What do you think?
Rate this book
The Burning of Rosemont Abbey
1956: In the quiet village of Wilbeth Green, the smoldering ruins of Rosemont Abbey set the residents' tongues wagging, and everyone is quick to accuse troublemaker Paul Everly of being the arsonist. Paul has vanished without a trace, leaving only his twin sister, Louisa, certain of his innocence. Fueling her conviction is an inexplicable connection--she felt her twin's death an hour before the abbey went up in flames. Knowing no one will believe her, Louisa embarks on her own investigation, challenging the skepticism of her neighbors and the disdain of her aunt and uncle. Even Inspector Malcolm Sinclair, once Paul's closest friend, is torn between his duty and a lingering loyalty to Paul and warns Louisa to abandon her pursuit. But Louisa is determined to solve a murder no one else believes was committed, even if it means unraveling secrets that could shake Wilbeth Green to its core. Award-winning author Naomi Stephens presents a gripping whodunnit--reminiscent of the beloved Agatha Christie tales--of love and redemption set in a quaint British village.
336 pages, Paperback
First published October 1, 2024
51 people are currently reading
6478 people want to read
About the author
Naomi Stephens
5 books268 followersNaomi Stephens is a bookworm turned teacher turned writer. She received a B.A. in English from Concordia University in Ann Arbor, and an M.A. in English from Indiana University-Purdue University Fort Wayne.
In bookstores, Naomi gravitates towards 19th-century British novels—the broodier the better (i.e., Jane Eyre)—but she can also be found perusing the young adult, mystery, and fantasy sections. Anything that keeps her turning pages past midnight.
Though she has called many places home over the years, she currently lives in Ohio with her husband, her two children, and a rascal of a dog named Sherlock. When not writing or having adventures with her family, she can be found drinking tea, practicing photography, and pining for London.
In bookstores, Naomi gravitates towards 19th-century British novels—the broodier the better (i.e., Jane Eyre)—but she can also be found perusing the young adult, mystery, and fantasy sections. Anything that keeps her turning pages past midnight.
Though she has called many places home over the years, she currently lives in Ohio with her husband, her two children, and a rascal of a dog named Sherlock. When not writing or having adventures with her family, she can be found drinking tea, practicing photography, and pining for London.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 230 reviews
May 28, 2025
3.5 stars ⭐️ Christian Fiction - Historical Mystery (murder)
About this book:
“1956: In the quiet village of Wilbeth Green, the smoldering ruins of Rosemont Abbey set the residents' tongues wagging, and everyone is quick to accuse troublemaker Paul Everly of being the arsonist. Paul has vanished without a trace, leaving only his twin sister, Louisa, certain of his innocence. Fueling her conviction is an inexplicable connection--she felt her twin's death an hour before the abbey went up in flames. Knowing no one will believe her, Louisa embarks on her own investigation, challenging the skepticism of her neighbors and the disdain of her aunt and uncle. Even Inspector Malcolm Sinclair, once Paul's closest friend, is torn between his duty and a lingering loyalty to Paul and warns Louisa to abandon her pursuit. But Louisa is determined to solve a murder no one else believes was committed, even if it means unraveling secrets that could shake Wilbeth Green to its core.”
Series: No, seems to be a stand-alone novel.
Spiritual Content- A hymn is quoted at the beginning; A Scripture is quoted; Prayers; Church going & part of a sermon; Talks about God, those and events in the Bible, sin/sinners; 'H’s are capital when referring to God; Louisa says her brother is “as devout as a man in his circumstances is able to be”; Louisa’s brother has a necklace of St. Jude (noted to be the patron saint of lost and desperate causes) that a Catholic priest gave to him at their father’s funeral; Many mentions of churches/abbeys, church going, services, sermons, worshiping, clergymen, & church events; Mentions of God; Mentions of prayers & praying; Mentions of sins/sinners, confessing sins, & absolution; Mentions of stained glass depicting scenes from the Bible; Mentions of Catholics and a saint; A couple mentions of benedictions & blessings from a chaplain; A couple mentions of homilies; A couple mentions of the liturgy; A mention of the Lord’s Supper at church; A mention of eternity;
*Note: ‘Damning’ is used once as an adjective for being condemned; The phrase “come hell or high water” is used once; Religious phrases/exclamations are said: a ‘heavens’, a ‘heaven knows’, a ‘merciful heaven’, a ‘old devil’, three ‘devilishly’, three forms of ‘thank heaven/heavens’, three ‘what/where/why the devil’, and eight ‘Good Heavens’; Someone says a place is cursed; A mention of Louisa telling her brother that despite his name being of apostolic origin, he had grown up into a “crass, disagreeable young man”; A woman mentions her Catholic grandson throughout the book, originally commenting that he “went and became a Catholic when none of us were looking” (and tells Louisa that if she’s interested in him, she would have to convert); A couple people are called saints for their helpfulness & someone wants to nominate another for sainthood; A man sneers about going to confess his sins (of being with another woman) to a vicar before proposing to a woman; A few mentions of luck; A couple mentions of a statue of a Greek goddess; A mention of a woman saying that it’s “unchristian” to have more than six courses for a dinner party after learning to have less during the war; A mention of someone looking like an avenging angel; A mention of someone doing an evil thing (of setting a church on fire); A mention of there being “the devil to pay”; A mention of being hell-bent to get away from a place; A mention of death possibly being swift like a pair of scissors snipping the body from the soul; A mention of Louisa not believing in omens (but if she did, one would be a bad one); A mention of something perhaps being fate’s influence; A mention of someone’s ghost; A mention of someone being called a vampire as an insult; A mention of a dog being called a “devil dog”; A mention of Greek mythology (Odysseus).
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘bastard’ (used in the literal illegitimate child meaning), a ‘blimey’, a ‘hurt like the dickens’, an unfinished ‘pain in the—‘, two ‘balderdash’, two ‘drat’, two ‘hang it all’, four forms of ‘blasted’, three forms of ‘idiot’, three forms of ‘shut up’, and six ‘stupid’s; Curses are said, not written (including by Louisa and others) & mentions of curses said as well; Lies & Lying (Louisa to others including the police officer friend and her aunt; Also including lying to others to get information about the case); Eavesdropping; Harsh and hurtful words are said to Louisa and she also says them to others in moments of anger; Eye rolling & Sarcasm; Louisa says ‘drat’ and argues with an elderly woman that it isn’t swearing and she doesn’t need to tell the vicar on her because the vicar would agree with her; Almost dying, Being drugged/poisoned, Being grabbed/attacked, Being held at gunpoint, Breaking and entering into a crime scene, Being chased, & Shaking in fear (semi-detailed); Going to a pub & a fight club (up to semi-detailed); Grief & Stuffing her emotions aside (for a sibling and parents, up to semi-detailed); Seeing a dead body (and being very affected by it, up to semi-detailed); Imagining possible accidental murders (up to semi-detailed); At the very beginning, Louisa physically feels as if her twin brother has died (she recalls hearing stories about twins sensing when their twin is suffering or dying without being right there with them; up to semi-detailed); A man comments on sometimes wishing he had died in the war when he was still handsome instead of praying for the day to come when he can join the rest of his men from the war; *Major Spoilers* ; Many mentions of murders, murderers, deaths, grief, & dead bodies (border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed); Many mentions of attackers and attacks, fainting, injuries, stitches, pain, & blood/bleeding; Many mentions of crimes, crime scenes, criminals, a fire, arson, & the culprit (up to semi-detailed); Many mentions of blackmail & threats (including some blackmail “for the greater good” to solve a case); Many of the side characters drink alcohol (including at a party on-page) & smoke pipes, cigars, and/or cigarettes; Many mentions of smoking, cigarettes, cigars, & pipes; Many mentions of alcohol, drinking, drunks, & pubs (including vicars drinking); Mentions of World War II, deaths, bombings, & injuries; Mentions of weapons, being shot, bullets, poisons, & being drugged/poisoned; Mentions of stealing, stolen items and money, & thieves; Mentions of break-ins; Mentions of prisons & arrests; Mentions of gambling & cheating; Mentions of hatred; Mentions of lies, lying, & liars (including when Paul told Louisa that she was a terrible liar and said it like it was “the most pulverizing kind of insult”); Mentions of eavesdropping; Mentions of gossip & rumors; A couple mentions of vandalism; A couple mentions of vomit/throwing up; A mention of novels where people are thrown into bodies of water for knowing too much about a crime; A mention of a con-man; A mention of a nightmare about being trapped in a fire;
*Note: Mentions of car brands; Mentions of singers & songs (The Andrew Sisters, Bing Crosby, Fat’s Domino, & ‘Rum and Coca-Cola’); A few mentions of brand names (Dansette, Brown Betty, & Lenthéric); A couple mentions of prejudice towards those with German names after the war (and a family changing their name because of it); A couple mentions of gypsies; A mention of Grace Kelly; A mention of BBC; A mention of Louisa thinking her uncle would send for a different doctor if she told him her concerns about feeling as if her brother died (implied because he would think she’s crazy).
Sexual Content- An almost (border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed) kiss, a throat/neck kisses (barely-above-not-detailed), and two semi-detailed kisses (one going from one’s neck to ear); Touches, Embraces, Hand holding, Nearness (up to semi-detailed); Wanting to touch (barely-above-not-detailed); Blushes; Noticing (barely-above-not-detailed); Louisa goes into a male friend’s apartment and his shirt is untucked and half unbuttoned which makes her feel nervous and embarrassed; A ‘bastard’ (used in the illegitimate child meaning); Mentions of an illegitimate child; Mentions of affairs (one is also called “illicit affair”); Mentions of a woman being in love with someone else when she got married; Mentions of unmarried couple being in a “compromising position” and while one half is in a “modern” engagement with someone else, the other promises to stop their relationship when he gets engaged; Mentions of dancing & touches; Mentions of romantic feelings for others, dates, & dating; Mentions of jealousy; A few mentions of kisses & a first kiss; A few mentions of flirting; A mention of a trip with two unmarried couples keeping “everything proper” by having a set of parents come; A mention of “worldly” women; A mention of girls going “a bit mad” for a handsome young man; Some love, possibly falling in love, & the emotions.
-Louisa Everly, age 26
P.O.V. of Lousia
Set in 1956
336 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star (and a half)
Early High School Teens- Two Stars (and a half)
Older High School Teens- Three Stars (and a half)
My personal Rating- Three Stars (and a half)
Oh, I have mixed feelings on this book. I liked so many parts about it, but I didn’t like the ending.
This book had a charm about it that could only come from a book set in 1950s England; there were many humorous parts and lots of British phrases that added a delightful charm to the story. At times, it reminded me of a Murder She Wrote episode, just without the cringy 80s hairstyles.
On that note, though, there was mentions of affairs and family skeletons which aren’t my personal favorite thing to be included in a Christian Fiction book. Another thing is that there was a lot of casual drinking and smoking by side characters. Perhaps accurate to the time, but it was nearly every time a side character appeared they were doing one or the other, which felt a little much.
I liked Louisa and Malcom—we don’t get his POV, but because he is apart of her mystery solving parts, I mention him with her—but it was really the vicar and Mrs. Watson that stole the show for me. The vicar has to be one of the best members of the cloth I’ve seen in a book. And Mrs. Watson needs her own book series. Both of them were fantastic and added wisdom and humor to the plot.
With the ending, let’s be honest. I cried with the epilogue. I was nervous about this book because of the sibling grief and that being something I’m all too familiar with. Prior to the epilogue, I actually didn’t see the villain coming and when I had an inkling it could be that person, I pushed it away because I didn’t want it to be that person. That’s what has dropped my rating half a star, because it felt a little far fetched, even if the motivation made sense.
I suppose we can say I overall enjoyed it and would recommend for ages 16+. I will definitely try another book by this author in the feature.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
About this book:
“1956: In the quiet village of Wilbeth Green, the smoldering ruins of Rosemont Abbey set the residents' tongues wagging, and everyone is quick to accuse troublemaker Paul Everly of being the arsonist. Paul has vanished without a trace, leaving only his twin sister, Louisa, certain of his innocence. Fueling her conviction is an inexplicable connection--she felt her twin's death an hour before the abbey went up in flames. Knowing no one will believe her, Louisa embarks on her own investigation, challenging the skepticism of her neighbors and the disdain of her aunt and uncle. Even Inspector Malcolm Sinclair, once Paul's closest friend, is torn between his duty and a lingering loyalty to Paul and warns Louisa to abandon her pursuit. But Louisa is determined to solve a murder no one else believes was committed, even if it means unraveling secrets that could shake Wilbeth Green to its core.”
Series: No, seems to be a stand-alone novel.
Spiritual Content- A hymn is quoted at the beginning; A Scripture is quoted; Prayers; Church going & part of a sermon; Talks about God, those and events in the Bible, sin/sinners; 'H’s are capital when referring to God; Louisa says her brother is “as devout as a man in his circumstances is able to be”; Louisa’s brother has a necklace of St. Jude (noted to be the patron saint of lost and desperate causes) that a Catholic priest gave to him at their father’s funeral; Many mentions of churches/abbeys, church going, services, sermons, worshiping, clergymen, & church events; Mentions of God; Mentions of prayers & praying; Mentions of sins/sinners, confessing sins, & absolution; Mentions of stained glass depicting scenes from the Bible; Mentions of Catholics and a saint; A couple mentions of benedictions & blessings from a chaplain; A couple mentions of homilies; A couple mentions of the liturgy; A mention of the Lord’s Supper at church; A mention of eternity;
*Note: ‘Damning’ is used once as an adjective for being condemned; The phrase “come hell or high water” is used once; Religious phrases/exclamations are said: a ‘heavens’, a ‘heaven knows’, a ‘merciful heaven’, a ‘old devil’, three ‘devilishly’, three forms of ‘thank heaven/heavens’, three ‘what/where/why the devil’, and eight ‘Good Heavens’; Someone says a place is cursed; A mention of Louisa telling her brother that despite his name being of apostolic origin, he had grown up into a “crass, disagreeable young man”; A woman mentions her Catholic grandson throughout the book, originally commenting that he “went and became a Catholic when none of us were looking” (and tells Louisa that if she’s interested in him, she would have to convert); A couple people are called saints for their helpfulness & someone wants to nominate another for sainthood; A man sneers about going to confess his sins (of being with another woman) to a vicar before proposing to a woman; A few mentions of luck; A couple mentions of a statue of a Greek goddess; A mention of a woman saying that it’s “unchristian” to have more than six courses for a dinner party after learning to have less during the war; A mention of someone looking like an avenging angel; A mention of someone doing an evil thing (of setting a church on fire); A mention of there being “the devil to pay”; A mention of being hell-bent to get away from a place; A mention of death possibly being swift like a pair of scissors snipping the body from the soul; A mention of Louisa not believing in omens (but if she did, one would be a bad one); A mention of something perhaps being fate’s influence; A mention of someone’s ghost; A mention of someone being called a vampire as an insult; A mention of a dog being called a “devil dog”; A mention of Greek mythology (Odysseus).
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘bastard’ (used in the literal illegitimate child meaning), a ‘blimey’, a ‘hurt like the dickens’, an unfinished ‘pain in the—‘, two ‘balderdash’, two ‘drat’, two ‘hang it all’, four forms of ‘blasted’, three forms of ‘idiot’, three forms of ‘shut up’, and six ‘stupid’s; Curses are said, not written (including by Louisa and others) & mentions of curses said as well; Lies & Lying (Louisa to others including the police officer friend and her aunt; Also including lying to others to get information about the case); Eavesdropping; Harsh and hurtful words are said to Louisa and she also says them to others in moments of anger; Eye rolling & Sarcasm; Louisa says ‘drat’ and argues with an elderly woman that it isn’t swearing and she doesn’t need to tell the vicar on her because the vicar would agree with her; Almost dying, Being drugged/poisoned, Being grabbed/attacked, Being held at gunpoint, Breaking and entering into a crime scene, Being chased, & Shaking in fear (semi-detailed); Going to a pub & a fight club (up to semi-detailed); Grief & Stuffing her emotions aside (for a sibling and parents, up to semi-detailed); Seeing a dead body (and being very affected by it, up to semi-detailed); Imagining possible accidental murders (up to semi-detailed); At the very beginning, Louisa physically feels as if her twin brother has died (she recalls hearing stories about twins sensing when their twin is suffering or dying without being right there with them; up to semi-detailed); A man comments on sometimes wishing he had died in the war when he was still handsome instead of praying for the day to come when he can join the rest of his men from the war; *Major Spoilers* ; Many mentions of murders, murderers, deaths, grief, & dead bodies (border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed); Many mentions of attackers and attacks, fainting, injuries, stitches, pain, & blood/bleeding; Many mentions of crimes, crime scenes, criminals, a fire, arson, & the culprit (up to semi-detailed); Many mentions of blackmail & threats (including some blackmail “for the greater good” to solve a case); Many of the side characters drink alcohol (including at a party on-page) & smoke pipes, cigars, and/or cigarettes; Many mentions of smoking, cigarettes, cigars, & pipes; Many mentions of alcohol, drinking, drunks, & pubs (including vicars drinking); Mentions of World War II, deaths, bombings, & injuries; Mentions of weapons, being shot, bullets, poisons, & being drugged/poisoned; Mentions of stealing, stolen items and money, & thieves; Mentions of break-ins; Mentions of prisons & arrests; Mentions of gambling & cheating; Mentions of hatred; Mentions of lies, lying, & liars (including when Paul told Louisa that she was a terrible liar and said it like it was “the most pulverizing kind of insult”); Mentions of eavesdropping; Mentions of gossip & rumors; A couple mentions of vandalism; A couple mentions of vomit/throwing up; A mention of novels where people are thrown into bodies of water for knowing too much about a crime; A mention of a con-man; A mention of a nightmare about being trapped in a fire;
*Note: Mentions of car brands; Mentions of singers & songs (The Andrew Sisters, Bing Crosby, Fat’s Domino, & ‘Rum and Coca-Cola’); A few mentions of brand names (Dansette, Brown Betty, & Lenthéric); A couple mentions of prejudice towards those with German names after the war (and a family changing their name because of it); A couple mentions of gypsies; A mention of Grace Kelly; A mention of BBC; A mention of Louisa thinking her uncle would send for a different doctor if she told him her concerns about feeling as if her brother died (implied because he would think she’s crazy).
Sexual Content- An almost (border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed) kiss, a throat/neck kisses (barely-above-not-detailed), and two semi-detailed kisses (one going from one’s neck to ear); Touches, Embraces, Hand holding, Nearness (up to semi-detailed); Wanting to touch (barely-above-not-detailed); Blushes; Noticing (barely-above-not-detailed); Louisa goes into a male friend’s apartment and his shirt is untucked and half unbuttoned which makes her feel nervous and embarrassed; A ‘bastard’ (used in the illegitimate child meaning); Mentions of an illegitimate child; Mentions of affairs (one is also called “illicit affair”); Mentions of a woman being in love with someone else when she got married; Mentions of unmarried couple being in a “compromising position” and while one half is in a “modern” engagement with someone else, the other promises to stop their relationship when he gets engaged; Mentions of dancing & touches; Mentions of romantic feelings for others, dates, & dating; Mentions of jealousy; A few mentions of kisses & a first kiss; A few mentions of flirting; A mention of a trip with two unmarried couples keeping “everything proper” by having a set of parents come; A mention of “worldly” women; A mention of girls going “a bit mad” for a handsome young man; Some love, possibly falling in love, & the emotions.
-Louisa Everly, age 26
P.O.V. of Lousia
Set in 1956
336 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star (and a half)
Early High School Teens- Two Stars (and a half)
Older High School Teens- Three Stars (and a half)
My personal Rating- Three Stars (and a half)
Oh, I have mixed feelings on this book. I liked so many parts about it, but I didn’t like the ending.
This book had a charm about it that could only come from a book set in 1950s England; there were many humorous parts and lots of British phrases that added a delightful charm to the story. At times, it reminded me of a Murder She Wrote episode, just without the cringy 80s hairstyles.
On that note, though, there was mentions of affairs and family skeletons which aren’t my personal favorite thing to be included in a Christian Fiction book. Another thing is that there was a lot of casual drinking and smoking by side characters. Perhaps accurate to the time, but it was nearly every time a side character appeared they were doing one or the other, which felt a little much.
I liked Louisa and Malcom—we don’t get his POV, but because he is apart of her mystery solving parts, I mention him with her—but it was really the vicar and Mrs. Watson that stole the show for me. The vicar has to be one of the best members of the cloth I’ve seen in a book. And Mrs. Watson needs her own book series. Both of them were fantastic and added wisdom and humor to the plot.
With the ending, let’s be honest. I cried with the epilogue. I was nervous about this book because of the sibling grief and that being something I’m all too familiar with. Prior to the epilogue, I actually didn’t see the villain coming and when I had an inkling it could be that person, I pushed it away because I didn’t want it to be that person. That’s what has dropped my rating half a star, because it felt a little far fetched, even if the motivation made sense.
I suppose we can say I overall enjoyed it and would recommend for ages 16+. I will definitely try another book by this author in the feature.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
October 16, 2024
New-to-me author Naomi Stephens wowed me with her clever and twisty mystery and kept me glued to the pages from cover to cover. She paired her atmospheric setting of a sleepy British village, Wilbeth Green, in the 1950s with a perfect complement of family drama, faith, suspense/mystery and tied it together with a touch of romance and humour.
At the root of this story is Louisa Everly’s insistence that a fire was set at Rosemont Abbey to cover up a murder and she’s willing to go up against family and villagers to prove it. Stephens’ characters are wonderful; her Inspector Malcolm Sinclair struggles with his loyalty, making this character one to watch, and examining the twin bond adds weight to Lousia’s insistence. I’m not a big cozy mystery reader, but the twists and mystery pulled me in and I couldn’t put it down.
When the quest to clear someone’s name gets bogged down with secrets, Lousia’s focus doesn’t waiver. Is Louisa’s gut feeling wrong? Is this a case of appearances are deceiving? You’ll have to find out what really happened that day!
I was gifted this copy by Bethany House and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.
At the root of this story is Louisa Everly’s insistence that a fire was set at Rosemont Abbey to cover up a murder and she’s willing to go up against family and villagers to prove it. Stephens’ characters are wonderful; her Inspector Malcolm Sinclair struggles with his loyalty, making this character one to watch, and examining the twin bond adds weight to Lousia’s insistence. I’m not a big cozy mystery reader, but the twists and mystery pulled me in and I couldn’t put it down.
When the quest to clear someone’s name gets bogged down with secrets, Lousia’s focus doesn’t waiver. Is Louisa’s gut feeling wrong? Is this a case of appearances are deceiving? You’ll have to find out what really happened that day!
I was gifted this copy by Bethany House and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.
October 18, 2024
The Burning of Rosemont Abbey by Naomi Stephens
4 Stars
Blog Post with Review Graphic: https://bookloveramanda.blogspot.com/...
Fans of Agatha Christie will enjoy this one! 1956 England - Naomi Stephens weaves an intricate and atmospheric mystery in The Burning of Rosemont Abbey. The story centers on Louisa Everly, a young woman determined to uncover the truth behind the smoldering ruins of the abbey and the disappearance of her twin brother, Paul. Everyone in the village accuses her brother of being the arsonist but Louisa is certain of his innocence - as she felt as though her twin died before it was set ablaze.
This book was so engaging to me - they mystery really reminded me of a classic Agatha Christie like story. Lots of side characters and small-town dynamics, where suspicious spreads like wildflower. Louisa stands out as a determined woman to figure out what happened with her brother, balancing possible grief with her unwavering devotion to prove his innocence.
The setting of Rosemont Abbey felt like gothic ruins with mysterious history and will appeal to readers, specifically during the fall time with its haunting atmosphere. Light faith elements add a layer to the story as well.
Overall, a perfect read for fans of British mysteries with a modern twist. Thank you to Bethany House for proving a copy to honestly read and review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
4 Stars
Blog Post with Review Graphic: https://bookloveramanda.blogspot.com/...
Fans of Agatha Christie will enjoy this one! 1956 England - Naomi Stephens weaves an intricate and atmospheric mystery in The Burning of Rosemont Abbey. The story centers on Louisa Everly, a young woman determined to uncover the truth behind the smoldering ruins of the abbey and the disappearance of her twin brother, Paul. Everyone in the village accuses her brother of being the arsonist but Louisa is certain of his innocence - as she felt as though her twin died before it was set ablaze.
This book was so engaging to me - they mystery really reminded me of a classic Agatha Christie like story. Lots of side characters and small-town dynamics, where suspicious spreads like wildflower. Louisa stands out as a determined woman to figure out what happened with her brother, balancing possible grief with her unwavering devotion to prove his innocence.
The setting of Rosemont Abbey felt like gothic ruins with mysterious history and will appeal to readers, specifically during the fall time with its haunting atmosphere. Light faith elements add a layer to the story as well.
Overall, a perfect read for fans of British mysteries with a modern twist. Thank you to Bethany House for proving a copy to honestly read and review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
October 28, 2024
This was quite the enjoyable and captivating book overall! It felt as if I was transported almost back to the 1950s as the setting in England felt so imaginable. There were plenty of satisfying elements with a few despicable characters as there in real life too of course which were needed to have a story in the first place. I liked the spiritual and Biblical references with their natural appearances adding to the stories. This was my first by this author but she easily passed my "one chance" read and will gladly read other mysteries by her. * The cover was what initially grabbed my attention I must admit (despite the head being partially "lopped off") as I am so drawn to gorgeous covers* ( I confess, I have bought at times, just for the fabulous covers to add to my collection ;) ha
October 15, 2025
This was my first read by this author and I absolutely loved it!!! Such a great story! I loved the fact that it is set in the 1950’s in England. I haven’t ever read a book set in that time period in England so that was fun! I loved Louisa’s character. She was very determined to solve the mystery of what happened to her brother and the Abbey. I also loved Malcolm, the detective. His personality was fun. I loved Louisa and Malcolm’s relationship, how they go from bickering/ and poking fun at each other to romance. Just great! The mystery element was really well done. And the story had great Christian content. Overall, great read and I definitely recommend!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Content: murder
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from netgalley. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Content: murder
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from netgalley. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
October 7, 2024
1956 England
Yes! A historical mystery novel!
The Burning of Rosemont Abbey is well written and engaging. Love the bits of humor sprinkled throughout. Louisa Everly is convinced her twin brother Paul didn't set fire to Rosemont Abbey and becomes an amateur sleuth. There are so many great secondary characters in the novel. My favorite was likely Mrs. Watson.
Delighted that there is another historical mystery novel coming in 2025 by the author.
My gratitude to the author and publisher for a complimentary copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
Yes! A historical mystery novel!
The Burning of Rosemont Abbey is well written and engaging. Love the bits of humor sprinkled throughout. Louisa Everly is convinced her twin brother Paul didn't set fire to Rosemont Abbey and becomes an amateur sleuth. There are so many great secondary characters in the novel. My favorite was likely Mrs. Watson.
Delighted that there is another historical mystery novel coming in 2025 by the author.
My gratitude to the author and publisher for a complimentary copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
October 29, 2024
"The Burning of Rosemont Abbey" by Naomi Stephens is a wonderful classic British mystery, perfect for fans of Agatha Christie and Nancy Drew! The book takes place in 1956 in a sleepy English village, where everyone knows one another. The village of Wilbeth Green, along with its abbey, Rosemont Abbey, is such a beautiful and atmospheric setting. I felt transported to the village. Our heroine and amateur sleuth, Louisa Everly, is determined to find out what happened to her twin brother and does not believe he is behind the burning of the abbey. Louisa is stubborn, headstrong, brave and armed with lipstick and taffeta. She sets out to investigate on her own. Readers will love following Louisa as she picks locks, questions locals, pretends to faint and partakes in a high-speed car chase. During her investigation, she runs into an old friend, with shared history, who just happens to be the inspector on the case, Malcolm Sinclair. Malcolm and Louisa butt heads at first, but eventually team up to solve the mystery. Sparks fly between the two as the investigation becomes more serious.
I love all the history and fashion woven into the story. Even though Louisa’s sibling, Paul, is missing in the present time of the story, the relationship between Louisa and Paul is still very much front and center. There are lots of memories and flashbacks of Louisa, her brother and Malcolm. There are wonderful themes of forgiveness, class, family and sibling relationships and faith. I especially loved the lesson that the vicar imparts to Louisa about not thinking we are better than others and that the only comparison that really matters is who we are in Christ. This story of Ms. Stephens’ kept me guessing throughout and it was a great surprise at the end. If you love fashion, mystery and history, you will love this story!
Content: I give this book a PG rating. Some examples of the content: a character smokes cigarettes, steals and is drunk; mention of drinking and gambling; a character goes to a place with a bar; the word “da*n” is used; mention of someone possibly having an affair; a man says he was in a compromising position with a woman; a child is a bastard; someone curses but the words aren’t actually written.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
I love all the history and fashion woven into the story. Even though Louisa’s sibling, Paul, is missing in the present time of the story, the relationship between Louisa and Paul is still very much front and center. There are lots of memories and flashbacks of Louisa, her brother and Malcolm. There are wonderful themes of forgiveness, class, family and sibling relationships and faith. I especially loved the lesson that the vicar imparts to Louisa about not thinking we are better than others and that the only comparison that really matters is who we are in Christ. This story of Ms. Stephens’ kept me guessing throughout and it was a great surprise at the end. If you love fashion, mystery and history, you will love this story!
Content: I give this book a PG rating. Some examples of the content: a character smokes cigarettes, steals and is drunk; mention of drinking and gambling; a character goes to a place with a bar; the word “da*n” is used; mention of someone possibly having an affair; a man says he was in a compromising position with a woman; a child is a bastard; someone curses but the words aren’t actually written.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
November 26, 2024
I'm going to honest—I wasn't sure how I was going to feel about this one when I first started it. Historical fiction isn't my go-to genre and mystery/suspense isn't either. However, as the story progressed, I was totally into it!
Set in the small town of Wilbeth Green, Louisa Everly feels the death of her troublemaker twin brother Paul when it occurs. Subsequently, the beloved Rosemont Abbey (where her deceased father once served as the vicar) is set ablaze and everyone in town believes Paul is to blame. They believe his disappearance is due to him being on the run after the arson while Louisa is sure he was murdered and framed.
Louisa wants to prove Paul's innocence and discover his murderer, but everyone has a rock solid alibi—or so it seems. When Paul's old chum-turned-police inspector, Malcolm Sinclair shows up to investigate the case, Louisa forms an alliance with him to uncover the truth. Neither of them realize what a twisty-turny, dangerous road it would take them down.
This was such a fun, unpredictable adventure! I enjoyed all of the twists and turns and the side characters were well-written. All the way through, I was left wondering what truly happened and the motive behind the crime.
I listened on audio and the narrator was phenomenal! I felt transported to England and totally engrossed in the story. Definitely recommend checking this one out!
Thank you to @bethanyhousefiction for gifting me a copy to read and review. All opinions are my own.
Set in the small town of Wilbeth Green, Louisa Everly feels the death of her troublemaker twin brother Paul when it occurs. Subsequently, the beloved Rosemont Abbey (where her deceased father once served as the vicar) is set ablaze and everyone in town believes Paul is to blame. They believe his disappearance is due to him being on the run after the arson while Louisa is sure he was murdered and framed.
Louisa wants to prove Paul's innocence and discover his murderer, but everyone has a rock solid alibi—or so it seems. When Paul's old chum-turned-police inspector, Malcolm Sinclair shows up to investigate the case, Louisa forms an alliance with him to uncover the truth. Neither of them realize what a twisty-turny, dangerous road it would take them down.
This was such a fun, unpredictable adventure! I enjoyed all of the twists and turns and the side characters were well-written. All the way through, I was left wondering what truly happened and the motive behind the crime.
I listened on audio and the narrator was phenomenal! I felt transported to England and totally engrossed in the story. Definitely recommend checking this one out!
Thank you to @bethanyhousefiction for gifting me a copy to read and review. All opinions are my own.
November 23, 2024
What a fun, hilarious ride with a very classic mystery feel! All of the characters were so colorful and dynamic, especially Mrs. Watson! The ending was extremely shocking, and the mystery proved clever and suspenseful. The only things I would've preferred more of would be the faith content and the romance development. All in all, though, this was a fun and entertaining mystery!!
January 13, 2025
What could be better than a mystery set in the 1950s in England? How about Christian fiction? Maybe throw in an abbey that burns (I weep just thinking about it). How about a vicar who is the most beautiful soul I've read in fiction in a long time. If you took the best of Sidney Chambers from the Grantchester mysteries and combined him with Father Brown, you'd almost have it right. Utter brilliance (and he's not a primary character!).
This was one of those mysteries where I knew who did it, but I couldn't figure out why and so I believed I was being ridiculous. But no one else worked! When the why hit, a great whodunnit became a gripping suspense as well, because I knew what would happen next. Just didn't want to believe it.
Stephens wrote beautiful prose in her Biblical retelling set in Victorian times, but this book... this one. This is her niche. I could read her mysteries all day long. A great cast of flawed characters who don't get it all right, enough red herrings to make the obvious seem not so obvious after all (and the reverse), and subtle but strong (how is that possible???) nuggets of faith appearing just when you need them...
Definitely my favorite book of the year. Sure, we're only two weeks in, but I doubt it'll get bumped out of position easily.
Note: there were two (that I recall at the moment--money and pharmacy... that's all I'm sayin') places where Anglophiles will cringe at word choice. Those who read a lot of British lit or watch a lot of British TV will know which ones I mean. However, since she's writing for a predominantly American audience, I didn't let that affect my rating.
This was one of those mysteries where I knew who did it, but I couldn't figure out why and so I believed I was being ridiculous. But no one else worked! When the why hit, a great whodunnit became a gripping suspense as well, because I knew what would happen next. Just didn't want to believe it.
Stephens wrote beautiful prose in her Biblical retelling set in Victorian times, but this book... this one. This is her niche. I could read her mysteries all day long. A great cast of flawed characters who don't get it all right, enough red herrings to make the obvious seem not so obvious after all (and the reverse), and subtle but strong (how is that possible???) nuggets of faith appearing just when you need them...
Definitely my favorite book of the year. Sure, we're only two weeks in, but I doubt it'll get bumped out of position easily.
Note: there were two (that I recall at the moment--money and pharmacy... that's all I'm sayin') places where Anglophiles will cringe at word choice. Those who read a lot of British lit or watch a lot of British TV will know which ones I mean. However, since she's writing for a predominantly American audience, I didn't let that affect my rating.
February 11, 2025
When I got this audio book from the Library, I had no idea what it was all about. I had seen some great reviews and thought I'd give it a whirl. Well, y'all this was Dana's catnip! I was drawn in from the get go. The main female character was quite cheeky and brave. I want to be her when I grow up. Plus, lots of other fun characters too. The main male character had his hands full with the lot. There was humor, wit and sweet moments of reflection too. I have to hand it to the author, I was clueless as to who the bad guy was. I highly recommend this book. Also, the narrator did such a great job. She was perfect for it.
January 18, 2025
6 STARS. EVERY STAR. I LOVE THIS. Please oh please make this a series. I need more of Malcom and Louisa in my life. And MRS. WATSON. Full RTC
November 19, 2024
A wonderful mystery in the veins of Nancy Drew. A nosey main character who plans on solving the case, and nobody better get in her way. With a dash of romance and lots of intrigue I thoroughly enjoyed the plot and characters.
This story was beautifully written. I loved the 1950s setting and our plucky heroine. The mystery kept me guessing until the last page, and also kept me turning the pages...well listening to the audiobook. Which by the way, the narrator did a fantastic job with the characters too.
*thank you to Baker Publishing for a complimentary copy of this book to read. All thoughts are my own.
This story was beautifully written. I loved the 1950s setting and our plucky heroine. The mystery kept me guessing until the last page, and also kept me turning the pages...well listening to the audiobook. Which by the way, the narrator did a fantastic job with the characters too.
*thank you to Baker Publishing for a complimentary copy of this book to read. All thoughts are my own.
February 18, 2025
There’s just something about a mystery set in the 1950s that is immediately cozy. Which is likely a strange way to feel about stories that revolve around one or more murders. Regardless, murder mysteries set in this specific time and place pull readers in, not only because those readers are involved in the mystery to be solved, but because there’s something about the time and place that is enchanting. And there’s a brightness to that time and place that keeps even the gnarliest of murders from feeling too heavy.
The Burning of Rosemont Abbey was billed to me as a mystery in the tradition of Agatha Christie. I think that description might have caused me to not temper my expectations as much as I generally do when trying a new-to-me author for the first time. All of the hallmarks of an excellent Christie-esque novel were present here, and yet there was something that kept it from landing quite as strongly as I’d hoped it would.
Don’t get me wrong: there’s a lot I enjoyed about this novel. I liked the voice and the setting. The cast of characters was varied and interesting. There was a twin element that I found fascinating, as my dad is an identical twin. And the mystery itself kept me guessing right up until the big reveal. I often guess such mysteries correctly, long before the characters figure things out, so that was refreshing.
So why did I like it without quite loving it?
There is a charm to this story that begged for deeper exploration. I wish this had leaned a little more heavily into that charm. I think that, in mysteries such as this one and the type of stories after which it is modeled, the charm of the area that serves as the setting is a wonderful and vital dichotomy to the mystery at the core of the novel.
The mystery and its investigation cast a wide net onto possible motives and suspects. Too wide a net, in my opinion, with not enough believable explanation regarding most of them. I think this stems in part from the believability of Louisa as our investigating protagonist. There was something about her that didn’t quite ring true, though she was plenty likable and intelligent.
I think most of my issues with this book come down to feeling that I was told a lot without being shown for myself. That’s one of Christie’s great strengths. She lets you play detective alongside Poirot and Marple, making some discoveries and inferences for yourself as you read. This is possible because their stories are told in third person. In The Burning of Rosemont Abbey, we have Louisa’s first person narrative, which just isn’t quite as successful in terms of this type of mystery, in my opinion.
In spite of my qualms, this was a solid, entertaining mystery. It just didn’t quite live up to its comparisons to Christie. But in all honesty and fairness, what book does? There’s a reason Christie was billed the queen of mystery, and why she retains that title so long after her death. I enjoyed this first offering from Stephens enough that I can see myself reading her again in the future.
(As this is a novel from a Christian publisher, I’d like to touch on the faith element in the book. It was present, but felt like an afterthought in most instances. It wasn’t a large building block of the story. A non Christian wouldn’t find this novel unpalatable.)
The Burning of Rosemont Abbey was billed to me as a mystery in the tradition of Agatha Christie. I think that description might have caused me to not temper my expectations as much as I generally do when trying a new-to-me author for the first time. All of the hallmarks of an excellent Christie-esque novel were present here, and yet there was something that kept it from landing quite as strongly as I’d hoped it would.
Don’t get me wrong: there’s a lot I enjoyed about this novel. I liked the voice and the setting. The cast of characters was varied and interesting. There was a twin element that I found fascinating, as my dad is an identical twin. And the mystery itself kept me guessing right up until the big reveal. I often guess such mysteries correctly, long before the characters figure things out, so that was refreshing.
So why did I like it without quite loving it?
There is a charm to this story that begged for deeper exploration. I wish this had leaned a little more heavily into that charm. I think that, in mysteries such as this one and the type of stories after which it is modeled, the charm of the area that serves as the setting is a wonderful and vital dichotomy to the mystery at the core of the novel.
The mystery and its investigation cast a wide net onto possible motives and suspects. Too wide a net, in my opinion, with not enough believable explanation regarding most of them. I think this stems in part from the believability of Louisa as our investigating protagonist. There was something about her that didn’t quite ring true, though she was plenty likable and intelligent.
I think most of my issues with this book come down to feeling that I was told a lot without being shown for myself. That’s one of Christie’s great strengths. She lets you play detective alongside Poirot and Marple, making some discoveries and inferences for yourself as you read. This is possible because their stories are told in third person. In The Burning of Rosemont Abbey, we have Louisa’s first person narrative, which just isn’t quite as successful in terms of this type of mystery, in my opinion.
In spite of my qualms, this was a solid, entertaining mystery. It just didn’t quite live up to its comparisons to Christie. But in all honesty and fairness, what book does? There’s a reason Christie was billed the queen of mystery, and why she retains that title so long after her death. I enjoyed this first offering from Stephens enough that I can see myself reading her again in the future.
(As this is a novel from a Christian publisher, I’d like to touch on the faith element in the book. It was present, but felt like an afterthought in most instances. It wasn’t a large building block of the story. A non Christian wouldn’t find this novel unpalatable.)
February 4, 2025
This was such a fun story/mystery to be swept up in! I read the second half all in one evening because I was that eager to know who was behind all the mischief...I was honestly shocked by the end. I loved the feel of this mystery with its Golden Age nods. It felt like a modern Patricia Wentworth with a Miss Silver (Mrs Watson) who is the comic relief instead of the sleuth. Great characters, fun action, a good romance, and a lovely brother-sister redemptive arc.
April 28, 2025
The Burning of Rosemont Abbey is an engaging mystery filled with unexpected twists and turns. What struck me especially was that although billed as Christian Fiction—and it is with its brief but poignant moments of faith—this is a mystery that should appeal to any reader, regardless of their faith. Its characters are real people with real faults—some quite nasty such as the MC’s aunt and uncle—people who are far from perfect, a story without a fainting wallflower and her constant handwringing, constant preaching, and appeals to heaven for deliverance from evil. There are plenty of novels like that if that is your niche. Ironically, although Christian Fiction, I couldn’t help but smile at a few scenes, and would immediately think the book should be rated PG for Historic Smoking as you sometimes see in movies. That rating always makes me laugh! Kidding aside, this is a wonderful mystery and I love the author’s use of descriptive language and choice of words without being wordy. Less is more quite often, and Naomi Stephens demonstrates it beautifully. It’s easy to see why so many have raved about this book. An easy five stars.
September 13, 2024
Wow! This is an exceptional book! It's almost like Clue. There are so many different scenarios and potential culprits that my mind was swirling with the possibilities. The perpetrator was the last person that I would have thought it was.
What an array of remarkable characters! Louisa is a complex character. Her relationship with her twin brother is strained. She loves her high society life, and Paul detests it. Malcolm, an old friend of the family, instantly clashes with Louisa as she remains adamant about her brothers innocence. Mrs. Watson is my favorite! She speaks her mind, but her heart is genuine.
During the investigation regarding the Burning Of Rosemont Abbey, so many other things come to light. A secret romance, blackmail, betrayals, and murders. I loved the ending except that it was kind of a cliffhanger.
This is the first book that I've read written by Naomi Stephens, but it certainly won't be the last! I'm already looking forward to the book coming in 2025!!
I won this book from Bethany House through LibraryThing via Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
What an array of remarkable characters! Louisa is a complex character. Her relationship with her twin brother is strained. She loves her high society life, and Paul detests it. Malcolm, an old friend of the family, instantly clashes with Louisa as she remains adamant about her brothers innocence. Mrs. Watson is my favorite! She speaks her mind, but her heart is genuine.
During the investigation regarding the Burning Of Rosemont Abbey, so many other things come to light. A secret romance, blackmail, betrayals, and murders. I loved the ending except that it was kind of a cliffhanger.
This is the first book that I've read written by Naomi Stephens, but it certainly won't be the last! I'm already looking forward to the book coming in 2025!!
I won this book from Bethany House through LibraryThing via Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
November 26, 2025
Dear Reader, I must beg your finest pardon for not reading and recommending this book sooner! Indeed, I'm rather vexed with myself for allowing such a fabulous novel to languish on my TBR for so long. Rest assured, I shall endeavor to make amends by gushing about this story at every opportunity, given or contrived!
In "The Burning of Rosemont Abbey," Naomi Stephens has crafted a cozy mystery with the perfect blend of page-turning suspense and page-savoring charm. Set in the 1950's, this period drama takes place in a quaint English village populated by a fascinating cast of characters, ranging from the endearing and eccentric to the sophisticated and suspicious.
Fans of Masterpiece Mystery on PBS will be captivated by this clever whodunnit with an atmospheric setting, keep-you-guessing mystery, and a simmering slow burn romance between a protective inspector and a glamorous amateur sleuth in red lipstick.
If you prefer your mysteries prim and properly arresting in a string of pearls, "The Burning of Rosemont Abbey" is sure to be your cup of tea!
In "The Burning of Rosemont Abbey," Naomi Stephens has crafted a cozy mystery with the perfect blend of page-turning suspense and page-savoring charm. Set in the 1950's, this period drama takes place in a quaint English village populated by a fascinating cast of characters, ranging from the endearing and eccentric to the sophisticated and suspicious.
Fans of Masterpiece Mystery on PBS will be captivated by this clever whodunnit with an atmospheric setting, keep-you-guessing mystery, and a simmering slow burn romance between a protective inspector and a glamorous amateur sleuth in red lipstick.
If you prefer your mysteries prim and properly arresting in a string of pearls, "The Burning of Rosemont Abbey" is sure to be your cup of tea!
August 31, 2025
Louisa faints after an event at home, cutting her hand--even though she's never felt a twin connection before, she knows her twin brother is dead. That night, Rosemont Abbey burns, and clues left behind make it appear like her brother was the arsonist, but she knows that can't be true. She starts investigating a long with her son's old childhood friend, Malcolm, a Scotland Yard Inspector. At first he warns her to stay away, but in the end has her promise to not do anything dangerous and to tell him what she finds.
Along the way, Louisa learns more about Paul's life since he became estranged from their family, but other secrets are also unlocked. Good twists and turns, well written Christian romantic suspense.
4.5 stars.
Along the way, Louisa learns more about Paul's life since he became estranged from their family, but other secrets are also unlocked. Good twists and turns, well written Christian romantic suspense.
4.5 stars.
April 22, 2024
Stephens leaves the reader guessing with this delightful homage to Agatha Christie where the mystery gets more intricate with each page and every character is a suspect. Fast-paced and beautifully plotted, The Burning of Rosemont Abbey is a novel sprinkled with clues, seeped in timeless truths, and capped off with a twist of an ending you’ll never see coming.
November 14, 2024
I enjoyed this one, it’s good mystery with a fair amount of action. I liked the setting in 1950’s England and all of the characters. It had some unexpected twists.
April 1, 2025
That got me, did not see it coming! I'd give this 5 stars but the sister didn't seem as upset about the brother as I'd expect. Otherwise, great story!
October 4, 2024
Friends, if you’re looking for a great mystery to read this fall season, then this is the one for you. I devoured this book and found it to be such a satisfying read in all the ways.
What I loved:
🔎the atmospheric 1956 England setting
🔎the many layers and threads of family secrets, reveals, and twists
🔎the sweet romance
🔎Christian themes & Scripture references throughout the book
Good to Know:
A church fire, multiple murders (not descriptive), infidelity (mentioned, not described in any detail), cursing mentioned but no specific instances of profanity on the page.
I really enjoyed The Burning of Rosemont Abbey and look forward to reading the next mystery from Naomi Stephens, which we get the first glimpse of at the end of this book.
Thank you to the author and publisher for a gifted copy of the book. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
What I loved:
🔎the atmospheric 1956 England setting
🔎the many layers and threads of family secrets, reveals, and twists
🔎the sweet romance
🔎Christian themes & Scripture references throughout the book
Good to Know:
A church fire, multiple murders (not descriptive), infidelity (mentioned, not described in any detail), cursing mentioned but no specific instances of profanity on the page.
I really enjoyed The Burning of Rosemont Abbey and look forward to reading the next mystery from Naomi Stephens, which we get the first glimpse of at the end of this book.
Thank you to the author and publisher for a gifted copy of the book. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
September 5, 2024
Stephens is now on my must-read list. This was an entertaining and well-written historical mystery, and the Christian content was meaningful without being preachy. I appreciated that our heroine was flawed and human, and that the villain was a true surprise (at least to me!).
*Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for providing an e-galley in exchange for an honest review.
*Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for providing an e-galley in exchange for an honest review.
July 28, 2025
The mystery in this story was superb. It featured twins, which was especially fun in the Gothic atmosphere. Speaking of that, what a surprise to discover a Gothic tale set in the 1950s! A disappearance, mysterious fire, and a suspected murder combined beautifully in the craft of this novel. It was quite easy to get wrapped up in the amateur detective journey Louisa engaged in to discover the truth of what happened to her brother and the burned abbey. Whew! Seems like she suspected absolutely everyone, other than herself, at one point or other. It was interesting to follow her logic for each.
The expletives used were disappointments. There are much more appropriate words to use than curses.
The narration by Moira Quirk was excellent. I’ll have to check out to which other titles she’s lent her vocal talents.
Mrs. Watson was such fun! I love a good quirky character, and she was a spark indeed.
Lingering question: Whatever happened to Dorothy Simms?
Content: expletives, alcohol, tobacco, premarital sex mentioned, replacement profanity, replacement expletives, marital affair mentioned
The expletives used were disappointments. There are much more appropriate words to use than curses.
The narration by Moira Quirk was excellent. I’ll have to check out to which other titles she’s lent her vocal talents.
Mrs. Watson was such fun! I love a good quirky character, and she was a spark indeed.
Lingering question: Whatever happened to Dorothy Simms?
Content: expletives, alcohol, tobacco, premarital sex mentioned, replacement profanity, replacement expletives, marital affair mentioned
September 30, 2025
This book was a pleasant surprise! The Burning Of Rosemont Abbey Was one of my September book club picks, I must say I had a good time reading this book!
I like that this was a historical fiction/ mystery set in 1957 London. This book definitely gives off cozy-fall-mystery vibes. I like the twin connection aspect of this story between Louisa and her brother Paul. The range of characters in this book is what I loved about this book the most. I didn’t know who to trust, but some characters made me laugh out loud (Mrs. Watson will forever be my favorite). I’m looking forward to reading more from this author. 3.75 out of 5 stars
I like that this was a historical fiction/ mystery set in 1957 London. This book definitely gives off cozy-fall-mystery vibes. I like the twin connection aspect of this story between Louisa and her brother Paul. The range of characters in this book is what I loved about this book the most. I didn’t know who to trust, but some characters made me laugh out loud (Mrs. Watson will forever be my favorite). I’m looking forward to reading more from this author. 3.75 out of 5 stars
April 29, 2025
favorite book of 2025 so far!!
I started this a while back and then set it down for some reason. I picked it back up and read it in a single day’s time. It reminded me so much of one of my favorite books of all time, “A Proper Pursuit” by Lynn Austin. It had humor, whit, depth, and memorable characters.
I loved Louisa’s spunky, headstrong personality. Oftentimes this type of heroine, the one that rushes headfirst into danger, just gets on my nerves. Not so with Louisa. She was brave, stubborn, caring, and whip smart. I loved her interactions with Malcom, the vicar, and Mrs. Watson.
Malcom! I loved his as a hero. He was calm, cool, and collected, but he also let his imperfections show. I loved the moments where he cracked up at Louisa’s shenanigans, and his bickering with Mrs. Watson.
I enjoyed and appreciated the wise input from the vicar, and how he effortlessly pointed Louisa to the gospel.
MRS WATSON! What a spitfire. I loved her instantly, and her Catholic grandson’s car. She added just the right touch of comic relief and wonderful one-liners.
I was fully engrossed in the mystery, but I loved that it wasn’t dark. I appreciated the overall lightheartedness. I was completely surprised at the end. I love when that happens.
Naomi Stephen’s knocked it out of the park with this one. 10 out of 10, no critiques. I will be watching closely for the next book from this author
I started this a while back and then set it down for some reason. I picked it back up and read it in a single day’s time. It reminded me so much of one of my favorite books of all time, “A Proper Pursuit” by Lynn Austin. It had humor, whit, depth, and memorable characters.
I loved Louisa’s spunky, headstrong personality. Oftentimes this type of heroine, the one that rushes headfirst into danger, just gets on my nerves. Not so with Louisa. She was brave, stubborn, caring, and whip smart. I loved her interactions with Malcom, the vicar, and Mrs. Watson.
Malcom! I loved his as a hero. He was calm, cool, and collected, but he also let his imperfections show. I loved the moments where he cracked up at Louisa’s shenanigans, and his bickering with Mrs. Watson.
I enjoyed and appreciated the wise input from the vicar, and how he effortlessly pointed Louisa to the gospel.
MRS WATSON! What a spitfire. I loved her instantly, and her Catholic grandson’s car. She added just the right touch of comic relief and wonderful one-liners.
I was fully engrossed in the mystery, but I loved that it wasn’t dark. I appreciated the overall lightheartedness. I was completely surprised at the end. I love when that happens.
Naomi Stephen’s knocked it out of the park with this one. 10 out of 10, no critiques. I will be watching closely for the next book from this author
October 13, 2024
Classic mystery with a cast of characters that will have you wondering who-done-it. As an avid fan of mysteries, I am always trying to solve the mystery as the clues are parceled out. But there were a couple of twists that kept me thoroughly engaged in this 1950's mystery.
In the beginning, Louisa seemed superficial, yet under Ms. Stephen's skillful pen, she became fully fleshed out, and I quickly became a fan. With a supporting cast reminiscent of Agatha Christie's, readers will love this jaunt to the village of Wilbeth Green with its many secrets coming to light. While there is definitely an atmosphere of suspense, I found moments of humor deftly tucked within the pages.
This is an expertly plotted tale that will keep readers engaged from the first page to the last. It is the first book I have read by Ms. Stephens but will not the last.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher through Netgalley and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
In the beginning, Louisa seemed superficial, yet under Ms. Stephen's skillful pen, she became fully fleshed out, and I quickly became a fan. With a supporting cast reminiscent of Agatha Christie's, readers will love this jaunt to the village of Wilbeth Green with its many secrets coming to light. While there is definitely an atmosphere of suspense, I found moments of humor deftly tucked within the pages.
This is an expertly plotted tale that will keep readers engaged from the first page to the last. It is the first book I have read by Ms. Stephens but will not the last.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher through Netgalley and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
November 23, 2024
The Burning of Rosemont Abbey was my first introduction to Naomi Stephen's, but it won't be the last.
From the first line, I was immediately drawn into the story and found it to move quickly.
"Louisa felt him die."
What?! How? This intriguing murder mystery set in the 1950s had many plot twists and kept me guessing until the very end. With a quirky cast of characters and a determined heroine full of sass, this was a memorable story that I could not put down. Louisa is determined to figure out where her brother has disappeared to while clearing his name of a crime she is sure he did not commit. This takes her into some dangerous areas and gets her into heaps of trouble.
Malcolm, the inspector assigned to the case, knows what Paul is capable of since they got into scrapes when they were children. While he would like to believe his friend is innocent, he has to follow the evidence. The last thing he needs is Louisa playing Nancy Drew.
Read for:
🔥England Setting
🔥Childhood friends to more
🔥pops of humor
🔥Agatha Christie vibes
🔥character growth
🔥family secrets
Bottom line, I loved this story. I prefer books that are more dialogue-driven, rather than plot-driven. This story was plot-driven, but it kept my interest and engaged for the full story. That is a sign of excellent writing.
Thank you to Bethany House for the opportunity to read this book. I was not required to provide a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.
From the first line, I was immediately drawn into the story and found it to move quickly.
"Louisa felt him die."
What?! How? This intriguing murder mystery set in the 1950s had many plot twists and kept me guessing until the very end. With a quirky cast of characters and a determined heroine full of sass, this was a memorable story that I could not put down. Louisa is determined to figure out where her brother has disappeared to while clearing his name of a crime she is sure he did not commit. This takes her into some dangerous areas and gets her into heaps of trouble.
Malcolm, the inspector assigned to the case, knows what Paul is capable of since they got into scrapes when they were children. While he would like to believe his friend is innocent, he has to follow the evidence. The last thing he needs is Louisa playing Nancy Drew.
Read for:
🔥England Setting
🔥Childhood friends to more
🔥pops of humor
🔥Agatha Christie vibes
🔥character growth
🔥family secrets
Bottom line, I loved this story. I prefer books that are more dialogue-driven, rather than plot-driven. This story was plot-driven, but it kept my interest and engaged for the full story. That is a sign of excellent writing.
Thank you to Bethany House for the opportunity to read this book. I was not required to provide a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.
October 24, 2024
I was immediately pulled into this intriguing story. The setting reminds me of Father Brown mysteries in a small English village of 1956. Louisa Everly is a twin to Paul and feels as if he is dead.
Paul is missing and accused of burning down Rosemont Abbey, the Everly home until their vicar father died. Louisa has a a lot at stake and sets off to sleuth much to the consternation of Malcolm Sinclair, a childhood friend who is now a detective inspector.
The story moves quickly as Louisa finds clues, and as a result gets into trouble more than once. But never fear, Malcolm is close at hand to rescue or thwart her. A killer is still on the loose and the author did an admirable job of giving us lots of suspects.
A favorite character is Mrs. Watson, the elderly housekeeper to the vicar, who has an opinion about everything. The vicar was a solid man of faith and dispensed solid spiritual advice.
I always admire this authors writing.
*I won a NetGalley copy of this book from Library Thing and received a print copy from Bethany House for review. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are mine alone.*
Paul is missing and accused of burning down Rosemont Abbey, the Everly home until their vicar father died. Louisa has a a lot at stake and sets off to sleuth much to the consternation of Malcolm Sinclair, a childhood friend who is now a detective inspector.
The story moves quickly as Louisa finds clues, and as a result gets into trouble more than once. But never fear, Malcolm is close at hand to rescue or thwart her. A killer is still on the loose and the author did an admirable job of giving us lots of suspects.
A favorite character is Mrs. Watson, the elderly housekeeper to the vicar, who has an opinion about everything. The vicar was a solid man of faith and dispensed solid spiritual advice.
I always admire this authors writing.
*I won a NetGalley copy of this book from Library Thing and received a print copy from Bethany House for review. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are mine alone.*
Displaying 1 - 30 of 230 reviews