I was given an ARC in exchange for my honest review... And I was NOT disappointed!
Prior to Caine’s devastating passing, Caine left a partial manuscript and a roadmap for the sixth book Trapper Road in the Stillhouse Lake series. Ryan, a close friend and someone who saw Caine as a mentor agreed to pick up where Caine left off so the readers of the series could have this book, and it is a genuine gift. I honestly couldn’t tell when exactly Ryan took over the writing, and this is a testament to Caine’s vision, back-catalogue, Ryan’s writing skills and a truly skilled editor who edited each of the books in the series. I was very impressed.
This is my favourite of the series. As a social worker and a trainee therapist, so much of this book was just so on the nose. It shows the ugliness and destructiveness of vengeance over justice and the danger of the mob that bays for blood when assuming polarising positions rather than being curious and leaving space for the possibility of multiple stories; nobody is 2D and there are so many shade of morality and thought processes, they rivals Dulux's colour chart. Without an ounce of sanctimonious sermonising, this book continues to shine a light on how important processing pain and grief is. It models how to have difficult conversations with your children, how to attempt to understand where they are at - even if it hurts and you reject their conclusions, and how to offer repair when you’ve done things wrong as a parent, all while moving the plot along. That is mind-blowing. The social worker and trainee therapist in me was jumping for joy because this rarely shown in novels.
Gwen’s partner, Sam, made a comment that I highlighted; “we’re doing the work every day. We’re seeing therapists, we’re talking, we’re moving forward. It’s a process, Gwen. It can’t happen overnight...” – this is so important, not just as reassurance for Gwen and showing ongoing Sam’s support and commitment, but as a general message to send out into the world. De-stigmatising therapy is so important. Thank you.
While the familial situation is uncommon (this series centres around Gwen Proctor as the ex-wife of a convicted serial killer and their children, Lanny and Connor), the fears that Gwen experiences in respect to modern day nightmares are all too common problems. Her worries about: the safety of her children, grooming, managing and navigating peer pressure or death threats via social media, teenage risk taking, male entitlement and toxicity within her son, first sexual experiences, and teenage secrecy are all relatable. This mix of the familiar and uncommon makes it all the more interesting as the usual stakes are higher and heightened. This book continues to build on themes of family, trust, and navigating betrayal across ages, gender, and all types of relationships. Gwen’s need to control her children’s lives, and hyper-vigilance make sense to me as they kept her alive, even six books in she’s still in survival mode, but these things are also powder kegs waiting to be ignited in her children. Hindsight, or any social worker/therapist, or savvy crime/thriller reader can see the portents for disaster (both usual teenage stuff or those associated with risks that likely to result in life or limb risks), and the tension is kept throughout. It’s just not clear where or when or which guillotine will fall. The twists are truly twisty and I didn’t see all of them coming - I was too busy enjoying the ride to analyse it all.
PTSD continues to be described accurately and extremely realistically, as well as grounding exercises, and sexual risk taking being utilised as a common coping mechanism, and attempts to connect.
This will not be a comfortable read for most (especially Americans), I would add a trigger warning that is also a mini spoiler… Stop reading if you don’t want to know:
---------------------------------
There’s also a school shooting - with the number of school shootings in the USA by young white males, I was wondering when this might come up as a scenario in this series prior to Caine’s passing. It may create some issues for people who have experienced this when they read those scenes.
----------------------------------
Gwen’s growth in this book is important for her character arc because there’s only so much that a parent or a character can remain at that high level of vigilance, regardless of trauma and training. Also, with Lanny reaching Uni age, it wouldn’t be feasible for Gwen not to reach this epiphany without the destruction of the mother daughter relationship. Connor reaching mid-teens is also another tumultuous time of change in any family life-cycle… Both kids are used as vehicles to explore how does trauma impact teens, how do you define good and evil, and is evil genetic?
I hope there’s more but if there isn’t, I’m still thankful.