What do you think?
Rate this book
The Ultimate Earth – Hugo and Nebula Winner
Generations of clones on the moon chronicle the recovery of mother Earth, which has been destroyed and deserted. Eons have passed and a new generation of clones discover that their own base on the moon had been destroyed in the past and then rediscovered and rebuilt by the man known as Sandor Pen.
In the meantime the remnants of humanity have just started unlocking the mysteries of interstellar flight, but over the years their memory of old Earth has faded…a memory Sandor Pen intends to reignite.
The Ultimate Earth is classic Williamson. A multi-layered story with subtle interpretations. The novella was published to much critical acclaim, winning both the Hugo and Nebula Awards.
In the meantime the remnants of humanity have just started unlocking the mysteries of interstellar flight, but over the years their memory of old Earth has faded…a memory Sandor Pen intends to reignite.
The Ultimate Earth is classic Williamson. A multi-layered story with subtle interpretations. The novella was published to much critical acclaim, winning both the Hugo and Nebula Awards.
48 pages, Kindle Edition
First published December 1, 2000
About the author
Jack Williamson
583 books176 followersJohn Stewart Williamson who wrote as Jack Williamson (and occasionally under the pseudonym Will Stewart) was a U.S. writer often referred to as the "Dean of Science Fiction".
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews
November 23, 2021
When I see that a story has won both the Nebula and the Hugo, it sets a certain level of expectation before I've even cracked open the cover.
In short, I'm expecting to read the best SF novel/novella/short story published that year - the finest Science Fiction (in English at least) the world produced in a twelve month period.
Judging from The Ultimate Earth the year 2000 was a poor year for SF. It would seem that some drought or pestilence hit the vines that support the genre, and the resulting vintage is thin.
Realistically I'm sure there were worthier candidates for honors that year than The Ultimate Earth.
That isn't to say the The Ultimate Earth is a terrible story. It isn't. It's just not a particularly interesting or innovative one. It feels like it was written decades earlier, with a decidedly 1950s/60s vibe in the way that it is told and in the outsiders journey style of narrative it employs.
Essentially, there is a colony of clones on the moon, at a base that was set up to re-animate human society if an extinction-level disaster struck the Earth. A set of clones have awaken, under the rather distant guidance of a strange being called Sandor Pen. The clones are destined to stay on the Moon as part of a living museum, but naturally, some of them want more from life than lurking around an old moonbase, and conspire to escape to Earth.
Of course, they do so, and find themselves in a society so advanced that they are barely able to function in it.
And so we have a fish-out-of-water scenario, where the old-style humans enter the confusing, nano-teched and essentially alien world of the future. Without nanochines in their bodies they are perilously mortal (future people live forever), unreliable (future people cannot be cruel/dishonest etc.) and barely able to communicate (future people can connect telepathically).
They land in what is effectively a theme park showing the 'olden days' of human society, where the locals think the newcomers are part of the exhibits. From here they eventually make allies, and join Sandor on an interstellar mission to uncover a threat to humans everywhere in the galaxy.
You've probably seen most of these ideas before - I have certainly have - and sadly they aren't done here in an interesting way. There is an exceedingly unlikely reunion between two characters that doesn't hold up under much scrutiny, and the ending is both abrupt and unsatisfying.
The author (Jack Williamson) is a veteran of SF, and wrote many books that appear to be highly regarded. I'm guessing this story isn't representative of his work, and it is odd that it garnered both the Hugo and Nebula.
Perhaps a lifetime achievement award might have been a better way to honor a writer of Williamson's standing. Sadly, The Ultimate Earth doesn't stand out among the great SF novellas the genre has been blessed with over the last two decades.
Two naive moon-men out of five.
In short, I'm expecting to read the best SF novel/novella/short story published that year - the finest Science Fiction (in English at least) the world produced in a twelve month period.
Judging from The Ultimate Earth the year 2000 was a poor year for SF. It would seem that some drought or pestilence hit the vines that support the genre, and the resulting vintage is thin.
Realistically I'm sure there were worthier candidates for honors that year than The Ultimate Earth.
That isn't to say the The Ultimate Earth is a terrible story. It isn't. It's just not a particularly interesting or innovative one. It feels like it was written decades earlier, with a decidedly 1950s/60s vibe in the way that it is told and in the outsiders journey style of narrative it employs.
Essentially, there is a colony of clones on the moon, at a base that was set up to re-animate human society if an extinction-level disaster struck the Earth. A set of clones have awaken, under the rather distant guidance of a strange being called Sandor Pen. The clones are destined to stay on the Moon as part of a living museum, but naturally, some of them want more from life than lurking around an old moonbase, and conspire to escape to Earth.
Of course, they do so, and find themselves in a society so advanced that they are barely able to function in it.
And so we have a fish-out-of-water scenario, where the old-style humans enter the confusing, nano-teched and essentially alien world of the future. Without nanochines in their bodies they are perilously mortal (future people live forever), unreliable (future people cannot be cruel/dishonest etc.) and barely able to communicate (future people can connect telepathically).
They land in what is effectively a theme park showing the 'olden days' of human society, where the locals think the newcomers are part of the exhibits. From here they eventually make allies, and join Sandor on an interstellar mission to uncover a threat to humans everywhere in the galaxy.
You've probably seen most of these ideas before - I have certainly have - and sadly they aren't done here in an interesting way. There is an exceedingly unlikely reunion between two characters that doesn't hold up under much scrutiny, and the ending is both abrupt and unsatisfying.
The author (Jack Williamson) is a veteran of SF, and wrote many books that appear to be highly regarded. I'm guessing this story isn't representative of his work, and it is odd that it garnered both the Hugo and Nebula.
Perhaps a lifetime achievement award might have been a better way to honor a writer of Williamson's standing. Sadly, The Ultimate Earth doesn't stand out among the great SF novellas the genre has been blessed with over the last two decades.
Two naive moon-men out of five.
May 30, 2026
1.5 - Wow, the year 2000 must have been pretty rough for sci-fi if this novella won both the Hugo and the Nebula…😬
October 27, 2020
I bought this, thinking it was a novel. Turns out its just a small "booklet" - read short story. An interesting read, but not a lot of substance for a Hugo and Nebula Award winner...
July 14, 2020
Nebula and Hugo Award Winning Novella. People, clones and robots rebuilding and rediscovering Earth to ferret out their long forgotten roots and restore the monumental achievements, memorials and relics of humanity. A story about how their rich and beautiful earthen home was destroyed. A quest to find out what makes them diversley unique. A journey to a home from centuries in the past. Technology that only leads them to everything good. Minimal scientific and quasi-scientific jargon. No Asimov's three laws of robots. Just a story about the longings of clones and people to find a way to belong. A story informed by his own emotional struggles. His writing is conversational and familiar and lyrical and engaging. Williamson is a master science fiction writer--a master writer period.
April 28, 2025
https://fromtheheartofeurope.eu/the-ultimate-earth-by-jack-williamson/
After disaster strikes Earth, a group of clone children who have been raised on the Moon steal a spaceship to go back to the home planet. They find it is not what they expected (this is where the nanobots come in) and head off into the stars. Not very new ideas, and not really done in a new way.
After disaster strikes Earth, a group of clone children who have been raised on the Moon steal a spaceship to go back to the home planet. They find it is not what they expected (this is where the nanobots come in) and head off into the stars. Not very new ideas, and not really done in a new way.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 9, 2023
good quick sci fi adventure read, more a short story than a novella
Really interesting Sci-Fi story. Length is closer to a short story than a novella. Which is my one problem. It took me three evenings to finish reading. Again it was during my recreation reading times. I understand some people can read faster and some slower. Personally I enjoyed the story.
Really interesting Sci-Fi story. Length is closer to a short story than a novella. Which is my one problem. It took me three evenings to finish reading. Again it was during my recreation reading times. I understand some people can read faster and some slower. Personally I enjoyed the story.
November 30, 2017
B. Clones, a galactic plague, a missing twin found and the antidote to the plague.
August 16, 2019
Verwachtingen waren hoog wegens Hugo & Nebula Award voor kortverhaal, maar beetje van kale reis teruggekomen. Goed geschreven maar geen echt verrassende visies of plots.
March 2, 2023
book seemed incomplete
lots of loose ends
lots of loose ends
April 4, 2023
I just love Jack Williamson.
April 11, 2025
Very abrupt ending, almost like the author died and they published the story anyway.
July 9, 2025
This novella seems stilted and not very well written.
September 4, 2013
An excellent first-person novella with excellent prose. Not to be missed for anyone who loves science fiction with sweeping ideas.
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews