A highly enjoyable read, for the most part.
After reading and loving Jane Austen's novels many years ago, I've just started reading some other Regency novels. I began with Georgette Heyer and tried Eden's book after two of Heyer's fabulous novels. For me, Heyer feels like an author OF the Regency era and Eden feels like a 21st century author writing about the Regency era. Though Eden's book had a little more of your typical "romance" factor though it's very clean (she's very good at making innocent scenes totally swoony--riding in a carriage at night a mere few inches from one another, for example, nothing happens except the girl falls asleep with her head on the guy's chest -- but it's pretty sexy -- at least until the one of the other passengers snores, LOL!)
I really liked Phillip for the hero. The Jonqils are a wonderful family and he's now the head of it. The brothers are all great friends with one another, have the utmost respect for women, and most especially for their dear Mater. Sorrel was an interesting heroine. I appreciated her wit and her courage, but at times I got a bit annoyed by the constant references to her injury, her painful leg, her feelings of disappointment and heartbreak etc. Not that I didn't empathize with her, or feel that she should be a Pollyanna about everything, but it did get a tad tedious. Their enemies-to-friends-to-lovers relationship progression was, for the most part, well done. However, I found a few aspects rather infuriating, particularly the misunderstandings. The one in the beginning was necessary to set up the relationship, I suppose, but others were just annoying, such as when Sorrel finds a reason to suspect Philip isn't all that he says he is and she starts to doubt him... but then this is never touched on again! Then shortly after there's a misunderstanding that made me want to hurl the book against the wall, especially because these two are supposedly so intelligent and observant and Philip is renowned for tracking down French spies for goodness sake and the misunderstanding is something you'd see in a Hallmark movie.
Speaking of spies, I expected a bit more Scarlet Pimpernel type action but the spy subplot is almost completely ignored for the entire mid-section of the book and sections there dragged a bit for me. An entire chapter consists of Sorrel trying to get downstairs without her cane. Again, I appreciate her courage, and it did allow a few swoony moments with Philip coming to assist her (yet not in an obnoxious "oh, you weak female, let me help you" way -- he really is the only person who believes she is more than her lameness and builds up her confidence in herself, it's very well done!) BUT there is supposedly one of the top French spies nearby, whose capture would mean much to saving lives in the war, and I just don't think enough weight was given to that. It makes perfect sense that Philip would be distracted by Sorrel, but we still needed moments for him to come back to the weightier matter at hand. Fortunately, the last section of the book gets back on track with the spy capturing action and I thought it was done very well.
A few key aspects of the plot were never fully realized and I don't know if this was due to a rushed ending or because Eden wanted to leave it up to our own imaginations what happened. However, I really feel that the issue of Sorrel's leg needed to be addressed more fully. Was having a man fall in love with her all she needed to feel whole again? Maybe. Maybe that's fine. I don't know. It was the Regency era, after all, so marrying for love let alone for love to a very well off gentleman was an often unattainable goal for any woman let alone for one who believed no man would ever want her. It's just that after all the focus on how horrible her ailment was, the constant pain, the difficulty walking, etc. I guess I wanted just a bit more about whether she was, indeed, going to pursue further medical attention (obviously with Philips full approval and constant adoration and ministrations! ;-) Philip really was rather wonderful!)
All these quibbles aside, I really did enjoy the novel on the whole. It was immensely readable, and a wonderful "meeting of the minds" meets "swoony" romance and I would recommend it to fans of clean Regency romances.