It used to be that time of year when Lee Child would publish his annual outing with one of my favorite fictional heroes, Jack Reacher. Those days are gone and the transition from big brother to younger brother is in full process. Andrew Child, Lee’s brother, is the writer while Lee provides editorial feedback and support. It is also my understanding based on an article I read right before reading this book last weekend, this is Lee’s last book in an editor role. Moving forward, Andrew will be flying solo starting with next year’s Reacher book… That will be interesting…
The transition of Andrew taking the lead, some things have remained the same while other things have changed. Andrew was definitely not Lee and his changes were weren’t always subtle to the millions of Reacher fans. In my personal opinion, it’s taken Andrew several books to develop his own rhythm with the character and his behaviors. The result is that Andrew’s version Reacher is not necessarily Lee’s Reacher. As a reader, you can choose to like that or not. It’s just the reality of the situation.
This year, Andrew has delivered his fourth Reacher novel, “The Secret”, which continues much of the same approach, style, and plotting as his last novel, “No Plan B”. For me personally, there seems to be some more incremental improvement. Reacher is not talking near as much as he did in Andrew’s first book. In addition, the plotting is continuing to improve, strengthening the overall story.
“The Secret” as another one of the flashback stories from when Reacher was serving in the military back in 1992. It starts off with Reacher investigating an inventory problem but gets pulled off to represent the Army on an interagency task force pulled together by the U.S. Secretary of Defense.
The purpose of the task force is to find out who is killing a group of ex-military scientists who are retired from service for years and appear to have nothing in common. However, they are showing up dead in what appears to be strange and unique accidents that raise questions.
The bad news for Reacher, recently demoted from Major to Captain due to insubordination, is that he and the rest of the task force members have been chosen for a reason. They are on the outs with their government organizations, and if they fail, they will become convenient fall guys who will be forced to take the blame…
Once he understands the rules of this forced assignment, Reacher decides its time to find a connection between the victims and who’s hunting them down, as well as rallying his fellow task force members to figure out why this is all happening. And to make matters worse, Reacher is getting the sense that someone in the government above their level is somehow involved and hiding key information… Information that could get them killed…
Like the last book, this was an easy and fast read. In some ways too fast. Most of that is because this book is only 296 pages in length, which I think is one of the shortest, if not the shortest, Reacher novel in the series. I am not for adding fluff to get to a higher word count, but it would be nice to have a longer read in the 300-to-400-page range.
The plotting and pacing were good most of the time. Andrew captures much of the same plot development style and flow as his brother, Lee. Although it felt a bit too clinical at moments, the storyline revealed itself scene by scene as Reacher played the role of investigator. One thing that I noticed and appreciated was that the fight sequences flowed more organically and were not so over-choreographed.
Another area of strengthening was the overall plotting. The mystery was multi-layered and the various pieces were revealed throughout the book at different point along the way, providing more tension and surprise along the way. Although I have to say that I figured out the last big reveal at the end, which means a lot of other readers will most likely have done the same.
The villains were also more worthier opponents for Reacher than Andrew’s first two books. The good news is that Andrew’s adding more perspectives from the villain’s points of view added more tension and depth to the mystery and adversarial elements. It also helped Reacher come across as multi-dimensional and intelligent rather than just a strong brute. At the same time, I have noticed that there are some readers that felt this diminished the amount of screen time that Reacher had in the book, and I must admit that there is definitely some truth to that. Especially with the lower page count, this choice to focus more on other characters in the story did take away from Reacher’s screen time. For me, that’s a tough call as a writer, and I can see both sides of that argument.
Now, for the elephant in the room. Andrew writes Reacher differently than Lee. That is reality and it isn’t going to change anytime soon (per his interviews). Andrew’s Reacher is focused more on his physical skills and instinctual strengths. I especially appreciated in this book how Reacher used his analytical skills more, which reminded me more of Lee Child’s writing, and I really enjoyed getting the “smart” Reacher back.
I also felt like the ending did not fully deliver on the buildup as well as it could have. It wasn’t a bad ending, and improved over the previous two, but it seems like Andrew struggles some with putting it all together at the end. Mechanically he got all of the pieces connected, but emotionally, it still felt a little bit lacking when it came to experiencing closure. By the time you got to the climax, the villains have all been turned into weak hackneyed versions of their former stronger selves in the first half of the book and pretty much laid down for Reacher without a proper fight.
Overall, it felt like to me that “The Secret” showed that Andrew Child is continuing to get better in his writing of Reacher. His understanding of what works with the character is getting better. His plotlines and mystery elements are improving.
That being said, we, as readers, must come to terms with understanding that Andrew is not Lee and cannot be Lee. He is his own writer. For example, nobody will ever be James Bond in my mind, but Sean Connery. He was the first, the best, and the model every other Bond is compared to. Most cannot come close to his greatness. However, everything considered, Daniel Craig did pretty dang good in his own version and I am enjoying his take on the character. He’s not Connery, but he’s much better than the others.
I fully understand that some Reacher fans will learn to enjoy Andrew’s version of Reacher and others will never be satisfied with Andrew, choosing rather to pick it apart. Although it probably doesn’t feel that way after reading my review, I am probably somewhere in the middle. Lee was certainly burning out on writing Reacher. That was clear in his later interviews, so it was time to move on.
In the same way, it isn’t fair to judge Andrew Child with the expectation of being a Lee Child clone or copycat. We owe him the right to deliver Reacher using his own style, which means that we may have to accept his version of Reacher with different nuances than that which his creator instilled. At that point, we can choose to stick with him or leave, and that’s a personal choice readers can make on their own.
For me, Andrew is getting better. We’ll see how his solo outing goes in 2024, but until then, “The Secret” is a gracious and optimistic 4-stars for me.