabra, amor-oo-na-na, Abracadabra, morta-oo-ga-ga, Abracadabra, abra-oo-na-na all the gay manga you’ll read this year are going to be your new favorites!" on me. wow! Thanks spirit of gayness, and thanks Lady Gaga!! Speaking of gayness, this manga is actually very similar to both I Hear the Sunspot by Yuki Fumino and My Summer of You by Nagisa Furuya in that they all feature the lovely pairing between the “super cool, attractive” guy and the “hyperactive and loud, yet kind and sweet” dude. At this point it’s a classic dynamic, really, and I get it, you know? Contrasts are always striking, and it's a good show of shorthand that gets the audience on board right away with minimal exposition while also giving us a comforting sense of familiarity with the characters. Though I will say that it does beg the question if all of these manga artists have also grown up on Naruto the same way I did and felt robbed when it ended without Naruto and Sasuke getting together? I don’t know, probably not… but on the other hand… why not? Why shouldn't I just add that my core belief system anyway. I mean, to this day I've never actually finished Naruto because it started sucking ass even outside of all the queerbaiting, but I do know that the ending was awful. Not Game of Thrones season eight level of trash, but bad enough to the point where I don't list it among my favorites even though it was my first experience in realizing how amazing a story could have been had it just been queer.
Anyway, anyway, anyway, in this gay and lovely story that's so cute it ripped my heart out in the process, we follow the gay shenanigans of Yamato, who is apparently the most handsome on the planet (no really, literally everybody in this manga says so at every given opportunity) as he tries desperately to communicate to his childhood bestie, Kakeru, that he’s hopelessly in love with him. It’s nice and simple, and while I could see how this push-and-pull could get a little tiresome after a while, I think I give a lot of leeway to these characters because they’re clearly portrayed as not yet having come to terms with their sexuality. Sure, I think it's fun to laugh at oblivious characters every now and then, but I’m also acutely aware that there’s a different underlying subtext hidden there when writing queer characters, as queer folk can't be as “out in the open” as their peers. Not everyone has the luxury of being forthcoming and freewheeling with their feelings. So yeah, I keep saying this, but I can't seem to get over just how good I Cannot Reach You really was! I mean, I hope I'm not overselling things, because it's important for you to know that nothing here is actually all that unique, but that didn't dull my enjoyment at all! Not everything needs to be subversive in order to capture my attention. Besides, at least this manga does exactly what it said it on the tin. You know, because it’s called “I Can’t Reach You,” I almost figured the story would get real melancholic with it, something tragic happening or whatever, but... nah, it turns out Yamato literally can’t reach Kakeru because he’s just so damn clueless! Who would have thought? I was watching this YouTube video titled “Roasting YouTuber’s attempts at music” and I had to stop it a quarter of the way through because the lady kept being too nice about it and saying stuff like, “ooh, this is pretty good, I can’t lie teehee” and it’s like, NO! Under no circumstance does the guy who thinks saying the word "moist" over and over again is a good substitute for humor makes music that slaps!! It's trash just like his trash react content. Well, now I'm the one roasting YouTubers, but it's like... if you title something “roasting YouTubers,” then you'd better get to roasting some Tubers! The tin, remember the TIN!!! Don't lie to me, Peter Molyneux style! I never was a big fan of false advertising... or advertising in general for that matter, but that's a conversation for another day.
Okay, tuber rant over. I'm calm again. There are no major twists or left turns here in I Cannot Reach You, and that’s totally fine by me. Otherwise, what’s nice about gay manga (or at least the few that I’ve read) is that they get the specific dynamics between the characters that I really enjoy. Maybe that makes me selfish for simply rating things higher because they cater to my specific tastes, but I've never been accused of being an objective reviewer! Anyway, I know I’m literally always saying this, but whatever, I'll say it again. What's one more time, huh? Well in my experience, if there’s a character that’s loved by everyone within the narrative, then it’s ironically harder to make them likable to the reader. It's like some kind of "contrarian oxymoron" or something. The more a character is said to be perfect, the more I look at them with disdain! In my opinion, the best way to offset this is by having the super handsome and beloved one do most of the “chasing” throughout the romance, so to speak. Mr. Perfectly Fine is the one who’s got to be running through airports, making grand gestures, and apologizing profusely if need be. I don't think I need to explain this, but you'd be surprised at how many books I've read where the antagonistic aspect of the romance between the characters just fizzles out without any kind of satisfying resolution. Yeah so, as long as a story has the "cool" dude doing literally anything to make it look like they’re putting in the work, then I’m totally cool with it. Sorry, I don’t make the rules. Ann~nnd, that’s exactly what I got here with Yamato, the coolest man on the planet, so… yay, I'm happy! I hope I'm not laying it on too thick at just how much I loved this manga, because I know for a fact that it's always a uphill battle to get me to like something whenever other people sing its praises too much. I still haven't started Severance season 2 yet because of how many people keep talking about how great that scene is where Adam Scott is running through a bunch of hallways, so I think I'll probably leave the compliments right there. Don't want to over hype it. Oh, there is one more thing, though! I thought it was kind of funny how within the story Yamato seems like the luckiest man in the world (good grades, everybody loves him, he’s good looking) but because he’s so hopelessly in love with the most dense idiot alive, it almost feels like a cruel joke is being played on him. Well "cruel" might be too strong a word, because maybe he just hasn’t been visited by the spirit of gayness yet? Hopefully soon, though, Lady Gaga, might be looking over him in the future! Well, I guess we’ll find out in the next volume!
“It’d be nice to stop… having unwanted feelings”