Someone Had To Lie is a political mystery / thriller. DEA agent Joe Aguilar is dead. His life was taken as he talked to his friend, defense attorney James Butler. His last words: “It was bigger than we thought and now we’re in danger.” Now James and his wife, Erica Walsh, are on a perilous quest to find the truth behind Aguilar’s death.
Bottom line: Someone Had To Lie is for you if you like political mysteries told against the backdrop of true crime.
James Butler and his wife/partner Erica Walsh are on a quest to hold accountable the person responsible for Joe Aquilar’s death. The file James inherited has no coherency, but articles and notes did have a theme: Fentanyl. Their starting point is the place where Joe was investigating something secretively, where he died using a pay phone, Yuma, Arizona.
With the fictional story set against the persons and events associated with the Mexican cartel including the 1985 murder of DEA Agent Enrique “Kiki” Camarena, SOMEONE HAD TO LIE is an outstanding read for both lovers of political thrillers and true crime junkies. This crossover novel gives context to the complex and dangerous worlds lived in by people on both sides of the battle.
James is our storyteller and lead detective. He is a man of high morals and values with connections and resources that enable this amateur detective to connect into closed societies. Erica is his wife and investigative partner. She is a paralegal in the law firm where her father and husband are partners. It is clear she is a paralegal by choice, preferring to stay in the background to work her magic. Throughout the book, both act true to their natures and drive the story with their unwillingness to let their friend’s death be written off as a robbery gone bad.
There are many supporting characters. Tim Speer and Arthur Collins, CIA operatives, Bobby Burgess, NFL pro turned PI, Bill Belmonte, DEA Agent, Brian Wilson, retired reporter, and a myriad of experts- some polished, some not- who help James and Erica move from stepping stone to stepping stone. Their stories aren’t always pretty and the same can be said for the consequences of their decision to help. These minor characters, with their well-developed backgrounds and expertises, were one of my favorite parts of this book.
Setting for this book is more about the complex world of cartels, drug dealing, and law enforcement than a particular place. In many ways, Yuma, AZ could be replaced with a number of other cities, where the societal structure and mechanisms of moving drugs cannot, making these the true setting.
The logic of James and Erica’s actions are fairly straightforward as they follow one lead to next, to the next. The logic of the bad guys is more interesting and less obvious to understand as SOMEONE HAD TO LIE does an excellent job of protecting their identity. This is not a story where the detectives hit a brick wall at the end and the bad guy steps out and says “here I am.”
The complex nature of the story is both a strength and a weakness. There are passages that read more like a lecture from a class or excerpt from a legal document. True crime lovers will absolutely eat these up. I did have some trouble following these passages when it came to connecting them into James and Erica’s story. If you are someone who has trouble with too many characters, my advice is to treat these passages as descriptions of the setting, holding on to the events and drivers and not necessarily the names and relationships.
SOMEONE HAD TO LIE is the second book in the James Butler mystery series. Luellen does a nice job with hints as to past struggles, life threatening situations, and trust borne in danger, giving James and Erica a credibility to jump into Aguilar’s death that otherwise would have been a stretch. I did not read the first book and followed without it. Reading the first, SOMEONE HAD TO DIE, would have given a deeper understanding of some character relationships, but that is a “nice to have” as this story felt independent.