Every once in a while, a book comes along that makes you question why you even bothered to finish it. What Lies Buried by Leslie Kain is, unfortunately, one of those books. Packed with convoluted storytelling, characters who feel more like cardboard cutouts than real people, and a plot that drags on without delivering much of anything, this novel is an exercise in patience rather than suspense.
The title What Lies Buried promises, but what’s actually buried is any hope of an engaging story. Kain attempts to write a psychological thriller, but the suspense is so watered down that by the time anything remotely interesting happens, you’ve already lost all investment. The story meanders through lifeless dialogue, predictable plot twists, and characters making decisions that defy common sense.
A strong thriller hinges on its characters, but this novel fails to deliver anyone worth cheering for. The protagonist is frustratingly bland, and their internal struggles are so over-explained that any sense of subtlety is completely lost. Supporting characters? Forgettable. Villains? Predictable. No one in this book feels like a real person, just a collection of clichés thrown together to move the plot forward.
Kain’s writing is the kind that desperately wants to sound intelligent and profound but instead comes across as clunky and overwritten. The prose is bogged down by excessive description, unnecessary introspection, and dialogue that doesn’t sound remotely natural. The pacing is equally off—the book drags where it should be gripping and rushes through the few moments that could have been compelling.
If you’re hoping for a thrilling, psychological deep novel, you’ll be sorely disappointed. The pacing is inconsistent, the plot lacks urgency, and the conclusion is as underwhelming as the rest of the book. By the end, I wasn’t shocked, moved, or even mildly entertained—I was just relieved it was over.
Final Verdict: A Total Miss
If you’re looking for a psychological thriller that actually delivers, there are far better books out there. What Lies Buried is the kind of novel that makes you appreciate well-paced, well-written mysteries even more—because this isn’t one of them.
Rating: One star (and that’s being generous)
Save yourself the time and pick something else.