1 star due to lots (lots) of issues. This book was really frustrating to read.
Firstly, there were a metric f-ton of typos and repeated sentences, such as:
It was so rare that he appeared in public he’d been in public like this,
Emeric straightened and met the councillors’ gazes head-on. “I trust that won’t be a problem?”
“I trust that won’t be a problem?” Emeric asked, his voice a challenge. A dare.
Then there were lots of misspellings, wonky grammar, bad formatting, etc., such as:
unbiddden (should be "unbidden")
itm ust (should be "it must")
He smilesd, (should be "He smiled")
So many of them were painfully obvious, and yet they made it through, like writing "Julia" instead of Julian.
There was also a lot of strange wording, such as:
his soles ponderous against the cold floors.
Soles cannot be ponderous - seriously, look at the bottom of your own foot and try to imagine using ponderous as a descriptor. I think the author meant something like "one's footsteps were ponderous." Maybe.
Quite honestly, I'm probably the last person who should be acting like the grammar police, but really, there were just SO many truly blatant instances that it became quite maddening.
There was also a real lack of continuity. The first time Julian's eyes are described, we read that they are "a deep, stormy gray." Later on, Emeric comments on Julian's eye color again and we read about the "deep brown of his eyes" - in fact, there are two times that Julian's eyes are described as brown. There's a similar issue with Emeric's hair color - we first read a description that it is white, but then later on Julian calls it "the dark sweep of his hair."
Another example is a point where the Important Relic (I won't reveal more) is described as being held by Emeric, but then "Julian looked back down at the artifact in his hands" (where "his" is strongly implied as being Julian in this case). The confusion continues as we wrap up this scene with:
The (relic to be announced) rested innocuously in Julian’s hands now, his eyes wide with wonder, and Emeric couldn’t help but smile. This was what he’d hoped for, when he first took Julian on as his apprentice: the thrill of discovery, the chance to uncover something that could change the course of history. “Careful,” Emeric said as Julian reached for the (relic to be announced)."
So Julian is holding it, then it somehow teleports into Emeric's hand, then back to Julian, who then has to reach for . . . a thing in his own hands? This is the point where I threw up my hands and wrote "OK, who the hell is holding this thing?" in my Kindle notes.
There are also instances where both MC's are interacting and male pronouns are used in a manner that leaves you wondering just which "he/him/his" is being referred to at any give point in the interaction/dialogue. I know that pronouns are particularly tricky when referring to same sex individuals, but there were a few places where there could have been more clarity on exactly who was doing/saying what.
To sum it up, if there was an editor for this book (dubious at best), they need to look for a different line of work. I ended up with an absolute laundry list of typos/issues, every one of which broke up the flow of the story, which had more than enough issues to begin with.
Moving on beyond grammar, spelling, formatting, et al, I had some real dislikes about the story/characters. To start with, this book is described as "cozy", which I believe usually means that said book will not have any sex on the page; well, this supposedly "cozy" book definitely did have sex on the page in several places. The way this book is written outside of the sex scenes made those scenes feel like an uncomfortable intrusion of a completely different writing style. Now, to be clear, I don't mind sex in a book, but in this particular book the overall tone of the MC's relationship is strongly portrayed as being of a G-rated variety of attraction. This makes it feel really bizarre/startling when we suddenly get a scene dropped in that incorporates very specific body parts and very specific "tab A goes into slot B" type descriptions.
Even if this wasn't being marketed as "cozy", I was unable to buy into Emeric being sexual or capable of intimacy. While the author has Julian make occasional references about Emeric having a nice body and being in some manner good-looking, I just couldn't conceive of this character as anything other than a crotchety old man who liked to bang his cane on the floor to make a point and who was completely non-sexual in nature. Granted, Julian didn't come across as particularly sexual/passionate either, but at least his character was clearly delineated as someone who would be open to a physical relationship - but certainly not with a character that comes across as rigid, sterile, and pretty much incapable of intimate interaction. To add to the oddity of this partnership, once these two do have sex, the next day they revert back to interacting in a manner that contains no intimacy or emotions. The way their interactions are written, it's like a switch goes off and on regarding intimacy and sex, which comes across as weird and even jarring.
There's not a lot to like about the pairing of these two. The plot line that causes the two to break up (aka your standard late-in-the-book dose of miscommunication and incorrect assumptions) made Julian seem like an infuriatingly hypocritical jerk, which is compounded by the fact that Julian KNOWS he's being an infuriatingly hypocritical jerk but is hell-bent on having his feathers in a kerfluffle because he was accused of a specific thing that he didn't do. In other words, Emeric implies that Julian has screwed him over based on a theft, Julian gets all pissy about being accused of such a thing and rides off on his high horse, despite the fact that Julian literally was screwing Emeric over in a different way, well before the theft. So we have to endure Julian going through a whole range of existential angst as he ping-pongs between being pissed off and being ashamed:
We start with Julian telling Emeric:
“You’re a coward,” he spat.
Not sure how the hell Julian comes up with calling Emeric a "coward", but anyway . . . this leads to:
“I thought . . .” Julian’s voice cracked, and Emeric felt his heart shatter with it. “I thought we had something special.
Which leads to Julian thinking about himself:
He’d deserved it, of course. He was nothing but a liar and a coward, and now he’d lost the only thing that mattered to him.
Yep, that is correct - especially the ironic use of the word "coward" to describe himself this time. Anyway, this leads to:
Julian may have deserved Emeric’s scorn, but not for the reasons Emeric thought. And the reasons Emeric thought were foolish.
The wording "the reasons Emeric thought" doesn't make sense as written, but I suppose I got the gist of this rationale, erroneous as it is. This then leads to Julian thinking:
But it didn’t change things. It didn’t change the fact that Julian had betrayed him.
Did you get all that? You'd need a scorecard to figure out where Julian's pea brain is from minute to minute. And then his numerous ruminations lead him to this stunning conclusion:
But . . . what could he do?
Oh, for the love of God, you idiot. Pardon me while I smack this dumbass kid. Hell's bells, Julian - maybe you could have taken up one of Emeric's multiple and very genuine offers where he told you that "you can talk to me about anything"? For god's sake, Emeric even makes the offer again, after Julian runs off to have his dramatic pissy fit:
“But I hope you know you can talk to me about whatever’s troubling you.”
Of course, rather than do that, Julian spills everything to someone else, who then quite sensibly tells him "“You’re a damned idiot, Jules.” Yep, my feelings exactly.
This book was just strange all the way around. The best part of it was the cover, which is really intriguing. Unfortunately, the characters on the cover remained as two-dimensional as a screenshot and were made to navigate through a very awkward set of circumstances, none of which came close to creating a sense of romance, much less HEA. I was left scratching my head over the whole thing.
Cannot recommend reading this; what I DO recommend is for this author to hunt down a real editor and take their lumps before they publish anything further. This was downright painful.