A haunting, an obsession, a Tim Z. Hernandez has been searching for people his whole life. Now, in this highly anticipated memoir, he takes us along on an investigative odyssey through personal and collective history to uncover the surprising conjunctions that bind our stories together.
Hernandez’s mission to find the families of the twenty-eight Mexicans who were killed in the 1948 plane wreck at Los Gatos Canyon formed the basis for his acclaimed documentary novel All They Will Call You, which the San Francisco Chronicle dubbed “a stunning piece of investigative journalism,” and the New York Times hailed as “painstaking detective work by a writer who is the descendant of farmworkers.”
In this riveting new work, Hernandez continues his search for the plane crash victims while also turning the lens on himself and his ancestral past, revealing the tumultuous and deeply intimate experiences that have fueled his investigations—a lifelong journey haunted by memory, addiction, generational trauma, and the spirit world.
They Call You Back is the true chronicle of one man’s obsession to restore dignity to an undignified chapter in America’s past, while at the same time making a case for why we must heal our personal wounds if we are ever to heal our political ones.
I wish I could give 10 stars. What a moving experience. I initially started this book months ago. I stopped around page 145. I really couldn’t get into at the time. I started again yesterday. Tried to pick it up where I had left off, but it was so good I started back at the beginning. I could not do anything else yesterday. I was mesmerized by the story, the stories, by the writing. I could not put it down. Finally finished it today, but did not want it to end. I’m puzzled about my different experiences. Why it didn’t “speak” to me before, but grabbed me this time around, and won’t let go! I read the authors book, All They Will Call You, several years ago. I have bought numerous copies of that amazing book to share and have recommended it to so many friends and relatives. I don’t know if any one of them has actually read it, one of my all time favorites. I have read his book, Breathing, In Dust, which was hard to read, such suffering and injustice. I have his book, Mañana Means Heaven, which I will read soon. Thank you, Tim Hernandez, for your writing and your hard work, physical, psychological, and spiritual. You have poured so much of your life into these literary works. I just have no words.
I just finished reading “They Call You Back: A Lost History, A Search, A Memoir,” Tim Z. Hernandez’s (TZH) newest book. A couple of things before sharing my thoughts: I had already read his previous book, “All They Will Call You.” This book, however, also made me want to read “Mañana Means Heaven.” I am intrigued by the story of Bea Franco and how she’s influenced both, “All They Will Call You” and this book.
Earlier on in the book, I realized I was reading about generational trauma and a desire to heal, to sanar. The book is dedicated to his grandparents with the words, “sanemos juntos.” And that is what I think the book is about. It is about the Los Gatos Canyon plane crash. It is about his first book and the process, the “methodology of ghosts,” which I think is so Avery Gordon-ish. It is about being brown and poor in NM, TX, and CA. It is about so many critical and important things. But I think at the root is TZH’s desire to heal that generational trauma that “began” with his grandparents. I put “began” in quotes because we know there are never clear beginnings or endings.
There are several stories that TZH weaves together that shape him. Stories of poverty, of violence, of injustice, of racism, of dignity and humanity-or a desire for this. I must admit that the toughest ones to read were the stories of Virgil and the massacres in El Paso and Uvalde. I had to put the book down.
How do we heal from generational trauma? From trauma that is there before we are born, waiting for us? How do we recognize that anxiety or chaos is not peaceful but what we know? How do we create joy when most of what we’ve known is suffering and violence? TZH takes us on a journey of his own healing: writing, art, therapy, love, justice, his children, his vision of the world. He does it with sensitivity, rawness, honesty knowing fully well that healing is a life long process. It’s something that we work on, that needs to be protected.
This book reminds me of Mercy Romero’s “Towards Camden” —a memoir of the changing nature of home, Mercy’ home. I have previously shared my thoughts on this book. It also reminds me of Martha Gonzalez’s “Chican@Aritivista.” Even though TZH’s and Romero’s books are described as memoirs and Gonzalez’s as auto-ethnography, I see an important “genre” if I may for us to situate ourselves in the stories that matter to us, the stories that have shaped us. As much as TZH cringes when asked about his methodology, he is putting together a beautiful methodology, one of sanación.
The second title is a good description of the book....a lost history, a search, a memoir. In a lot of ways this book is about a process of finding stories. Listening. Setting out on the course and letting "it" find you...the story, the history, the forgotten. There is so much to this book. Continuing from a previous book on the search for the families of the "deportees" killed in the worst plane accident in California history and made famous by Woodie Guthrie and others who have sung the song. But it also includes his life, his family's and so much more. Book is so much more about writing and keeping stories and history and an account for our existence. The book seemed to have many roads or trails. Seems like the author has had quite a life. He spoke about some of his experiences growing up in Visalia and dealing with law enforcement. For how it was living in a place like Visalia. I could see picking up this book at a time where the different paths would have frustrated me, but I was in right state of mind for this book.
The sequel to All They Will Call You. Hernandez did not find all the names of those killed in the Los Gatos plane crash, nor their families. But people learn of his search and contact him. By the end, 18 of the 28 have been identified and a headstone carved and a memorial service held. His children are by his side for most of this quest. You also learn his multi-generational family history and what has motivated him for this long, long quest. We are not anonymous. We have names. We have compelling stories. All of us. The book is suffused with gentle humanity and the poignant reactions of families who at last have their family members acknowledged. His own son spontaneously calls out Presente as each identified member of the flight and the crew has their name called out at the official memorial service ... others join. If only all of the US had the wisdom of that son.
They Call You Back: A Lost History, A Search, A Memoir is a powerful and deeply moving blend of memoir, history, and investigative storytelling. Tim Z. Hernandez skillfully intertwines his personal journey with his ongoing effort to restore dignity and recognition to the victims of the 1948 Los Gatos Canyon plane crash.
Through themes of memory, family, addiction, generational trauma, and cultural identity, the book becomes more than a historical investigation it is a profound exploration of healing, justice, and belonging. Honest, compelling, and beautifully written, this memoir leaves a lasting impression.
I'm trying to think of the last time a book moved me this much....On a mission to read some of the greats which have thus far escaped me, I recently read "A Tree Grows in Brooklyn". I felt it was everything a book should aspire to be. In between reading the escaped greats I catch my breath by reading contemporary books I know little about. This one, published in late 2024, took my breath away. As well it should have.
Wow. This is a work of luminous beauty, with love and kindness woven throughout. Having read “All They Will Call You,” I wept at times in “They Call You Back,” in all the best ways. These two books together call me to be a better person; to be more attentive to how politically we live in circular ways; and to ensure I am doing all I can to limit erasure. To be part of the righting and writing of names.
I absolutely recommend this beautiful, loving book.
Tim Z. Hernandez is one of the most soulful witnesses of our time. He doesn’t just voyage to the end of the earth for his stories, he steps beyond—invoking the spirits as he follows the blood. THEY CALL YOU BACK is the genesis of his artistry, as riveting as it is necessary.