The 4 lenses of Innovation by Rowan Gibson is a 3,5 out of 5 stars for me.
In short, the four lenses are
• Challenging orthodoxies
• Harnessing trends
• Leveraging resources
• Understanding needs
In addition, Gibson proposes what he feels is the typical process for innovation breakthroughs, in eight steps
• Frame a specific challenge and focus on solving it.
• Research the subject. Learn from the work of others.
• Immerse yourself in the problem. Explore possible solutions.
• Reach a roadblock. Feel the creative frustration.
• Relax. Detach from the problem. Let it incubate in the unconscious mind.
• Come to an illuminating insight that fundamentally shifts your perspective.
• Build the insight (or insights) into a big idea - a new combination of thoughts.
• Test and validate the new idea - try to make it work.
Pros:
• Loved the design and layout. Easy to read, and lots to rest your eyes on here.
• Does a nice job of connecting the four lenses of innovation from the renaissance to companies and people we are familiar with today (Amazon, Google, Apple, Steve Jobs, Richard Branson, Elon Musk, etc.)
• Does a decent job of pulling lessons from the four lenses (what is taken for granted that shouldn’t be? What is the difference between what people say they want, and what they actually need?)
Cons
• Way too much focus on people and companies and what they do, did, or have done, than actual tools, and a clear how-to-approach to using each of the lenses.
• The case studies are all looking back in time, meaning it’s easy to say they’re following the four lenses, or the 8 steps to innovation breakthroughs. But can you really know that’s the case?
• The same old cases you’ll find in every book. Google, Amazon, Virgin, Apple, Steve Jobs, Elon Musk, Einstein, Edison… I’ll give Gibson props for actually pointing out that it always seems to be the same companies. Still, I would much rather have heard from results from organizations that have used the four lenses approach to gain breakthroughs. The author states that he’s done lots of workshops and have facilitated many processes, so there should be some examples available.
I would choose the paperback version over the kindle, as the book has a very nice design. Think Business Model Generation or Ten Types of Innovation.
As an overview of innovation and a specific framework, I have no problem recomending The 4 Lenses of Innovation, though I feel the subtitle, “a power tool for creative thinking” is a bit misleading. I need more actual cases using the four lenses directly for that to be a fitting subtitle.
If you like the design format of the book, but you’re pressed for time, I would rather go Ten Types of Innovation by Keeley, Pikkel, Quinn and Walters. That is a great and very practical read