I read this for this first time about ten years ago, and I recently reread this, wondering if it held up. I was so happy to see that it did. It's a charming, heartwarming, down to earth time travel romance about a modern (well, late '90s) woman named Elle taken back to 1792 by... fairies. Yes, this all sounds potentially very cringe but I thought it was handled very well, and the themes of fairies and folklore and midsummer magic were worked in a really cohesive and satisfying way. It's never cutesy or twee. It's charming, romantic, lush and descriptive without being tedious.
I also enjoyed the relationship with Henry, the nobleman she finds herself married to in a marriage of convenience. There's no stupid misunderstandings, and even though they argue at first, they both grow to like and respect each other. The romance slowly blossoms, turning from distrust to slowly missing each other to a genuine honest emotional connection, and it was so nice to see. I put down the book with a happy sigh, which isn't what I usually do these days.
Also: the sex is HOT! Without it getting in the way of the plot! And there was just enough angst and humor to leaven everything and keep everything balanced. Cach is such a talented author-- I really need to read more of her work.
The only reason I'm not giving this five stars is because some of the historical stuff was off. For the most part, the period details were well done. I really appreciated how down-to-earth it was compared to 90% of the other time travel romances out there, with issues of peeing and periods addressed, but Elle's behavior, given that she was a countess, was so bizarre-- rolling around on the floor, playing with her dog? running off into the woods in her nightgown?-- I'm surprised there wasn't more blowback.
And then there was annoying goofs like women wearing wigs (they did not), and stays being described as literal torture devices (they were not), and the author having no idea that the War of the First Coalition (aka the French Revolutionary Wars) had started in April 1792 and war with England and other nations was not just something Napoleon dreamed up because he wanted to unite his country. (This is a point made by Elle when discussing a potential "young and charismatic leader" of future France, and the hero of course thinks she makes an intelligent argument. My eyes rolled so hard they almost fell out of my head.)
Anyway, with all this said, I still recommend this book for fans of time travel romance. It's almost as good as A KNIGHT IN SHINING ARMOR, and I don't say that lightly!