Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Shouldn't Have Come

Rate this book
Shouldn’t Have Come merges Her Soul to Take with The Four Horsemen series by Laura Thalassa into a horror romance set in a haunted motel. The harbingers are hot, deadly, and queer, the heroine won’t choose, and everybody wins at the end… well, mostly. This is a paranormal dark monster romance dripping with depravity and spice. It is very smutty and strictly for adults—please check the Reader’s Advisory before reading.

What happens when a void witch who has nothing left to lose accidentally summons the four horsemen who are all monsters? Well, she can either submit, fight, or fall...

Valeria is feared for her magic, and it's bad for business. When she gets a big offer, a séance on live tv during a full moon, she can't resist. Ignoring the red flags, she's determined to be seen, to be heard. But when the ritual goes to shit and the four horsemen are unleashed and she's forced into a corner. They want her, exactly as she is, to be theirs. People are dying and Valeria needs to make her choice. Who does she choose to save?

This book features pansexual and non-binary rep, themes of mental illness, bullying, and, above all, self-acceptance. The spice is depraved, the aftercare is real, and the HEA is well-earned.

204 pages, Kindle Edition

Published March 1, 2024

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Sloane Sabel

6 books14 followers
Sloane Sabel is the pen name of a neurodivergent, queer, writer and witch of the woods. Drawing from her love of horror, she crafts morally ambiguous tales with high stakes and hot monsters. After all, there’s nothing quite like a harbinger of the apocalypse on their knees.

Find her on instagram: @authorsloanesabel

Embrace your darkness.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
68 (13%)
4 stars
117 (22%)
3 stars
150 (29%)
2 stars
105 (20%)
1 star
77 (14%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 73 reviews
Profile Image for Erin.
300 reviews7 followers
May 1, 2024
I’m not entirely sure what i just read
733 reviews7 followers
April 30, 2024
Depraved to the point that it’s baffling, poorly edited, and a confusing plot made this book almost unreadable. The spicy scenes are plentiful and yet fail to titillate, and the FMC’s insta-lust is embarrassing in situations no human being would find erotic. The MMCs’ personalities are alluded to but never really come across on the page, and the “four horsemen [of the apocalypse]” aspect is oft mentioned but no apocalypse actually occurs.
Profile Image for Maizie.
127 reviews8 followers
April 4, 2024
"Neither one of us asked for this, did we witch? Yet here we are, and if I'm honest, which I rarely am, I think we're better for it."

What is a witch to do when four dark monsters crash her seance? 😅😊

I came upon the details of this book on Booktok and I'm so thankful I did. I didn't realize this was a debut novel for this author until I had finished it. I also had never read a Paranormal horror romance before, so I guess the author and I have something in common.

🩶 Vengeful Heroine
🩶 Enemies to Murderers, I mean Lovers 🤭
🩶 Why Choose
🩶 Forced Proximity
🩶 Forbidden Dark Monster Romance
🩶 A little sweet and a whole lotta heat ❤️‍🔥
🩶 Monster Alphaholes

Shunned for her abilities as a witch, Valeria hurtles into the opportunity to film during an eclipse with the four members of the Apparition Authority via a live broadcast ghost hunt. Unbeknownst to Valeria, the Apparition members are sneaky sneaks and the summoning doesn't go to plan......... and the four horsemen are released. There is a sacrifice to be made, but who will be strong enough to survive!

Buckle up because you're in for a wild ride. It's incredibly well written for a debut author. Spooky, mysterious, violent, romantic with a "touch" of horror, thrilling and quite addictive. Be warned though, please read the trigger warnings because this book will have you clutching your pearls 🤭👻💀🖤🥀🥵🔥❤️‍🔥🫶
Profile Image for SoulsHaven.
104 reviews3 followers
March 31, 2024
More like 4.5 ⭐️ and 4 🌶️

I was lucky enough to ARC this book and wow!

Very easy read coming in at 210 pages but it packs a punch! Suspenseful, intriguing, horror, dark, smutty this book covers it all.

It takes place in the course of an evening but is so well done that even being fast passed you don’t miss anything.

Highly recommend and will be diving in to more from this author.

Definitely read tigger warnings for those who are not a normal reader of this genre. It is dark themed with horror elements but it is so worth it!i
Profile Image for Jess_feelzinsane .
370 reviews10 followers
March 29, 2024
First of all Valeria reminds us to watch who we keep close as friends😩😄the way she kept getting almost unalived because of the group she had with her kept making me as a reader want to grab them and do my own justice😄😭the spice was spicy in this book!! So if you're looking for a book that has lots of twists and steam and action please read this one!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Anissa Cosby.
Author 9 books29 followers
April 12, 2024
This was a great book and a quick read. So much happens in such a short timespan and it’s worth every morsel I could get.

Val has made it on my book girlfriend list. She’s absolutely delicious and I love how she fights for herself.

Each of the harbingers have their own quirks, pros, and cons. If I had to choose a favorite, it would be Maalik.

Overall, I highly enjoyed it!
1 review
May 5, 2024
Good story

The use of they/their pronouns made the story confusing, but the story itself was worth the read. Wish Death had more book time, though.
Profile Image for Jess.
31 reviews6 followers
May 8, 2024
Great for the smut. There could have been so much more that happened in the book though. Like, I would have loved to see them move and grow together. Idk, it was okay.
Profile Image for Chai.
56 reviews
May 8, 2024
I was confused. I don’t know where the story’s going. This could’ve been better.
Insta-lust
There are multiple spice scenes but it didn’t make me feel something.
Profile Image for Amy.
163 reviews7 followers
May 3, 2024
Well that was different and entertaining.
Lots of 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ . Great character descriptions; I loved Maalik so much. ❤️
Profile Image for Mary S..
1,045 reviews13 followers
April 5, 2024
This was really a good read! Love all the witching the apocalyptic kind of read. Love the characters especially the four horsemen!It captured me through the whole story. Wishing there will be more to come.
Profile Image for Sarah.
878 reviews16 followers
May 7, 2024
Now this was a why choose monster romance set in a scary movie haunted house setting. Lots of gore, lots of smut, yet strangely fascinating as well with its “we’ve triggered the apocalypse and the bad guys aren’t what it seems” vibes.

⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 (3.5 stars)
Profile Image for Emily.
615 reviews12 followers
May 9, 2024
Four horsemen monster smut? Yes please.

I don’t know what I was expecting but this book was more, to say the least. Solid and new storyline.
Profile Image for Remy Kennedy.
76 reviews
June 1, 2024
If the smut is what you want- this book has it. A plot? We don’t know her.
Profile Image for Stephanies.books_.
683 reviews6 followers
January 7, 2025
I want to start out by saying this book could have been amazing.

First of all, referring to all the characters as they is 100 percent confusing and makes it hard to follow along. It also makes it difficult to know which characters are who during events.

I realize that they, them, their are acronyms. But not for every single character.

I also hate that it was just at first sight. It was ick. Make them hate each other. Then, work up to the lusting.

The plot was not solid. Every order was said multiple times in the same paragraph. As well as Gaslighting themselves. It was insane and frustrating. Like answer the question instead of barking orders or asking why.

After all, horsemen were summoned, and "they" left for her home. It was pretty much a 🍆💦 fest. Which was a waste.

Just a solid no for this book.
6 reviews
April 10, 2025
“Come for the mystery, stay for the steam. And by steam, I mean holy hell 🔥”

⭐⭐⭐⭐

Sloane Sabel… what exactly was in your pen when you wrote this? Because I was not prepared 😮‍💨 From the moment she steps foot in that creepy cabin, I knew I was in for a ride—and whew, was it deliciously chaotic. 🌲😈

The suspense had my heart racing, but the spicy scenes? Let’s just say I had to pause, blink, and fan myself like a Victorian lady. 🫠💅 The chemistry was off the charts, the tension was criminal, and the way it all built up? Pure gold.

And can we talk about the queer rep?? Subtle, real, and so appreciated. It made the world feel more authentic, and I love when authors make space for everyone. 🏳️‍🌈✨

This book gave danger, drama, and downright dirty in all the best ways. I ate it up and already want seconds. More please, Sloane. Like… now. 👏🔥💋
Profile Image for Emma Demopoulos.
474 reviews2 followers
October 31, 2026
This book needs a few added chapters. Right now, there's a bunch of loose ends, haphazard world building, and a very confusing beginning. It had potential so I continued reading, but I kept having moments of "wait, who is that?" "what's happening?" "Was that mentioned before?" I liked the magic and the combination of horror and romance. It kept my attention for 200 pages but I'm not sure I would call it good.
7 reviews
April 4, 2024
Not my usual read, enjoyed some parts more than others - read the content advisory and take it seriously!
Profile Image for Nicole Henry.
102 reviews19 followers
April 6, 2024
The foreword was what really drew me in and the characters made me stay. This was a book that I didn't know I needed to read and really spoke to me.
Author 1 book5 followers
May 5, 2024
This one took me little bit to get into it but so worth it.
Four horse men it dark and spicy. Magic and mystery to it.
Let your monsters out to play your won't be disappointed. I do hope she write more to this story the ending is ok but I still want more.
Profile Image for Jay.
12 reviews
May 2, 2024
This book was a bit hard to follow at times. It wasn’t bad but definitely needed more details on certain aspects of things.
Profile Image for Aspen.
9 reviews1 follower
April 29, 2024
Unexpectedly Loved

I wasn’t sure if I’d like this when I learned of a horror aspect. I kept reading though, I love a good story unraveling a mystery. I read through this so quickly, I wanted to know what happened at every page turn.

I love Why Choose and the spicy parts?? Magical. I’m new to dark romance but enjoyed this book more than I thought I would. I’d definitely recommend to other dark romance lovers.
Profile Image for Megan Butchard.
71 reviews2 followers
May 1, 2024
Note to self: Don't start a horror book right before bed.

I really enjoyed this book. The horror parts would have made me cover my eyes if I was watching it as a movie.
Profile Image for liv.
41 reviews1 follower
April 29, 2024
this was good, quick and snappy. it’s crazy to think this story legit takes place over like 3 days and they have sexual interactions like 6 times
Profile Image for Jessica Hall.
1,191 reviews1 follower
April 24, 2024
This book asks the question - what if instead of stopping the 4 horsemen from starting the apocalypse, you just had sex with all of them?

This is a smut book. If that’s what you’re looking for, then congrats - you found it. If you’re looking for a serious plot, you should look elsewhere. 😂

🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️/5
All the holes with up to 5 people at a time. Some of this I don’t think would actually work geometrically, but I’ve never tried, so what do I know.
Profile Image for kailesbooks.
453 reviews11 followers
May 1, 2024
“Shouldn’t Have Come” by Sloan Sabel is a thrilling debut novel that seamlessly blends paranormal romance with an irresistible touch of danger. It takes place during a solar eclipse, like ours recently, the story follows a witch in her 30s who unwittingly summons the four horsemen in a seance gone wrong. This is a tale of unexpected fated mates entangled in a steamy and electrifying romance that will leave you breathless. The chemistry between the characters leaps off the page, drawing readers into a world where magic and desire collide in the most intoxicating way. I truly enjoyed this novel and would say it is a must-read for fans of paranormal romance.

Quick Takeaways:
>>Quick Read
>>Engaging and Thrilling
>>Hot n Spicy scenes
>>Witches and other supernatural creatures
Displaying 1 - 30 of 73 reviews