All Your Pucking Secrets was about 21-year-old Tyler Kinsey, A college senior who was the first-line center for the hockey team, and 21-year-old Echo Dean, a college senior majoring in Psychology.
Echo and Tyler had attended the same high school growing up. During their Senior year, Tyler needed a science tutor and his father hired the "best student", who ended up being Echo. Although they knew about each other, they were from opposite sides of the social society. Tyler's family were among the town's wealthiest, while Echo was from the poorer side. Unknown to the rest of his classmates and friends (but accidentally discovered by Echo), Tyler's father was an abusive man who loved to take his anger out on his wife, son, and daughter.
I'm not going to write my usual review this time, mainly because this book hit me differently than almost all of the books I've read before it...and not in a good or bad way. Just...different. The book was more about exorcising past traumas, betrayals, hurts, and abuse...all experienced by the two main characters. While the FMC was the one who went through most of the above issues, the MMC had his fair share of them too. Unfortunately, the things that the FMC endured were triggered by the actions/non-actions of the MMC, thus giving this review its outcome.
For me, the connection between Ty and Echo wasn't romantic or even love-related. It felt more like dealing with the trauma, betrayal, and other hurts that Echo endured because of the things Tyler said, did, or did not do. Everything she went through was because of him. When he showed up at her college three years after everything that happened in high school, it was more like he was triggering her trauma than he was wooing her.
Both of the main characters, while mature and well-developed, had so many issues with the past that they really shouldn't have been together until they were dealt with and put to rest. One too many secrets came to light on the part of the MMC's past actions that ended up being the cause of one thing after another that happened to the FMC. I don't know how one could ever get past some of them, let alone all of them combined. He should have told her the truth about the past, and then let her move on instead of bulldozing her into giving him chance after chance. I understand that the author wanted these two to end up together and heal each other, but it seemed to be asking too much of Echo.
There was more drama and angst than a lot of romance books contain, but there was less spiciness than one comes to expect from this genre. In fact, in light of the trope used, any form of romance would be almost too much to ask for. Since both main characters were in some form of therapy, this was like two addicts (no addictions involved in this book) trying to have a relationship that they weren't ready for.
I only gave this book a two-star rating. The romance was lacking, the length was too long, the MMC was too pushy, and the FMC forgave him too quickly. If they hadn't been apart for so long, or if the author had written the book with more scenes of them together rather than apart, it might have been given a higher rating. But with the subject matters this story covered, the two main characters weren't together often enough to have had any REAL time to heal or to deal with each issue they endured...and there were a TON of issues this book covered.