Not a fan. First off, it started way too slow for me. I couldn’t get myself to read more than 10-20 pages a day and that never happens. Second, I couldn’t believe how unlikable almost every single female character was.
Alice sucks from start to finish, which luckily ended up being the point. But honestly she disturbed me. I’m all for a woman wanting a big career but she basically sucks at her lawyer job, only cares about the nursery because of fame, and is uninvolved in her family. She barely even does her work for the law firm yet chooses to spend so much time there instead of coming home because she’s salty that her kids like their dad more?? Then, when Simon says he’s leaving her, all she’s thinking about is her career and how she can use this position herself better. I’m glad she didn’t have a redemption because it wouldn’t have worked but even at the end I hated how unbelievably selfish she was.
I’m glad Georgia and Beth had their redemption moments at the end but I still didn’t like their characters. Georgia has a daughter who is terminally ill, and to deal with the stress, Georgia starts taking pills and becomes addicted. The moment I decided I hated her was when her husband, Kasper, tells her that her daughter really isn’t doing well and she, who is nervous she left her pill bottle somewhere, says “I got to go” and leaves. Then, after a FAR-FETCHED coincidence (which I’ll want about in a bit), she gets more pills which her daughter finds and overdoses with. The fact that she left the pills just casually in a medicine cabinet is beyond me.
Next, we have Beth. I appreciate that she told the truth later on but, I still don’t care for her character. She’s been through a lot, I’m glad she was able to build a new life for herself. But, to decide to leave and break her husband and step-kids hearts instead of just telling them about her past is BEYOND selfish. It’d be one thing if she had the type of past where she couldn’t be involved with law enforcement but in this case, she could’ve easily gone to the police. A convicted felon, who she testified against, is trying to find her. The cops would’ve helped. Rather raise your kid alone on the run and break your family apart than tell them the truth????
Lenore was fine. She had problems but she was working through it and she was a good mother. I do think it’s nuts that she just moves her and her daughter away from her husband to prove she can be a good mother, but I also have no idea what it’d be like to be in her position dealing with postpartum, so I’ll let that slide.
Now, onto the plot. First off, Beth calling Jess and revealing all of her information (where she lives, what she does for work) prior to Jess actually speaking on the call bothered me. No one really does this?? I get rambling, but if you’ve been running from your past for YEARS and then call a person connected to that life, you do NOT just start telling them everything immediately. ESPECIALLY when the person hasn’t actually said words on the call. Of COURSE, the person on the other end of the phone was not Jess, the intended recipient, but the ex that Beth had run away from. (Also, what did actually happen to Jess??). This just bothered me so much because she does so much to hide her past and become invisible and then to just give it all away like that made no sense.
Another horribly done coincidence was when Georgia went to buy drugs. You’re telling me that after Beth’s call, her ex (Curtis), happened to find a place & start selling drugs in the area IMMEDIATELY and that that place is exactly where Georgia goes to buy drugs for the first time. AND, Georgia wearing her work outfit?????
I just felt like all these women were made out to sound like idiots. Who divulges their life they’ve kept secret on a phone call with no recipient? Who buys drugs in a “sketchy neighborhood” in their work outfits? Who responds to hearing that their daughter isn’t doing well with “I got to go”? Who chooses to leave their family “to protect them” when realistically Curtis would’ve easily used them as leverage to get her back in town??
I’m glad that James ended up being a POS because I was a little sick of all the women being the bad guys. Also glad that the truth came out about what happened at the Nest because I was worried the 2nd car accident was going to torpedo that narrative. But still overall it was pretty bad & I just had to finish because I’ll always finish a book.