What do you think?
Rate this book
The Innermost House
Raised in a nineteenth-century saltbox house in Wellfleet, Massachusetts, Cynthia Blakeley was both surrounded by generations of immediate and extended family and isolated by the mysteries locked inside her affectionate yet elusive mother and short-fused father. While she and her sisters and cousins roamed the Outer Cape—drinking in the dunes, swimming in kettle ponds, and dancing in Provincetown—Blakeley also turned to the inner world of her journals as she contended with her own secrets and memories.
Over-identifying with her unconventional and artistic mother, Blakeley felt certain that the key to understanding her mother’s drinking and distractions, her generosity and easy forgiveness, was the unexplained absence of two of Blakeley’s half-siblings and their connection to her mother’s unhappy first marriage. Blakeley kept her distance, however, from her disciplinarian father. Though he took his daughters sailing and clamming and beachcombing, he was the chill to their mother’s warmth, the maker, not the breaker, of rules. Slipping through these dynamics in that small house and evocative landscape, Blakeley eventually crossed the bridge and left home, only to return later in search of the family stories that would help her decode her present.
Blakeley’s captivating memoir moves fluidly through time, grappling with the question of who owns a memory or secret and how our narrative choices not only describe but also shape and change us. In this insightful and poignant account of tenacious year-rounders on Cape Cod, Blakeley contends that making sense of ourselves is a collaborative affair, one that begins with understanding those we came from.
Over-identifying with her unconventional and artistic mother, Blakeley felt certain that the key to understanding her mother’s drinking and distractions, her generosity and easy forgiveness, was the unexplained absence of two of Blakeley’s half-siblings and their connection to her mother’s unhappy first marriage. Blakeley kept her distance, however, from her disciplinarian father. Though he took his daughters sailing and clamming and beachcombing, he was the chill to their mother’s warmth, the maker, not the breaker, of rules. Slipping through these dynamics in that small house and evocative landscape, Blakeley eventually crossed the bridge and left home, only to return later in search of the family stories that would help her decode her present.
Blakeley’s captivating memoir moves fluidly through time, grappling with the question of who owns a memory or secret and how our narrative choices not only describe but also shape and change us. In this insightful and poignant account of tenacious year-rounders on Cape Cod, Blakeley contends that making sense of ourselves is a collaborative affair, one that begins with understanding those we came from.
- GenresMemoirNonfiction
276 pages, Paperback
Published December 1, 2024
17 people are currently reading
3191 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 19 of 19 reviews
November 27, 2024
This is one of the most beautifully written memoirs and books that I have recently read.
I am of the idea that memoirs need even a more interesting shape and writing style than plot driven fiction.
I enjoyed the insights into the arts scene, and the author’s citations and complementary notes read like the rest of the book, which is rare. Such a breeze!
Thank you #netgalley.
I am of the idea that memoirs need even a more interesting shape and writing style than plot driven fiction.
I enjoyed the insights into the arts scene, and the author’s citations and complementary notes read like the rest of the book, which is rare. Such a breeze!
Thank you #netgalley.
August 31, 2024
I have a visceral reaction to anything which is even tangentially about Cape Cod. I grew up spending summers there staying with family friends who owned a house on the Cape. When I saw that The Innermost House by Cynthia Blakeley was about her childhood growing up in Wellfleet on the Cape, I knew I had to give it a read. I was left disappointed.
As with all memoirs I rate, a disclaimer is needed. My rating of the book has nothing to do with Blakeley's life experience. My rating is entirely based upon how well the author presents and explains those life experiences to the reader. Also, Blakeley does not use the setting of Cape Cod very often as part of her narrative. For the most part, her stories could happen at any beach town which has the ebb and flows of summer migration. This was personally disappointing, but I didn't ding the book for it because the story is what is important.
Blakeley has had an interesting life with many colorful characters around her. Some of these people are loving but with their own quirks. Others are malevolent and readers should be warned that a sexual assault is depicted rather graphically. There are many ways Blakeley can tell these stories for the readers to take away some sort of life lesson or realization. We all have our memories where maybe we had family members who were our favorite while a sibling hated them or our first crush in high school. The issue with this book is not the subject matter because there are many avenues for Blakeley to explore.
The problem comes down to execution and lack of clear purpose. Blakeley's chapters cover various topics and jump in time periods. For example, one chapter deals with her father and their relationship up until his death and the aftermath. Following chapters will then jump back to a time when her father was alive and then back again. While a memoir does not have to be linear, the reader needs to feel comfortable with how stories fall in the timeline. I was consistently forced to stop and think about how old the author was and who was alive, dead, off in Vietnam, or married. Characters will also be put into the narrative only to disappear without any resolution.
The lack of clear purpose is what truly ruined the book for me. Blakeley will often drone on with comments about dreams and memories. Blakeley
has experience with dreams and psychoanalysis, but she does not provide this information in a way which convinces the reader that she is making a point steeped in sturdy science. These diatribes often break the flow of a truly interesting family story. Instead of insight to what we just read, it sounds like someone who is talking off the top of their head and never reaching an actual conclusion about what it all means. This was a major problem for me because Blakeley even discusses in the book that much of her research required speaking to her mother and grandmother who were seemingly re-traumatized by her questioning of their histories. Ultimately, I don't think Blakeley makes a strong enough point to the reader that this was all worth it.
(This book was provided as an advance copy by Netgalley and the University of Massachusetts Press.)
As with all memoirs I rate, a disclaimer is needed. My rating of the book has nothing to do with Blakeley's life experience. My rating is entirely based upon how well the author presents and explains those life experiences to the reader. Also, Blakeley does not use the setting of Cape Cod very often as part of her narrative. For the most part, her stories could happen at any beach town which has the ebb and flows of summer migration. This was personally disappointing, but I didn't ding the book for it because the story is what is important.
Blakeley has had an interesting life with many colorful characters around her. Some of these people are loving but with their own quirks. Others are malevolent and readers should be warned that a sexual assault is depicted rather graphically. There are many ways Blakeley can tell these stories for the readers to take away some sort of life lesson or realization. We all have our memories where maybe we had family members who were our favorite while a sibling hated them or our first crush in high school. The issue with this book is not the subject matter because there are many avenues for Blakeley to explore.
The problem comes down to execution and lack of clear purpose. Blakeley's chapters cover various topics and jump in time periods. For example, one chapter deals with her father and their relationship up until his death and the aftermath. Following chapters will then jump back to a time when her father was alive and then back again. While a memoir does not have to be linear, the reader needs to feel comfortable with how stories fall in the timeline. I was consistently forced to stop and think about how old the author was and who was alive, dead, off in Vietnam, or married. Characters will also be put into the narrative only to disappear without any resolution.
The lack of clear purpose is what truly ruined the book for me. Blakeley will often drone on with comments about dreams and memories. Blakeley
has experience with dreams and psychoanalysis, but she does not provide this information in a way which convinces the reader that she is making a point steeped in sturdy science. These diatribes often break the flow of a truly interesting family story. Instead of insight to what we just read, it sounds like someone who is talking off the top of their head and never reaching an actual conclusion about what it all means. This was a major problem for me because Blakeley even discusses in the book that much of her research required speaking to her mother and grandmother who were seemingly re-traumatized by her questioning of their histories. Ultimately, I don't think Blakeley makes a strong enough point to the reader that this was all worth it.
(This book was provided as an advance copy by Netgalley and the University of Massachusetts Press.)
December 18, 2024
This was not what I expected from a memoir based in Cape Cod. It was much deeper than the sun, sand and fried clams that I expected. The author had a difficult childhood with challenging parents, homelife and at times, schooling. Not to mention one shocking incident that I won't mention due to it being a spoiler. I Googled the author and it appears her life has turned out well and she has been successful. One thing - please fix Newberry Street in Boston to Newbury. An easily checked error.
August 18, 2025
Fantastic. A memoir, but also a discourse and exploration on the foibles of memory. The title is not only fitting for a memoir - the “innermost house” being oneself - but also a nod to the classic Cape Cod book The Outermost House. The Wellfleet details were perfect.
June 13, 2025
I absolutely love memoirs written by non-celebrities/non-famous people, and this one is a bonus for taking place on Cape Cod, though I’m more familiar with the Upper Cape than the Outer Cape. I’ve also read The Outermost House: A Year of Life On The Great Beach of Cape Cod, which the title of this book references.
What I found interesting about this book, and something I’ve learned in therapy, is that everyone has their own truth, and it can vary widely from the truth you know. It was most evident in Blakeley’s recounting of reconnecting with her childhood bully, who later became a good friend of hers. The friend really doesn’t remember how badly she targeted Blakeley that year, though everyone else seemed to have seen it as well. To her credit, she never dismisses Blakeley’s story and openly apologizes for her behavior then. It’s also interesting that Blakeley’s mother Shirley doesn’t remember how Blakeley’s father physically abused her and had a violent temper, while Blakeley absolutely recalls those aspects of her father. I did appreciate the chapter in which Blakeley was able to come to some sort of terms with her father, though he was deceased. While some people are simply evil, a lot of people who hurt others do so because they were themselves hurt. I’m not here to advocate blanket forgiveness for anyone who abuses others because context matters a whole lot, but there are some people we can have compassion for, and I do agree that Blakeley’s father seems to land in that category.
There are times that this book gets a bit too into the woo factor, with Blakeley recalling and analyzing dreams, but then that’s what she wrote her PhD dissertation on. This memoir is a really vulnerable recollection of a life full of pain and hurt, not always done to her — sometimes she herself has been the agent of pain and hurt. It is quite intriguing to read a memoir that is so honest.
I will say that even though Blakeley’s mother Shirley struggled with alcoholism, she is the one person in this narrative that I would have connected the most with. She seemed like a person with a lot of love and compassion to give.
What I found interesting about this book, and something I’ve learned in therapy, is that everyone has their own truth, and it can vary widely from the truth you know. It was most evident in Blakeley’s recounting of reconnecting with her childhood bully, who later became a good friend of hers. The friend really doesn’t remember how badly she targeted Blakeley that year, though everyone else seemed to have seen it as well. To her credit, she never dismisses Blakeley’s story and openly apologizes for her behavior then. It’s also interesting that Blakeley’s mother Shirley doesn’t remember how Blakeley’s father physically abused her and had a violent temper, while Blakeley absolutely recalls those aspects of her father. I did appreciate the chapter in which Blakeley was able to come to some sort of terms with her father, though he was deceased. While some people are simply evil, a lot of people who hurt others do so because they were themselves hurt. I’m not here to advocate blanket forgiveness for anyone who abuses others because context matters a whole lot, but there are some people we can have compassion for, and I do agree that Blakeley’s father seems to land in that category.
There are times that this book gets a bit too into the woo factor, with Blakeley recalling and analyzing dreams, but then that’s what she wrote her PhD dissertation on. This memoir is a really vulnerable recollection of a life full of pain and hurt, not always done to her — sometimes she herself has been the agent of pain and hurt. It is quite intriguing to read a memoir that is so honest.
I will say that even though Blakeley’s mother Shirley struggled with alcoholism, she is the one person in this narrative that I would have connected the most with. She seemed like a person with a lot of love and compassion to give.
October 10, 2025
At first glance, a spider’s web might appear to be a tangled mess. So might the stories that shape Cynthia’s memories and memoir. Nothing could be further from the truth. She weaves a beautiful story from questions, fragmented memories and events that are downright tragic. And yet, the through line of this memoir is one of the resilience and stability of an extraordinary writer and individual whose words become a tapestry of deep meaning and insight.
May 16, 2025
Honest and moving.
December 6, 2024
Thought this memoir would focus on Cape Code but it was more about how people perceive events in shared lives differently than others and even differently in later years of their own life. Blakeley talks to many people to get a more complete version of events that she remembered sometimes confusing because of the changing timeline and overwritten, this was still an interesting exploration of her life.
February 24, 2025
Thought provoking. Gave me validation that my version is my version of things and my sister’s version is hers.
Plus growing up in the next town I knew all the names and worked with her mother. She was a special person
Plus growing up in the next town I knew all the names and worked with her mother. She was a special person
January 13, 2025
Absolutely wonderful! I can comfortably say this is the best memoir that I have read. It was beyond just a memoir, it also felt like an analysis of what memoir is.
Thank you to Goodreads and University of Massachusetts press for the #giveaway
Thank you to Goodreads and University of Massachusetts press for the #giveaway
December 21, 2024
Innermost House is a powerful work of self discovery. Cynthia Blakely rips off bandages to reveal the family story of struggle, pain, dysfunction, abuse, but also acceptance, love and humanity. The author traces the history behind the family’s generational trauma to discover the roots of her own childhood struggles. The book has a good start but like a train barreling down the tracks, it gains compelling
momentum that leads to a heart warming and inspiring conclusion. Blakely has applied her own expertise regarding memory to help unravel the events of her life. While we may not have experienced the same chaotic life, we are there with her as she strives to make sense of her family and environment.
To add clarity - I also grew up in Wellfleet about ten years earlier than Blakely and knew some of the people she mentions (despite the pseudonyms). I had a far different childhood but a number of my friends experienced similar difficulties. Many year round locals struggle to make ends meet in a seasonal economy and the rates of alcohol and substance abuse are much higher than the state average. Wellfleet is a beautiful town with lots of great people but the lack of affordable housing and well paying year round jobs force many locals into trying circumstances.
momentum that leads to a heart warming and inspiring conclusion. Blakely has applied her own expertise regarding memory to help unravel the events of her life. While we may not have experienced the same chaotic life, we are there with her as she strives to make sense of her family and environment.
To add clarity - I also grew up in Wellfleet about ten years earlier than Blakely and knew some of the people she mentions (despite the pseudonyms). I had a far different childhood but a number of my friends experienced similar difficulties. Many year round locals struggle to make ends meet in a seasonal economy and the rates of alcohol and substance abuse are much higher than the state average. Wellfleet is a beautiful town with lots of great people but the lack of affordable housing and well paying year round jobs force many locals into trying circumstances.
February 6, 2026
Cynthia Blakeley’s The Innermost House is a memoir shaped like the landscape it inhabits wind worn, luminous, and layered with quiet histories. Set in a nineteenth century saltbox on Cape Cod, the book moves gracefully between the outer world of dunes, ponds, and Provincetown summers and the more complicated interior terrain of family loyalties and unspoken secrets.
Blakeley writes with tenderness about the gravitational pull of her artistic, unpredictable mother and the cooler steadiness of her rule bound father, capturing how a child learns to read a household the way others read weather. Her search for the truth about absent half siblings becomes less a detective story than an exploration of how memory is shared property shaped by what is told, withheld, or simply forgotten.
Rich with place and emotional honesty, The Innermost House shows how returning home can be an act of interpretation as much as reunion, and how the stories we inherit continue to revise us long after we believe we’ve left.
Blakeley writes with tenderness about the gravitational pull of her artistic, unpredictable mother and the cooler steadiness of her rule bound father, capturing how a child learns to read a household the way others read weather. Her search for the truth about absent half siblings becomes less a detective story than an exploration of how memory is shared property shaped by what is told, withheld, or simply forgotten.
Rich with place and emotional honesty, The Innermost House shows how returning home can be an act of interpretation as much as reunion, and how the stories we inherit continue to revise us long after we believe we’ve left.
November 27, 2024
This is a lyrical and moving memoir that reflects time and place in a magical way. Set in Wellfleet, Massachusetts with a large extended family and close knit community, the author sorts out a childhood mix of remembered and forgotten neglect, trauma, close ties, and warm affection in varying degrees. As an adult, she searches for the missing pieces of her family’s history and looks closely and compassionately at three generations of women who had to make their own luck or cope with the lack thereof. She takes the reader along as she reconsiders her personal story by looking back, asking questions, seeking reconnection, and actively listening to the recollections of others. This brave exploration of a complicated family with both an open heart and an open mind results in a thrilling and meaningful narrative. Beautifully written and thoughtfully considered, it caused me to reflect more deeply on my own family’s chronicle. Highly recommended as a contemplative and satisfying read.
October 27, 2025
The Innermost House by Cynthia Blakeley is published by The University of Massachusetts Press. Being a native Massachusetts resident and a UMass Amherst alum myself was the first reason I was drawn to the book. I have always loved Cape Cod. I enjoy reading books in settings I am familiar with, and the Cape is beautiful. As I delved into the book, I realized there are other reasons I would be drawn to it. It is a memoir, so realistically, it is not just painting the Cape as a beautiful place. It gives you a little snapshot of what's inside. Also, the author touches upon the value of story and memory in our lives. Without the ability to frame our lives in stories, there would be no life lessons. We would not learn from experience, as the author certainly has. I am glad that she shared her story with us.
August 16, 2024
THE INNERMOST HOUSE is billed as a memoir, but it’s more like a PhD dissertation about memory or even a “how-to-write-a-memoir” manual, with attention paid to the act of constructing the book you're reading. Don’t go in expecting one cohesive narrative; rather, each chapter explores a different “theme” in the author’s life.
October 13, 2025
This is not so much a story of growing up as a year rounder on the Cape (which is what I was looking for).
It’s more a story of abuse and how our memories and revisiting those memories change and shape our life.
I typically love memoirs and this was okay, but not much my taste.
I did enjoy the honest and authentic view of a family’s history and experiences.
It’s more a story of abuse and how our memories and revisiting those memories change and shape our life.
I typically love memoirs and this was okay, but not much my taste.
I did enjoy the honest and authentic view of a family’s history and experiences.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 20, 2024
This is a penetrating, highly intelligent memoir. The author relates her family’s complicated story and simultaneously considers her own reliability and memory. It reminds me of Mary McCarthy’s memoir in terms of self-awareness and strong voice, and perhaps supersedes it.
December 27, 2025
Weaving personal narrative with research into the workings of memory, Cynthia Blakeley writes a compelling memoir that prompts the reader to think deeply about her/his relationship to life experiences and the people with whom she/he has shared those experiences.
November 14, 2025
Good memoir, and loved it at the Cape, but really didn’t like the characters
Displaying 1 - 19 of 19 reviews