It was by chance that this book suddenly came to mind as I browsed the list of books tagged under Goodreads’ Classics category. I watched the Japanese anime series adaptation of A Dog of Flanders as a kid, and if I hadn’t seen the movie The Land Before Time beforehand and witnessed a character die for the first time, Nello and Patrasche’s story would have been the very first children’s narrative to ever shatter my faith in “happily ever afters”.
Reading the original story now made me realize that the lives of Nello and Patrasche are indeed heartbreaking, though not perpetually tragic as I’d first thought. They have been mostly quite content with their lot and have easily carried the burden of poverty with their optimism and togetherness. They have grown up to be work partners and shared their innermost thoughts like what best friends do.
Patrasche gives us his own account of happiness for finally finding a true family in Nello and his grandfather, after years of knowing only cruelty from a previous master. He vows to be loyal and to serve his new human wholeheartedly, a task he has fulfilled until his dying breath. I’m a dog lover, and so I wholeheartedly agree with Ouida/Marie Louise de la Ramée’s depiction of Patrasche’s undivided faithfulness and acuity. There was a time when a dog had shown the same absolute affection to me and made me realize that while people you’ve known your whole life may sometimes turn their back on you, dogs will loyally remain by your side and be your comfortable silence.
Nello is given the liberty to dream as children do, to imagine an ideal future in which he is rich and famous, or not looked down at because of his social standing. He is kind, fair and wise, and has developed a great talent for creating art. He cherishes his friendship with rich girl Alois and is devastated when Alois’s father (who admires Nello's goodhearted nature but loathes his destitution) has forbidden any future meeting between them. Despite the tragic circumstances that befell him, Nello continues to tread on kindness and hope.
The good fortune that eluded Nello and Patrasche through the years has finally come knocking at their door; only, it has come several hours too late. As a child watching that sad anime ending so many years ago, I used to think that both life and death had been cruel to Nello and Patrasche. While the book offers the same miserable conclusion, I now find a new light in this tragic story—that of Nello finally fulfilling his greatest dream of seeing a Rubens artwork, and of Patrasche dying in the arms of the boy he has loved and served unconditionally. For me, such insight makes a much more bearable conclusion to the story.