An interesting collection of short stories, with some being better than others. While some are good, and all definitely have very 'Dostoevsky' themes, I don't think that short stories are his best medium. His dry writing style is much better suited to his longer novels. However, if you are a fan and have read his other books, I think you will enjoy this collection.
I'll review/rank in order of how good I thought they were:
Great/must read
- The Dream of a Ridiculous Man: Feels like a chapter straight out of "The Brothers Karamazov." Philosophical, existential, mystical, it deals with themes of depression, madness, society, hope, and human love. I read a quote that said this was Dostoevsky's philosophy in twenty pages. Maybe one of my favorite short stories ever.
- White Nights: A romantic classic from Dostoevsky's early days. It deserves the hype and is a great short story. It is a story of a lonely and idealistic young man who falls in love with a woman he meets on the street. It is sort of an anti-romance, which critiques romanticism while being romantic. While I liked it, it is quite different than Dostoevsky in his later period.
- The Heavenly Christmas Tree: A social commentary on child poverty. Feels very Dickensian. A touching and socially important story, it highlights Dostoevsky's attitude towards the plight of children.
Good/worth the read
- Mr. Prohartchin: An interesting story about a miserly old man who holds surprising secrets. I liked how it portrayed a marginalized person in society and showed how people's prejudices are often incorrect. A little rough around the edges and confusing in some moments.
- The Peasant Marey: A beautiful vignette about a child Dostoevsky's interaction with a kind peasant.
- A Christmas Treet and a Wedding: Social commentary about abuse and the messed-up situations that happen in society. Dostoevsky's psychological realism and concern for children are on display here.
- A Novel in Nine Letters: I think this one is actually pretty funny. A friendship falls apart in a darkly comedic way because of logistical miscommunication.
Didn't Like
- An Honest Thief: Sort of like Mr. Prohartchin, but the story didn't really work, in my opinion.
- Another Man's Wife and the Husband Under the Bed: Seemed like an attempt at slapstick comedy. I didn't really find it funny and was pretty confused most of the time.
- A Little Hero: Even though this one was pretty well written, I don't think the story worked. An eleven-year-old boy falls in love with an adult woman and goes on a quixotic quest to win her over. The themes and message are very similar to White Nights. However, the narrator isn't believable, and the story is kind of creepy.
If you're a Dostoevsky fan, this collection is worth your time. Don't go for these over his novels, which are his real achievement. Easy reads full of classic Dostoevsky themes.