The Malleus Maleficarum is one of the best-known treatises dealing with the problem of what to do with witches. It was written in 1487 by a Dominican inquisitor, Heinrich Institoris, following his failure to prosecute a number of women for witchcraft, it is in many ways a highly personal document, full of frustration at official complacency in the face of a spiritual threat, as well as being a practical guide for law-officers who have to deal with a cunning, dangerous enemy. Combining theological discussion, illustrative anecdotes, and useful advice for those involved in suppressing witchcraft, its influence on witchcraft studies has been extensive.
The only previous translation into English, that by Montague Summers produced in 1928, is full of inaccuracies. It is written in a style almost unreadable nowadays, and is unfortunately coloured by his personal agenda. This new edited translation, with an introductory essay setting witchcraft, Institoris, and the Malleus into clear, readable English, corrects Summers’ mistakes and offers a lean, unvarnished version of what Institoris actually wrote. It will undoubtedly become the standard translation of this important and controversial late-medieval text.
Peter G. Maxwell-Stuart is a Research Fellow in the Department of History at the University of Aberdeen and an Honorary Lecturer in the Department of History in the University of St. Andrews.
5 stars for the WONDERFUL introduction and translation. A beautifully presented version of what is without a doubt the most paranoid, bizarre, and downright evil pile of garbage I've ever had the displeasure of reading.
The introductory historical points for media influence analysis of the book, towards actual impact in Holy Inquisitorial practices, was exactly what I wanted to know. Will drop at 12% until I find interest in reading further again. =)
Point in case, this paranoid part essay-manual, influenced majorly only German demonology. The ambience in which it was used and critiqued had many other authors and publications regarding witchcraft at the time, for their own purposes of clergical advancement (e.g. Dominicans vs Franciscans) at the expense of medieval concepts of theology and gender physiology/psychology.
This book was mentioned in Margaret Alice Murray’s The God Of The Witches, and I was surprised to find a copy sitting on the university stacks. P.G. Maxwell-Stuart’s translation is excellent, though it did take me a while to get used to the format, much in the same way my long-ago readings of Inferno and The Iliad went. There is no plot, nor satisfying conclusion; this is not a book that one would sit down and read for pleasure. It’s a witch hunter’s manual, and all the more fascinating because it was really used on our timeline to determine if actual people were burned at stakes in town squares.
The Malleus was originally written in Latin by Institoris, a rather zealous inquisitor who I like to picture as a medieval master of misinformation. Here, hundreds of years after the fact, is a prime example of a man who was overeducated in a narrow discipline without perspective. He often misquotes and mis-cites his sources, and twists scripture to best fit the execution of his duties. Though beneath all the delusion and self-righteous justification, I can’t help but wonder how much actual witchcraft was occurring at that time (or nowadays, for that matter). Between this and Murray’s book it’s not hard to think that there must have been some basis in fact for the rise of inquisitorial action against (alleged) sorcerous heretics.
Maxwell-Stuart is a far superior researcher to Institoris. There are eighty-six primary sources listed in the select bibliography for this edition of the Malleus—a lifetime of study should one be so inclined. I think it’s enough for me to know that the materials exist. Perhaps someday I’ll revisit this corner of history with a pickaxe in one hand and a crucifix in the other…
A closing note here: this read, of all the books I’ve read in my near half-century, was the first to bring home the true value of reading for the sake of reading, as a writer. As I read through Institoris’s ramblings I was presciently aware that I would likely never directly use any of the material that I was consuming, but I also knew that on some level, on some archival sub-basement of my brain, everything was being stored just in case.
What a thing to realize. I’m just sorry it took this long.
This translation does make me consider reading a Latin facsimile if not attempting access to an early edition, although I am now certain Heinrich Kramer (Henricus Institoris) was an absolute imbecile.
A note on the translator’s perspective:
Maxwell-Stuart should not under any circumstances refer to the modern feminist reaction to this medieval religious tract as hysterical. This is reductive and sexist. Additional authors notes need to be added as a warning about the contemporaneous historical context the translator has chosen to pursue, with clearer explanations (not justifications) of why the text, in Maxwell-Stuart’s opinion, is not misogynistic but skewed towards a patriarchal pre-reformation Catholic (Dominican) perspective. Brushing off negative reactions to translations as modern feminist hysteria is disgusting and speaks volumes of the translator’s own misogyny. Yes, this period of history was violently patriarchal, and women were little more than chattel slaves owned by their fathers, brothers and husbands, but Henricus Institoris’ open hatred (and almost incomprehensible misunderstandings) of women pushes at the borders of standard period comprehension. Institoris was responsible for mass femicide and should not be defended as simply a man of his time.
In addition, further information on disputes between medieval Catholics and Jews, including references to ALL Papal Bulls regarding pogroms, needs to be discussed. Antisemitism was an ongoing issue for medieval Catholics, something Institoris goes to no effort to hide. Even at the time of printing, this text was in violation of the Sicut Judaeis (1120).
Maxwell-Stuart’s text is also lacking a reference list and/or further reading list. Texts are referenced in footnotes, but there is no concentrated list of citations. This is a small, irritating formatting issue for academic readers who may wish to read referenced texts.
Reader note: I would not recommend this translation (or this text) to feminists. Read Margaret Atwood’s Handmaid’s Tale instead. Yes, the Handmaid’s Tale is fiction, but the visceral understanding of the Malleus Maleificarum in that novel is second to none.
Giving the book one star because the content got thousands of innocents killed. However, I think it was a fascinating and horrifying read into the minds of those filled with stupid hatred. Parts of the book were even empowering, as the fear the author had of powerful women was astonishing. Weak men are afraid of us.
De introductie was indrukwekkend; wat een onderzoek! De Malleus wordt veel geciteerd en gebruikt in discussies en literatuur over de ‘heksenjachten’, en ik vind het belangrijk om toegang te hebben tot een goede vertaling. 👍
I’m glad I’ve finally read it but I’ll never read it again. Good for the novelty factor, but it is, essentially, a legal treatise, and not even one of the better written ones.