What do you think?
Rate this book
You Say Goodbye
Once a successful rock musician, Sean Hightower is now a bitter, aging, one-hit wonder struggling to revive a career that peaked years before. After a disastrous performance and meltdown on stage, he returns to his girlfriend's condo seeking comfort from the woman he loves.
Instead, he finds her murdered.
The crime scene contains two pieces of paper taped above the headboard of the bed. One says, "Hello." The other, "Goodbye."
Detective Ray Maldonado immediately recognizes the meaning behind these two words. The Beatles Song Murderer has struck again—a serial killer whose crimes are connected to Beatles song titles. But this time, the detective reaches a disturbing
The killer might be someone that Sean knows.
At the request of the detective, Sean begins gathering whatever information he can about the whereabouts of his friends and co-workers the night of the murder, forcing him to look at them through a different lens – one of suspicion.
During this chaotic time, an unexpected and unique friendship with his neighbor, Kayleigh, a little girl fighting cancer, changes his perspective on life in ways he never anticipated.
What begins as the devastating murder of the woman he loves becomes a journey through grief, regret, and a life-altering friendship – while simultaneously hoping to find a serial killer he may know.
A search that ultimately will not only endanger Sean, but Kayleigh as well.
Instead, he finds her murdered.
The crime scene contains two pieces of paper taped above the headboard of the bed. One says, "Hello." The other, "Goodbye."
Detective Ray Maldonado immediately recognizes the meaning behind these two words. The Beatles Song Murderer has struck again—a serial killer whose crimes are connected to Beatles song titles. But this time, the detective reaches a disturbing
The killer might be someone that Sean knows.
At the request of the detective, Sean begins gathering whatever information he can about the whereabouts of his friends and co-workers the night of the murder, forcing him to look at them through a different lens – one of suspicion.
During this chaotic time, an unexpected and unique friendship with his neighbor, Kayleigh, a little girl fighting cancer, changes his perspective on life in ways he never anticipated.
What begins as the devastating murder of the woman he loves becomes a journey through grief, regret, and a life-altering friendship – while simultaneously hoping to find a serial killer he may know.
A search that ultimately will not only endanger Sean, but Kayleigh as well.
332 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 19, 2019
About the author
Keith Steinbaum
3 books93 followersKeith Steinbaum
Keith Steinbaum is the author of three multi-award-winning novels spanning mystery, suspense, horror, supernatural fiction, and human drama.
His stories are driven by complex characters, emotional depth, unexpected turns, and the questions that emerge when ordinary lives are pushed into extraordinary circumstances. Across his work, Steinbaum blends suspenseful storytelling with character-driven narratives that explore loss, relationships, personal transformation, and the darker side of human nature.
His novels have received Winner and Finalist recognition from the Book Excellence Awards, Maincrest Media Awards, TopShelf Book Awards, IAN Book of the Year Awards, Chanticleer International Book Awards, Global Book Awards, American Fiction Book Awards, and Goodreads' 2026 Rising Reader Choice Awards.
To learn more about Keith Steinbaum and his books, visit www.keithsteinbaum.com
Keith Steinbaum is the author of three multi-award-winning novels spanning mystery, suspense, horror, supernatural fiction, and human drama.
His stories are driven by complex characters, emotional depth, unexpected turns, and the questions that emerge when ordinary lives are pushed into extraordinary circumstances. Across his work, Steinbaum blends suspenseful storytelling with character-driven narratives that explore loss, relationships, personal transformation, and the darker side of human nature.
His novels have received Winner and Finalist recognition from the Book Excellence Awards, Maincrest Media Awards, TopShelf Book Awards, IAN Book of the Year Awards, Chanticleer International Book Awards, Global Book Awards, American Fiction Book Awards, and Goodreads' 2026 Rising Reader Choice Awards.
To learn more about Keith Steinbaum and his books, visit www.keithsteinbaum.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 106 reviews
June 5, 2019
I thoroughly enjoyed Keith Steinbaum’s book, YOU SAY GOODBYE. This is a book that, on the surface, is a murder mystery, but in a deeper sense, explores the ups and downs – the joy and the pathos – of life.
The story is about a rock musician, Sean Hightower, who is desperately seeking to replicate his one big hit, “Looking Glass”. Turned 50, twice divorced and working at his father’s used car dealership, he is consumed with the depression of failure, finding happiness only with his girlfriend colleague, Merissa. When he returns one evening to find her brutally raped and murdered, with the words “Hello—Goodbye” on the wall behind the corpse, he is driven to contemplate suicide. However, these words connect the murderer first to a Beatles song and thence to the Beatles song murderer who has already raped and killed seven women prior to Merissa. The attending detective suggests the murderer is someone Sean and Merissa know.
The book depicts how Sean is gradually pulled out of his suicidal depression by his determination to help find his girlfriend’s murderer and by his connection to a young neighbor who is bravely fighting cancer. Sean’s admiration of the exemplary courage of this little girl, Kayleigh, becomes a key factor not only in his finding a new purpose in life but also in the final resolution of the mystery.
The plot is well constructed and although there are a number of clues that emerge and point to possible suspects, the identity of the murderer is a well-kept secret until the end. The characters are diverse and well constructed. The writing is flawless. The one thing I might have done differently is edit out some of the description of the daily humdrum of Sean’s existence which tends to slow down the pace of the plot.
All in all, this is a good read and highly recommended. No doubt there will be more of the same from Keith Steinbaum.
The story is about a rock musician, Sean Hightower, who is desperately seeking to replicate his one big hit, “Looking Glass”. Turned 50, twice divorced and working at his father’s used car dealership, he is consumed with the depression of failure, finding happiness only with his girlfriend colleague, Merissa. When he returns one evening to find her brutally raped and murdered, with the words “Hello—Goodbye” on the wall behind the corpse, he is driven to contemplate suicide. However, these words connect the murderer first to a Beatles song and thence to the Beatles song murderer who has already raped and killed seven women prior to Merissa. The attending detective suggests the murderer is someone Sean and Merissa know.
The book depicts how Sean is gradually pulled out of his suicidal depression by his determination to help find his girlfriend’s murderer and by his connection to a young neighbor who is bravely fighting cancer. Sean’s admiration of the exemplary courage of this little girl, Kayleigh, becomes a key factor not only in his finding a new purpose in life but also in the final resolution of the mystery.
The plot is well constructed and although there are a number of clues that emerge and point to possible suspects, the identity of the murderer is a well-kept secret until the end. The characters are diverse and well constructed. The writing is flawless. The one thing I might have done differently is edit out some of the description of the daily humdrum of Sean’s existence which tends to slow down the pace of the plot.
All in all, this is a good read and highly recommended. No doubt there will be more of the same from Keith Steinbaum.
June 25, 2019
Keith Steinbaum has borrowed from the 1967 Beatles song "Hello, Goodbye" for the title of his latest novel, "You Say Goodbye". Unlike his debut novel, "The Poe Consequence", a supernatural thriller, this work is a whodunnit, almost in the old-fashioned sense, though with an unusual touch – the serial killer leaves a Beatles song title at each of his crime scenes, leading to his appellation as The Beatles’ Song Murderer. Here we have Sean Hightower, a washed up rock star, now middle-aged, who dreams of making a come-back. At a gig he does manage to get, he has a melt-down on stage when hecklers call for him to sing the song that made him famous back in the day, "Looking Glass", when all he is trying to do is garner interest in a song he has written as an older, wiser lyricist and musician. He returns, dejected and demoralised to his girlfriend, Merissa’s condo for comfort, only to find her naked, violated body lying on her bed, brutally murdered by a gunshot to her head. His life having taken a dive before this event, it has now reached rock bottom. To make matters worse, his doctor finds a suspicious shadow on a routine X-ray and he fears he has cancer. Feeling there is nothing left for him in this life, he decides to end it but is pulled back from the brink by a sick little girl, Kayleigh, who smiles through her own suffering, touching his heart and giving him a reason to live. He decides to assist the police officer investing Merissa’s murder, Detective Maldonaldo. It becomes clear that Merissa knew her killer and it’s possible that Sean may also know the person who took the love of his life from him. All he has to do to assist Maldonaldo is question his friends and colleagues. Little does he know that in doing so, he is putting his own life in grave danger.
Whodunnits come and go and quite often they can get a little boring as authors try to lure their readers down cul-de-sacs, away from the real killer. In "You Say Goodbye", author, Keith Steinbaum keeps up the interest by throwing in a sub-plot or two. There are two love interests, one his endearing relationship with Kayleigh, the other, the growing fondness he has for Kayleigh’s aunt, Jenny. There are also frequent references to old rock and roll stars and their songs (sadly, I’m old enough to remember them all!). As a lyricist himself, the author also uses the clever device of including original lyrics as though penned by Sean. And who doesn’t love recalling all those old Beatles songs? The writing is flawless with an excellent use of prose. Steinbaum is adept at observing life and putting what he sees into words. His characterisation is spot on, too. There are plenty of red herrings to lead you down the wrong path, then, just when you think you’ve figured it out, there is a major surprise. When the assassin is eventually identified, the pace picks up considerably and it’s a mad rush to the end to see how it all turns out. "You Say Goodbye" is a lot of fun and a jolly good read.
Whodunnits come and go and quite often they can get a little boring as authors try to lure their readers down cul-de-sacs, away from the real killer. In "You Say Goodbye", author, Keith Steinbaum keeps up the interest by throwing in a sub-plot or two. There are two love interests, one his endearing relationship with Kayleigh, the other, the growing fondness he has for Kayleigh’s aunt, Jenny. There are also frequent references to old rock and roll stars and their songs (sadly, I’m old enough to remember them all!). As a lyricist himself, the author also uses the clever device of including original lyrics as though penned by Sean. And who doesn’t love recalling all those old Beatles songs? The writing is flawless with an excellent use of prose. Steinbaum is adept at observing life and putting what he sees into words. His characterisation is spot on, too. There are plenty of red herrings to lead you down the wrong path, then, just when you think you’ve figured it out, there is a major surprise. When the assassin is eventually identified, the pace picks up considerably and it’s a mad rush to the end to see how it all turns out. "You Say Goodbye" is a lot of fun and a jolly good read.
June 5, 2021
I LOVE thrillers. A good book that I can sink into that has a mystery for me to unravel is just what gets my boat floating these days (aside from romance, but those are a very different genre).
You Say Goodbye is about a serial killer who leaves behind notes with Beatles lyrics. The title had already gotten my brain singing some epic Beatles tunes, but the premise just sounded way too cool for me to turn down. Beatles songs were my childhood, so the little smile of singing Hello Goodbye in my head was sweet.
Let's start out by saying the acknowledgement to Alexandra Scot wanted to make me weep. Google her. Look her up. Hear her story and make a difference. My poor heart couldn't take it. So kind, so sweet. Thank you for reminding me of her story Mr. Steinbaum. I had forgotten about it, but being reminded of it was such a lovely moment.
Now, off to the races... We start out with a magic trick away. It's engaging, fun and makes the reader think we're in for maybe a light hearted story. Until it takes a creepy and cruel twist... The story starts hard and fast to get you into the narrative. Melissa is murdered by a man who isn't who he appears to be. He's done this before, and each time he leaves behind lyrics from Beatles songs. It's an interesting calling card, and it's one that everybody has heard of at this point.
Merissa's murder ruins Sean. Him and Merissa were dating, and Sean hasn't had the best of times lately. He's a bit of a wash up musician. The lad did have some amazing songs back in the day, but lately everyone just wants him to play his classics instead of his new tunes. It's degrading and doesn't help his mental health... And then this comes along. The "has been" faces the love of his life dying, some health scares yet meets a young girl who just wants to learn how to play some music. She's a wee bit sickly, which takes to Sean's heart. He finds a small purpose, alongside wanting to find Merissa's murderer.
Alex's Lemonade stand made me smile, alongside the millennial references of Hannah Montana and Cheetah Girls. It felt like my childhood was being thrown into this book and that it was made for me. It was honestly a nice breather from the very current references I've seen in other books.
But, we strayed away from the plot. Kayleigh is Sean's new friend, and along the way we meet many more. Maybe Sean's shady co-workers killed Merissa. Or was it Kayleigh's Aunt's new fling? A random stranger? Why are there so many suspicious people? Why can't people just calm down and live their lives instead of being shady and appearing like murder suspects.
Kayleigh helps Sean come out of his depression, slowly but surely. And eventually we find out who killed Merissa...
I liked this book! It was fun and addictive. The pace was fast, the thrills are insane and there's some heartfelt moments that will make you smile. There's gotta be some positive in these harsh stories.
Five out of five stars.
I received this book for free from the author, Keith Steinbaum, in exchange of an honest review.
You Say Goodbye is about a serial killer who leaves behind notes with Beatles lyrics. The title had already gotten my brain singing some epic Beatles tunes, but the premise just sounded way too cool for me to turn down. Beatles songs were my childhood, so the little smile of singing Hello Goodbye in my head was sweet.
Let's start out by saying the acknowledgement to Alexandra Scot wanted to make me weep. Google her. Look her up. Hear her story and make a difference. My poor heart couldn't take it. So kind, so sweet. Thank you for reminding me of her story Mr. Steinbaum. I had forgotten about it, but being reminded of it was such a lovely moment.
Now, off to the races... We start out with a magic trick away. It's engaging, fun and makes the reader think we're in for maybe a light hearted story. Until it takes a creepy and cruel twist... The story starts hard and fast to get you into the narrative. Melissa is murdered by a man who isn't who he appears to be. He's done this before, and each time he leaves behind lyrics from Beatles songs. It's an interesting calling card, and it's one that everybody has heard of at this point.
Merissa's murder ruins Sean. Him and Merissa were dating, and Sean hasn't had the best of times lately. He's a bit of a wash up musician. The lad did have some amazing songs back in the day, but lately everyone just wants him to play his classics instead of his new tunes. It's degrading and doesn't help his mental health... And then this comes along. The "has been" faces the love of his life dying, some health scares yet meets a young girl who just wants to learn how to play some music. She's a wee bit sickly, which takes to Sean's heart. He finds a small purpose, alongside wanting to find Merissa's murderer.
Alex's Lemonade stand made me smile, alongside the millennial references of Hannah Montana and Cheetah Girls. It felt like my childhood was being thrown into this book and that it was made for me. It was honestly a nice breather from the very current references I've seen in other books.
But, we strayed away from the plot. Kayleigh is Sean's new friend, and along the way we meet many more. Maybe Sean's shady co-workers killed Merissa. Or was it Kayleigh's Aunt's new fling? A random stranger? Why are there so many suspicious people? Why can't people just calm down and live their lives instead of being shady and appearing like murder suspects.
Kayleigh helps Sean come out of his depression, slowly but surely. And eventually we find out who killed Merissa...
I liked this book! It was fun and addictive. The pace was fast, the thrills are insane and there's some heartfelt moments that will make you smile. There's gotta be some positive in these harsh stories.
Five out of five stars.
I received this book for free from the author, Keith Steinbaum, in exchange of an honest review.
April 2, 2019
Well, the joke’s on me for thinking this one would be any good. In all fairness, it wasn’t terrible, more like consistently barely average. If you’re expecting a serial killer thriller, you’ll be disappointed. There is a murder here, but the center stage (appropriately so) belongs to a washed up musician who at 50 finally decides to enter something resembling adulthood following a straight out of Lifetime movie emotional reawakening. The author’s first book apparently made some waves on the indie circuit, so maybe this is a case of sophomore slump. Or maybe the indie standards were pretty relaxed that year. But either way, this lackluster thriller doesn’t offer many or any, really, thrills and not much to recommend itself in other ways. It’s very much like it’s cover, not quite a pro job. The editing is perfectly competent, so that’s already sets it above average for this sort of thing, but the writing brings it down. It’s flat, bland, characterizations lack dimensionality and the dialogue is leaden with clunky expositions, because that seems to be the only way the author provides backstories. The lyrics to Sean’s songs (since we can’t hear the music through the pages) are a good indication as to why his career failed. Oh well, he can always sell cars, all he needs is a steadily working conscience and a love of a good woman. Trite generic story trite generic writing. Mild suspense. Nothing much, but at least it reads quickly. Thanks Netgalley.
February 20, 2020
One of the interesting things about Keith Steinbaum's books is that they're never quite what you think they're going to be.
In 'The Poe Consequence' he took what should have been a gimmicky concept and turned it into a compelling modern-day tale of vengeance. For 'You Say Goodbye' he begins with an intriguing premise for a murder mystery and makes of it a meditation on what really matters in life.
In a way, 'You Say Goodbye' is two books. The surface-level story begins on page one, with a horrific murder and a Beatles song. The boyfriend of the murder victim is aging musician Sean Hightower. Sean had one musical hit early in his career and has since failed to achieve those heights of success. When we first meet Sean he is depressed and suicidal, but he becomes determined to discover and confront his girlfriend's killer. The ensuing game of cat and mouse is the stuff most mysteries are made of - there are clues along the way, there are twists and turns, and as a mystery, 'You Say Goodbye' works just fine.
More surprising, and more delightful, is the second story. By happenstance, Sean meets his next-door neighbor, a young girl battling cancer with remarkable bravery and a positive attitude. While the mystery is preoccupying Sean, it is Kayleigh who gives him something to look forward to. The relationship that develops between the two is the true unexpected twist of 'You Say Goodbye,' and what turns the book from a well-crafted but somewhat standard mystery story into something more.
Mysteries are stories of the process of justice, of righting a wrong. Justice, or even vengeance, are powerful motivators - this is why we love a good mystery, and 'You Say Goodbye' lives up to that standard. Under the surface, though, is a much more interesting tale: not just discovering a cause to risk one's life for, but finding along the way a reason to live for, even if it's not the life you thought you wanted. It is this story which elevates 'You Say Goodbye' into something more meaningful than a standard murder mystery, and a story worth reading.
In 'The Poe Consequence' he took what should have been a gimmicky concept and turned it into a compelling modern-day tale of vengeance. For 'You Say Goodbye' he begins with an intriguing premise for a murder mystery and makes of it a meditation on what really matters in life.
In a way, 'You Say Goodbye' is two books. The surface-level story begins on page one, with a horrific murder and a Beatles song. The boyfriend of the murder victim is aging musician Sean Hightower. Sean had one musical hit early in his career and has since failed to achieve those heights of success. When we first meet Sean he is depressed and suicidal, but he becomes determined to discover and confront his girlfriend's killer. The ensuing game of cat and mouse is the stuff most mysteries are made of - there are clues along the way, there are twists and turns, and as a mystery, 'You Say Goodbye' works just fine.
More surprising, and more delightful, is the second story. By happenstance, Sean meets his next-door neighbor, a young girl battling cancer with remarkable bravery and a positive attitude. While the mystery is preoccupying Sean, it is Kayleigh who gives him something to look forward to. The relationship that develops between the two is the true unexpected twist of 'You Say Goodbye,' and what turns the book from a well-crafted but somewhat standard mystery story into something more.
Mysteries are stories of the process of justice, of righting a wrong. Justice, or even vengeance, are powerful motivators - this is why we love a good mystery, and 'You Say Goodbye' lives up to that standard. Under the surface, though, is a much more interesting tale: not just discovering a cause to risk one's life for, but finding along the way a reason to live for, even if it's not the life you thought you wanted. It is this story which elevates 'You Say Goodbye' into something more meaningful than a standard murder mystery, and a story worth reading.
April 4, 2019
5 Stars
I am not sure what I was expecting based on the cover of this book: classic detective fiction, maybe? But what I found was an angry former musician, one-hit-wonder, playing for peanuts in a dive bar, working at his dad’s dealership and through it all finding himself and his passion again after the death of his girlfriend.
I felt like I was peeking into this real guy’s life and watching as he figured out how to navigate all the challenges that kept coming up and trying to throw him off course. At first he just wanted to get his new song heard and have it catapult him back into the music career of his dreams.
I felt bad for this guy. His life was crap. He wanted to die at one point and he discovered how the friendship he opened himself up to made his life better than any rock star career.
In the midst of it all, the detective in his girlfriend’s murder case kept coming to him for assistance. Not sure this would happen in real life but it made for good distraction for Sean while he figured it all out.
Great book. Sweet ending. Read this. Loved it.
I received this as an ARC (Advanced Reader Copy) in return for an honest review. I thank NetGalley, the publisher and the author for allowing me to read this title.
I am not sure what I was expecting based on the cover of this book: classic detective fiction, maybe? But what I found was an angry former musician, one-hit-wonder, playing for peanuts in a dive bar, working at his dad’s dealership and through it all finding himself and his passion again after the death of his girlfriend.
I felt like I was peeking into this real guy’s life and watching as he figured out how to navigate all the challenges that kept coming up and trying to throw him off course. At first he just wanted to get his new song heard and have it catapult him back into the music career of his dreams.
I felt bad for this guy. His life was crap. He wanted to die at one point and he discovered how the friendship he opened himself up to made his life better than any rock star career.
In the midst of it all, the detective in his girlfriend’s murder case kept coming to him for assistance. Not sure this would happen in real life but it made for good distraction for Sean while he figured it all out.
Great book. Sweet ending. Read this. Loved it.
I received this as an ARC (Advanced Reader Copy) in return for an honest review. I thank NetGalley, the publisher and the author for allowing me to read this title.
July 15, 2019
You Say Goodbye by Keith Steinbaum. This is not just a mystery, it's much more than that. Although it does begin with a brutal murder of a beautiful woman Merisa, who was Sean's girlfriend, it's also far more about the relationships between people and how they affect us. Sean Hightower, our protagonist, is a former rock-star who had one-hit wonder of a song that was immensely popular, but he never had that success again after that. The author uses some beautiful lyrics from two of Sean's songs- one "Looking Glass" and the other later in the story to be especially symbolic and fit into the plot. I really enjoyed this book particularly because of these complex characters such as Sean and a little girl Kaleigh who lives next door next to him who plays an important role in the story. Check it out for a different kind of a novel that is indeed more than just a mystery. I look forward to reading more books by this author!
May 5, 2019
I have never read this author before and I was a bit concerned at first that I had misread the genre but it all came together soon. I am so glad I kept reading as it is very worth it. It is not that I did not enjoy the first part of the story, I just thought it to be different than I thought it would be. Even that first part was interesting and worth the read. I highly recommend this book and recommend that you read it to the end!
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
June 29, 2019
"You Say Goodbye" Is one hell of a rollercoaster. I was completely engrossed. The story and the plot are so realistic and intelligently crafted.. If you want a different kind of suspense/novel this book is a must-read. It is well written and keeps you guessing.
September 21, 2021
You Say Goodbye by Keith Steinbaum is a fantastic read. It is a murder mystery with a lot of depth and interesting characters. The plot is very well thought out and it is moving. The characters are compelling, realistic and relatable. I enjoyed reading this book and I recommend it to all that like murder mysteries.
March 2, 2026
As a woman who reads a lot of psychological thrillers, I was drawn in immediately by the premise but what truly kept me reading was the emotional depth. Sean isn’t your typical hero. He’s flawed, angry, grieving, and lost. Watching him navigate trauma while becoming entangled in a serial killer investigation made this story feel raw and real. The emotional growth felt earned, not forced.
April 11, 2026
A brilliant mix of music culture and crime fiction! The premise is unique, and the execution is even better. The pacing is spot on, keeping readers engaged from start to finish. The twists are unpredictable, and the suspense is relentless. Definitely a standout thriller that deserves more attention.
March 3, 2026
There’s something powerful about watching a broken man slowly rebuild himself. I found myself unexpectedly invested in Sean’s personal growth. The killer plotline was gripping, but the emotional transformation was the true highlight for me.
April 14, 2019
You Say Goodbye, a mystery novel that tells the story of a washed-up musician. Sean is a one hit wonder. He had a good run while it lasted, but though he’s 50 years old he’s still looking to get that next hit. The downside of it is…nobody is really looking for him to make a comeback. All the way want is to hear the song that they liked, but Sean…well…he’s not having it. He intends to show his girlfriend just how much he appreciates her after an epic fail performance, but what he finds is totally tragic. Now, the question is…who murdered her and why?
You Say Goodbye by Keith Steinbaum is a character-driven mystery novel. The story follows Sean as he struggles with the reality that he finds himself in. The author gives the reader a hint of who the killer might be from the beginning of the story. Mind you now I said a “hint.” We don’t know who the killer is, but we do know that Merissa knows who it is that ends her life too early and that it’s possible that Sean knows who it as well. The author weaves a mysterious mystery, but the mystery is done a piece at a time. Mostly the story follows Sean and the other characters that he interacts with. The mystery is mixed in but for me, it doesn’t take the forefront of the storyline.
While the author does do a good job at keeping me mostly engaged in the storyline, I wish that the story had focused more on the mystery of Sean and the police piecing together the murder(s). I was mildly disappointed that the story follows Sean’s life on essentially a day to day basis as he deals with the aftermath (emotional and mental) of the murder and his own life choices.
All in all, I am rating this book 4 out of 5 stars. The author does a good job mixing music with mystery. The additional characters that the main character interacts with help move the story along, but I was a bit disappointed that the mystery and the solving of the crimes was not the forefront of the overall story. I will say that for those who are fans of the Beatles and enjoy a unique mystery that this is a good book to pick up.
You Say Goodbye by Keith Steinbaum is a character-driven mystery novel. The story follows Sean as he struggles with the reality that he finds himself in. The author gives the reader a hint of who the killer might be from the beginning of the story. Mind you now I said a “hint.” We don’t know who the killer is, but we do know that Merissa knows who it is that ends her life too early and that it’s possible that Sean knows who it as well. The author weaves a mysterious mystery, but the mystery is done a piece at a time. Mostly the story follows Sean and the other characters that he interacts with. The mystery is mixed in but for me, it doesn’t take the forefront of the storyline.
While the author does do a good job at keeping me mostly engaged in the storyline, I wish that the story had focused more on the mystery of Sean and the police piecing together the murder(s). I was mildly disappointed that the story follows Sean’s life on essentially a day to day basis as he deals with the aftermath (emotional and mental) of the murder and his own life choices.
All in all, I am rating this book 4 out of 5 stars. The author does a good job mixing music with mystery. The additional characters that the main character interacts with help move the story along, but I was a bit disappointed that the mystery and the solving of the crimes was not the forefront of the overall story. I will say that for those who are fans of the Beatles and enjoy a unique mystery that this is a good book to pick up.
March 25, 2019
I remember reading the first of this author's books and loving it--it was called The Poe Consequence. When the author contacted me to read and possibly review his second novel-of course I said yes!
Sean didn't think he had anything going for him-he was depression personified--his Mom was definitely not helping matters. Sean had one hit song--that was it--he now worked part time in his Dad's car dealership. The only thing that kept him going was his girlfriend-----when he came home after a bad night---he found her murdered.
The detective was bound and determined to get Sean to help--you see this serial killer had been dubbed the Beatles Song murderer. The detective was sure that Sean and his girlfriend knew this person. Sean began to work with the detective--he really did want to know who murdered his only reason for living.
He had written a suicide note--and had a bunch of pills ready to swallow--when he noticed a new neighbors young daughter sitting outside with a lemonade stand. She had cancer and had more then a will to live!! She dubbed Sean Mr. Music-she had a nickname for everyone she liked.
They became close friends and Sean finally agreed to teach her how to play the guitar--there were stipulations of course-I loved them and so will you!
Sean's big time lawyer brother was trying to get him to allow his song to be used in a commercial-he kept refusing--until he found out something--
You will not believe who the murderer turned out to be-I actually did not guess it either--
There is much good in this novel and it has a beautiful and happy ending!!
Sean didn't think he had anything going for him-he was depression personified--his Mom was definitely not helping matters. Sean had one hit song--that was it--he now worked part time in his Dad's car dealership. The only thing that kept him going was his girlfriend-----when he came home after a bad night---he found her murdered.
The detective was bound and determined to get Sean to help--you see this serial killer had been dubbed the Beatles Song murderer. The detective was sure that Sean and his girlfriend knew this person. Sean began to work with the detective--he really did want to know who murdered his only reason for living.
He had written a suicide note--and had a bunch of pills ready to swallow--when he noticed a new neighbors young daughter sitting outside with a lemonade stand. She had cancer and had more then a will to live!! She dubbed Sean Mr. Music-she had a nickname for everyone she liked.
They became close friends and Sean finally agreed to teach her how to play the guitar--there were stipulations of course-I loved them and so will you!
Sean's big time lawyer brother was trying to get him to allow his song to be used in a commercial-he kept refusing--until he found out something--
You will not believe who the murderer turned out to be-I actually did not guess it either--
There is much good in this novel and it has a beautiful and happy ending!!
March 21, 2019
In You Say Goodbye, Keith Steinbaum shows us both the monstrous inhumanity of life and the humanity—born of connectivity and purpose. Sean Hightower is a has-been musician, a one-hit wonder whose life goes horribly wrong when he discovers the body of his lover Merissa in her apartment. Plagued by his loss and his self-perceived failures, Sean plans to end his life. A chance encounter with the 10-year-old cancer patient next door, a young girl selling lemonade for the Alex’s Lemonade Stand Foundation that funds research for childhood cancers, stays his hand. With a tentative new lease on life, and with the aid of a local detective, Sean sets out to discover who killed Merissa and to recapture his reason for living. Deftly and sensitively written, this book will keep you guessing until the end as to the identity of the murderer.
April 23, 2019
I read Keith's first book, The Poe Consequence, and loved it. His second book is amazing as well!! This book kept me guessing right up until the end and to me that makes an awesome mystery! Like his first book, there are subtle morals to be learned from the book, but not so much that they get in the way of the actual storyline. Keith writes in a way that I feel like I really know the characters, both good and bad. I love that when I was reading this book, I felt the characters pain and emotions. Keith is a wonderful author and I highly recommend both of his books! I'm looking forward to the next one!
April 29, 2020
Another fast read by this Author... I can’t wait for the 3rd book ... both his books should be made into movies
A whodunnit that keeps you trying to guess all along .. characters some you love , some you have doubts about ... very animated story which feels like you’re watching a movie ... the little girls role adds emotion to this story ..interesting every day characters ...
A whodunnit that keeps you trying to guess all along .. characters some you love , some you have doubts about ... very animated story which feels like you’re watching a movie ... the little girls role adds emotion to this story ..interesting every day characters ...
October 16, 2026
Keith Steinbaum’s You Say Goodbye takes its title from the Beatles’ 1967 hit song “Hello, Goodbye.” Unlike his debut novel, The Poe Consequence, which explores supernatural thriller territory, this novel is a murder mystery with a classic whodunnit feel and an intriguing musical twist. The serial killer leaves the title of a Beatles song at each crime scene, earning the nickname “The Beatles’ Song Murderer.”
The story follows Sean Hightower, a middle-aged, washed-up rock star who dreams of reviving his music career. When an attempted comeback performance goes badly, Sean returns to his girlfriend Merissa’s condo, hoping for comfort. Instead, he discovers her brutally murdered body. Already struggling with his fading career and personal disappointments, Sean is devastated by the tragedy. Matters become even more difficult when a suspicious shadow on a routine X-ray raises concerns about his health.
Overwhelmed by his circumstances, Sean reaches a desperate point in his life. However, his encounter with Kayleigh, a seriously ill young girl whose optimism persists despite her suffering, gives him a renewed sense of purpose. Determined to find answers following Merissa’s death, Sean begins assisting Detective Maldonaldo with the investigation. As he questions friends and former colleagues, he discovers that Merissa may have known her killer—and that the murderer could be closer to him than he realizes. His search for the truth soon places his own life in danger.
Although murder mysteries can sometimes become predictable as authors lead readers through a series of misleading clues, Steinbaum maintains interest by incorporating several engaging subplots. Sean’s growing affection for Kayleigh and his developing relationship with her aunt, Jenny, add emotional depth to the story. The frequent references to classic rock musicians and their songs also contribute to the novel’s nostalgic appeal.
One particularly enjoyable feature is the inclusion of original song lyrics supposedly written by Sean. This creative touch reflects the author’s understanding of music and strengthens the connection between the protagonist’s personal struggles and his artistic ambitions. Fans of the Beatles and classic rock will especially appreciate the musical references woven throughout the narrative.
Steinbaum demonstrates a strong command of prose and an ability to observe human behavior with insight. The characterizations are convincing, and the mystery contains plenty of red herrings to keep readers guessing. Just when the solution seems apparent, an unexpected revelation changes the direction of the investigation. Once the killer’s identity is revealed, the pace accelerates, carrying the story toward an exciting and suspenseful conclusion.
Overall, You Say Goodbye is an entertaining murder mystery that combines suspense, music, personal redemption, and emotional connections. With its nostalgic references, engaging subplots, and surprising twists, it offers an enjoyable reading experience, particularly for readers who appreciate classic rock and traditional whodunnits.
Final Verdict: A lively, engaging, and entertaining mystery that delivers a satisfying blend of musical nostalgia and suspense.
The story follows Sean Hightower, a middle-aged, washed-up rock star who dreams of reviving his music career. When an attempted comeback performance goes badly, Sean returns to his girlfriend Merissa’s condo, hoping for comfort. Instead, he discovers her brutally murdered body. Already struggling with his fading career and personal disappointments, Sean is devastated by the tragedy. Matters become even more difficult when a suspicious shadow on a routine X-ray raises concerns about his health.
Overwhelmed by his circumstances, Sean reaches a desperate point in his life. However, his encounter with Kayleigh, a seriously ill young girl whose optimism persists despite her suffering, gives him a renewed sense of purpose. Determined to find answers following Merissa’s death, Sean begins assisting Detective Maldonaldo with the investigation. As he questions friends and former colleagues, he discovers that Merissa may have known her killer—and that the murderer could be closer to him than he realizes. His search for the truth soon places his own life in danger.
Although murder mysteries can sometimes become predictable as authors lead readers through a series of misleading clues, Steinbaum maintains interest by incorporating several engaging subplots. Sean’s growing affection for Kayleigh and his developing relationship with her aunt, Jenny, add emotional depth to the story. The frequent references to classic rock musicians and their songs also contribute to the novel’s nostalgic appeal.
One particularly enjoyable feature is the inclusion of original song lyrics supposedly written by Sean. This creative touch reflects the author’s understanding of music and strengthens the connection between the protagonist’s personal struggles and his artistic ambitions. Fans of the Beatles and classic rock will especially appreciate the musical references woven throughout the narrative.
Steinbaum demonstrates a strong command of prose and an ability to observe human behavior with insight. The characterizations are convincing, and the mystery contains plenty of red herrings to keep readers guessing. Just when the solution seems apparent, an unexpected revelation changes the direction of the investigation. Once the killer’s identity is revealed, the pace accelerates, carrying the story toward an exciting and suspenseful conclusion.
Overall, You Say Goodbye is an entertaining murder mystery that combines suspense, music, personal redemption, and emotional connections. With its nostalgic references, engaging subplots, and surprising twists, it offers an enjoyable reading experience, particularly for readers who appreciate classic rock and traditional whodunnits.
Final Verdict: A lively, engaging, and entertaining mystery that delivers a satisfying blend of musical nostalgia and suspense.
March 3, 2026
There are certain characters in fiction that you encounter once and never forget. Hermione Granger. Atticus Finch. Scout. I know it might seem like an overstatement to place a character from a contemporary thriller in that company, but I genuinely believe that Kayleigh the terminally ill young girl at the heart of You Say Goodbye's most powerful subplot belongs on that list. She is one of the most fully realized, emotionally resonant characters I have encountered in recent fiction, and Keith Steinbaum writes her with a love and precision that is evident on every page she inhabits.
But let me back up, because to describe this book purely through the lens of Kayleigh's storyline would be to shortchange the rest of what Steinbaum has built here. At its most basic level, You Say Goodbye is a serial killer mystery well-plotted, suspenseful, and cleverly constructed around a villain whose methodology draws on Beatles songs in ways that are simultaneously chilling and fascinating. The mystery works on its own terms. The clues are fair, the suspects are plausible, and the reveal is genuinely surprising. Any reader who picks this up purely for the whodunit will get their money's worth.
But what elevates the novel into something special is the way Steinbaum layers the mystery with an exploration of grief, regret, and the strange ways that human connection can rescue us from ourselves. Sean Hightower arrives in this story as a deeply wounded man a musician who briefly touched greatness and has spent years since then nursing his resentment and his sense of failure. His girlfriend's murder does not simply make him a witness to a crime; it forces him to confront everything he has been avoiding, and the process of that confrontation is written with remarkable honesty.
When Kayleigh enters his life, something extraordinary happens. Here is this child who has every reason to be angry and frightened and despairing, and yet she approaches each day with a generosity of spirit that gradually begins to change the way Sean sees himself and his circumstances. Their relationship is not sentimental or manipulative it is specific and earned and completely convincing. The scenes between them are the best-written passages in a book that contains a great deal of excellent writing.
I finished You Say Goodbye on a Tuesday evening and spent most of that night thinking about it. That is the highest compliment I know how to pay a novel. Read it.
But let me back up, because to describe this book purely through the lens of Kayleigh's storyline would be to shortchange the rest of what Steinbaum has built here. At its most basic level, You Say Goodbye is a serial killer mystery well-plotted, suspenseful, and cleverly constructed around a villain whose methodology draws on Beatles songs in ways that are simultaneously chilling and fascinating. The mystery works on its own terms. The clues are fair, the suspects are plausible, and the reveal is genuinely surprising. Any reader who picks this up purely for the whodunit will get their money's worth.
But what elevates the novel into something special is the way Steinbaum layers the mystery with an exploration of grief, regret, and the strange ways that human connection can rescue us from ourselves. Sean Hightower arrives in this story as a deeply wounded man a musician who briefly touched greatness and has spent years since then nursing his resentment and his sense of failure. His girlfriend's murder does not simply make him a witness to a crime; it forces him to confront everything he has been avoiding, and the process of that confrontation is written with remarkable honesty.
When Kayleigh enters his life, something extraordinary happens. Here is this child who has every reason to be angry and frightened and despairing, and yet she approaches each day with a generosity of spirit that gradually begins to change the way Sean sees himself and his circumstances. Their relationship is not sentimental or manipulative it is specific and earned and completely convincing. The scenes between them are the best-written passages in a book that contains a great deal of excellent writing.
I finished You Say Goodbye on a Tuesday evening and spent most of that night thinking about it. That is the highest compliment I know how to pay a novel. Read it.
October 16, 2026
Keith Steinbaum delivers an intriguing mystery in You Say Goodbye, a novel that brings together crime, music, and personal struggles in an engaging story. With its unusual connection to Beatles songs, the book offers a distinctive twist that sets it apart from a conventional murder mystery.
The story follows Sean Hightower, a former rock musician whose life takes a devastating turn when he discovers that his girlfriend has been murdered. The case becomes even more unsettling when investigators uncover the killer’s unusual habit of leaving Beatles song titles at crime scenes. As the investigation progresses, Sean becomes increasingly involved in the search for answers, and the possibility that someone within his own circle may be responsible adds another layer of suspense.
One of the novel’s strengths is the way it combines the central investigation with the protagonist’s personal challenges. Sean is not simply trying to uncover the truth; he is also struggling with disappointment, uncertainty, and the consequences of his past. These experiences give the story an emotional dimension that complements the mystery.
Steinbaum creates an atmosphere that encourages readers to question what they know and reconsider their suspicions as new information emerges. The musical references add a nostalgic touch, while the unfolding clues help sustain interest in the investigation. The balance between Sean’s personal journey and the search for the murderer gives the narrative additional substance.
At its heart, You Say Goodbye is a story about loss, resilience, and the difficult process of finding direction after life takes an unexpected turn. Sean’s determination to move forward despite his circumstances makes him an interesting central character, and his experiences give the mystery a more personal significance.
Overall, Keith Steinbaum has written an appealing novel for readers who enjoy crime fiction with musical influences and character-driven storytelling. The combination of an unusual killer, an unfolding investigation, and a protagonist facing personal difficulties makes You Say Goodbye an interesting choice for mystery enthusiasts.
Final Verdict: A compelling blend of crime, music, and personal drama that offers readers an engaging mystery with an emotional foundation. Recommended for fans of murder mysteries and character-focused thrillers.
The story follows Sean Hightower, a former rock musician whose life takes a devastating turn when he discovers that his girlfriend has been murdered. The case becomes even more unsettling when investigators uncover the killer’s unusual habit of leaving Beatles song titles at crime scenes. As the investigation progresses, Sean becomes increasingly involved in the search for answers, and the possibility that someone within his own circle may be responsible adds another layer of suspense.
One of the novel’s strengths is the way it combines the central investigation with the protagonist’s personal challenges. Sean is not simply trying to uncover the truth; he is also struggling with disappointment, uncertainty, and the consequences of his past. These experiences give the story an emotional dimension that complements the mystery.
Steinbaum creates an atmosphere that encourages readers to question what they know and reconsider their suspicions as new information emerges. The musical references add a nostalgic touch, while the unfolding clues help sustain interest in the investigation. The balance between Sean’s personal journey and the search for the murderer gives the narrative additional substance.
At its heart, You Say Goodbye is a story about loss, resilience, and the difficult process of finding direction after life takes an unexpected turn. Sean’s determination to move forward despite his circumstances makes him an interesting central character, and his experiences give the mystery a more personal significance.
Overall, Keith Steinbaum has written an appealing novel for readers who enjoy crime fiction with musical influences and character-driven storytelling. The combination of an unusual killer, an unfolding investigation, and a protagonist facing personal difficulties makes You Say Goodbye an interesting choice for mystery enthusiasts.
Final Verdict: A compelling blend of crime, music, and personal drama that offers readers an engaging mystery with an emotional foundation. Recommended for fans of murder mysteries and character-focused thrillers.
August 9, 2024
"You Say Goodbye" by Keith Steinbaum is a compelling and intricately woven murder mystery that captivates from the first page. The story begins with the murder of Merrisa, the girlfriend of Sean Hightower, a disillusioned musician struggling to find meaning in his life after the fleeting success of his song "Looking Glass." The killer, known as the Beatle’s Murderer, leaves behind cryptic notes featuring Beatles lyrics, adding an enigmatic touch to the chilling narrative.
Sean’s world is turned upside down, and his initial response is one of bitterness and despair. As he contemplates ending his life, he encounters a young girl battling cancer whose radiant optimism begins to pierce through his gloom. Her presence in his life is transformative, igniting a profound change in Sean. As he says, “Sometimes, the light in someone else’s heart can shine through the darkest of our own.”
Determined to find Merrisa’s killer, Sean collaborates with the investigator on the case. The investigator’s insistence that the murderer is someone within their circle drives Sean to confront his own demons and embrace a path of redemption. Steinbaum excels in portraying Sean’s evolution from a self-pitying figure to a compassionate and engaged individual. This character development is poignantly captured as Sean reflects, “Redemption is not a destination, but a journey, and every step forward is a step away from my own shadows.
The suspense throughout the novel is skillfully maintained, with Steinbaum’s storytelling ensuring that the identity of the killer remains a tantalizing mystery until the very end. The interplay of suspense and character growth makes "You Say Goodbye" a gripping and emotionally resonant read. As the novel draws to a close, readers are left not only pondering the twists and turns of the mystery but also reflecting on the profound personal transformation of the protagonist.
Keith Steinbaum’s talent for crafting engaging, emotionally rich stories. It is journey of redemption and self-discovery, underscored by an expertly executed suspense plot. I highly recommend this novel to anyone who enjoys a well-crafted mystery with a powerful emotional.
Sean’s world is turned upside down, and his initial response is one of bitterness and despair. As he contemplates ending his life, he encounters a young girl battling cancer whose radiant optimism begins to pierce through his gloom. Her presence in his life is transformative, igniting a profound change in Sean. As he says, “Sometimes, the light in someone else’s heart can shine through the darkest of our own.”
Determined to find Merrisa’s killer, Sean collaborates with the investigator on the case. The investigator’s insistence that the murderer is someone within their circle drives Sean to confront his own demons and embrace a path of redemption. Steinbaum excels in portraying Sean’s evolution from a self-pitying figure to a compassionate and engaged individual. This character development is poignantly captured as Sean reflects, “Redemption is not a destination, but a journey, and every step forward is a step away from my own shadows.
The suspense throughout the novel is skillfully maintained, with Steinbaum’s storytelling ensuring that the identity of the killer remains a tantalizing mystery until the very end. The interplay of suspense and character growth makes "You Say Goodbye" a gripping and emotionally resonant read. As the novel draws to a close, readers are left not only pondering the twists and turns of the mystery but also reflecting on the profound personal transformation of the protagonist.
Keith Steinbaum’s talent for crafting engaging, emotionally rich stories. It is journey of redemption and self-discovery, underscored by an expertly executed suspense plot. I highly recommend this novel to anyone who enjoys a well-crafted mystery with a powerful emotional.
October 16, 2026
## Book Review: *You Say Goodbye* by Keith Steinbaum
From the opening pages, *You Say Goodbye* draws readers into an intense and intriguing story that combines murder, mystery, and musical nostalgia. The title, inspired by the Beatles song “Hello, Goodbye,” hints at the important role music plays throughout this suspenseful narrative.
Sean Hightower, a former rock star struggling with fading fame, finds his life turned upside down when he discovers his girlfriend brutally murdered. The killer’s chilling signature, a Beatles song title left at the crime scene, adds an unusual and unsettling dimension to the investigation. As the mystery unfolds, Sean’s connection to the case raises questions that keep readers guessing about the killer’s identity and motives.
Keith Steinbaum delivers an engaging narrative that balances suspense with emotional drama. The dialogue and descriptions help bring the characters and events to life, while the developing mystery encourages readers to continue turning the pages. The combination of musical references and criminal investigation gives the novel a distinctive atmosphere.
Beyond its central mystery, the book explores themes of regret, redemption, personal struggles, and the consequences of past decisions. Sean’s journey highlights the challenges of confronting painful experiences and finding a renewed sense of purpose when life seems to have reached its lowest point. These emotional elements add depth to the suspense and make his personal journey an important part of the story.
Overall, *You Say Goodbye* offers an engaging blend of mystery, music, and human emotion. Sean Hightower’s determination to move beyond despair and seek answers makes his journey compelling, while the whodunnit structure maintains interest throughout the investigation. Steinbaum brings these elements together in a story that offers both suspense and opportunities for reflection.
**Final Verdict:** An entertaining and emotionally engaging mystery that combines musical nostalgia with suspenseful storytelling. Recommended for readers who enjoy murder mysteries, intriguing twists, and stories that explore the human side of personal struggles.
From the opening pages, *You Say Goodbye* draws readers into an intense and intriguing story that combines murder, mystery, and musical nostalgia. The title, inspired by the Beatles song “Hello, Goodbye,” hints at the important role music plays throughout this suspenseful narrative.
Sean Hightower, a former rock star struggling with fading fame, finds his life turned upside down when he discovers his girlfriend brutally murdered. The killer’s chilling signature, a Beatles song title left at the crime scene, adds an unusual and unsettling dimension to the investigation. As the mystery unfolds, Sean’s connection to the case raises questions that keep readers guessing about the killer’s identity and motives.
Keith Steinbaum delivers an engaging narrative that balances suspense with emotional drama. The dialogue and descriptions help bring the characters and events to life, while the developing mystery encourages readers to continue turning the pages. The combination of musical references and criminal investigation gives the novel a distinctive atmosphere.
Beyond its central mystery, the book explores themes of regret, redemption, personal struggles, and the consequences of past decisions. Sean’s journey highlights the challenges of confronting painful experiences and finding a renewed sense of purpose when life seems to have reached its lowest point. These emotional elements add depth to the suspense and make his personal journey an important part of the story.
Overall, *You Say Goodbye* offers an engaging blend of mystery, music, and human emotion. Sean Hightower’s determination to move beyond despair and seek answers makes his journey compelling, while the whodunnit structure maintains interest throughout the investigation. Steinbaum brings these elements together in a story that offers both suspense and opportunities for reflection.
**Final Verdict:** An entertaining and emotionally engaging mystery that combines musical nostalgia with suspenseful storytelling. Recommended for readers who enjoy murder mysteries, intriguing twists, and stories that explore the human side of personal struggles.
October 16, 2026
I had hoped this book would be a more engaging read, but unfortunately, it fell short of my expectations. It was not entirely terrible, but it remained consistently average throughout.
Readers expecting a gripping serial-killer thriller may be disappointed. Although a murder is central to the plot, the story focuses more on Sean Hightower, a washed-up musician approaching the age of 50 who begins to confront his personal shortcomings and make changes in his life following an emotional awakening. While this character-driven approach could have been compelling, the execution lacked the depth and originality needed to make the story truly memorable.
Perhaps the book suffers from the familiar challenge of a second novel failing to live up to the success of its predecessor. Whatever the reason, the suspense is mild, and the narrative offers few genuinely thrilling moments.
The editing is reasonably competent, which helps the book maintain a readable pace. However, the writing itself feels flat and uninspired. The characters lack depth and complexity, while the dialogue often feels heavy-handed, relying on awkward exposition to communicate their backgrounds and personal histories. Even the lyrics to Sean’s songs, which serve as a substitute for the music readers cannot hear, do little to establish him as a convincing or compelling musician.
The story also relies on familiar, predictable themes, including personal redemption, the development of a conscience, and the transformative influence of romantic love. Unfortunately, these elements are presented in a way that feels generic rather than emotionally convincing.
Overall, this is a quick and accessible read, but it lacks the tension, strong characterization, and engaging writing necessary to make it stand out as a thriller. While it has a few redeeming qualities, it ultimately leaves little lasting impression.
Rating: An average read with mild suspense and limited thrills.
Thanks to NetGalley for providing the opportunity to read and review this book.
July 31, 2024
From the very first page, You Say Goodbye hooks you with its gripping and intense storyline. The title itself, referencing a Beatles song, sets the stage for a thriller intertwined with musical nostalgia.
Sean Hightower, a former rock star struggling with his fading fame, is thrust into a nightmare when he finds his girlfriend brutally murdered. The presence of the infamous Beatles Song Murderer's signature at the crime scene adds a chilling twist. As the investigation unfolds, Sean's connection to the killer becomes a heart-pounding mystery that keeps you guessing until the end.
Keith Steinbaum's writing style is crisp and engaging, capturing the essence of suspense and drama. His vivid descriptions and dynamic dialogues make the characters and scenes come alive, creating a cinematic reading experience. The pacing is perfect, with each chapter leaving you eager for more.
The book explores themes of regret, redemption, and the dark side of fame. It delves into the complexities of human emotions and relationships, highlighting how past actions can haunt the present. The underlying message about the impact of unresolved issues and the quest for closure adds depth to the thrilling narrative.
You Say Goodbye is a masterful blend of mystery and emotional depth. Sean Hightower's journey from despair to determination is both compelling and relatable. The whodunit aspect keeps you on edge, and the emotional undercurrents make it a memorable read. Steinbaum has crafted a novel that is as thought-provoking as it is thrilling.
In short this book is a captivating thriller that combines music, mystery, and emotion. Keith Steinbaum's expert storytelling ensures that this book will linger in your mind long after you've turned the last page. Highly recommended for fans of suspenseful and emotionally charged stories.
Sean Hightower, a former rock star struggling with his fading fame, is thrust into a nightmare when he finds his girlfriend brutally murdered. The presence of the infamous Beatles Song Murderer's signature at the crime scene adds a chilling twist. As the investigation unfolds, Sean's connection to the killer becomes a heart-pounding mystery that keeps you guessing until the end.
Keith Steinbaum's writing style is crisp and engaging, capturing the essence of suspense and drama. His vivid descriptions and dynamic dialogues make the characters and scenes come alive, creating a cinematic reading experience. The pacing is perfect, with each chapter leaving you eager for more.
The book explores themes of regret, redemption, and the dark side of fame. It delves into the complexities of human emotions and relationships, highlighting how past actions can haunt the present. The underlying message about the impact of unresolved issues and the quest for closure adds depth to the thrilling narrative.
You Say Goodbye is a masterful blend of mystery and emotional depth. Sean Hightower's journey from despair to determination is both compelling and relatable. The whodunit aspect keeps you on edge, and the emotional undercurrents make it a memorable read. Steinbaum has crafted a novel that is as thought-provoking as it is thrilling.
In short this book is a captivating thriller that combines music, mystery, and emotion. Keith Steinbaum's expert storytelling ensures that this book will linger in your mind long after you've turned the last page. Highly recommended for fans of suspenseful and emotionally charged stories.
September 6, 2024
In "The Poe Consequence," he transformed what could have been a gimmicky concept into a gripping modern tale of vengeance. With "You Say Goodbye," he starts with a fascinating murder mystery premise and evolves it into a profound exploration of life's true priorities.
Sean Hightower, a rock singer, is the protagonist of the tale. He is fervently trying to recreate his one major success, "Looking Glass." At fifty years old, having gone through two divorces, and employed at his father's used car business, he is overcome with a sense of failure and finds solace only in his relationship with Merissa, a co-worker. He is compelled to consider suicide after returning one evening to see her brutally raped and murdered, with the words "Hello—Goodbye" written on the wall behind the corpse. But these same words link the killer to a Beatles song, and from there to the Beatles song murderer who killed and sexually assaulted seven other women before Merissa. The investigating investigator speculates that Sean and Merissa know the perpetrator.
The book describes how Sean's resolve to assist uncover his girlfriend's killer and his relationship with a young neighbor who is courageously battling cancer gradually bring him out of his suicidal misery. Sean's adoration for Kayleigh, the young child, and her extraordinary bravery plays a crucial role in both the mystery's eventual resolution and in helping him discover a new purpose in life.
Mysteries delve into the pursuit of justice and the quest to right wrongs, driven by the powerful forces of justice and vengeance. This is why we are captivated by a compelling mystery, and "You Say Goodbye" certainly delivers. It’s an exhilarating ride from start to finish. The narrative and plot are incredibly realistic and skilfully constructed. If you're seeking a unique suspense novel, this book is a must-read.
Sean Hightower, a rock singer, is the protagonist of the tale. He is fervently trying to recreate his one major success, "Looking Glass." At fifty years old, having gone through two divorces, and employed at his father's used car business, he is overcome with a sense of failure and finds solace only in his relationship with Merissa, a co-worker. He is compelled to consider suicide after returning one evening to see her brutally raped and murdered, with the words "Hello—Goodbye" written on the wall behind the corpse. But these same words link the killer to a Beatles song, and from there to the Beatles song murderer who killed and sexually assaulted seven other women before Merissa. The investigating investigator speculates that Sean and Merissa know the perpetrator.
The book describes how Sean's resolve to assist uncover his girlfriend's killer and his relationship with a young neighbor who is courageously battling cancer gradually bring him out of his suicidal misery. Sean's adoration for Kayleigh, the young child, and her extraordinary bravery plays a crucial role in both the mystery's eventual resolution and in helping him discover a new purpose in life.
Mysteries delve into the pursuit of justice and the quest to right wrongs, driven by the powerful forces of justice and vengeance. This is why we are captivated by a compelling mystery, and "You Say Goodbye" certainly delivers. It’s an exhilarating ride from start to finish. The narrative and plot are incredibly realistic and skilfully constructed. If you're seeking a unique suspense novel, this book is a must-read.
September 13, 2024
Keith Steinbaum’s "You Say Goodbye" is a masterfully crafted murder mystery that drew me in with its dark and compelling premise. The story starts with the shocking murder of Merrisa, Sean Hightower’s girlfriend, and introduces the cryptic Beatle’s Murderer, whose ominous notes filled with Beatles lyrics set the stage for a gripping mystery.
What truly resonated with me was Sean’s journey from despair to redemption. His struggle with self-pity and hopelessness felt deeply personal, reflecting my own experiences with doubt. The turning point comes when Sean meets a young girl battling cancer, whose radiant optimism brings a much-needed light into his life. Her influence on Sean underscores a poignant truth: “Sometimes, the light in someone else’s heart can shine through the darkest of our own.”
As Sean teams up with an investigator to uncover the killer, the suspense builds masterfully, keeping the reader guessing until the end. Steinbaum’s depiction of Sean’s transformation—from a figure lost in his own shadows to one seeking compassion—is both moving and inspiring. The realization that “Redemption is not a destination, but a journey” beautifully captures this profound evolution.
In conclusion, "You Say Goodbye" is more than just a suspenseful mystery; it’s a powerful exploration of personal growth and redemption. Steinbaum’s ability to intertwine a thrilling plot with deep emotional resonance makes this book a standout read. For anyone who enjoys a gripping mystery with a heartfelt core, this novel is a must-read that will stay with you long after you turn the last page.
What truly resonated with me was Sean’s journey from despair to redemption. His struggle with self-pity and hopelessness felt deeply personal, reflecting my own experiences with doubt. The turning point comes when Sean meets a young girl battling cancer, whose radiant optimism brings a much-needed light into his life. Her influence on Sean underscores a poignant truth: “Sometimes, the light in someone else’s heart can shine through the darkest of our own.”
As Sean teams up with an investigator to uncover the killer, the suspense builds masterfully, keeping the reader guessing until the end. Steinbaum’s depiction of Sean’s transformation—from a figure lost in his own shadows to one seeking compassion—is both moving and inspiring. The realization that “Redemption is not a destination, but a journey” beautifully captures this profound evolution.
In conclusion, "You Say Goodbye" is more than just a suspenseful mystery; it’s a powerful exploration of personal growth and redemption. Steinbaum’s ability to intertwine a thrilling plot with deep emotional resonance makes this book a standout read. For anyone who enjoys a gripping mystery with a heartfelt core, this novel is a must-read that will stay with you long after you turn the last page.
September 6, 2024
🎸 ”You Say Goodbye” by Keith Steinbaum is a thrilling ride through the dark side of fame and the twisted mind of a serial killer. 🕵️♂️ Sean Hightower, a washed-up rock star, is just trying to piece his life back together when he stumbles into a nightmare. Finding his girlfriend brutally murdered, with eerie notes on the wall referencing Beatles lyrics, Sean is thrown into a terrifying mystery.
😱 The story grips you from the start, blending the glitz of the music world with the gritty reality of murder. As the police close in on The Beatles Song Murderer, Sean is forced to confront the possibility that this killer is someone he knows. The suspense builds with every page, leaving you questioning everyone around Sean. Could it really be someone from his past?
🎶 Keith’s clever use of Beatles references adds a unique twist, making the story not just a murder mystery but also a deep dive into the psyche of a tormented artist. If you’re into thrillers with a rock ‘n’ roll edge, “You Say Goodbye” will keep you guessing until the very end. A must-read for mystery lovers and music fans alike! 🎤
😱 The story grips you from the start, blending the glitz of the music world with the gritty reality of murder. As the police close in on The Beatles Song Murderer, Sean is forced to confront the possibility that this killer is someone he knows. The suspense builds with every page, leaving you questioning everyone around Sean. Could it really be someone from his past?
🎶 Keith’s clever use of Beatles references adds a unique twist, making the story not just a murder mystery but also a deep dive into the psyche of a tormented artist. If you’re into thrillers with a rock ‘n’ roll edge, “You Say Goodbye” will keep you guessing until the very end. A must-read for mystery lovers and music fans alike! 🎤
March 3, 2026
Let me be upfront about something: I am a hard person to impress when it comes to crime fiction. I have read hundreds of mystery and thriller novels over the years, and the genre has a tendency to follow well-worn grooves. Clever killer. Dogged detective. A series of clues leading to a satisfying but not particularly surprising reveal. You Say Goodbye breaks that mold in ways I genuinely did not anticipate, and Keith Steinbaum deserves enormous credit for writing a thriller that functions equally well as a literary exploration of grief, failure, and human connection.
The setup is familiar enough: a serial killer is terrorizing the community, leaving behind clues drawn from Beatles songs, and the investigation centers on a reluctant civilian Sean Hightower whose personal connection to the murders makes him both an asset and a suspect. But Steinbaum takes this premise and pushes it somewhere much more interesting. Sean is not a charming, witty everyman hero. He is depressed, angry, sometimes cruel, and deeply self-sabotaging. Watching him navigate the investigation while also confronting the wreckage of his personal and professional life is a genuinely compelling experience.
The setup is familiar enough: a serial killer is terrorizing the community, leaving behind clues drawn from Beatles songs, and the investigation centers on a reluctant civilian Sean Hightower whose personal connection to the murders makes him both an asset and a suspect. But Steinbaum takes this premise and pushes it somewhere much more interesting. Sean is not a charming, witty everyman hero. He is depressed, angry, sometimes cruel, and deeply self-sabotaging. Watching him navigate the investigation while also confronting the wreckage of his personal and professional life is a genuinely compelling experience.
August 4, 2019
WHat a great read.
I would like to start off by Thanking, Keith Steinbaum for sending me a hard copy of his book.
And for that I am writing my honest review on this book.
In point form here the just of it:
TOTAL SCORE : 4 1/2 Stars.
Title: 4 stars, Why? Because it tied in very well to the story.
Book cover: 4 stars. Loved the cove , Why? Everything on it was a clues as to “Who did it”. And the black and white cover really works.
Writing style: 5 starts, I absolutely loved his style of writing. Beautifully written, easy to follow and read. I really liked his descriptions of various physical aspects of the characters.
Plot: 4 stars, good plot, nice flow to it.
OK, here it goes, I apologize in advance or my writing, as I am definitely not a writer. But I am a Reader of various genres.
This novel would be a great read for anyone who likes to read - a “Who did it” story and/or Anyone who likes to read stories about Life’s Journey with all it's truggles and rewards. This book has both.
I truly enjoyed this book.
This novel has two stories, intertwined . One is the mystery and search for the killer of Sean’s girlfriend . The second is Sean’s life journey, his personal struggles with the murder, his music career (which was going no where) , his day to day sales job , and his feeling of desperation and depression.
With all of this going on, there is a shining light in Sean’s life however, and that light just happens to be a young girl named , Keileigh, who although suffers with cancer ,has the “Joy de Vivre”.
In seeing her fight so hard with her sickness and her amazing attitude through it all , Sean begins to better appreciate his own life and all the things in it.
I found, I not only had to keep reading to find out, Who the Murder was, but gosh darn, I needed to see where Sean’s journey would take him.
I recommend you pick this book up to read. You will not be disappointed.
I would like to start off by Thanking, Keith Steinbaum for sending me a hard copy of his book.
And for that I am writing my honest review on this book.
In point form here the just of it:
TOTAL SCORE : 4 1/2 Stars.
Title: 4 stars, Why? Because it tied in very well to the story.
Book cover: 4 stars. Loved the cove , Why? Everything on it was a clues as to “Who did it”. And the black and white cover really works.
Writing style: 5 starts, I absolutely loved his style of writing. Beautifully written, easy to follow and read. I really liked his descriptions of various physical aspects of the characters.
Plot: 4 stars, good plot, nice flow to it.
OK, here it goes, I apologize in advance or my writing, as I am definitely not a writer. But I am a Reader of various genres.
This novel would be a great read for anyone who likes to read - a “Who did it” story and/or Anyone who likes to read stories about Life’s Journey with all it's truggles and rewards. This book has both.
I truly enjoyed this book.
This novel has two stories, intertwined . One is the mystery and search for the killer of Sean’s girlfriend . The second is Sean’s life journey, his personal struggles with the murder, his music career (which was going no where) , his day to day sales job , and his feeling of desperation and depression.
With all of this going on, there is a shining light in Sean’s life however, and that light just happens to be a young girl named , Keileigh, who although suffers with cancer ,has the “Joy de Vivre”.
In seeing her fight so hard with her sickness and her amazing attitude through it all , Sean begins to better appreciate his own life and all the things in it.
I found, I not only had to keep reading to find out, Who the Murder was, but gosh darn, I needed to see where Sean’s journey would take him.
I recommend you pick this book up to read. You will not be disappointed.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 106 reviews