Imagine a story in which a "Betty" and a "Veronica" type were BOTH protagonists worth rooting for.
This is that story.
When we get two very different but admirable-in-their-own-way heroines, one a petite, plucky ingenue and the other a stately, glamorous playgirl, each caught in a situation that puts her out of her depth and each trying valiantly to play to her own strengths, I'm already halfway there. Add some intriguing world-building, mystery, ominously powerful magical creatures, a dash of darkness, and an ending that makes me eager to get my hands on the sequel, and I'm sold.
I do have a couple of reservations, however. One is that I tend to prefer when protagonists, male or female, develop romantic attachments to people around their own age, people with whom they would naturally have more in common in terms of experience and outlook. Yet in this book, the naive teen spends a lot of her page time with a much older man, while the experienced thirtysomething (and it is very pleasing to see a fantasy heroine this age) spends a lot of her page time with a much younger man. As long as these attachments remain admiring but platonic, I'm okay with that, but I can't help getting a romantic vibe. I haven't been Spoiled at all. Maybe I'll turn out to be wrong. But I have to shake my head a little when I find I'm hoping the couples will NOT get together.
The other is a quibble, a very minor issue. With its contrasting heroines of disparate ages, this book is, for the most part, a gender Win. Yet in the course of the story we meet several animals -- the pseudo-hawk, the pseudo-hound, the pseudo-ferret, and the tiny flying reptile -- and every single one of them is male. This smacks of a trope I'm not fond of, "male as default gender." I have my doubts that English made them all male on purpose; I suspect she didn't think about it, which only shows how deeply ingrained "male as default gender" is.
Still and all, an enjoyable read, and I look forward to seeing where the story goes next, and how each of our heroines develops.