What do you think?
Rate this book
That Which Remains...: 5 New Sherlock Holmes Mysteries
This is a compilation of five more cases from the decades-long career of Sherlock Holmes as compiled by his friend and colleague Dr. John Watson.
213 pages, Kindle Edition
Published March 6, 2024
91 people are currently reading
20 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews
November 27, 2025
1. Pandora's Box - Travelling to Edinburgh on the train a body of a woman is discovered.
2. The Singular Affair of the Aluminium Crutch - Holmes relives an old case from 1877 and the aluminium crutch belonging to Simon van Pelt.
3. The Puzzle Master - Holmes comes across a dying man, but what of his missing son.
4. The Totten Wood Mystery - 1897 - Wallace Fernsby has been shot in mysterious circumstances in Totten Wood.
5. The Mystery of the Broken Window - 1894 - 19 year old Stanley Hopkins believes his 15 year old sister Fiona has been abducted.
Enjoyable short stories
2. The Singular Affair of the Aluminium Crutch - Holmes relives an old case from 1877 and the aluminium crutch belonging to Simon van Pelt.
3. The Puzzle Master - Holmes comes across a dying man, but what of his missing son.
4. The Totten Wood Mystery - 1897 - Wallace Fernsby has been shot in mysterious circumstances in Totten Wood.
5. The Mystery of the Broken Window - 1894 - 19 year old Stanley Hopkins believes his 15 year old sister Fiona has been abducted.
Enjoyable short stories
August 26, 2024
If you're a fan of Sherlock Holmes, you’re in for a treat with William Todd’s collection. Todd, who started his writing career with gothic horror, has seamlessly transitioned into the world of Sherlock Holmes with this collection of five short stories. His deep love for the character and the genre is evident on every page, making this a must-read for both longtime fans and newcomers alike.
William Todd isn’t new to the writing scene; he’s been honing his craft for over twenty years, starting with gothic horror before diving into Sherlock Holmes pastiches. His passion for Holmes led him to contribute to MX Publishing's "New Sherlock Holmes Stories," and his latest work continues to showcase his respect for the original material while bringing something fresh to the table.
The collection offers five short stories, each featuring Holmes and Watson as they navigate complex mysteries filled with twists and turns. Todd stays true to the classic Holmes formula—there’s no shortage of intricate plots, cryptic clues, and the kind of climactic reveals that make you want to revisit the story as soon as you finish it. What sets these stories apart is Todd’s ability to inject new life into familiar scenarios, making them feel both nostalgic and innovative.
Todd’s writing style is both an homage to Conan Doyle and a showcase of his unique voice. His prose is sharp and descriptive, capturing the foggy streets of London with an atmospheric touch. But where he truly excels is in his characterization of Holmes. Todd manages to keep Holmes' intellectual brilliance intact while also exploring a more playful, cheeky side of the detective—something that adds a refreshing twist to the stories.
Holmes and Watson are as compelling as ever under Todd’s pen. Holmes is depicted with the sharpness and wit you’d expect, but Todd adds layers to his personality, making him feel more human and relatable. The themes of loyalty, justice, and truth are deeply embedded in the narrative, resonating with the moral fabric of the original stories while also bringing in contemporary relevance.
Each story in this collection is tightly woven, with a clear structure that keeps you engaged from start to finish. The pacing is spot-on, and Todd’s ability to build suspense is impressive. The final story in particular stands out for its intricate plot and satisfying resolution, leaving you with that classic “aha!” moment that every good mystery should deliver.
Todd’s stories explore timeless themes of justice, loyalty, and the relentless pursuit of truth, much like the original Holmes tales. However, he also introduces modern nuances, making the stories resonate with today’s readers. There’s an underlying message about the complexity of human nature and the moral dilemmas that often accompany the pursuit of justice.
Reading Todd’s collection is like revisiting an old friend—you feel comforted by the familiarity but excited by the new twists. There are moments of tension, surprise, and even humor that make the stories emotionally engaging. The balance between suspense and lighter moments adds depth to the reading experience.
One of the collection’s biggest strengths is how it balances the old with the new. Todd respects the source material but isn’t afraid to take creative risks, such as showing Holmes’ more playful side. The vivid descriptions, sharp dialogue, and well-crafted plots make this a standout in the world of Sherlock Holmes pastiches.
While the collection is strong overall, some readers might find the dialogue a bit too formal at times. Though it fits the period, there are moments where it can feel a bit stiff, potentially pulling you out of the story. It’s a minor quibble, but something that might be refined in future works.
Personally, I loved how Todd managed to breathe new life into the world of Sherlock Holmes. His stories felt like a comfortable return to familiar territory, but with enough originality to keep things exciting. The final story, in particular, left a lasting impression, and I’m already looking forward to what Todd will write next.
In conclusion, William Todd’s Sherlock Holmes collection is a brilliant addition to the detective genre. It’s a well-crafted, engaging, and thoroughly enjoyable read that offers something for both die-hard Holmes fans and those new to the character. With its blend of classic elements and fresh perspectives, this collection is a must-read. I highly recommend it to anyone who loves a good mystery.
#SherlockHolmes #MysteryReads #BookReview #DetectiveFiction #WilliamTodd
William Todd isn’t new to the writing scene; he’s been honing his craft for over twenty years, starting with gothic horror before diving into Sherlock Holmes pastiches. His passion for Holmes led him to contribute to MX Publishing's "New Sherlock Holmes Stories," and his latest work continues to showcase his respect for the original material while bringing something fresh to the table.
The collection offers five short stories, each featuring Holmes and Watson as they navigate complex mysteries filled with twists and turns. Todd stays true to the classic Holmes formula—there’s no shortage of intricate plots, cryptic clues, and the kind of climactic reveals that make you want to revisit the story as soon as you finish it. What sets these stories apart is Todd’s ability to inject new life into familiar scenarios, making them feel both nostalgic and innovative.
Todd’s writing style is both an homage to Conan Doyle and a showcase of his unique voice. His prose is sharp and descriptive, capturing the foggy streets of London with an atmospheric touch. But where he truly excels is in his characterization of Holmes. Todd manages to keep Holmes' intellectual brilliance intact while also exploring a more playful, cheeky side of the detective—something that adds a refreshing twist to the stories.
Holmes and Watson are as compelling as ever under Todd’s pen. Holmes is depicted with the sharpness and wit you’d expect, but Todd adds layers to his personality, making him feel more human and relatable. The themes of loyalty, justice, and truth are deeply embedded in the narrative, resonating with the moral fabric of the original stories while also bringing in contemporary relevance.
Each story in this collection is tightly woven, with a clear structure that keeps you engaged from start to finish. The pacing is spot-on, and Todd’s ability to build suspense is impressive. The final story in particular stands out for its intricate plot and satisfying resolution, leaving you with that classic “aha!” moment that every good mystery should deliver.
Todd’s stories explore timeless themes of justice, loyalty, and the relentless pursuit of truth, much like the original Holmes tales. However, he also introduces modern nuances, making the stories resonate with today’s readers. There’s an underlying message about the complexity of human nature and the moral dilemmas that often accompany the pursuit of justice.
Reading Todd’s collection is like revisiting an old friend—you feel comforted by the familiarity but excited by the new twists. There are moments of tension, surprise, and even humor that make the stories emotionally engaging. The balance between suspense and lighter moments adds depth to the reading experience.
One of the collection’s biggest strengths is how it balances the old with the new. Todd respects the source material but isn’t afraid to take creative risks, such as showing Holmes’ more playful side. The vivid descriptions, sharp dialogue, and well-crafted plots make this a standout in the world of Sherlock Holmes pastiches.
While the collection is strong overall, some readers might find the dialogue a bit too formal at times. Though it fits the period, there are moments where it can feel a bit stiff, potentially pulling you out of the story. It’s a minor quibble, but something that might be refined in future works.
Personally, I loved how Todd managed to breathe new life into the world of Sherlock Holmes. His stories felt like a comfortable return to familiar territory, but with enough originality to keep things exciting. The final story, in particular, left a lasting impression, and I’m already looking forward to what Todd will write next.
In conclusion, William Todd’s Sherlock Holmes collection is a brilliant addition to the detective genre. It’s a well-crafted, engaging, and thoroughly enjoyable read that offers something for both die-hard Holmes fans and those new to the character. With its blend of classic elements and fresh perspectives, this collection is a must-read. I highly recommend it to anyone who loves a good mystery.
#SherlockHolmes #MysteryReads #BookReview #DetectiveFiction #WilliamTodd
July 29, 2024
William Todd’s collection of Sherlock Holmes stories offers an invigorating take on stands as a luminous gem in the realm of detective literature.This compilation features five short stories that are a testament to Todd’s deep understanding and respect for the original character while injecting his unique flair.
The collection opens with a gripping mystery that sets the tone for the rest of the book. Todd skillfully revives the classic elements of a Holmes narrative: the intricate plots, the enigmatic clues, and the climactic reveals. Each story is thoughtfully constructed, demonstrating Todd’s ability to weave compelling tales that maintain the high standards of the Holmes tradition.
One of the most striking aspects of Todd’s writing is his ability to capture Holmes' intellectual brilliance while also exploring the more playful, cheeky facets of his personality. This adds a refreshing dimension to the character, making him feel both familiar and intriguingly new. The way Todd balances Holmes’ deductive skills with moments of lightheartedness provides a richer and more nuanced portrayal of the detective.
The final story in the collection is particularly noteworthy. It stands out not only for its intricate plot but also for the clever and satisfying resolution that ties everything together. Todd’s adept handling of suspense and character dynamics culminates in a conclusion that is both surprising and rewarding, showcasing his talent for crafting a memorable narrative.
Overall, Todd’s collection is a worthy tribute to Sherlock Holmes. It successfully blends classic detective elements with fresh perspectives, offering both new and seasoned readers an engaging and enjoyable experience. The stories are well-crafted, with each narrative contributing to a cohesive and entertaining exploration of Holmes' world. Todd creation is a masterpiece that continues to captivate and inspire, securing its place as an enduring treasure in the world of literature
The collection opens with a gripping mystery that sets the tone for the rest of the book. Todd skillfully revives the classic elements of a Holmes narrative: the intricate plots, the enigmatic clues, and the climactic reveals. Each story is thoughtfully constructed, demonstrating Todd’s ability to weave compelling tales that maintain the high standards of the Holmes tradition.
One of the most striking aspects of Todd’s writing is his ability to capture Holmes' intellectual brilliance while also exploring the more playful, cheeky facets of his personality. This adds a refreshing dimension to the character, making him feel both familiar and intriguingly new. The way Todd balances Holmes’ deductive skills with moments of lightheartedness provides a richer and more nuanced portrayal of the detective.
The final story in the collection is particularly noteworthy. It stands out not only for its intricate plot but also for the clever and satisfying resolution that ties everything together. Todd’s adept handling of suspense and character dynamics culminates in a conclusion that is both surprising and rewarding, showcasing his talent for crafting a memorable narrative.
Overall, Todd’s collection is a worthy tribute to Sherlock Holmes. It successfully blends classic detective elements with fresh perspectives, offering both new and seasoned readers an engaging and enjoyable experience. The stories are well-crafted, with each narrative contributing to a cohesive and entertaining exploration of Holmes' world. Todd creation is a masterpiece that continues to captivate and inspire, securing its place as an enduring treasure in the world of literature
September 2, 2024
William Todd’s latest collection is a delightful addition to the world of Sherlock Holmes, offering five short stories that capture the essence of the legendary detective while introducing a refreshing twist. Todd, a seasoned writer with roots in gothic horror, brings his expertise to the Holmes universe with a deep respect for the original material, making this collection a must-read for both long-time fans and newcomers. Each story is meticulously crafted, showcasing the classic elements that make Holmes so enduring—intricate plots, cryptic clues, and those iconic climactic reveals.
Todd’s ability to balance these traditional aspects with a fresh, modern flair is impressive. He manages to explore new dimensions of Holmes’ character, particularly a more playful, cheeky side, which adds a unique layer to the detective we all know and love. The final story in the collection is particularly noteworthy, with a complex plot and a satisfying resolution that ties everything together beautifully. Todd’s writing is sharp and descriptive, vividly bringing to life the foggy streets of London and the intense atmosphere of each case.
His portrayal of Holmes is both familiar and intriguingly new, making the character feel more human and relatable. Overall, this collection is a brilliant tribute to Sherlock Holmes, blending classic detective elements with fresh perspectives. Todd’s stories are engaging, well-paced, and full of clever mysteries that will keep readers hooked from start to finish. Whether you’re a die-hard Holmes fan or just love a good mystery, this collection is a standout in the genre.
Todd’s ability to balance these traditional aspects with a fresh, modern flair is impressive. He manages to explore new dimensions of Holmes’ character, particularly a more playful, cheeky side, which adds a unique layer to the detective we all know and love. The final story in the collection is particularly noteworthy, with a complex plot and a satisfying resolution that ties everything together beautifully. Todd’s writing is sharp and descriptive, vividly bringing to life the foggy streets of London and the intense atmosphere of each case.
His portrayal of Holmes is both familiar and intriguingly new, making the character feel more human and relatable. Overall, this collection is a brilliant tribute to Sherlock Holmes, blending classic detective elements with fresh perspectives. Todd’s stories are engaging, well-paced, and full of clever mysteries that will keep readers hooked from start to finish. Whether you’re a die-hard Holmes fan or just love a good mystery, this collection is a standout in the genre.
August 16, 2024
Few figures in the world of detective fiction have captivated readers quite like Sherlock Holmes. William Todd's unique collection of five short stories offers a refreshing and innovative perspective on this iconic character, blending traditional elements with a fresh twist that is bound to enchant both new and seasoned fans. From the very first story, it is evident that Todd possesses a profound understanding and admiration for the original material. He masterfully resurrects the intricate plots, mysterious clues, and dramatic revelations that have solidified Holmes' status as a literary legend. Each tale is meticulously crafted, drawing readers in with its tantalizing mysteries and unexpected twists. The final story in the collection is a true standout, showcasing Todd's prowess at weaving a compelling narrative filled with suspense and intrigue. Todd's collection is a must-read for enthusiasts of the genre and anyone seeking a new take on the beloved Sherlock Holmes stories. With its captivating narratives, suspenseful plots, and satisfying conclusions, this compilation is certain to earn a lasting place in the annals of literature
August 28, 2024
I’ve only read a few Sherlock Holmes books, but every one of them has impressed me greatly. I’m always amazed by how Sherlock’s mind works and by his sharp focus on solving each case.
Many times, I used to forget that Sherlock is a character and not a real person, as he always feels so real in all the books. I was really excited to pick this book up and it met my expectations.
I highly recommend this collection to anyone who loves detective stories or is looking for a fresh twist on the classic Sherlock Holmes tales. As a fan, I found it engaging, with clever mysteries that kept me hooked from start to finish.
Todd masterfully retains Holmes' intellectual genius while also highlighting a more playful, cheeky aspect of the detective, which introduces a refreshing twist to the classic tales. The collection is full of complex plots and enigmatic clues that keep you intrigued. Each story builds up to dramatic revelations that are both unexpected and fulfilling. This new perspective on Holmes combines sharp wit with engaging mysteries, making it a must-read for anyone who enjoys the genre.
Many times, I used to forget that Sherlock is a character and not a real person, as he always feels so real in all the books. I was really excited to pick this book up and it met my expectations.
I highly recommend this collection to anyone who loves detective stories or is looking for a fresh twist on the classic Sherlock Holmes tales. As a fan, I found it engaging, with clever mysteries that kept me hooked from start to finish.
Todd masterfully retains Holmes' intellectual genius while also highlighting a more playful, cheeky aspect of the detective, which introduces a refreshing twist to the classic tales. The collection is full of complex plots and enigmatic clues that keep you intrigued. Each story builds up to dramatic revelations that are both unexpected and fulfilling. This new perspective on Holmes combines sharp wit with engaging mysteries, making it a must-read for anyone who enjoys the genre.
August 21, 2024
Mystery tales are very nail biting and enthusiastic filled twists that gives you an endless reasons to read this is one such amazing collection of Sherlock Homes stories by the author William Todd.
I was teenager then when I read the story of Hound of Baskervilles and can't express how good I felt for the amazing stories that were framed around the character detective Sherlock Homes and Watson.
This is again a good to read few more stories from the collection which gives us glimpse of mystery that has many gripping and riveting twists that flows throughout the story.
A must try one in the thriller genre.
I was teenager then when I read the story of Hound of Baskervilles and can't express how good I felt for the amazing stories that were framed around the character detective Sherlock Homes and Watson.
This is again a good to read few more stories from the collection which gives us glimpse of mystery that has many gripping and riveting twists that flows throughout the story.
A must try one in the thriller genre.
November 22, 2024
Well done Sherlock Holmes, with intriguing cases and solid characterization. I don't tend to like long form Sherlock stories, they usually pad out the case and weaken his abilities just to make it last longer, while the short stories are punchy and make Holmes seem brilliant.
These stories tend to cover topics that were too sensitive or shocking for Victorian reader sensibilities, but were a real issue at the time such as child trafficking. And often there is more menace than the canon stories, genuine danger for the pair.
These stories tend to cover topics that were too sensitive or shocking for Victorian reader sensibilities, but were a real issue at the time such as child trafficking. And often there is more menace than the canon stories, genuine danger for the pair.
April 29, 2024
A Wonderful Collection
This is a collection of five short stories featuring the Great Detective at his best. I enjoyed every bit, especially the last story!
William Todd does a wonderful job showcasing not only Holmes' talents but a bit of his cheeky side as well.
Definitely worth a read.
Christa
This is a collection of five short stories featuring the Great Detective at his best. I enjoyed every bit, especially the last story!
William Todd does a wonderful job showcasing not only Holmes' talents but a bit of his cheeky side as well.
Definitely worth a read.
Christa
April 30, 2025
Most excellent
The keys to writing a great ACD pastiche includes re-creating the Victorian ambience, staying true to the original characters, and creating a worthy mystery. Many can do some but not all. In this 5 story collection, Mr Todd achieves them all. if you’re a fan of ACD, you will love this book.
The keys to writing a great ACD pastiche includes re-creating the Victorian ambience, staying true to the original characters, and creating a worthy mystery. Many can do some but not all. In this 5 story collection, Mr Todd achieves them all. if you’re a fan of ACD, you will love this book.
June 13, 2024
Sherlock yet not
OK, the stories good. Good enough to overlook the not good. The wring of dialog awful. Like using a thesaurus to find words it seemed. Very stilted verbiage and storytelling
Good stories.
OK, the stories good. Good enough to overlook the not good. The wring of dialog awful. Like using a thesaurus to find words it seemed. Very stilted verbiage and storytelling
Good stories.
June 24, 2024
well written
Good addition to the “canon” involving the usual players and crafty Holmes solutions. A comfortable and gratifying read without too much drama.
Good addition to the “canon” involving the usual players and crafty Holmes solutions. A comfortable and gratifying read without too much drama.
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews